High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1092/2024dismissed

Sheetal Kaur v. Daljit Singh

2024-03-21Mr. Justice Sudhir Singh,Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger13 pages

$!%&'&"() *+*

,-!! .

/01

******22!..(

3!1'0'

.4& ,&(5-

*********!'2"($!(

1!'!( )

1* 016

0 7 $6"% !7 22!..( *

21!'!( 22!.

$&1!% !$ 5&('

40$58!(

$ !$ +** 2''!$ .!1(!$ 1&(%&2.

0$5!7 8&.:

"01 7 "'-&12017 ;-!1!9:

2! & &"(

&($0 % #&.!$7 1!'2"($!(

-0'9($ ..";!$

$!%.1!$ 6"&$ 51"0($

22!..( ;&#!7 -6&(5

.&6&(5 '2"0'!

1!'2"($!( -0'9($*

91&!# #% '

%'!

1!'2"($!(

-0'9($ #&.!$

2! & &"( &($0

11&5!

% 7 <<

'-"1 = -!

% > &( !1 .&7 %"( !($&(5

'".!8(&?!$ @* *<

2!1 &($0 1& !'* # !1 811&5!7 .&6!$ "5! -!1

-0'9($ ;&#!7 &''0!

9"1( "0

;!$."%A* 6!11!$ %"((&6(%!

21!( '

1!. &6!'

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ 2!1#"18!$ 22!..( ;&#!7 $!'2& !

#% '-!

.1!$:

811&!$ "(!

-186&1

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ #&.!$

%"82.&(

5&('

-!8 ,!% &"('

7 7 B

#01 -!1 6!11!$ 2! & &"( #% 08 21!6&"0'

$8& !$

2! & &"( #&.!$ < 1***

2! & &"( & '!.#7 22!..( #.'!.:

8!( &"(!$

-189&1 $&''".6!$ +** 80 0..:

-!1!

"9 &(!$

21!6&"0'

-0'9($ #1"8 %"82! !( .;*

6!11!$ 1!'2"($!( -0'9($ #% 08

21!6&"0'

%"(%!.!$

#8&.:

8!89!1'* 22!..( ;&#!

.'"

#01(&'-!$ #.'!

&(#"18 &"( ':&(5 '-!

0(811&!$

1!'2"($!( -0'9($7 9!#"1!

!5&' 11

11&5!7 .;1 9!#"1!

(%"8!

C 0 -"1& &!'7 ;-&.!

"9 &(&(5 %1$* %-! !$

$!%!&6!$

1!'2"($!( -0'9($

21"6&$&(5

;1"(5

&(#"18 &"( 1!51$&(5 &$!( & :

9!#"1!

0 -"1& &!'*

!'&$!'

-&'7 22!..( ;&#!

#&.!$

#.'!

%"82.&(

**D

9!#"1!

,!(&"1

,02!1&( !($!(

".&%!7

!-51- ,-&97 5&('

1!'2"($!( -0'9($

21!( '

1!51$&(5 $!8($ $";1:

#%!$ '0%-

'& 0 &"(7 1!'2"($!( -0'9($ ;& -$1;

2! & &"(

% 1!' & 0 &"( %"(405.

1&5- '* (

-!'!

21!8&'!'7 2.!$!$ 1!'2"($!( -0'9($

$!%.1!$ 6"&$*

2"( (" &%!7 22!1!$ #&.!$

;1& !( ' !8!( * ' !$ -!1!&( 2! & &"(

#&.!$ 1!'2"($!( -0'9($ 911!$ %"($0%

1!'2"($!( -0'9($* #% 08 $8& !$*

, &..

#01 -!17 #% 08 !1.&!1 "(!

-186&1 .'"

$8& !$7 6!11!$

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ ;1!

21!6&"0'

2!1#"18!$

'"0($ $&'2"'&(5 8&($* #01 -!1

2.!$!$ ;!1!

#"..";!1'

&1(A1& ,!%

-!:

;!1!

5"6!1(!$ %0' "8'

,!% * %%"1$&(5

%0' "8'

21!6&.&(5 &1(A1& ,!% 7 $&''".0 &"(

%0' "81:

1!%"5(&?!$ -!1!#"1!7

%0' "81:

"9 &(!$ 9!#"1!

