High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7493/2021dismissed

M/S Shri Ram Logistic Company v. Food Corporation Of India And ANR

2021-09-02The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli8 pages

CWP No. 7493-2021 1

! "#$%$&'(')*+ ,(-./' "012'(#'&03")4 5 $#'#')$/ 6$/(7(

%/3/"#'))%'"")%")#.$/ $(3)%$)#(

/$($)#*+ /)7/"2.3/"8%9&"#$8/#.$3$#'#')$/ /-70$$#$:8-$)'/%9&"#$;'#. / ")"9"<"<8%9&"#$8//$(3)%$)# /"(#$<-')2.8%9&"#$8//$(3)%$)#

.$ "/$("'% 3/$($)&$ '( =$')2 /$&/%$% #./72. 9'%$ &)$/$)&')2 (')&$ #.$ 3/&$$%')2("/$=$')2&)%7&#$%')9'/#7":7/#! >>>> /":!

! "# # .$"33:'&"#')/3/$3)')2#.$%"#$.$"/')2'("::;$%/ #.$/$"()(0$)#')$%#.$/$').$&"($'(#"?$)73)="/%/.$"/')2 $ %&' "# # .'( 3$#'#') ."( =$$) ':$% =4 #.$ 3$#'#')$/ '/08 ;.($ #$&.)'&": ='% ."( =$$) /$<$&#$% =4 #.$ /$(3)%$)#+"7#./'#'$( ;.'&. ;"( (7=0'##$% 37/(7")# # #.$ #$)%$/ )#'&$ %"#$% @ 8 '((7$% / #.$ 37/3($(&"::')2='%(#";"/%#.$&)#/"&#.")%:')2")%#/")(3/# ")'" # -'/("8 ) #.$ 2/7)% #."# #.$ 3$#'#')$/ '/0 ."( )# 73:"%$%#.$&34#.$

&%$8;.'&.;"(/$A7'/$%#=$%)$')#$/0( &:"7($@#.$#'&$)9'#')2$)%$/833$)%'B8&70$)#C")% &:"7($D !#.$ 1$"/)$% &7)($: "33$"/')2 / #.$ 3$#'#')$/ (7=0'#( #."# ') 37/(7")&$ # #.$ #$)%$/ )#'&$ %"#$% @ #.$ 3$#'#')$/ '/0 ."% "33:'$%7)%$/#.$')$B3$/'$)&$%&"#$2/4")%;"($B$03#$%/0':')2#.$

%$ "( 3$/ #.$ #$/0( ")% &)%'#')( #.$ #'&$ )9'#')2 $)%$/

CWP No. 7493-2021 2 '#($: $ (7=0'#( #."# #.$ "7#./'#'$( ;'#.7# :?')2 ')# #.$ "/$("'% "(3$&##$&.)'&"::4/$<$&#$%#.$3$#'#')$/E(='%)#.$2/7)%)#':')2#.$

&%$=4&007)'&"#')%"#$% C ))$B7/$ +!$(7=0'#( #."# #.$ 3$#'#')$/ '/0 ."% ':$% " /$3/$($)#"#') =$/$ #.$ /$(3)%$)# "7#./'#'$( "2"')(# #.$ /$<$&#') '#( #$&.)'&": ='%8 ;.'&. ."( ":( =$$) /$<$&#$%9'%$#.$'0372)$%/%$/%"#$%F ))$B7/$ +C!)#.$ ("0$2/7)%( 1$"/)$% &7)($: / #.$ 3$#'#')$/ '/0 7/#.$/ (7=0'#( #."# " ="/$/$"%')2/$:$9")#&:"7($(#.$#$)%$/%&70$)#(")%#.$&)%'#')( $)70$/"#$%#.$/$')8'#'($9'%$)##."##.$3$#'#')$/'/0;"()#/$A7'/$%# 73:"%#.$

&%$1$"/)$%&7)($:."(#"?$)#.'(7/##./72.&:"7($+@ 33$)%'B+ #.$ "# 3"2$ F #.$ 3$#'#') $)70$/"#')2 #.$ %&70$)#(#."#."9$#=$(7=0'##$%=4"='%%$/7)%$/#.$')$B3$/'$)&$% &"#$2/4 $ (7=0'#( #."#') #.$ ("'%:'(#8 #.$/$ '() 0$)#') #.$

