Nectar Lifesciences Limited And ORS v. Abb Limited And ANR.



 

   

     

 





!"#"

$%&'&'


   
 
 




 
 
 
 










%
 () & * 

* 

* () & * *

 ) 


 


 



 


 
! "
 
 
# 


 "
 
 

 
$ %%%%%


* 

*+& &

 '





$()**)**


 "+

!

 
! 
!  '
#"+

 
    ,  
- '





  
 

./
 "   
!    

$001
2 
 


3$001
34 
# 
 
*
24
 
1


!

 
!  
!

  , 
!

 

,
5 '
! 

*)$(

 '
 

"  
#

$/)0*)$6



"+

 " 
7
 
*
  
 
$
*  









  ! 
"#
  

 



#
# 
8  " 




 
#

 
# 
 
.$




$001


&
" '

:

'
#
#

 
   
 
" 

 

"

# 
# 
# '
  
 
$
 
; '



9



 


5 '
 




 +

<

;
 

"
 "



 +
 
+ 

#
 "

"



#
 
$ "


   +

"

  

" 


  
"+ 


 

 +





;
"+
 
$
# 
; '



9 . 

 
" 





# 


#


#
#
 
"+
 
$

!






"9 
.

 
.$


$001


"  #





# 


"



' 





"
' 


#

" 
#

'

.)

&
" '

9 
#
# 




 " '
 

 " 
 +
 





 
=
" 



:


  

  
8 +

 '

 "+




9  

#:
 '

 



+
:

'

;

   =
" 



+





'

)/)$*))6
"


  

:

 
  
$
 
 :


 

 
 
 

;
# 
 
# 
'


#
 '

;
  
$

!





 


# 
#

 

 '
   
 
 
25!4

'


"

 ' +
2 !4


&
 
&&
#

:+
"


&

"


 "  +



"  +
 
"
 "

 

 

&



  

#


+


'
 "
 



:
 +
  '


#
"

 


+


!

"

 
 '

+

<


<
  
#:



# 



"+


+
 :
"+

"     
# 

#
"+

" 

 + '
" +
 
#  
;

   

/  







 

 ;

'


5 3"
 
! 

**"!, -."$,#/ &) & 0#&1  -  -2#

# 0& & 1" .3-$- - -2# +2 "!

-"$ $ 

-#
*)*$
2.4
!
2! 4
16$


  





&


 
+
"+

 











$()**)**



"+

!

 
!  !  '
"

 
 

  
 
"+



  
./


$001

+
"

( >


 
 



 
$








"+

!

 
! 
!  '
#  

 


"

  


 
  

 

 
# 
#

=
#



"



"+


" 
7
 
*
 $/)0*)$6

"

  

 
   

" 
 

5







# 
'

 " '
+


<

;
 "




 

#

4


$
 '


"






+

# 
  +
# 
'



; "+
 
$

'

)/)$*))6
+
+

#

+
# 
#
 
 
8 

"





 


"
 

 
$

=

'

 
"+


#

 


 '
# 





 



? 



"


"+

 9 
2@ 4 
*A)**)$(

 




 
=
 
   

 
 

 
 



' " 

 '+











9


  
+


"


 

   " '


 '





#

$/)0*)$6 1  



 
*

 


 

! 
"#







#    
  "

./


$001

&


 '+
"  





./


$001

  



  +
 


< 

;

  

# 

 

 
#



 
A   
 
 " 


;

  
 #



#



"+


" 
 




 
$





#

"

# 
# 

' 

+
  


#

" 

#

 
#

=
  
 







" 
 

! 




<

5


#

./

=
#
" 
'



 

' 
 
" 
 +
'

 

 " 
 +

&  
 


 +

"+

! 

5




" 


#
 
 

!  

  

#
#




" 
6  



 
*

 
;

'

5 3"
 
! 

 )"."

0#&0 $  )"."

*)$0
2/4
!!
$1.

 


 
 
 
< '
"#
# 
 
"

 


# 

#

" 







&





 



  


;

'


5 3"  
! 

! -.

$

-$ $,$!&0#&2-$* $ - 

& ) &
*))1
2$$4
!!
$6$ 0 
'




 









9
 
"+

 

; "+

" 
#  
  '

  
# 



 
 



 
$





9


#
"



2

< 
!9$

!9.*4
# 
#


+
*))A
 
#
 
 


'

)/)$*))6

= 

'
 


 


 
 
#
'
 









 


# 
# 


#
#  '
 
#

"+
"

  

= 

 

  
"+

 '
 
    


" '
 
 



 '+
"
;
"+


6

" 


#

$/)0*)$6
 '


 


9 
 9 
"+

 

>
"




+





$) 5 '






"+

 




  

' '
 '



 $()**)**




"+

!