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ 6.&$ %(

1! !$ !E0&6.!(

$&6"1%!* #01 -!1

2.!$!$ #% 08 21!6&"0'

A(";.!$5!

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ $8& !$

'8!

2! & &"( % * #01 -!1

6!11!$ 1!'2"($!( -0'9($ #8&.:

8!89!1'

"1 01&(5 1&'&(5 $!8($

$";1:

-!:

%"82!..!$ 9"1 %-&.$ 5&('

$!'&1!* %%"1$&(5.:7 21:!1 $&'8&''.

2! & &"(

8$!*

( 9'&'

2.!$&(5'

21 &!'7

.!1(!1 #18!$ 8(:

'!6!( &''0!'

;-&%-

0($!1)

G-! -!1 2! & &"(!1 1!'2"($!(

6"&$ 2! & &"(!1 !( & .!$

&6"1%!

6"&$

. !1( &6!.:7 ;-! -!1 1!'2"($!( %"(%!.!$

#% 08 !1.&!1

6"&$9.!

G-! -!1 2! & &"( 8&( &(9.!

21!'!( #"18H

G-! -!1 2! & &"( 2! & &"(!1 ;& -&(

.&8& &"(H

G-! -!1 2! & &"(!1 !' "22!$ %

%"($0% H

G-! -!1 1!'2"($!( !' "22!$

";( % %"($0% H

!.&!#*J

!6&$!(%!7 1!'2"($!( -0'9($ !C8&(!$

-&8'!.# G #01 -!1 !C8&(!$ 184& ,&(5-

,09-'- -($!1 / -01& G G+ .'"

!($!1!$

$"%08!( C-&9& * ( " -!1 -($7

!6&$!(%!7 !C8&(!$ -!1'!.# G7

# -!1 G7 '2.

,&(5- G+7 1(!A ,&(5- G

KA-6&1 ,&(5- G<7 9!'&$!'

.!$&(5 $"%08!( 1:

!6&$!(%!*

.!1(!$ ;-&.!

..";&(5 2! & &"(

#&.!$ 1!'2"($!( -0'9($7 $!%.1!$

6"&$* 40$58!(

%-..!(5!

21!'!( 22!.*

K!1(!$ %"0('!.

22!1&(5

6!-!8!( .:

150!$ -!1!

21""# 21!6&"0'

-186&17 &('80%- 91"05-

1!%"1$ 1!51$'

2!1#"18(%!

,2 2$& .;( !1

811&5!* #01 -!1 %"( !($!$ #% 7

#% 08 !1.&!1

-189&1

A(";.!$5!

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ $8& !$

#% 2! & &"( #&.!$ % *

#01 -!1 '098& !$ -"05- 1!'2"($!( -0'9($

2.!$!$ 2! & &"( 9!#"1!

22!..(

%-! !$ -&87 :!

#% 8 !1 -6&(5 A(";(

#0..:

;!..

811&!$

1!'2"($!( -0'9($7 1!'2"($!( -0'9($ ;-"

%"88& !$ %-! &(5 ;&#!

#&1' .:

$!'!1 &(5 -!1!

-!( #&.&(5 2! & &"(* &'7 -0'7

150!$ "(%!

22!..( ;&#!

21"$0%!$ 1!%"1$

80 0.

51!!8!( +**7 -!1!

"%%'&"(

$&'%1$ '8!

-".$

6"&$*

&'7 #01 -!1

150!$ 8. 1! !$

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ #8&.:

8!89!1'

-1";( "0

8 1&8"(&.

-"8!

"1$!1 '6!

-!8 #1"8

%1&8&(.

21"'!%0 &"(

-($ 22!..( ;&#!7

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ $!6&'!$ 8!%-(&'8 #&.&(5

2! & &"(*

-6!

-!1$ .!1(!$ %"0('!.

22!..(

-6!

.'"

5"(!

-1"0540$58!( 2''!$

"01 *

'".!

&''0!

1&'!'

%"('&$!1 &"( 9!#"1!

;-! -!1 #&($&(5 1!%"1$!$

.1!$:

811&!$

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ ($7 -!1!#"1!7

6"&$7 '0##!1'

#1"8

2!16!1'& :

&..!5.& :*

1!51$ ;"1 - (" &%&(5 22!..( ;&#!

