High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2256/2019dismissed

Rajinder Kumar Mehta v. Rinkesh Malhotra

2019-03-26Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain,Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill8 pages

!" #$%$!&'()(

*$&+ ,-./ , &+ 0 ,% ((1((22 33 &% 4 ,%.%

$&5 %0

30!, 1(( %2!&+ & ' 67

( 8 -8-

( 8 8877

, % &'

,(90$/ &:.- 3%:;+<!# ;"!,0 &%(

0$% 3 $% +$, # + $&% 0 !,+ , + )((> 2 %% + 9: 0 3 ,& + .

& .+= ; 7.+0$ & ; ?0 , 9:2 $$!& .&+ ,8 #$!&%>; &+ !"0 .

&+ @ ,+% #; > "!, %0!, A0 #6 ; "$3 + 9: , %2!&+ &

$&5 %0

30!, ; 9 $&= 0 "

0 , !" 0 /$&!, #0$3+, &; 0 9 & 33!? + &+0 #.%!+:!"0 #0$3+, &$%0 &+ +!< ,! 0$/( 80!,& !" 33 .&& # %% ,: + $3%; +/$ + "

#% !& , #!,+ , 0 , %2!&+ & $&5 %0

30!, ?

% / ,,$ + ! 0 & ; + .=0 , !" & !%( &+ %$% ,!" &!();!&(((?!#0$3+, &? , 9!,& !. !" 0 % $+ ? +3!#5( 0 & #!//$ + %.$#$+ !& B(B(B , = ,+$&= ?0$#0 !( + + (B(B .&+ , 8 #$!& ) ?

%, =$% , + !3$# 8 $!&$<$%$!&!(); 7.+0$ & ; $&%0 , %2!&+ &(0 , %2!&+ &?

,, % +

" ,0 <$&="

# +0 ,$ 3;0 ?

#C.$ +!"0 #0 ,= % 3 < 33 + $&% 0$/( .,%.

& ! 0$% #C.$ 3; 0 %!.=0 #.%!+:!"0 #0$3+, &;& / 3:;+ .=0 ,&= 3

30!, = + :

,% &+%!&&%./

30!, = +:

,%;?0!? , 3$<$&= ?$0 0 / ,& 3 =, &+2 , &%; " , 0 $, /!0 , 0 #!//$ + %.$#$+ &+ 0 , %2!&+ & ?

% $&<!3< + $& 0 , =$% , +"!,0 % $+!"" &# ( 0 2 $$!&"$3 +9:0 , %2!&+ &?

%, %$% +9: &%9:"$3$&= ?,$ &% / & < ,,$&=0 , $&0 0 &

30!, ;/!0 ,!"0 /$&!,%;0 +#!//$ +%.$#$+ !& ##!.& !" 0 9 / & !" 0 , %2!&+ &D 0 0 , %2!&+ &?

%&!2 :$&=/ $& & &# !0 #0$3+, &D0 0 , %2!&+ &0 &+!& +0 #0$3+, & &+0 0 &% ? , # 93 !"9,$&=$&=.20 #0$3+, & &+=$<$&=0 /2,!2 , +.# $!&( &0 23 +$&=%;0 3 ,& +,$ 3!.,", / +0 "!33!?$&=$%%. %' ( @0 0 , 0 2 $$!& , $% &$3 + "!, 0 #.%!+: !" 0 /$&!, + .=0 , &+ %!& 2, : +"!,E

( @0 0 , 0$% !., 0 % &! *.,$%+$#$!& ! + #$+ 0 2, % &2 $$!&E

)( 3$ "(

,$ %3 +0 $,, %2 #$< <$+ &# (

&+ ,$%%. !(;0 !&.%!2,!< ?0 , !"?

%!& 0 , %2!&+ &;0 3 ,& +,$ 3!.,; " ,0 <$&= 22, #$ 0 <$+ &# !&, #!,+;, .,& + "$&+$&=0 $#!.3+&!9

) %0!?& %!$&?0 / && ,;0 , %2!&+ &?

