Jarmanjit Singh v. State Of Punjab
! "
#$ @6%! ! &
+(+ ) "!!% &' (
@6%+,& !% &'
!% &'
!% &'
!% &' %* %* %* %* !% &' ,-& !% &' ,-& !% &' ,-& !% &' ,-& / / / / !/ !/ !/ !/
/ / / / *$ 9 *$ 9 *$ 9 *$ 95
&.
#/ &.
#/ &.
#/ &.
#/ *$ 9 *$ 9 *$ 9 *$ 95
30 6 " " 30 6 " " 30 6 " " 30 6 " " 0 0 0 0 6 8 #-5 .7&*!% +6 -7 ## :-5 .7&*!% 6 1, %%! "
#$5 ( )6 ;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;
0 0 0 05 6 <04 5 6 <04 5 6 <04 5 6 <04 " " " " ! ,%! ! & $+ )%% ' -% %. ( "%*! & A= &' !$% $ ! 1 # 2 "( 2+$ " $ !5 = <'& +$& ! > ""34 '&
) - !
!& !$% ,%! ! & *+% )%
# &6 .!%. B66 5
%# +!% %. '&
!$% &''% *%+ ,( +$)-% (
"%*! & <)45 <*4 B &'
*&! * (#+ . +1*$&!
&, * "()+!
*%+ *!5 B <'& +$& ! > "
*!345 ! &- *% "!! & $&#,( 5 - .$
$% # 7 &' ?(%+!
+ !$! !$% ,%! ! & +
**(+%. &' ) )% ,%
# !& " *!
7&-7 --%#%.
%*&7 1 &' # + &' % *&**(+%. &' !$% ,%! ! &
%-15 "(2$ $, %%! "
#$ . 8 ) #$ $5 . & !$% )+ + &' . +*-&+(
&' *&**(+%. C "(2$, %%! "
#$5 !$% ,%! ! & $+ )%%
,- *!%.
*+%6 =6 0%
%. *&( +%- '& $+ !% !%. !$! !$% ,%! ! &
*(+!&.1 + *% A66 6 0%
%. *&( +%- $+ '( +() !!%. !$!
$+ )%% '-+%-1 ,- *!%.
!& !$% ?(%+! & 6 0%
*&( +%- $+ !% !%. !$!
.!& 1 , &7 + & + &' !$% " *! $7% +* (,(-&(+-1 )%% ,- %. : !$5 . !$(+5 !$% , &+%*(! & *+% +(''%
! .%'%*!+6 0%
%. *&( +%- $+ '( !% !%. !$! ++(
#(% .&5 !$% , &+%*(! & + !2% !& )% *&
%*!5 !$% ,%! ! & $+ )%%
!%.
!& !$% ?(%+! & !$% )+ + &' . +*-&+( % &' *& **(+%. C "(2$, %%! "
#$6 0%
%. *&( +%- $+ '( !% !%. !$! !$% $+ +(''% ! &
% !$ B !$+6 $(+5
) - + , 1%. '& A6 0%
%. "!!% *&( +%- $+ &,,&+%. !$% , ! ,%! ! & )1 #( # !$! !$% --%#! & +%. # +! !$% ,%! ! & % +% &(+
!( .5 !$(+5 !$% ,%! ! & .&%+ &! .%+% 7% !$% *& *%++ & &' !$% ) -6 0%
%. "!!% *&( +%- +%%2+ !& ,-*% &
%*& . !$% *(+!&.1 *% ! ' *!% .!%.
6=6
!$% &( ! !&.15 :$ *$ + !2%
%*& .6 6
$7% $% . *&( +%- '& 7- , ! %+ . $7% #& % !$ &(#$ !$% 7 -)-% %*& .+ &' !$% *+%6
$% ,%! ! & :+
%+!%. & A66 :$% '!% 5 !$%
:+ *
%. &(! . !$% *$-- .+ , !%. &
66 6 (! &' !&!- * !%. , &+%*(! & : !
%++%+5 % $+ )%%
%D
%. ! -- .!%6 ! +5 !$(+5 .() !)-% !$! *& *-(+ & &' !$% !
- : -- !2%
=
-& #6 $% *& ) . --%#%. !& $7% )%%
%*&7% %. '
!$% *&**(+%. &'
+ # + &' % *&**(+%. &' !$% ,%! ! & 5 !$% )+ + &' . +*-&+( % &' *&**(+%.5 !$% ,%! ! & $+ )%%
,- *!%.5
!$ + *+%6 + ,% , &+%*(! & 5 !$% % + & &!$%
!% - 7 -)-% !& *&
%*! !$% ,%! ! & : !$ !$% *& ) . %D*%,! '& !$% + . . +*-&+( +!!% !6 ! + ,% ! !& &!% !$! +(*$ . +*-&+( % +!!% !+5 )+% *% &' *&
&)& ! 7% %7 .% *% $&-. - !%. %7 .% ! 1 7-(% . *
)% +&-% )+ + '&
,- *!
