S.C Sharma v. Union Of India And Other
! "# $ '
()(
*+ $ -.!.%& '
()(
(((((((( +.+.%& "
! 2 "!3!
&.%& &$.* %+0 "!
((((((( !4%&$ &+
! '
5 6 ( / 2 /
5 6 ( / 76 / " ! &+' +.+.%& "
4 "!%&( ( ( 76 /8 ( +.+.%& "*449.-*&+ !%3:0+ ;3*!0.&:
&& <3" =8 4"*? "
&+"*9 .#.9 / "#.- !
&!.%&
0 " .&*,+ "
" , "" $ 5+0
@5 " !4%&$ &+!(
! B!
*44"%4".*+ $." -+.%&!
-%149?
(
&& <3"
&& <3" )8 &+"*9
$1.&.!+"*+.# 0*&$.:*"0
&-08 0*&$.:*"08
0 " .&*,+ "
" , "" $ 5+0 ".A3&*958 ! B.&:
4%!+ " +."*9 A & ,.+!
&+."
! "#.- ( 3&$.!43+ $ ,*-+!
*44%.&+ $ ".&-.4*9
7 &$".?* 2.$?*9*?* /*&:*+0*&
0 " .&*,+ "
" , "" $ 572/5
(
(
3&*3+0%".C $9?
*A! &+ $ 0.1! 9,
>( (,(
()(
%&>*"$!
9 ,+ ,%" .:& -%3&+"?
%A+*.&.&:
%AD -+.%&
- "+.,.-*+ *3+0%".+?(
/.&- $.$ " !4%&$ $ !4.+ 43A9.-
&%+.- !
(@(
((
43A9.!0 $
$*.9?
& >!4*4 "
,*.9 $ " 4%"+ $3+?8
((
/*.$ -0*99 &: $ A ,%"
%(
=
@(
( 8 $." -+ $ " .&!+*+
*99 -%&! ;3 &+.*9
A & ,.+!
:*# 9.A "+?
72/ .&.+.*+ $.!-.49.&*"?
4"%- $.&:!
*:*.&!+ !+*:
! "#.&:
-0*": !0 +(
".+ *:*.&!+
340 9$ .:0 %3"+ (( )(
%&! ;3 &+9?8
" .&!+*+ $
)( ( =(
72/ .&.+.*+ $ $ 4*"+1 &+*9
4"%- $.&:!
.!!3.&:
-0*": !0 +
()( -0*":
9 *#.&:
!+*+.%& %A+*.&.&:
%AD -+.%& - "+.,.-*+ > 99 " 1*.&.&:
3&*3+0%".C $9?
*A! &+ >( (,(
()(
((
@(
-0*": !0 + $ ,*.9.&:
" 4%"+ *+
& > 0 *$;3*"+ "!
$3".&:
4 ".%$
!3!4 &!.%&(
,+ "
.&;3."?8 -0*": !
4"%# $ $.!1.!!*9 4*!! $(
&+."
4 ".%$ 3&*3+0%".C $ *A! &-
()(
@((
+" *+ $
$. !&%&(
44 *9 *:*.&!+ " D -+ $(
*44"%*-0 $ *:*.&!+ %"$ "8
*449.-*+.%&
=( (
340 9$ .:0 %3"+
> 99
4 <
%3"+ A -%1 ,.&*9 *,+ "
$.!1.!!*9 /6 ( )(
1%# $ *449.-*+.%& )()(
:"%3&$
" D -+ $8
)
()( =(
,.9 $
%( @= :"*&+.&:
*99%>*&- 8 @(( ,.&*9
$." -+.&:
" -%&!.$ "
-*!
4*!!
> 99 " *!%& $ !4 *B.&:
%"$ "(
-%149.*&- %"$ "8 (
4*!! $8 -%&# ? $ *449.-*&+4 +.+.%& "8 9 ++ "
(=( (
*:*.&
*44"%*-0 $ *:*.& ;3*!0 $ ( $." -+.&:
4*!!
," !0 9.:0+
>.+0.& 4 ".%$ +0"
> B!
) ( @(
--%"$.&:
*449.-*&+4 +.+.%& "8
? *"!
%9$8
$.*A +.- 4*+. &+ !3,, ".&:
139+.49 *.91 &+!(
((
-931!?
:"%3&$!
0*$ ,.:0+ 9.+.:*+.%&(
0*$
1 ".+%".%3!
72/8 .:&%" $(
&+.+9 $
@( 0 *"$ 9 *"& $ -%3&! 9 4*"+. !
-*" ,399?
:%& +0"%3:0 -*!
,.9 (
-9*.1 $8 " 4"%$3- $ ' 5= %14*!!.%&*+
%# "&1 &+ ! "#*&+ >0% " 1%# $ !0*99 ,%", .+ :"*+3.+?
