Munna Lal Alias Manna Lal v. Narender And Others
!"#!"
$$"" %& '&(&()& *
+$( ,& & +-)./"0(10&)$$"" & %(. $0(10&&$(' 3) $$" ) 4 ( 4/ ) $$"""5 67 )5 5$ 8&(( 4/ ) & ( 9"5 3&4 "0 ,$ & )& :) 93;0 () &-0 8) <$&( 5& 1) "& (0 8)) 6 $"
"5 $ (& = ) & %)" 0 >
& )& :) % ; 8 "( 4/ ) "50 4&)& &- ? 8 $"(( )
0 ) "5 ( &-0 8& 77 5&/"4&7+7&' @+ A2 &5,$ . &1(&9B&/1""7=()$ &0& ,$ 3) ( 5&/" 8 47 (&1 4/ )
5$" ( ((&- 8 &(7 $""
08))/&)(!"""7=,&", 5$0 .1&5 4 4&7 &7& @+ C
)&& &&&( :) (7 1)";0 8)) 8 47(&1&)(7"75&(1&/)7) $(0))5&/"&54)(0& "8))0) "5 "" (8 ) 5""( $& ) &(0 8)&)((4&)& &-"")&((5 (&)4 &-84& 7))91"@$"0,$0 8)& ) & ("&( )5 (( 3) (&1& "( &5 ) $ "7 8) ) (7 1)" ?+ ' ((
(&= >(2 ?,98&7&( ," = "( ?( &" &0 & ,$ &7 170 ) 5$" 7 $$"5&/ 5 &&(( ) ( 560 8&7 54& ) (7 1)" 8 5( ) ?+ ( ) && 54& 8 @+ C &(7"/05$+
D8 "5( )()(&- +$( ' ( ( ) $ 4/ "78&5067$&"5&/4-&7&(7 54"/0
( 5&0 8&())()(6$"( 7"7 )(()5"08) "(4&1)&& " (517&)&( ?)"&108$"(( ) ) 93 5 ) " ) &$( ' 8 &$4" & ) ( E 0 ) "4"/ ) "(4( $&$(' 2? &95$/
2 +$( 2? & 95$/ "( $& 8& 5 67 $&"5&/ 4- &7&(7
F 0 5&0 8 1&&( ) ) (&1& ( ) 8& ) (7 1)" "(&5)? &95$/4 )(( ) )/ )( 1"( ) &5 ) & $"/ 3) 5 ) ( 8 (( ( &)&0 8 &( ) ) ?+0 ) 54& ) (7 1)" 8 5(@+ C 04 )5 45) "&$&)9 &0)585(@+ C 08))"&"/)8())(8 (4/ )(&1&)@&/+(8/4 4&7&7&' @+ C &5 ) $"(7 ) $&0 ""87 8&&5(
! "##$% & $&'( ) $*&! )(+ $&, $& * % "
*- )!". )*& *- (&% ! "+ **/0+"# %( *!") "&%& ,+$, & %!$1$&, *-*-- &%$&,()2 "!$&,! ,$) !" $*&* 453 5 27 ! )0*&% & *
") "++ , %8
9 - $))( * $) 0!*1 % $& "--$!:" $1 ;
" ":*(& *- #*:0 &)" $*& 0 $ $*& ! (&&" "+ < "&&" "+ $) & $ + % * "&% -!*:;
*:8
=
! 1 $#+ $& '( ) $*& ;") 2 $&, %!$1 & $& 1$*+" $*& *-
!:) "&% #*&%$ $*&) *- $&)(!"&# 0*+$#7 - )* * ;
" -- # 8
= > +$ -
,&"()&&$11(
%(8&(((
0)93""8() $ "( 4/ ) "50 8&(7 ) ""87 5$ =& @( 9" " + ?5
D $&5)
" (7 & $&$
DG
D D (( (
+
D H $&" <$ $&
5))(( 95$ &
< <2 H 5 "$"&2$$"( >0
1 !& 5 0
D 1 !