# !$% ,%! ! & 6 $% %- *% & +()+! ! !%. +!!% +%+ +% &(+ .&()!+ )&(! !$% '
%++ &) %*! 7 !1 &' !$% ! + . +,(!% !$! !$% ,%! ! & :+ , ! ! !$% +,&!6 $% 7% * !1 . :% #$!#% %?( %. !& )% !!*$%. !& !$% . +*-&+( % +!!% .% )1 !$% *&**(+%. : -- )% '(--1 !%+!%. ! !$% ! &' !
-6 $% 7- *& !% +%. ! # 7% +% !& .%)!)-% ++(%+5 :$ *$ +$-- )% !%. (,& .(
# !$% *&( +% &' !
-6 $ + &( ! .&%+
&! .%% ! ,, &, !% !& .%-7% .%%, !& !$%+% 7- *& !% +5 ! !$ + +!#%5 -%+! !
1 , % (. *% !$% !
-6 &!$ # ! # )-% $+ )%% ) &(#$!
: . !& . *!% !$% - 2%- $&&. &' !$% ,%! ! & )+*& # '
, &*%++ &' (+! *% &
!% '%
# : !$ !$% , &+%*(! & %7 .% *%6
66 ! !$ + ( *!( %5 ! :&(-. )% ,,&+ !% !& %'% !& (.# ,++%. )1 !$ + &( +$(- " . 7% +(+ "!!% &' ( ) +$(- " . 7% +(+ "!!% &' ( ) +$(- " . 7% +(+ "!!% &' ( ) +$(- " . 7% +(+ "!!% &' ( )5 ,++%.
BA
BA
BA
BA
A < / /AB45 :$% 5 '!%
%-1 # (,&
! & .%* .% . &' !$% (.# !+ &' !$% & 3)-% "(, % &( &'
#$ 7% +(+ "!!% &' - .(5 "(, % &( ! B E "
!6
+$5 ).(- . $ 1 F 0.&& ,( 7% +(+ "!!% &'
( !5 *&! *+ & &- ( %(5
" BE "!!% )1 < 4 % #-( ( 7+6 --(-) . $ .
(!! G
<4 <
-4 9
E . H 1 "
#$ 7+6 $% "!!% &' 1 5 )%
# ",%* - 0%7% !& ,,%- < -64 &6<+4
I =5 .%* .%. & 966 =5 $+ $%-.
!$(+/ J 6=
! + :%-- %+!)- +$%. ,
* ,-% &' -: !$! *& '%++ &
.% )1 *&**(+%. ( "%*! &
9 &' !$% " *! + !-1 1 :%2 , %*% &' %7 .% *%6 "(*$ +!!% !<+45 )1 !$% +%-7%+5 *
!$% +&-% )+ + '& !$% *& 7 *! & &'
. 7 .(- (+! )% +* (!
K%. : !$ (!
&+! *(! &
*! & : !$ &!$% +()+! ! 7% %7 .% *%6 & %&7% %*&7% 1 $+ )%% %''%*!%. '
!$% ,&++%++ & &'
5 :$& $+ )%% +()+%?(% !-1 ,- *!%. + **(+%. +&-%-1 !$% )+ + &' . +*-&+( % +!!% ! &' !$% *&**(+%.6 &:%7% 5 +
) - ,% + !& - '% . - )% !1 &'
. 7 .(-5 &( !+ % &)- #!%.
!& +!
2% )- *% )%!:%% +'%#( # ,% +& - - )% !1 . % +(
# !$% %''%*! 7% .
+!
! & &' (+! *% + -+& 6 $% '
- %7 .% ! 1 7-(% . .
++ ) - !1 &' !$% . +*-&+( % +!!% .% )1 *&**(+%. '-- : !$ !$% .& &' !$% !
- &( ! . % !& )% . (. *!%. .(
# !$% *&( +% &' !$% !
- **& . *% : !$ %+!)- +$%.
,
* ,-%+ &' -:6 &:%7% 5 :$ -% . (. *!
# ,-% '&
) -5 !$ + &( ! *
&)- 7 &(+ !& !$% * *( *%+ ( :$ *$ !$% $+ )%%
# %. &
,- *!%.5 *-(.
# !$% !( % &' !$% --%#! & +5 !$% %7 .% *% - # !$% ,%! ! & !& !$% &''% *% + :%-- + !$% +,%* ' * &-% !!
)(!%. !& !$% ,%! ! &
!$% *&
++ & &' !$% --%#%.
&''% *%6 ,
'* % %D
! & &' !$%+% '*!& + + %++% ! - !& % +( !$! !$% , &*%++ &' -: + +(+%.5 )(+%. &
+.
%*!%.6L
+ ,% *(+!&.1 *% ! ' *!% .!%. 6=6
' -%. )1 !$% -%
"!!% *&( +%-5 !$% ,%! ! & $+ - %.1 +(''% ! & ,% &.
&' B !$+ G 9 .1+6
6=6 ( 5 + ,% !$% + . *(+!&.1 *% ! ' *!%5 !$% ,%! ! & +!!%. !& )% <+46 &:%7% 5 !$ + '*!(
&! )% &( . +('' * % ! )1 !+%-'5 !& .%*- % !$% *& *%++ & &'
) - !& !$%
!$% ?(%+! & :$% *+% + .% &(! '&
) - ?( !$% ?(%+! & )1 !