;1& !( ' !8!( $8& !$ #% 08

21!6&"0'

-189&1* ";!6!17 '-!

""A

2.!

-189&1 $&''".6!$

80 0.

51!!8!( $ !$ +*** ";

E0!' &"( 1&'!'

;-! -!1 80 0.

51!!8!(

6.&$ .;

(" * ' ($

9!#"1!

;!1!

5"6!1(!$

&1(A1& ,!% 2!1 %0' "8'

21!6&.&(5

,!% 7

#"..";!1'

,!% 7 %(

$&''".6!$ ;:

80 0.

51!!8!( $&6"1%!*

(" &%!$ $! &.

21""# ( &E0& :7

%"( &(0(%!

0(&( !1102 !$ %0' "87 &(6".6!$ 21!'!( &"(

-&' "1&%.

!6&$!(%!7 !' &8"(&!'

$"%08!( &"( '2((&(5

%"('&$!19.!

2!1&"$ %"0.$ &(%.0$!

-&' "1&%.

1!%"1$'7 %"880(& :

1$& &"('

2''!$ $";( -1"055!(!1 &"('

!C2!1 "2&(&"('

##&18&(5 %"('&' !( 21% &%!

%0' "8* #"0($ ("(!

;& (!''!'

%"8!

#"1;1$ ' !

' ;!..

$&''".0 &"( -!1!"# #8&.:

9" - 21 &!'7 5"6!1(!$ '2!%&#&% %0' "8 &*!*

%0' "8 21!6&.!$ #"..";!$ #"..";!1'

&1(A1&

,!% *

1!.!6( !C 1% '

#1"8 40$58!( ;"0.$

1!$ 0($!1)

FLL**82"1 ( .:7 !' 9.&'-&(5 ( &E0& :7 %"( &(0(%!7

0(&( !1102 !$ %0' "87 &(6".6!'

21!'!( &"( -&' "1&%.

!6&$!(%!7

!' &8"(&!'

$"%08!( &"(

'2((&(5

%"('&$!19.!

2!1&"$* -&'

%"0.$ &(%.0$!

-&' "1&%.

1!%"1$'7

%"880(& :

1$& &"('

2''!$ $";( -1"05- 5!(!1 &"('7

!C2!1 "2&(&"('

##&18&(5 %"('&' !( 21% &%!

%0' "8*

'-"0.$ $!8"(' 1 !

."(5 ' ($&(5 !C&' !(%!

%"('&' !( 21% &%!

%0' "8 "6!1 ( !C !($!$ 2!1&"$*

"(!

;& (!''!'

9!-.# 1!'2"($!( %"8!

#"1;1$ ' !

811&5!'

;!..

$&''".0 &"(

811&5!'

#8&.:

9" - 5"6!1(!$ '2!%&#&%

%0' "8 &*!* %0' "8 21"6&$!$ &1(A1& ,!% * G

;-"

# -!1 1!'2"($!( $8& !$ %1"'' !C8&( &"( 9!."(5'

,&A- %"880(& :

%%"1$&(5.:7 2!1 21"6&'&"('

&($0

11&5!

% -!:

%"8!

$!#&(& &"( &($07 -!1!#"1!7 -!:

5"6!1(!$ &($0

11&5!

% * 1!'2"($!( -6&(5

82.!

"22"1 0(& &!'

'088"( ;& (!''

#1"8 &1(A1&

($.

!' 9.&'- 21"6!

%0' "8 $&''".0 &"(

2(%-: & .E(8 1!'2"($!(

91"05- 1!%"1$ 21"6!

!C%!2 G+ G<*

-!&1 !' &8"(:

$"!'

#0.#&..

!''!( &.'

8!( &"(!$ 9"6!

"1$!1 21"6!

6.&$

%0' "8* "(6!1'!.:7 2! & &"(!1 !C8&(!$ G+ ,09'-

-($!1 / -01& ;-"

,!;$1 ,( &1(A1&

($.

!5$* $8&(&' 1 &6!