&%$ $ (7=0'#( #."# #.$ 3$#'#')$/ '/0 ."9')2 (7=0'##$% '#( ='% "( ") ')$B3$/'$)&$%'/0."((3$&''&"::40$)#')$%')#.$#$)%$/%&70$)#(#."# '#."()#':$%#.$

&%$)70=$/;.'&.'($9'%$)#/0"3$/7(":3"2$ #.$3$#'#') 1$"/)$%&7)($:/#.$3$#'#')$/."(":(/$$//$%#&:"7($+ #.$ #$/0( ")% &)%'#')( #.$ ")% #.$ $)$/": )/0"#') # $)%$/$/( &)#"')$% ') 3"/"2/"3.+ '''! #.$ %$":')2 ;'#. #.$ #$&.)'&": ='%( 1$"/)$% &7)($: / #.$ 3$#'#')$/ ;.':$ /$:4')2 73) #.$ ("0$ (7=0'#( #."# #.$ 3$#'#')$/ '/0 ."9')2 (7=0'##$% '#( ='% 7)%$/ #.$ ')$B3$/'$)&$%&"#$2/4;"()#/$A7'/$%/#':$#.$

&%$":)2;'#. #.$#$)%$//0")%#.$/$/$8/$<$&#')'#(#$&.)'&":='%=4#.$"7#./'#'$( '(3$/9$/($")%3"#$)#:4'::$2":

CWP No. 7493-2021 3 1$"/)$% &7)($: "33$"/')2 / #.$ /$(3)%$)#+ % /3/"#'))%'"83$/+&)#/"8;.':$/$$//')2#&:"7($(")%@#.$ #$/0(")%&)%'#')(#.$"(;$::"(33$)%'B+8&70$)#C #.$$)$/":)/0"#')##$)%$/$/(")%&:"7($D 8(7=0'#( #."# " ="/$ 3$/7(": #.$ ("'% &:"7($( 0"?$( '# &:$"/ #."# #.$ 3$/() (7=0'##')2 .'( ='% $'#.$/ 7)%$/ #.$ $B3$/'$)&$% / #.$ ')$B3$/'$)&$% &"#$2/48 '( /$A7'/$% # 7/)'(. #.$

&%$ # '( (7=0'##$% #."# #.$ "/$("'%&)%'#')#.$#$)%$/%&70$)#'(&/4(#":&:$"/")%"("%0'##$%:4 #.$3$#'#')$/'/0."()#7/)'(.$%#.$

&%$8#.$/$/$8/$<$&#')'#( #$&.)'&":='%=4#.$/$(3)%$)#+"7#./'#'$()#.'(2/7)%'(')"&&/%")&$ ;'#.:";")%%$()#&"::/")4')#$/$/$)&$ 1$"/)$% &7)($: "33$"/')2 / #.$ 3/'9"#$ /$(3)%$)#( ."( /$'#$/"#$%#.$(7=0'((')0"%$=4:$"/)$%&7)($:/#.$/$(3)%$)#+ % /3/"#'))%'" $."9$.$"/%:$"/)$%&7)($:/#.$3"/#'$("#:$)2#. "33/$&'"#$ #.$ /'9": (7=0'((')( #.$ 3"/#'$(8 '# '( )$&$(("/4##"?$')#&)('%$/"#')#.$/$:$9")##$/0(")%&)%'#')(#.$ #$)%$/%&70$)#(:"7($(")%@#.$"/$##.$::;')2$$&#*+ 3.

!"#

$%&%

' ()*+ ',-% ., () ' ' - '

' ' % ., ()

' - ' ' ' % .,

CWP No. 7493-2021 4 ( ) ' ' -

' % (ii)

- ' % ()*+ ',-% ., () ' ' - '

' ' % ., ()

' - ' ' ' % ., ( ) ' ' -

' % 28.