%&!#!/2 & !0 < 0 #.%!+:!"0 #0$3+, &( %$+ %;0 , %2!&+ &0

3%! F /$& +0$%/!0 , @ !!& /

30!, ;!2,!< ,",!/0$/;0$%/!0 ,$% 3%!0 , ! 5 # , !"0 #0$3+, &( 0 3 ,& + ,$ 3 !.,; " , 0 <$&= F /$& + 0 +!#./ &% F( ! (; # / ! 0 #!&#3.%$!& 0 0 <$&= , = ,+ ! 0 2!!, &+ &# !" 0 #0$3+, & $& 0 8#0!!3; $

, +0 0 #0$3+, &? , &!9 $&=2,!<$+ +9 %!"0 +.# $!& 9: 0 &%( " , 0 <$&= 2 ,%!& 3 $& , #$!& ?$00 #0$3+, &;0 3 ,& +,$ 3!.,# / !0 #!&#3.%$!& 0 + %$, !" 0 #0$3+, & ! , / $& ?$0 0 $, / ,& 3 =, &+2 , &% $% 9 # .% !" 0 $, &+ , = 3 +$&= ! $&+ #$%$< & %% !& 0 $, 2 ,( ?

% "!.&+ 0 / , 3: 9 # .%

.&+ ,8 #$!&) ?

%, =$% , + $&%0 & "!, 0 33 = + 9 / & !" %.$#$+ !" 0$% ?$" ; #!.3+ &! 9 =,!.&+ ! + 2,$< 0$/ 0 #.%!+: !" 0 #0$3+, &; %2 #$ 33: ?0 &0 %!!+ #C.$ +$&0 % $+2,!# +$&=%(?

%".,0 , "!.&+0 0!.=00 &%0 +, %!.,# %!/ $& $&0 #0$3+, &;: /!& :#!.3+9 5 &!9 0 !&3:#!&%$+ , $!&( !&%$+ ,$&=0 "

#0 9!00 #0$3+, & , /$&!,

&+ &! $& 33$= & &!.=0 ! .&+ ,% &+ 0 $, ? 33 9 $&=; 0 ,& +,$ 3!.,;"!.&+0 , %2!&+ &"

0 ,;"$!0 < 0 $, #.%!+:; %#!/2 , +!0 $,!3+ = +/ ,& 3=, &+2 , &%( 0.%; $%%. !( ?

% + #$+ + $& "

<!., !" 0 , %2!&+ &

$&%0 &%(

B %0 2 ,$ % 3%!0 /$&!,#0$3+, &;? , 3$<$&=

7.+0$ & ; $%%. !( , = ,+$&= *.,$%+$#$!&; ?

% + #$+ + $& "

<!.,!"0 , %2!&+ &0.%9 $&%0 &%( ,& + #!.&% 3 ,$&= "!, 0 &% 0

,=. +0 , %2!&+ &?

%9!!5 +"!,0 9 / &!"%.$#$+ !"0$%?$" /!0 ,!"0 /$&!,#0$3+, & (0!.=0;0 0 %%$&# 9 & #C.$ +; : $ , / $&% $/2,$& + $& 0 /$&+% !" 0 #0$3+, & 0 $ ?

% 0 $, "

0 ,; ?0! +,!< 0 $, /!0 , ! #!//$%.$#$+ ($%".,0 , ,=. +0 ?$00$%$/2, %%$!&$& 0 /$&+%!"0 #0$3+, &;$?!.3+&!9 2!%%$93 "!,0 /! , %$+ ?$0 0 $, "

0 , &+ F2 # &+ F2, %% &: 3!<

"" #$!&( 0.%; < & $" 0 #.%!+: !" 0 #0$3+, & $% 0 &+ + !< , ! 0 , %2!&+ &; %$33 0 "!, % $+ $&#$+ & ?!.3+ #!&$&. ! 0 .& 0 / "!, 33 $/ % ! #!/ ( 0$% %2 #;

##!,+$&=!0 3 ,& +#!.&% 3;0 %9 &!

33:9,.%0 + %$+ 9:0 3 ,& +,$ 3!.,;?0$3 2 %%$&=0 $/2.=& +!,+ ,( @ 0 < 0 ,+ 3 ,& + #!.&% 3 "!, 0 &%; 9.? +!&!"$&+ &:/ ,$$&0 2, % & 3(

!, + ,/$&$&= 0 C. %$!& !" #!/2 &# !" 0 0.%9 &+6% 223$# $!& .&+ , 8 #$!& !" 0 #; $ $% & # %% ,:! F /$& 0 %#0 / !"0 # 3%!0 , 3 < & 2,!<$%$!&% !" 0 &+$ & $<!,# #( 0 # ?