."%A7 &1(A1& ,1"61 "82.!C

011& "$7

!.-& !' &8"(:

"94!% !$

51"0($ 2!1'"( ;-"

'088"(!$

21!'!( %'!* 2! & &"(!1 8"6!$ ( 22.&% &"(

@**+ '088"(&(5 ;& (!''

#1"8

($.

;"0.$ 5"

'-";

2! & &"(!1 '088"(!$ "5&($!1 ,0A-!4 ,!%1! 1:

!89!1 &(%-15!

,"%&.

G!.#1!

!21 8!( ,(

&1(A1&

($.7 &1(A1& -";A7

011& "$7

!.-&*

2! & &"(!1 '088"(!$ ..

10.!'7 1!50. &"('

%0' "8

1!51$&(5 221"6!$ ,( &1(A1&

($.M,( &1(A1&

&''&"( 21!6.!( 8"(5'

#"..";!1'

&1(A1&

&''&"(* G+ ,09'- -($!1 / -01&

'098& !$ 1 "* ##&$6& C*G+M

!C8&( &"(&(%-&!# 0 -"1&?!$ ,!%1! 1:

,( &1(A1&

($.

!5$* $!2"'!

%'!*

-!1!#"1!7 "94!% &"( 1&'!$ K$* "0('!.

1!'2"($!(

%"82! !(%!

!C8&( &"( 21!'!( ;& (!''

'0' &(9.!* G+ 21"6!$ $"%08!( C* G+M *

!' &8"(:

G+ %-..!(5!$ 1!51$&(5 811&5!'

%0' "8'

22.&%9.!

&1(A1& ,!% * G+ 21"6!$

10.!'

1!50. &"('

5"6!1(&(5 ..

811&5!'

&1(A1&

,!% ;-&%- C*G+M * %.!1 #1"8 C* G+M

,( &1(A1&

($.

81& .

' 0'

;"8( '-"0.$ 0(811&!$7 $&6"1%!!7 ;&$";

;&$";!1*

#01 -!1 %.1&#&!$ %'!

$&6"1%!!7 %"2:

&''0!$

.($ '-"0.$ %-!$* :7 #01 -!1

% !5"1&%..:

;1& !( 51!!8!( 8$!

"( 0$&%&.

, 82

2!1'

" 1:M18

(%-:

!' &"( ;&..

%%!2 !$* .'"7 %'!

;&$";7

;&$";!1 $! - %!1 &#&% !

$!%!'!$ '-"0.$ %-!$*

1!'2"($!( -6&(5 82.!

"22"1 0(& :

1!90 "1.

;!..

$"%08!( '

21"$0%!$ G+

1!'2"($!( 91"05- 1!%"1$

%"( 1$&% !' &8"(:

+* -!17 9!%"8!

%.!1

#1"8 ;& (!''!'

2! & &"(!1 &1(A1& ,!% "(.:

2!18& '

811&5!'

%"('"((%!

21"6&'&"('

.($* .!(5 -:

%1"''!C8&( &"( %"($0% !$ 02"(

G+ !' &8"(:

G+ %.!1 %"('&' !( !%-

!6!1:

1!.!6( 2"&( * " -&(5 #6"019.!

1!'2"($!(

%"0.$ !.&%& !$ #1"8 %1"''!C8&( &"(* -!1!#"1!7

!' &8"(:

G+ &('2&1!'

%"(#&$!(%!*

"1!"6!17 G+ G<

-6!

91"05- 1!%"1$ &(' (%!

%0' "81:

&1(A1& ,!% -6&(5 1!%"5(& &"( .;

.($*

-!1!#"1!7 51!!8!( G+M 6.0!

!:!'

.;* %"'

1!2! & &"(7 &(%089!( $0 :

1!'2"($!( 21"6!

6.&$ %0' "8 .!$&(5 %"5!(

%"(6&(%&(5 1!'2"($!( 8&'!19.:

#&.!$

21"6!

'0%- %0' "8 %( '#!.:

%"(%.0$!$

1!'2"($!(

-186&1 '09'&' &(5

2! & &"(!1

1!'2"($!( *

01 -!18"1!7 51!!8!( C*G+M %( %"('&$!1!$

(%-: & -6&(5 6.0!

!:!'