1 &"<$ 0
D 3"
D =67)5)(5$0) $$"""5)"()$$"
?)1)&("&( "&)$& > !&( " & ) $$"" 45 ) ) 93 &&( )"(7 ) )( 4 $&1( ) ((&- 8 8&67 $& 5& &/0 8)& ) ?+ "0 )( 4 &&(( ) 8) ) ( 6 $"0 ((&- "7 8) ) "5 8 77 &5 ,$ . &1(& 9 B &/ 1""7 =()$ &0 & ,$ !&( " 45 ))1"$1(8(&(4/)93 ? &)& 45( 4/ "&( " & ) $$"" ) ) 7 ((&- 8 " 8&7"/
( /&0 8)& ) 8 ""/ 2 /& "(0 ) 7) "&( " ( ) $& &5 ) $ 5&5&$&0)&81($&( (&&(4/) $$"""5 !&( " 45)"78)) $5&5&$&0)&8&508)))(4""( $ &) $/08)))7)((85( 2 /& !&( " " 45 ) &5 ) "8 "( (8 4/ ) @;4" = $&5 9 & " $*&"+ &)(!"&# *:0"&7$:$ %1) !"&"7 $"&% !) 96 ? @9A @#!$A 964 ( ",:" & !"+ &)(!"&# *:0"&7 %1)"&( ":< ( !( ":
@96 ?A ? =6 ) 5 8&(( & 5F &" <$ ("0"(&14)(
"&( " &$&7 ) &$(? &95$/ 45))5$ 8&(( 4/ ) 93 (E ( ) 93 &7)"/ ( ) 5)"/ 5 ) (( +
D" (7 &$&$ @81&0) "( (/ ) 5 ) & 5D"" 5$ 47 $/4"&5)- (75)@;4"= $&59 & ?() !"&"7 $ $& ?)1)&("&( "&)$& $&&5)5)?+01(8&) 50 8 $&( ( 10
$&1 ) ((&-8$&5&5&/ '$& &5 ) &/ 8 <5( ' &&( 8 $&( ( '
)&808) "()1(4 )$1 5&0 8 <5( I(& ) & 50 ) 930 (( 55 / ""7"/ &7 ((&-0 "4 &&(7) 5+
D$ ) 4)55 587$&1"7)5)() 2 ? & ) 7 ) (( &(0 (("/0)$5&5&$&0)7)(( 8 5( /& $& &5 )0 1( 8 $&( ( &7 ) (/0 ()& 9&( $( $&""/ 4/ 1&/ ' $&( ) ()& 9&( 8 "(("/77)$$"" 3)57) 7)((2 /&) $/&58 "(4 &"10 ) 7 ) $ 5&5 &$& 5( /&0 8)) 8 ( "/ $&( ( &&( 3)4"0)&&0(4&& @81&0 &5 ) & "( (8 4/ ) = $&59 &?() !"&"7 $ $&0"" & 50 # + 0
D0 8 &E &( 4 7&( ="" &)&0 & &" <$ ( " 0 + 0
(&))(08"&E &(48&((
@17(&() 455(4/"&( "&)$&0)5$8&((4/)93 )( (& =& @(9"5 8&((4/93 J)( 5$ 7 /& '9)7 ?5
$& 5)
& " (7 & '9)7 $&$
D (( (
+
')7 $&" <$ H+
$& 5) ) (( 1 95$ &
< <2 H ')7 5 "$"& 2 >0
$$"( 1 !& 5 0
0
1 !
0
1 &"<$ 0
3"
>0
3) " 5$0 )&&0 5 + >0
D & (( 7 5 +
D ( 4/ ) 930 ) 4" 5$ 5 0
D 3) 5 8 "( 4 $/4" (( ) 5 ( 4/ ) "&( 93 "7 8) & #
K ""/ 3) (4 &" ( "4"/ $/ ) 5 8 "(4$&)8&( 3)$&$$"&(7"/($( ,(7 $$" 0 /0 )"" " ( ($( @ A 9?6 9695 %) B))&$67D&( AD' B))&&$&4" AD'