← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20396/2018dismissed

Indo Tibetam Border Police Force v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2019-07-12Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan12 pages

        



 !"#$!%&'&"() *+*

($"&,! ("-$!-".&%!"-%!

/*! & &"(!- 0!-'1'

2  !"#-3(($" 4!-'

/*!'5"($!( '

)  67*2 0

2

2 8   

        



    

  

   



   !

    " #

$$$$$$ 0

2

2 8 9 * -.



                    #% &'

#&'()*+,'-

.

 /+0   +  .

 

   .

   !. 23)4!235-  

+0   " 6      7+8      /88    

+0 " %9 82  7+  /88 .

3/+    !. 23 '::#)4'::#5- +  .

/+

        .

   /    /8   +  )   4/  / 5- 8

2    39" %; #( '& #&'% + 6&;/ 2  +  98.

/     " 6<%     #= '& #&'%    8         8  9 

   + ,

   88+     > 38.

  +   8    7+8 

 

    . >  8 . +?.

 !2    88+

"

8 " 6<%8+ 

 .88+ @.

8   39  ! +     +.8     " 6<% ! 

8   " 6<% 

 . /+   3/+ 8+'::#  +  .

/+  

! /+  #% &'

#&'(8

  !   

  +,                     ! 

 

    "        !         #  



   

 

  $

%  #   

    &'(

               

# 

  )* + ,-./ 01#  . -$      2

  34'    '5+67  &     0!  &

(38+5 '5+' #

 

2



34'    '5+6 &0 &

( 38++    '5+'(   9 "

1/  ,.-$ 7  '2

7'5+6 '   :  /  . 7

 :   36    '557     

      " 7 '55&. ; (  

       

     

   

  !          1  #   # ! 

# 

   

 

 

  !         << 2 !          

    

 < 2729      

          2

 9       ! 

:   9!

  =  *9   

#   

#

  =  9    <5 2  29    



   

  !

 84  2  

 

9        7     

 7 

  $

   

 !   7# 

    1# >     

    ! 7<57<7<< 84 #        #    # 

 

  !    #     

  ?   * # !    

?        7      # @ ##     

  

       

    # !  # #

 

 

      " 0 7#

  

         7 86  2

   

 86 2 

)

; 86  #             ?    !   

  *&+(A     ! >     

  

   

 

  



 7 7 #   7 ? 

   8'  7  ! ! 

      

   

#7   

  7        9!

  &'(  86 27

  8' 2&=  *9  2 

=  *9 

 *9  (# 

   !                

     

#    ) +2> /   >72 :+85&-;(7 6+ ':>!  /   7"   =    $ 72 :'5+'&(86 6     /   >&+88(+ 85   9   $

 

    /    -  2 

     2

 3' '5++#   2



3    '5547  2   =   9   /

    !   + "7'5+'

&(     !    7    !##  8' 86 2                        !  >    





       #             !    =  *9  2  =  *9  

 *9  9 

 

  # 

   ! 

 @      @   !

#                B    1      

   7 :#  '<+5'5+                 !       *    +6  

  '55+'5+    



 1 B  

  ++5''5+47  #  # 

 



+ $  ! 

 7        

 =   9         ! @         8' 2 86 2 ++5''5+4 

    7#  @  

  =  9   #         @ 7

            ! !     9 

 #

  @     

C             << 2# @  <<  2 1           

  



   @        

       

        ! 

   #  !

!  !1 

!   << 27##      1   > 

    

  #>      

  

    " 0 # 

       



    7      #  # 

  

"       

         7 +86#

  

 #     @  =  9  

   8'

2A    8' 2    86      2        7                 =   9          @              

    !#!

?   

!       7# # #           # 

!

        7  #    #      !

  

     

  

       

  7    

 ! 

       

      ?  7!

  

           

D !   .    

.

 /+

> +  +.8 



   :#'::#  %=A /  /   " 6<% ..  3/++  3  :#'::# 

%=A/  /   + +, 

     *A         !>  

      

     

              =  *9  7  2   =  *9     

 *9       =  

 *9      2  = 

 *9  # # 

      !  

 

 7 # 

  

 7  

  

          

  

     D  

    !

    

 

   &+(  9!

   1   #   2

27+85&4 +85(73!27 +8&4' +8(7 2   27+85& +85(7    #7  2

   %  7

    7   # >   7 !   #7  #7 

  # 

  *

 C #       "    # 

  #      # 

  *

 7 "  

!    7 





 

  !  7 #   



  #  7

  

 #   7 

  

    7 !    7 

7

    *   E@

  *   * &(F F      7

7  7  7   7   

 7 &(F   *   F             #  

#    *      !  #

 2

  

%   &'(E! "  

7  ! #  







  

     7  

    

 



7    ! 

         

  &6(2;  7  1 7 

     > #    *    @    

     *  D > +  +  /+  8

 +

   



 

  

    +  8 /88 @ C     8

%=A)#-/  / + + 

  . 8 +  . + 

 /++



 8  



          +    +  8     @  .

 + " #, 8    

 

     + .



 

 +  +  

) -3  .

 &6 &= #&':8 +             &6

+ .* 8   +  /+ 

   39  #( '& #&'%D + '=6/  /  +.8#& &'

#&'A

/+ ?

 8  8  ''

&# #&';   +                   

     .

 

  +

.. 8  * + :#<:6 '::#

> + " #,8    +  1+8 5. + 8/+.,&-2&(<4($(-* 0'*2  !"#1(=,9

;

29 8    

  +

8   

) -  .   8''

&# #&';  /+?

 

         8   .

     8+     

  /+    .. 8 +

).-   + /+

+6'

+#(E

.* 8     

)-       8   

      8 +      #% &'

#&'(       /+          &(  E  

 .* 8 

 .

 ,!23 ..8 + +* 

3  8 + #% &'

#&'(

 

  + 8 +

.

 /+

   8

>0

2

2 8 ?

'# &= #&':   !   E 0  G0" E  . G0"