% & # + $& !,+ , ! #!&%!3$+ / &+ 0 3 ? , 3 $&= ! .

&+ @ ,+%( . % 2,!<$+ + 9: 8 #$!& ); 0 # $% &! ! 9 #!&%,.# +; $& , 3$ ; ! 5 ?

: 2!? , 2!%% %% + 9: &: $=0!.,(0 2,!<$%$!&%!"8 #$!&%G &+!"0 #

! 9 #!&%$+ , + 9: 0 !., $& 22!$&$&= !, + #3 ,$&= =.

&(0 % $+2,!<$%$!&%, %.&+ ,' HG(

,!9 #!&%$+ , +9:0 !.,$& 22!$&$&= =.

&( & 22!$&$&=!,+ #3 ,$&=0 =.

&!"

/$&!,;0 !.,%0 33;%.9* #!0 2,!<$%$!&%!"0$% % #$!&;9 =.$+ +9:?0 ;#!&%$% &3:?$00 3 ?! ?0$#0 /$&!, $% %.9* #;

,% $& #$,#./% &# %!9 "!,0 ? 3"

, !"0 /$&!,( &#!&%$+ ,$&=?0 ?$339 "!,0 ? 3"

, !"0 /$&!,;0 !.,%%0 330 < , = ,+!0 = ;% F , 3$=$!&!"0 /$&!,;0 #0 , # , &+# #$:!"0 2,!2!% +=.

&+0$%& ,& %%!"5$&!0 /$&!,; 0 ?$%0 %; $" &:; !" + # % + 2 , &; &: F$%$&=!,2, <$!.%, 3 $!&%!"0 2,!2!% +=.

?$00 /$&!,!,0$%2,!2 ,:( "0 /$&!,$%!3+ &!.=0!"!,/ &$& 33$= & 2, " , &# ;0 !.,/ :#!&%$+ ,0 2, " , &# ( 0 !.,%0 33&! 22!$&!,+ #3 &:2 ,%!& !9 =.

$&%0$%?$33( FF FF FF ( .

& &! ! 9 22!$& + 9: 0 !., $& # , $& # % %( !0$&= $& 0$% 0 2 , %0 33 .0!,$% 0 !., ! 22!$& !, + #3 =.

& !" 0 2,!2 ,: !" /$&!, ?0!% 2,!2 ,: $% .&+ , 0 %.2 ,$& &+ &# !" !., !" @ ,+% !, ! 22!$& !, + #3 =.

& !" 0 2 ,%!& !" /$&!, ?0! $% / ,,$ + " / 3 &+ ?0!% 0.%9 &+ $% &!; $& 0 !2$&$!&!"!.,;.&"$!9 =.

&!"0 ,2 ,%!&;!, !" /$&!, ?0!% "

0 , $% 3$<$&= &+ $% &! $& 0 !2$&$!&!"0 !.,;.&"$!9 =.

&!"0 2 ,%!& !"0 /$&!,;!,!" /$&!,?0!% 2,!2 ,:$%.&+ ,0 %.2 ,$& &+ &# !" !., !" @ ,+% #!/2 & !

22!$& =.

&!"0 2 ,%!&!"0 /$&!,(I 0 !&693 8.2, / !., !" &+$ $& !%: #!9 4%( #!9(0 5, / 3;G) 8>B;0 3+ %.&+ ,' HB( & !., !2$&$!&; 8 #$!& !" 0 . &% &+ @ ,+% # #!& /23 % &! !&3: #.

3 20:%$# 3 #.%!+: 9. 3%! #!&%,.#$< #.%!+: !" 0 =.

?0$#0 ,/ $&#3.+ % 33 # =!,$ % !" =.

&%( 0 !9* # &+ 2.,2!% !" 0$% 2,!<$%$!& 9 $&= F " #$ ! &%., 0 ? 3"

, !"0 /$&!,?

,+;?0$#0& # %% ,$3: $&<!3< % +. 2,! #$!& !" 0 ,$=0 !" 0$% =. & ! 2,!2 ,3:3!!5 " ,0 ?

,+J%0 30;/ $& & &# &+ +.# $!&; 0$% % #$!& + / &+% , %!& 93: 3$9 , 3 $& ,2, $!& %! % ! "" #.