 
! 
!  '

 
  
  
# 

" '


 '
# 
 ;

'

 

"+

  



#



 #




8 




 $()**)**
 

 
# 
#
 
"
   

 



"+



 $$ =
:

  

 

  '

"#

"
 9


 #

 

 


+


 '
   
  
25!4
 
"

 ' +
2 !4


& 
&&

"





 
 +

'





 
5 
 

 
$
#





" 
# 


 




& 
#


"+
 
 '

 
$


'
  
  ?#:


#
 '
   
 
 
25!4
 
"



' +
2 !4

8 


 

+


'  ?#:

#
 

 






 



  '
# 

#:
 
$

"  
 

&  


'



;
#  


-


*))1
 
, "
*))1
  +

 
&
 
 
&&

7

# 
# 
 

 
 

+


< 
 )/)$*))6
#

+
#
+


 


 


,
 
"# 



 '




 
$


 

8  
 <  



 '

+
 


8  
<



 

 


C  +
  
 
 








#



 
# 
#
  "+
 
$

@
  

 
#:

# 

 


"
'
"# 

'
#

 '





'

)/)$*))6

&  
'

 +
  "    
+ 
#
9 


 


 
#

 
$
"



+  
#
 
 
 

 
  

 

 '
# 


  

=




 9 
"+
 
$
 # 


   
#


 


 


 







  

'
# 



 
"+
"





  
# 
#



 

+ 
"+


 
 


' 
:

'
+
  

  


 
#
 
 

&

 

# 


 
 



 


'






# 


 
# 
# 
  
' 



 "    

&

 





9


 9 
"+


" 


" 

"

8


  



# 
#
 






'

)/)$*))6
=
" 
 


 '+


 


 


 


# 
 "
  
 



"


"


 '



9

;
"+

 

=
 ' 

 "   

 
#
 

'
# 

" 
 "




 '




 9 
"+
 
$


9
;
"+

 
&






"
 

 #



 
" 
  




:

'
#
$* 
'



 




 
+

<

;
 
" +
 "



 

 
$




+


 
 


+

# 


#

D
 '

"
'


"+
  




  

#
"


  
# 
# 

"


! 

<


#

.A


$001


&

"+
#



#


! 
# 
<

'
 
#

./
 .A


$001



:
  


 

#


&



 

" 
#
 

  
 


'

 

./
2*4
2"4
2 4



#

'



 " 
 +

&   !   


  
  
;

 
 
 
' +


 

  
#

&  

 

  

$001







 
# 
# 
  

! 


9




" 
#

&
+





 
#


 
./
2*42"42 4


$001

< 
 +
 
# 
"


"

&
+
"




 

#

" +
  


  
:

'



  

! 

#

' +

 
"


'








"
 



#

 

'
+
"



;

'


5 3"
 
! 

## !"

2", -0#&
*)$(
2.4
!!
/0

$. =
5 3"
 
! 



    
 

 
2

4



# 
 '



 
  
 
< '
# 
 
"
  




# 

" 3
;

  








= " 
 
#

+
;

:




  

' 
 '
"
 

"#

 

 

 



'

)/)$*))6 # 



#
 +

"+
"

 
  '
  "  +


 


 

 

+ 

"
 

'  
#
 
#
 

=
 

 '
"
  




"+

" 


9 
"+
 
$

  


# 



"

 

"
#  
 +
"


;

  


"
 

"
" 



  
$/ 
'

;

'


 

"+

 




  


 
  
 
2

4 
  
 
#


#

 
"

"+




! 
# 
<

'
#

./


$001



 "
8 


" 

 
" '

" ;
"+

 





"

  
"+
 !

 
! 
# 


'




 
#
 



 +
' +

 +


'

 
#
 

./
2*42"42 4

"
< 
# 
# 
  

"+

!  =
#
" '




#
"

  


  

"+

 


"+


 
 

" 
  
# 



 +



! 


 
' +
 


#



# 
 
"
 

' '



 



$( =
  
 
#
"+

5 3"
 
! 


 
  
 
2

4

 
"+




 
# 

"
 +



 

&
+
"

 


! 



 
"+ 

   

' 

  
./
@
<
#

.A




<








  


 
./

&

  

  
#

!

 
! 





"  #


! 

<

#

.A



"
< +



#

 "


  


$1 =
#

;

  
 #
" '
   
 
'  

./


$001



"
 


 
     

"
< 
"+

! 



 







# 
 
 "

! 

< 

#





# 

" 
#

$A &
#


" 
#



 +
'



# 



$()**)**



"+

!

 
!  !  '


 

 
 



" '
  
   


7
  
 &

 '









 8 

"



 
   
+
 


" 




, 



   

* 

*    &'&'

 *

 )  

           !

   

"
 !