High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7378/2021dismissed

Sube Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others

2021-12-23Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri8 pages

!" #$

!! !! % &'()'( % *+ ,()'(

$ %

% ())-(!"( $ (.

% )/%0()'(

$ !** #2 (3 4506 / 7 8 4)96$ "$ (:

0, 0 0 ;

<<84 6( <<=4 6(><<4 6><<4 6( ' '00

4;/06(? 0 - ( + 2 00"( -', = . . >(.8 @)7)( >.( 7 0,

/08,0( ' AB0:(;/0( ;

/ (2@, (%/0:( 'A/ $(? 0 - ,( $ "'@0*0%0?: $(

$0 ,$09 *0(,,0 0

0 " !" *0 '0$, $ @, 70"(': ,, , 0= (7 0'0' $ :$$:: $ , 0 , : . (

( #+0( #,( #, ;, @0

0 88 / 0 0 9 0,$ ;

<<84 6><<( ' '00 ;/0 $ ( >$40 88 6 :$ " 0 :

, $ 70,, :, 0 0 @)700( , :0 0 0 7$ ,: 0 0 7 + 0 00 0 : ( 0( #5( 0 0 B ?

:$ 0 "!C 0 $, ' . $@ > 4!"#"$

#%&#'#()*%+,#%#'-#*%6 * ,,(A0@ %', 046 40 $%"./$ #'0 %"$+".' ($1$'" #'0 ",$%)() '.' '0.##'0 ",$%)6 !C 0 $, 00 07*%?(%( 0 = . . > !C 0 $,('= . ( 9$," $ $ / $ 0 $ " 7<,$ 0 A (!C 0 $,('8 .( 46 !

7$ (:, >. .

4$%"./$ #'0 %"$+".' ($1$'" #'0 ",$%) () '.' '0.# #'0 ",$%)6 ?

($$04% 8= 6 0 !" ( = . $

"!C 0 $,:, >4)96 : 0 "$ ?000B 70"(' >( >..:$ /$ ': $ >8=>8> 8 -' $ : : $ $$ "!

:,, 0, 0 0(,$ 8 4)96 $(:

$" 0 , 7 + ?

' ,$ 07 0"'B !)*?00 0B$$

:/(:

$,$ 0$$ $ (

' . : 0 '0?:0(!**

0 $ *

'(: ' $ 888 88 4)9 6(: '0 0(:

, @)700 ;

<<=4 6><< 6 ,$ :$(:

: 0 :

888 4%#,1*""#'0",$%)()!"#"$ #%&#'##'0 ",$%)6 0$ (: '0 0( :

:9 ,, 0 ,

@)700( + 0 00 0 : ( 0(#5(

0 0 B * !C 0

. $,('8 .(,46 ?

(:, >. . * ,,( -', ?000B ,/ /0

:/ . , $ $7$ !)* $$ ?

00 ?000B;

/0 0/(0 0

+, '0" ,,($00" "0*%?(%2:0 @0" *%?(%( $0", ?000B "

$00, $ * /$( :/ ?000B

:/ *

0 $$" : "$ $(,0"

( #+0( #,( #, ;,( (

#, $:$ ":$ "

&'( )' ?

" 0( 0(,

0 5

,!**( * ,,( !" #5,@)( - ,( 0 !**: ,$ :

9 ;

<<8><< ?

(0 $: !**(

,0> (

900 ;

<<8( :

(= 8>7,:$,> 7 ,:,$" 0 < * :0 , 0,$ ;

><<:$,0"

0" ' 0 $$ : ,$" ,

=7, )$$ "#5 ,@)(- ,( 0 + =)

= @ )7 )( >.( 0 0 ,$ ;

<<8( <<=><<( ' ;/0 ) +( 0 ,$ / <<8( <<= ><<4:

$0 , ;0 "

:9 6:,, 0 #,,7 , 0:, !**('$= . >(%$+11$'0$0 "%$/$#)$",$%$).0$'".#/,*)$23,.+,3#)$4.)".'5'",$/#'01$#)*%.'5 -#'#/2+16%.)$0.'-,#)%#

778#'0%$+11$'0$0"#+9*.%$",$ /#'0*'0$%.+$ #+"%&2#)."3#) %1.'56#%" 5%$$':$/" ) $( 8 @)7): . > *: $ 4)96 ' ( 0 $

00 ;

<<8><<(:7 0 !)*?000B($$

:/(: (',$ 8 ,0 0 ) 0"( 0, $:+ * 0 0, ;0 00 ;

<<=( 0('

:$ 0:$ 88 A00"( 0,

0"+',$ 8 4)96 7 $$(C:

-', ?00 0B , ;

/ 0

:/( , 7 $ / ( . 0( ,

$ 7$ !*)(+ DE # ( ( , ' '2

( > > 4 > 6 * ( :

8 7 0(:

: $$ 0

C2 AF'" !0 (A/ CA $$(0: $ F'" ?

( -', 8 8 ) 8 %0 0 0 F'"+ F '0$,) "4F)6G=)=;0 >%0 0 $, !,)

H3430 2 6 F'").;0%0 0(:

: $ $0C 5

- -

%0 00 ( A/ F'" ?

:$:, " , + ,$ "!C 0 $,(:

" ':: ,/ $", ,$(0' -',,$ , " 0$$ ?

0:/ 0$0"

$$( :

(: 7 # :, ' "!C 0 $,

)*#>

: 0 I= 07'00 ' ,$0"( : 90 0 : '0 7 ?

$$0 0: ":

'0,$0"7'

0 0 7 "'$ 0$$ 0 E ?

'':: 00: " 3 2

)*#>

.=8 @( : 00: " 3 2

4>>6 = > ?

( " #" $% &

" & # '

4>>86=(!C 0

$, ' * :0000 0$ 07 $ 0 $$," 0$$ $0 ?

7'00", ,'0 "

,$ $$' $0 * 020/J!K:

: 7 0$ 0$$(,0"( : 0(

: 20/ J)K( 0 : ,/ 0(,,0,0$$$0"

0 $$ * $$00 $ 07

7 ,$0" * :$ $0

$0 ( 0 0 $

" $ 0$$(,0"(0,,,0 $$ ,$0"( 0$ 0$$, '0 $ 0$$ 0

0$ '$$'$0 *:0( ( " 0$ 0$$ 0900 ::, $/ " @)75

$ 0 $$ ?

: $/ ,'00' $: @)75

5/ $( ,'2%

,00, 0 "

00 0 "

$ 0'00"' ( , 0 ) $ ) ,00 0 0 ' : # '+ , $ 0$$( :

07(0:" 0$$ "

-', $,,0B 0 ?

7, ,,"/$'" ?

, ',

$ 0 ?

'2 ' 0 : $, !,)

H34302 6 %3,$09A/ ?

+0 # =00 : $ ,

$ 0: F) '

$0( $: 0 + F '0$,) "4F)6( + # 0 H ?: 0 H '0$,)(>>=(:00 ",0"< " -', !( 0 ' F)0 7 * $( '$$ "(:

!**('$= . >( 0 0, ;0(:

:,$;

<<= ,,7 , 0 "(:

, $ 0 ?

7$ '0"

0" ,0 @ > 4!"#"$ #%&#'# () *%+,#%#'-#*%6 ) ?000B "

!)*

:/( , ,$0 00 ,0 7 :( 07' -',$ + ,( '( 0 7 $ 0$$ 0$$ *': '( , ,$ 8 , , 4#*?F2)!#*6 3F-L 4)#!))F#*6 3F-L +$