# (,& !$% '*!+I* *( *%+ &'
!$% + . 6 %- %# . * )% ,-*%. (,& !$% (.# ! &' !$% & 3)-% "(, % &( (- &$.6
+$. 76 "!!% &'
(- &$.6
+$. 76 "!!% &'
(- &$.6
+$. 76 "!!% &'
(- &$.6
+$. 76 "!!% &' 66 66 66 66
. <4 <
-4
. <4 <
-4
. <4 <
-4
. <4 <
-4 E 7 + & % *$ (.# !$% & 3)-% -*(!! #$ &( *+% &' "
.$ + 76 "!!%5 BB < .$ + 76 "!!%5 BB < .$ + 76 "!!%5 BB < .$ + 76 "!!%5 BB < <
-4 A99 <
-4 A99 <
-4 A99 <
-4 A99 G (.# !+ &' !$ + &( &6=
! !-%. + 2$ -%+$ "
#$ 76 "!!% &' 2$ -%+$ "
#$ 76 "!!% &' 2$ -%+$ "
#$ 76 "!!% &' 2$ -%+$ "
#$ 76 "!!% &' 1 1 1 1 5 .%* .%. &
B66 5 - 76 "!!% &' 1 5 BB <=4 <
-4 B6 - 76 "!!% &' 1 5 BB <=4 <
-4 B6 - 76 "!!% &' 1 5 BB <=4 <
-4 B6 - 76 "!!% &' 1 5 BB <=4 <
-4 B6 "('' *% !& +15 '( .%!% &' !$% ,%! ! & +
- + &! :
!%.
!$% '*!+ . * *( *%+ &' !$% *+%6
7 %: &' )&7%5 !$% , ! ,%! ! & + --&:%.
--&:%.
--&:%.
--&:%.6 %! ! & %. !& )% %-%+%. &
) -5 '
%?( 1 &!$% *+%5 &
$ + '(
+$ # ) -I+( %!1 )& .+ !& !$% +! +'*! & &' !$% 0.6 *&
%. !
- &( !I(!1 # +!
!%6 &:%7% .. ! & !& *& . ! & + !$!
1 )%
,&+%. )1 !$% *&
%. !
- &( !I(!1 # +!
!%5 !$% ,%! ! & +$--
)&( . )1 !$% '&--&:
# *& . ! & +/ < 4 $% ,%! ! & +$-- +(+% !$% - )% !1 # !%.6 < 4 $% ,%! ! & +$-- &! ! ,% : !$ 1 %7 .% *%5 & - &
.&*( 15 .(
# !$% !
-6 < 4 $% ,%! ! & +$-- &! )+% ! $ +%-' & 1 .!% )%'& !$% !
-6 < 74 $% ,%! ! & +$-- &! *&
! 1 &''% *% :$ -% &
) -6 <74 $% ,%! ! & +$-- .%,&+ ! $ + ,++,& !5 ' 15 : !$ !$% - &( !6 <7 4 $% ,%! ! & +$-- # 7% $ + *%--,$& )% !& !$%
7%+! #!
# '' *% I" &' *&
%. &- *% "!! &
. +$-- &! *$ #% $ + *%--,$& )% : !$&(! ,
,%
++ & &' !$% !
- &( !I --? # +!
!%6 <7 4 $% ,%! ! & +$--
1 !& .%-1 !$% -6 <7 4 $% ,%! ! & +$-- +() !5 & !$% '
+! :& # .1 &'
%7% !$5 '' .7 !5 )%'& % !$% *&
%. !
- &( !5 !& !$% %''%*! !$! $% $+ &! )%%
++ & &' 1 &''% *% '!% )% %-%+%. & ) -6
*+% !$% ,%! ! & + '&( . !& )% &''% *% '!% $ + )% # % - #%. & ) - !$% , 5 & !$% )+ + &' $ + '' .7 ! & : +%5 !$% "!!% +
.!%. !& &7%5 '& !$: !$5 '& *%--! & &' $ + ) - :$ *$ ,-%5 )(! &' *&( +%5 +$-- )% !%. (,&
!+ !$% %&'6 6
*+% &' ) %*$ &' 1 &' !$% '& %+ . *& . ! & + . !$&+% :$ *$ 1 )% ,&+%. )1 *&
%. !
- &( !I(!1 # +!
!% + .
%*!%.
)&7%
(,&
+$&:
+('' * % *(+%5 "!!%I*& ,- ! +$-- )% ! - )% !1 !& &7% * *%--! & &' ) - &' !$% B6 %. **& #-16 6
&!$ # + . $% )&7% +$-- )% *& +!
(%. + %D, %++ & &'
&, !+ &' !$% *+%6 6 *% !$% *+% $+ )%% .%* .%.5 ,% +*%-- %&(+ ,,- *! & 5 ' 15 +$-- -+& +! .+ . +,&+%. &''6 <" 0 " 0 " 0 " 04 *$ 9 *$ 9 *$ 9 *$ 95
$7
M$%!$% +,%2 #I %+& %./ %+I M$%!$%
%,& !)-%/ %+I