High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1190/1997dismissed

Bimla Devi v. Ram Pal Etc.

2017-11-17Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

!"#$%!"

&& &&!!'%!''"

&&&))(( * +

,(-, &&& ). $&

&& &&!/0'!''"

(+ )12 . , &&&))(( * +

3 4-, &&& ). /& & &&/5$!!''"

(+ )12 . , &&& * + -, &&& ). 5&

&& &&!!66!''"

3 4 &&&))(( * +

,(-, &&& ).

7 &&&(#.

# ,))((8 &!!'%!''"9- ).&! &/5$!!''"& 7 &7+:,* #.

7 &,,+)#.

# ).&$8 &!!'%!''"9& 7 & &&;) #.

# (+ )1& <<<<<

"#$%& 7&!%6$=>$%!= &!!66!''"

1 ,))( ?4, +(. , 4&,))(+)) .1. &

, .,))(#,, 4, ) )..1& ))(..).&

&!!'%!''"-. , . ,((.)+ #&&# &!!'%#!/0'.!!66!''". ( &/5$!!''" ,

@+(A. ( .&

&!!'%!''".!!66!''", (.1 ,( :4 , )#A, &!/0'!''". ( &/5$!!''" , ,(+ )12 .,((44, A ..,( ,3+ .. 4,B & A+(. :4 , ))( ) . 1 , + )1#A, 1A .,7 .( +(8 , C +(D9,,((4.,4 +.,,. , +:

.., , . (.(,.,.# A,,,.:)(5&=&!''5& 7 & &&;) # ( . +( ) 4 , ( + )1+ ,,+ )1 (( . 1 A , ..,)(1, . 4(8?& !9A:&, 4 .#B+ 1 A)).# A, .,4+1,(.+., :

& ) A(. , .24+, 1# +, )(. .., 4 .))( A .#+, A 3..#,#,))(., & , 1#7 &&&(#( .+( ) 4

3 483+ .9. 8A ,B 9+ , ,+ )1,.(.., 4,+A, 4 ., +,1.4+1,. 4(1? 4, ( , ..) A, 4 ., #, # ,1, .) , 4, >? ,AA, 4 ., .((4&,+#,.4, +( . .+(1& 4 .,, )#7 &(+ ,,( &!!'%!''"(. , )+,. 4,B .,(

&!!66!''"((. , ) +,3+ + .1, , + A ..#&&#'%#%%%E> 4 & 3 4 .+. A&&&5&=&!''5!/&=&!''5#A,, . ,., 4 ?& !6&,+ ,3+ 1,() ., +4,, 1 F>$ &; (+)&((,?)# . 1#, )((,.& 7 &( , . , .( 8?& >$%9# A, 1) .(1,.,(.5%G&+ , !''5#, ( 3 4#A,A+.#A :$%%%E># ,, )(( .&

( 4 .,. 4,B #( , )+ ,., $%#%%%E>.()$#%%%E> .#, #, + )((,.

,. 4+.,B & 7 &((+ ,,+4,, .((() . , + , ) A ..# + , ?)#A,,,( ,)#, ) . .#+ , )+. ,?),+(., (4 .& , , .,( .+( ,) .)) . ,)) :& 4 . , )( , ) A, 4 .,. 4,B #&&# A,) B!5",7 *,(8 , C,D9#, 1(+,+ )(1, ( ) #( (. ) ,=#%%%E>A .. , #,A .. ) , ) (13+.

. (& 4 . , , ) @+ (

3 4#,A+..!'1 (.&1:4, $%%%E>) ,#.(15%G.1))(14 +()( !6 +) .(1.++ ( #, !#"$#6%%E> 8$%%%?5%?!6?!$H!%%9& ,+# , + ) ., .+++ ( 4.) .(1& 4 ., .(?)#, .((( , +0/#/65E>.#, #,1 .#.

) , + .( ?) 00#%%%E>& , )+, ) , 4# (,:#).

+ 4 +),(.& ,+# , ) A+(. !#"$#6%%E># !%#%%%E>+ (,:#).+ 4# 00#%%%E>

.(?).0#%%%E> ) , 48($#5$#6%%E>9& 4 .,)(,+ )1,,. A,(.4, (.. 4(, ( ) #, 7 & &&;) (((,+ )1, (., 4,+ ,:,. 4( 1(.4. E4 .( ,(4+, 1 ,? .) , & ,. (,))(

. ) 4 ., ) ,. 4(A+(. @+ , ? 4 , ( , 24 +, 1 ) , ) , & +((1# , .4+&/4,+ )1 +),(.&

, . # &!!66!''") (1 ((A.. &!!'%.!/0'!''". ( &/5$!

!''" . .& *+,-+#

& #$,+./

/+0/+# .1+$23456#+$.4+7 8+.6

/+0/+# +1#0$-%+ 8+.6