"%#.$ $
$.!1.!!
" 1%#
1*?8 ., -*!
$ ! "#.&:
!4 -.*9 -%&!.$ "*+.%&8
!*&-+.%&
= <- $.&:
+>% +0."$!
:"*+3.+?
A%+0 >%39$
*$1.!!.A9 ., 0*$ " +." $ -%14 &!*+.%& 4 &!.%&(5 "3!*9 *449.-*A9 !0%>!
-*! 8 *& 149%?
" 1%# $ ., -*!
$ ! "#.&:
!4 -.*9 -%&!.$ "*+.%&8 -*& !*&-+.%& <- $.&:
+>% +0."$!
:"*+3.+?
A%+0 >%39$ *$1.!!.A9 ., 0*$ " +." $ -%14 &!*+.%&
4 &!.%&(
-*! 8 *A! &+.&:
0.1! 9, 9 *#.&:
,%" .:& -%3&+"?
%A+*.&.&:
%AD -+.%& - "+.,.-*+ *3+0%".+?(
-9*.1
0*$ 1 ".+%".%3!
!0%39$ -%&!.$ " $(
,3"+0 "
!+*+ $ -%149. $ !*1 :.#.&:
!3,,.-. &+ " *!%&!(
8
-%149. $ >.+0( "3!*9 ) ( !0%>!
-*!
*449.-*&+4 +.+.%& "(
*99 :*+.%&!
*:*.&!+ *A! &- 9 *#.&:
,%" .:& -%3&+"?
%A+*.&.&:
%AD -+.%& - "+.,.-*+ *3+0%".+?( .!
,.&*&-.*9 -%&$.+.%& -%&!.$ " $(
%4 "*+.# 4*"+ " 4"%$3- $ ' 50 1*++ "
-%14*!!%&*+ /0".
" <*1.& $ %A! "# $ .+ !+.439*+ $ %# "&1 &+ &$.*5!
-.!.%&!
*"*
A 9%>
/
&!.%&
F
.&!+*&+ -*! 8 A .&:
" !4%&!.A9 %,,.- "
*$ &!+.+3+.%& >0.9 /0".
9 ,+ 2.$?*9*?* %3&+"?
4"%-3".&:
4 "1.!!.%&
3+0%".+?
72/(
$.$ A%+0 "
" !4%&$ *&?
-%113&.-*+.%& ! &+ " :*"$( 1.!-%&$3-+ -%11.++ $ /0".
:"*# &*+3"
" ,9 -+.&:
$.!9%?*9+?
":*&.C*+.%& *&$8 3&4*"$%&*A9 (
/3-0 *& *-+ 4*"+ +*&+*1%3&+ $.!0%& !+?
+%>*"$!
$3+. !8 >0 " 34%& 1*D%"
4 &*9+?
$.!1.!!*9 .14%! $ 34%& 0.1( .!
*44 *9 " #.!.%& $39?
" D -+ $ -%&- "& $
3+0%".+. !
A .&:
$ #%.$ 1 ".+!(
!3-08 /0".
/0*"1*8 <".&-.4*9
&+.+9 $ + "1!
*,%" !*.$ 4"%#.!.%&!
(G
-*! 8 *--%3&+ $.!1.!!*9 4*!+ ,%", .+ $ :"*&+ $ 4 &!.%&*"?
A & ,.+!(
+*B & #. > 4%# "+?
!! &+.*9 -%&$.+.%& 4" - $ &+
*99%>*&- (
1.!-%&$3-+(
".&-.4*9 !-0%%9(
#. > 1.!-%&$3-+ *449.-*&+
4 +.+.%& "
:"*# &*+3"
" ,9 -+.&:
$.!9%?*9+?
%":*&.C*+.%& *&$8 3&4*"$%&*A9 (
+ 0 9$ .+
+*&+*1%3&+ $.!0%& !+?
+%>*"$!
$3+. !( #. >
%3"+ -*&&%+ !.+ D3$:1 &+ *3+0%".+. !(
%14*!!.%&*+
!34"* -*&&%+ -9*.1 $ 1*++ "
".:0+(
+ -%&!.$ "(
!*1
$ -.$ $ 0.1(
+0 "
.99 :*9.+?
.&,."1.+?
&& <3" =8 $ -9.&.&:
.&+ ", "
!*1 (
%&! ;3 &+9?8 > $% ,.&$ *&?
1 ".+ 4" ! &+ !*1 *--%"$.&:9?
$.!1.!! $(
2 /
76 /
()(
!DB!
0 +0 "
!4 *B.&:
'
!
% 0 +0 "
" 4%"+*A9 '
!
%