Sk Kharbanda v. Presiding Officer And Others
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH CWP-7787-1998 (O&M) Date of Decision: 22.12.2023 S.K. KHARBANDA
...Petitioner
Versus
THE PRESIDING OFFICER, LABOUR COURT, BATHINDA AND OTHERS
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER Present :
Mr. Sharwan Sehgal, Advocate for the petitioner.
Mr. Deepak Agnihotri, Advocate for respondents No.2 and 3.
HARSH BUNGER, J.
!" # " $" %
%& %''
( )& * " + , - . * "" $/ " $ -* */" $%% &0 %'11 ()23 2 )) 4 )5"$6
#* 7 , - ))4 , 6 8 %'2 ))4 %'2 6 $$ 7 9 )5"$ $
$*
& %'1 ": %%;& ) $ $8/ " (!* <= *&% & %'1 "/ " 5 :/ ) $* * * / "= * ) $* "*: &)2;)2&& / & &'
%'1 () $ <= * &% & %'1 $ %;
& %'11 / * $* $$ 75:/6 " $$ ) 5"$$ / $ * !) $"* / $ * *$%;
& %'11 $* $ / $ $""*$ !$ $ $ $ / ") #* ) $ * $$ $* 7
$/ / . $ " / %'2 "* * $ $
* / " ! " # )$ * )5"$ $*6& &'
%'1 " $ * /" "/ / $/ "* $*$ / $ * $ / %'2 * $ $ $ $ $$ $ %'2 . #*)$ ;)< %'2 ;
< 7 "" 7 , ! $ /* $ $*$ / "
$ + $ 7 ) $*9 : %%;& ) $ 9 "/ "5:/ ! (* " $* $" * $ $ / )"
*/""/ / * $/$. ) $* $ / 9 " $"$
$ / " $ $" 5$ "* *$$ $ + " " $* , >)
!
"
#
$
%
" / $ / / , " * " * )$ $ '
, " , 7" $ $ , $ / / "
/
, $ 5 :/ / "= " / "/ ?/ / $*/" $ * $ $ $ / /%'2 $
"* * $" # " " # %& + " )5"$$ , ) 7 * * $ , / $ $ ""$ !
/ $ $* "* * $ $ %% / / )! % " $ / $ $ * / 7"$ * ?
>)
! &
'
() '*#
!
"
+
!
)
#
, ) '*#)
! !
!
- ) )
& &
. ) /
!
,
!
-
0-
+
1
2
!
)
#
3
)
+
) , !
!
)
! ) ) '
() '*#
-
2
!
,
!
! &
3 !
)
! ! 1
2
+
4
!
)
)
- )
,
- !
-
-
!
!
&
!
0
1!
)
+
$ % & ' (
% ) ) 2
!
- !
/
+
+
) )
/
!
!
- * * +,
+(- .% )
(
+ + /+
,0(-1 .%-)
2
3 4 5# 6
( 71 .% 1
!
- 2
/+
,0( 7 .%
!
-
) )
!
1 ,
!
) )
!
,
!
1
2 %
%0
$" , "">)
+
! !
) +
!
!
3
-,$)
&
& 1 (
!
-
&
!
56
*8
$
)
, + !)
3) '*8
3)
!
'
*8 /
!
(
)
, $!
&
(
:&0 ;
:&0 ;8) :&
;
:&0 ;
:&0 ;#
** :&0 ;7
< **
- :&0 ;8
'*8
!
. 3!
)
!
!
=,$3
+
)
:&0 ;8
! , $!
=! )
&
'
*8
!
:&0
;
- $
!)
!
4 :&!
-
3 )
!
+
/
/
-
14 2 . -
+ !; -
> ?
!
@0
-
) )
)
! !
!
1
!
-
%
)
!; B
3 4 CD 14 2
!
)
!
-
14 1
2 >
6 C=D B@ A; !
E ?
C
!D
!
!
&
+ = !;
3 A =) 1 $)
5 E! ?
) ''
5F$ #<) 14
1
2
@0
-
!
!
& ! CD
CD
+ E 3) ' 8)
G 4
- ) !
#05
3
!
%
#
) 14 3 1
2 , 3 !; $ E)
, ) > ) ''80++ BBF #<8
+ )
!
) )
! :&0,;) )
&
CD
CD
+
E 3) ' 8
!
#05
3
> + ) +
!
36 1 !; - 3 >
B
)
!
!
<
3 =
2 : 3) '77
<
!
*
+ !
) +
!
>
!
$:B+:5 @
'
+ !
H
?
!)
!
1!)
%
%2 <$ " * , / /
& %'1 9 " ( $ 0 & %'1
* ( ! )$* " "/ ? + " " : %%;& ) $ / & &'
%'1 "/" / ($ $ $ (
$"$ $/ >) C7D E
)
& ) !
C8D
3
)
! !
!
, (
)
. )
%
%;
($ &% &'
%'1 "/*
$ @( A $
/" * 5"$ "
$ / " "* " " / $ / " ""$ $ $ $ $. "* # * / ;)< %'2 % < * $ /" / "=$. / $* $ %
< $ $(7* ?"
//"
" * , 9 * 7/0 " 7 $$* 9 ( 7 9 "* $* # "/" * * * * 7 ?/ $$$ 7 ?"
/*7 *$ " * 9 / #"( 7"$ $ 9 $ /(# $" * 9/0 * -* !
$ $ $ / * $ $ / $ $" "
$* "/" * ?/ *#* /* 9 /0 * " * ?"
" * ,! $ * $" ) /* 89
0 % +9 + + ( 2 % 1
3
1--. +9+ *+ + 0 # 9 : + 0 + ( 2 % -) 3
. 4 /+ %+ + + 2 +5 . + (2 %71 3
- .%
,0
+ ( 1 % % # ;
< 4 ;)- * + ++5=29+ + 2'4> + ( 4))7 %1
" * $ "
/) " * " * , :* $$ %'
" * December 22, 2023 (HARSH BUNGER) gurpreet JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned:
Yes/No Whether reportable:
Yes/No