-. ' / '

0 ' - 1- 2/ !345 - ' ' -

'' 6 %7 -7=&:"7($ '''!&:"7($#.$ 8;.'&.."((3$&''&"::4 =$$)/$:'$%73)=4:$"/)$%&7)($:/#.$3$#'#')$/8'(##.$::;')2 $$&#*+ G'(iii)8'

, 9 : / 0 '

- ' & ' $ & !"#

';9

'' $ <

,$ (

= >, >9 ? $ &'$ )

/ %

' $ & 2 ?@ 2 ?!%7 33$)%'B+#.$#$)%$//0/$:"#$(##.$ "(#$/"#"#=$ 3/9'%$%=4#.$#$)%$/$/":)2;'#.&34#.$- $2'(#/"#')&$/#''&"#$ ")%#.$:'(#%&70$)#(":)2;'#.#.$#$)%$//0")%&:"7($+C#.$("0$ '(##.$::;')2$$&#*+ GA% - '

+ -

B>No√

CWP No. 7493-2021 5 :"7($+D 8;.'&.."(=$$)/$$//$%#=4:$"/)$% &7)($:/#.$3"/#'$(8'(##.$::;')2$$&#*+ GD &!= ' '

' ' /Confirmation of deposit of EPF by way of affidavit duly executed by the Employer (i.e.

Contractor/Bidder) * + 7 '

- 1- 2 !345

' ' ' * +' 7 ' / 9 +

'9 ' ' %

' 9 + % For any EPF violations which may be detected at any later stage, the contractor shall be liable and will be proceeded against as per law. The tenderer should be registered with EPFO as an independent employer, having separate code number as required for an employer under the provisions of EPF and MP Act 1952 and the EPF Scheme framed thereunder." /0"3$/7(":#.$"/$("'%&:"7($(8'#'($9'%$)##."##.($ $B3$/'$)&$%&)#/"&#/( %/3/"#'))%'"3"/#'&'3"#')2'))$; #$)%$/(."9')2')(7'&'$)#$B3$/'$)&$0"4"33:4=42'9')27)%$/#"?')2#."#

H "%%'#')": =")? 27"/")#$$ ;7:% =$ (7=0'##$% / /$:"B"#') $B3$/'$)&$ ")% ":( (7=0'# #.$ %&70$)#( #."# ."9$ =$$) $)70$/"#$% ') &:"7($#.$#$/0(")%&)%'#')(#.$$+#$)%$/)#'&$;.'&./$:"#$(# #.$3/9'(')(

")% &#8 F $ "/$ )# /$A7'/$% # 2 ')# #.$ "&#7": "(3$&# "( '# '( "%0'##$%=4#.$3$#'#')$/'/0#."#'#."()#':$%")4%&70$)#/$:"#')2#

"( $)70$/"#$% ') &:"7($ #.$ #$/0( ")% &)%'#')( #.$ #$)%$/ )#'&$#'(7/#.$/&:$"//0"3$/7(":#.$"/$("'%&:"7($+#."##.$

CWP No. 7493-2021 6 %&70$)#( /$:"#')2 #

."9$ # =$ ':$% =4 #.($ &)#/"&#/( ;. "/$ ='%%')2"(#.$3$/()(."9')2')(7'&'$)#$B3$/'$)&$"(;$::"(#.($;. "/$(7=0'##')2#.$#$)%$/("(."9')2$B3$/'$)&$%&$/#''&"#$ :"7($@#.$)#'&$')9'#')2#$)%$/8;.'&.'("33:'&"=:$# "::#.$#$)%$/$/(8$B3$/'$)&$%8')$B3$/'$)&$%/#.$/;'($87/#.$/3/9'%$( #."# #.$ #$)%$/$/ (.7:% =$ /$2'(#$/$% ;'#.

"( ") ')%$3$)%$)# $03:4$/8."9')2($3"/"#$&%$)70=$/"(/$A7'/$%/")$03:4$/7)%$/ #.$3/9'(')(

")% &#8 F")%.$'(":(/$A7'/$%#73:"% #.$ (&"))$% &34 #.$

&%$8 I"()*)+, -.)/. 0.1 01+213 - 4*2 51 6477(3)*83191/012E :"7($D ')=:%:$##$/("##.$=##0(#'37:"#$( #."# #.$ #$)%$/$/( ":: &"#$2/'$( (.7:% =$ /$2'(#$/$% ;'#.