0 !9* #( :2 , #0&$# 3$$ % %0!.3+ &! 9 33!? + ! + 2,$< 0 =.

&!"0 & # %% ,: %%$% &# ",!/0 !.,$& "" #$< 3: +$%#0 ,=$&= 0$% +.$ %

!93$= $!&% !?

,+%0$%?

,+%! %!2,!/! 0 3 ,J%? 3"

, (" 0 !.,.&+ ,0 $<!,# ## &&!/ 5 &:!,+ , ?$0 , %2 # ! 0 #.%!+: !" *$' 3$ % &+, ?

,: &+$$%&!!2 &!0 !.,.&+ , 0 .

&% &+ @ ,+% # ! 22!$& !, + #3 =.

&!"0 2 ,%!&!"0$%#0$3+, &.&+ ,8 #$!& +.,$&=0$%3$" $/ ;$"0 !.,%+! %&!#!&%$+ ,0$/ .&"$; 0 &; 0 !&3: 2,!<$%$!& ! ?0$#0 0 " 0 , # < , %!, "!, 0$% #0$3+, &J% #.%!+: $% 8 #$!& ( @$0!.; 0 , "!, ; :$&= +!?& F0 .%$< 3: #$,#./% &# % $& ?0$#0 8 #$!& # & 9 $&<!5 +; $& !.,!2$&$!&;!&0 "

#% &+#$,#./% &# %!"0$%# % 0 0.%9 &+J% 223$# $!& .&+ , 8 #$!& ?

#!/2 & ?$0 , %2 # ! 0 ?! 3+ , #0$3+, &( 0 !.,?

% &$3 +!#!&%$+ , 330 +$%2. +C. %$!&% !""

#!,3 ?2,!2 ,3:, $% +9 "!, $, 3 $&=!0 % ?! #0$3+, &( @$0 , %2 # !

0 %0 3$ % 0!/ %; 0!? < ,;0 !.,.&+ ,0 $<!,# #$% 2, % & /2!? , + ! / 5 %.$ 93 !,+ ,% , 3 $&= ! 0$% #.%!+:; / $& & &# &+ +.# $!&( $% 0 , "!, ; %!/ ?0 +$""$#.3 ! $/2. ! 0 7 =$%3 ., $& &$!& ! % .2 &!0 , 2 , 33 3 !., ! + 3 ?$0 0 C. %$!&!"0 #.%!+:!" /$&!,?0$#0$%?$0$& 0 2!? ,!" #!/2 &!.,.&+ ,0 $<!,# #( @ , .& 93 ! ## + !0 , %2!&+ &J%%.== %$!& 0$% 223$# $!&%0!.3+9 #!&%$+ , +!0 < 9 & 2, " ,, +"!, 22!$&$&=!,+ #3 ,$&=0$/ =.

&( .?0 0 ,0 , %2!&+ &J%2, : ,"!,#.%!+:!"0 /$&!,#0$3+, &9 #!&%$+ , +.&+ ,0 .

&% @ ,+%#!,.&+ ,0 &+$ &$<!,# #; %!9% ,< + 9:

, * & (; ?$0 ?0$#0 !9% ,< $!& ? &$, 3:

=, ; K0 #!&,!33$&= #!&%$+ , $!& =!< ,&$&= 0 #.%!+: !" 0 #0$3+, & $% 0 ? 3"

, !" 0 #0$3+, &

G #!&# ,& + &+&!0 ,$=0!"0 $,2 , &%K;?

%&! +$%2. + 0 .&+ , 0 &+$ & $<!,# # 0$% $% 0 #!&,!33$&= #!&%$+ , $!&( 0 !.,J% 2!? , .&+ , 8 #$!&!"0 .

&% &+@ ,+%#$% 3%!;$& !., !2$&$!&; ! 9 =!< ,& + 2,$/ ,$3: 9: #!&%$+ , $!& !" 0 ? 3"

, !" 0 /$&!,% #!&# ,& +( 0 +$%#, $!&< % +$&0 !.,$%; %$%0 # % ?$0

33*.+$#$ 3+$%#, $!&%!9 F ,#$% +*.+$#$!.%3:$&0 #5=,!.&+!" 330 , 3 < &"

#% &+#$,#./% &# %( #0# % 0 %!9 + #$+ +!&$%!?&"

#% &+!0 , # % %# &0 ,+3:% ,< %9$&+$&=2, # + &%;0 "

#% !" ?! # % % $& 0$% , %2 # 9 $&= % 3+!/$" < , $+ &$# 3(0 #!& &$!&0 $"0 0.%9 &+$%&!.&"$ ! 9 0 =.