.;LLJ

1"8 9"6!

#&($&(5 "01 7 %.!1

#&.!$

!' 9.&'- %0' "8 ;-&%-

51!!8!( 21"$0%!$ %"0.$ -!.$

6.&$*

%%"1$&(5.:7 -!.$ (%-: &

21"$0%!$ -6&(5 6.0!

!:!'

.;*

"(>9.!

,021!8!

8(4& * $-6

3'* &18.7

, D+I7 -!.$ 21!6.!(%!

%0' "81:

%"880(& :

;-&%- 9!."(57

%"( 11:

5!(!1.

80'

'2!%&#&%..:

2.!$!$

!' 9.&'-!$ 21 :

21"2"0($&(5 '0%- %0' "8 #&.&(5

;-&%-7 '098&''&"( 9'!$ & 7 %(("

!( !1 &(!$

"01 * -!.$ 0($!1)

6&!;

&(%.&(!$ A!

22!.7 ;!

-&(A (!%!''1:

&( "

%"( !( &"('

$6(%!$ .!1(!$ %"0('!.

%'!7 9!%0'!

#&($ %"01 '

9!.";

-6!

!11"(!"0'.:

21"%!!$!$ 9'&'

$!!$ 1!.&!$ 02"( E0!' &"(

$"%08!( ;-&%- %%!2 9.!

.;* (" !$

$!!$ E0!' &"( 2012"1 !$

$"%08!(

;-&%- %.&8!$ %"(#"18& :

%0' "8'

22.&%9.!

%"880(& :

;-&%-

.& &5 &"( 9!."(5 "* '

2!1 &($0 .;

$8&(&' !1!$ %"01 '

($&

1!%"5(&'!$

8!('

( !($ 811&5!7 ;-&%-

.;:'

%"('&$!1!$

'%18!( 7 "(.:

!C%!2 &"( ;-!1!

1!%"5(&'!$ %0' "8* 09.&% 2".&%:7

5""$ 8"1.'

&( !1!' '

'"%&! :

;!1!

%"('&$!1!$

1!E0&1!

!('01!

- 7 &#

..7 '!6!1(%!

'-"0.$

..";!$ "(.:

8((!1 1!'"( %0'!

'2!%&#&!$ .;* -0'

'0%-

%0' "8 9!&(5 ( !C%!2 &"(

5!(!1.

"05- -6!

'2!%&..:

2.!$!$ !' 9.&'-!$ 21 :

21"2"0($&(5 '0%-

%0' "8 '&(%!

%0' "8 %"( 11:

.($ ;-&%-7 &# 21"6!$7 ;&..

21% &%!

"22"'!$ 209.&% 2".&%:* -!1!#"1!7 -!1!

(

"9.&5 &"( %"01 -6!

#18!$ ( &''0!

;-! -!1 -!1!

21"2!1 2.!$&(5'

21 :

%"( !($&(5 !C&' !(%!

%0' "81:

%"880(& :

;-&%- 9!."(5!$ ;-! -!1

'0%- %0' "81:

%"82.&(%!

8((!1

#"18.& &!'

!($( -!1! "

#% !' 9.&'-!$

%'!

-($ ' &'#% &"( %"01 *

&(' ( %'!7 ;!

-6!

2!10'!$ 2.!$&(5'

9!#"1!

%"01 ;!

#&($ 8 !1&.

'-";

21!6.!(%!

'0%- %0' "81:

%"880(& :7 9'!$ ;-&%- $"%08!(

91"05- &( "

!C&' !(%!

!6!1 2.!$!$

$!#!($( 1!E0&1!$ .;

.!$

%'!

'09' ( & !

'8!* 10!

%"01 '

9!.";

$&$ '2!%&#&%..:

4"&( &''0!

1!51$ E0!' &"( .;:!1'

22!1&(5

$&$ "1..:

51!!

$"%08!( E0!' &"(

#% %%"1$(%!

%0' "81:

21!6&.&(5 %"880(& :

;-&%- 9!."(5!$

%"('!('0'

21 %"0('!.

.%A

'0##&%&!( 2.!$&(5 2.&( ;1& !(

' !8!( ;"0.$ (" 7 "01 "2&(&"(7 2!18& %"01

%"0( !((%!