"( ") ')%$3$)%$)# $03:4$/8 ."9')2 ($3"/"#$ &%$ )70=$/ "( /$A7'/$% / ") $03:4$/ 7)%$/ #.$

")% &#8 F ")% #.$

(&.$0$ /"0$% #.$/$7)%$/

/0#.$"/$("'%&:"7($(#.$$+#$)%$/)#'&$"(;$::"(#.$ 8 '# '( $9'%$)# #."# $9$) #.($ 3$/()( ;. "/$ "33:4')2 7)%$/ #.$ ')$B3$/'$)&$%&"#$2/4"/$/$A7'/$%#7/)'(.#.$

&%$ )#.$')(#")#&"($8'#'(")"%0'##$%"&##."##.$3$#'#')$/'/0 ."()#%)$(")%'(":($9'%$)#/0"&34#.$3$#'#')$/E(#$)%$/ %&70$)#((7=0'##$%=4'#=$/$#.$/$(3)%$)#+"7#./'#'$((3$&''&"::4"# 3"2$#.$3$#'#');.$/$')#.$3$#'#')$/."(0"/?$%IE')/$:"#')# '#$0C;.'&./$:"#$(#':')2"&34

&%$)70=$/.72.'# '((#"#$%#."##.$3$#'#')$/'/0%$(3(($((#.$

&%$8'#'(8.;$9$/8 7)%'(37#$%#."#)(7&.%&70$)#/$:"#')2##.$

&%$;"(':$%=4#.$ 3$#'#')$/":)2;'#.#.$#$)%$/%&70$)#(

CWP No. 7493-2021 7

/0 " 3$/7(": #.$ '0372)$% &007)'&"#') %"#$%

C ))$B7/$ +!/$<$&#')2#.$3$#'#')$/E(#$&.)'&":='%"(;$::"( /%$/ %"#$% F ))$B7/$ +C! /$<$&#')2 #.$ 3$#'#')$/E( /$3/$($)#"#')8'#'(:70')$(&$)#:4&:$"/#."##.$"7#./'#'$(."9$#$&.)'&"::4 /$<$&#$%#.$3$#'#')$/E(='%=4/$:4')273)&:"7($@#.$)#'&$')9'#')2 #$)%$/")%33$)%'B8&70$)#C")%&:"7($D ( .$:% =4 7( ') #.$ "=9$ 3"/"2/"3.8 #.$ "/$("'% &:"7($( %'% /$A7'/$ ")% 0")%"#$#.$':')2#.$

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

H#.$&)#/"&#9":7$/0"I-&.$%7:$%00$/&'":")?E)#''$% =4#.$ .$("'%&:"7($%$()#')")40"))$/$B$03##.$3$#'#')$/ /0 7/)'(.')2 #.$

&%$ "( 0")%"#$% =4 &:"7($ @ #.$ 8 33$)%'B+")%&:"7($D )/%$('#3/9'%$#."##.$3$/() ;.'("33:4')27)%$/#.$')$B3$/'$)&$%&"#$2/4'($B$03#$%/0':')2 #.$%&70$)#(/$:"#')2##.$

&%$

CWP No. 7493-2021 8 ) #.$ &)#/"/48 "( .$:% =4 #.'( 7/#8 &:"7($ @ #.$ 0"?$('#"=(:7#$:4&:$"/#."##.$#$)%$/$/07(#=$/$2'(#$/$%;'#.

"( ")')%$3$)%$)#$03:4$/."9')2($3"/"#$&%$)70=$/")%07(#73:"%#.$ (&"))$%&34#.$

&%$8"':')2;.'&.#.$#$)%$/;'::=$(700"/':4 /$<$&#$% )#.$')(#")#&"($8"%0'##$%:48#.$3$#'#')$/."()#7/)'(.$% #.$

&%$')#.$#$)%$//0")%#.$/$/$8#.$"7#./'#'$(."%)3#') =7# # /$<$&# #.$ 3$#'#')$/E( #$&.)'&": ='% "# #.$ #'0$ '#( #$&.)'&": $9":7"#').$"7#./'#'$(."9')2%)$(')"&&/%")&$;'#.#.$#$/0(")% &)%'#')(#.$#$)%$/%&70$)#(8;$')%)'::$2":'#4/3$/9$/('#4')#.$ '0372)$%/%$/()/%;$')%")40$/'#')#.$&)#$)#')(/"'($%=4#.$ 3$#'#')$/.$3$#'#')'("&&/%')2:4%'(0'(($%

6-J ! -

11!