& !" 0$% /$&!, #0$3+, &; 0 &; 0 C. %$!&!"0 $,? 3"

, +! %&! 33 ,$% $%!% 0 2,!2!%$$!& 9$ !! 9,!

+3: &+ / : $/ % 9 %!/ ?0 /$%3 +$&=(+! %&! 5 ".33&!$# !"0 , 3 #!, !" 0 % .!,: 2.,2!% ( & !., !2$&$!&; 0 +!/$& &#!&%$+ , $!&$&/ 5$&=!,+ ,%.&+ ,8 #$!& $% 0 ? 3"

, !" 0 /$&!, #0$3+, & &+ $& #!&%$+ ,$&=0$%C. %$!&+. , = ,+0 %!"#!.,% !9 $+ ! 0 ,$=0 !" 0 "

0 , ! 9 0 =.

3%!! 33!0 ,, 3 < &"

#!,%0 <$&= 9 ,$&=!&0 /$&!,J%? 3"

, (0 , $% 2, %./2$!&0 /$&!,J% , &% ?!.3+ +! 0 $, < ,: 9 % ! 2,!/! 0 $, #0$3+, &J% ? 3"

&+; $" & # %% ,:; ?!.3+ &! =,.+=

&: % #,$"$# !" 0 $, !?& 2 ,%!& 3 $& , % %., ( 0$% 2, %./2$!& ,$% % 9 # .% !" 0 & ., 3; % 3"3 %% "" #$!& &!,/ 33: F2 # + ",!/ 0 , &%"!,0 $,#0$3+, &(I +/$ +3:; $& 0 2, % & # % ; 0 , %2!&+ & "

0 ,0 2, " , &$ 3,$=0, = ,+$&=0 #.%!+:!"0 /$&!, #0$3+, &; 9 $&= 0 & ., 3 =.

&( &+$%2. + 3%! $% 0 2!%$$!& % , = ,+% 0 , %2!&+ &6% #C.$ 3 !" 0 !"" &# .&+ ,8 #$!&) (@ # &&!3!% %$=0!"0 "

#0 $& %.#0 # % %; ?0 , 2.,%.

& ! 0 %.$#$+ !" 0 /!0 ,; ?$0!. 5&!?$&= 0 #$,#./% &# % 3 +$&= ! 0 + 0 ".,0 , ?$0!. ?

$$&= "!, 0 !.#!/ !" 0 #,$/$& 3 ,$ 3; $"

> 0 /$&!,% , 2.$&0 #.%!+:!"0 / ,& 3=, &+2 , &%; 0 : ?!.3+ 3?

:% &+ .2 $& 9 3$ <$&= &:0$&= $&% 0 "

0 ,(&0$%# % ; %!"&!?;0 #0$3+, & , !"0 = !" :

,% &+ > :

,% , %2 #$< 3:( 0.%; 0 ,$ 3 !.,6% "$&+$&= 0 , %2!&+ &"

0 , %0!.3+ 9 33!? + ! F ,#$% 0$% ,$=0!"#.%!+:!"0 #0$3+, &;# &&!9 "!.&+"

.3?$0(@$0 0 =,!?$&= = &+,.0 / ,=$&=, = ,+$&=0 #.

3, %!&% "!, 0 $, /!0 ,6% + 0; 0 /$&!,% ?!.3+ 9 $& 2!%$$!& ! ".33: .&+ ,% &+ 0 $, ? 3"

&+ ".,0 , + 2 ! ## 2 0 3!< ; "" #$!& &+# , ;2,!<$+ +9:0 $,"

0 ,( &<$ ?!"0 9!< ;? +!&!"$&+ &:$33 = 3$:!, $&"$,/$: $& 0 !,+ , 2 %% + 9: 0 3 ,& + ,$ 3 !.,; ?0$#0 / :?

,, &$& ," , &# 9:0$%!.,$&0 2, % & 3( &# ;0 2, % & 3$%+$%/$%% +(

()( +% @0 0 ,82 5$&=L

%!& +' %L! @0 0 , 2!, 93 ' %L!