2.!

%0' "81:

0(.!''

0( &.

'0%- %0' "81:

21"2!1.:

!' 9.&'-!$

%"01 .;* "01 "2&(&"(7 !6!( -"05- 2.&( &##

8&5- -6!

E0!' &"(!$ 6.&$& :

%0' "81:

$&6"1%!7 %"01 "05- -6!

221!%& !$

%"('!E0!(%!'

-!1!

9!&(5

%0' "81:

9'!$ ;-&%- $"%08!( %"8!

&( "

!C&' !(%!

9!1&(5 8&($

%"('!(

.'"

1!%"5(&'9.!

%"01 0(.!''

'2!%&#&%..:

2!18& !$ .;* -!1!#"1!7 ;!

"2&(&"( $"

%"82.! !

40' &%!

%'!

(!%!''1:

%"01 $&1!% !$ #18!

'2!%&#&% &''0!

1!51$

%0' "81:

9'!$ ;-&%- $!!$ $ !$

DD@ %"8!

&( "

!C&' !(%!

;-&%-

'094!% 8 !1 '0& E0!' &"(* 1!51$7 ;!

2!18& 8!($ 2.!$&(5'7 &# -!:

$!'&1!

.'"

.!$ .&8& !$ !C !(

21"6&(5 !C&' !(%!

21"6&'&"( %0' "81:

" -!1;&'!

-1"05- 21"%!''

"0 '&$!

%"01

-!&1 %"880(& :

-!( !'

6.&$& :

$!!$ $ !$ DD@ 9'!$ #&($&(5 11&6!$

$!%&$&(5 (!;

&''0!*J

< % ' &20. !'

'".!8(&?!$ ;"

&($0'7 &# (!& -!1 21 :

'2"0'!

.&6&(5

811&5!* , &..

#01 -!17

% 7

' &20. !'

'".!8(&?!$

# !1

%"88!(%!8!( % 7 '-..

6"&$ 8:7

2! & &"( 21!'!( !$ !& -!1 21 :

-!1! "

5&('

" -!1

21 :7 '"

$!%.1!$

(0..& :7 &# %"( 16!(!'

%"($& &"('

'2!%&#&!$

%.0'!'

6 <*

% 7 21"6&$!'

(" -&(5%"( &(!$

% '-..

$!!8!$ ##!% 1&51!%"5(&'!$ %0' "8

%"(#!11!$ '2!%&.

!(% 8!( "9 &( $&''".0 &"(

&($0 811&5!7 ;-! -!1 '".!8(&?!$ 9!#"1!

# !1

%"88!(%!8!( % *

1!'2"($!( -0'9($ ;:

21"6!$ 1!%"1$

%"( 16!( &"( 21"6&'&"('

< % ($7

%%"1$&(5.:7 $!%.1!$ 6"&$

% *

"(.:

!C%!2 &"(

%"( &(!$ % 7 ;-&%-

#&.!$ !' 9.&'-* "

21"$0%!$

22!..( 21"6!

'-!

5"6!1(!$ 21"6&'&"('

% * -"05- .!1(!$ %"0('!.

150!$ 1!'2"($!( -0'9($

;1!

21!6&"0'

"(!

-186&1

. !17 :!

91"05-

1!%"1$ !##!% ;& (!''

!C8&(!$ 21"6!

#% A(";.!$5!

1!'2"($!(

-0'9($ '8!

91"05- (" &%!

21!'!(%!

2!1'"(*

%"0.$ '-";( .!1(!$ %"0('!.

22!..( 8&'1!$ A!( &( "

%"('&$!1 &"( "01 * -!1!#"1!7 ;!

#&($

40$58!( 2''!$ "01 7 '0##!1'

#1"8

&..!5.& :

2!16!1'& :

;11( &( !1#!1!(%!

21!'!( 22!.*

" -!1 2"&( 015!$*

6&!;

9"6!7 #&($&(5 8!1& '

21!'!(

22!.7 '8!

-!1!

$&'8&''!$*

2!($&(5 22.&% &"('

&# (: '-..

.'"

' ($

$&'2"'!$ "#*

*+*

1'-!1M$'

)

!'M"

)

!'M"