High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20741/2018dismissed

Sajni Bala And ANR. v. CBI Acb Sector 30a Chandigarh

2018-05-16Mr. Justice Gurmit Ram9 pages

!"#$!!!#%!# &'( )(&& #( *(+ $ $ ( & , -'!#%.!'

/(0 #%(#&

)((#&

)

-%1 !&( &'(0(&& #( +2((&3 (-%1 !&( (0 #%(#& $ '(0((#&0(&& #'!5((#(%+#%( #,) .!#& 65!& ! +(% 0(&& #(-#!2(6- !"#$!!!#% 7(8! 7'!# # !( /

/93 %!&(% (.&((% +#%( # $-:- ---- ) !#%

# , (!% 8&' # , !#% % )(1(#& +0& # &!&) ( &!& #$ -$-93-'!#%.!' ;(!#(% +#( &'( 0(&& #( #&(#% &'!& 5 &' &'( 0(&& #(!(+& !#%((%+ !&(%0( #!0(&& #(

'!0!(% &'&!#%!% #6-8'((!-0(&& #(

2!& +!&(!#%!1(.(&!5( (( $ &'&'(0(&& #(8((# &!8!(!5 +&&'(&!#! & #2!%( &' +.'&'(!

+#&!&'(0!5

<8((8&'&'(2!#! +(%-

#!2(6- !#"((17+2!-8'

8!8 <#.! +5) &2!&(!<'#3!&(-

<!%!!#%&'(!2(8((#(1(.1(#& &'(2;(!#(% +#(+&'(

#&(#%&'!&&'(0(&& #(8((# &'!1#.!#6%(!!5 +&&'(!(.(% !+%!!&'(1 + '(8((0(0!(%8&'&'(!2('!#%8&#.-8' ' 8!# & &'(0(&& #( (&'(!#62!00 0!& #'!5((#% #(56 &'(0(&& #(# &8!#&'(<# 8(%.('( #6!(.!& #(1((% !.!#&&'(0(&& #(&'!&&'(6! 8(%2!#! +(%

!#"((17+2!&

22&&!+%&' +.'&'(!

+#&;(!#(% +#(! #&(#%&'!& &'( 2!# ! +(% +(% & 5&!# .#!&+( &'( 0(&& #( # &'( 8&'%!8!=%(0 & 2!#%+(%& &'( 28&'

+&'!1#.!#6 <# 8(%.( &'(0(&& #('(0(&& #(!(# &5(#( !6!#(&'( !#6!2 +#& 8! 8&'%!8# 56 &'(2# &'(!2(8! +&>(% '( 0(&& #(!((!%6& "

#&'(#1(&.!& #!#%# &'#.& 5(( 1((% 2&'(2 +2((&3 (-(!#(% +#( $ '! (%&'( +52 #2!%(56(!#(% +#( &'(0(&& #( #&'(. +#%&'!& &'(0(&& #(8((8(!8!(!5 +&&'(&!#! & #! # & #6&'( !2 +#& 8! %(0 &(% 5+& 8&'%!8# ! '(( !( !(.!& # '(!&#.- .(6 !#% 2!00 0!& .

1(#2(#& !2 +#& '( !

+#&8(( 0(#(%= 0(!&(%# ##1!# (8&'2!#! +(%

!#"((1 7+2! &8!# &! !( 2(!.(!2 +#&5+&! !2 +#&8! %(0 &(%=8&'%!8# '( +& %! #&( .!& &'( 0(&& #( (?+(%!#%&'(6% # &%((1( # ( 65!;(!#(%

+#('!! ((%+0 #&'("+%.2(#& 9 #@5(&'(0(A +&#&'( !(

! "#$% !&'(

) ::,2(

&' +&# "(*& * ( +, % -.

$ !

%( %(% !#% '/ & ( !

,0"

% -.

$ !

, %( %(% #, #+00 & ' #&(#& # 9(!% &'( !.+2(#& !%1!# (% 56 (!#(% +#( &'( 0!&( !#%'!1(! .

#(&' +.'&'( #&(#& &'( /!#% &'( % +2(#&!1!!5( #&'(( %2&&(%6-&'((#&( %(0 &=8&'%!8! '+.(!2 +#& !(&'((#&'(0!5

< &'(0(&& #(

2( &'(.#!&+('!1( 5((#!%2&&(%56&'(0(&& #(&'(2(1(5+& 2(!(&!&(%& 5( .(%=!5 !&(%562!#! +(%

!#"((17+2!0(+! &'( / '

8&'!&&'((!(!(.!& # #0! 68&'2!#! +(%

!#"((1 7+2!!#%!

+#&8(( 0(#(%#) & (- !< %!#&'(#!2( &'(0(&& #(

& #6&'(!2 +#&8!%(0 &(%5+&&'(!2(8! 8&'%!8# #1! + ! #-8' ' (! 2&'((#&(2!%(#&'( !

+#& 5 &'&'(0(&& #( #1(&.!& #!&&'(#&!&!.(!#%5 &'

&'(0(&& #('!1(# &

0(!&(%#&'(!2(!#% +& %!#&( .!& # (?+(%& <# 8!& 8'!&2 %+ 0(!#%'!5((#!% 0&(%56&'( ! +(% 0( # # 22&&#. !+% !#% 2!00 0!& &'( .

1(#2(#&+#%

&!8((&&(%!8&'!&!#& 0!& 65! !## &5( !2(% !!2!&&( .'&5+&&! # ( #!#%&'(!2(& 5(.!#&(%56

#%(#.1! +! & .!#& 65!-&'(#!&+(-.!1&6

(# (!8(! ( &'(! +(%& 5(((#'((!( (&!#! & - 8' '!(& 5( #%((%8'(.!#&#.5!+#%( #,)9 #@5( &'(0(A +&#!"+%.2(#&(#%((%#( "

(&&!#( &( (% -.

!" !-(

B '!+22!>(% (&!#! & & 5(&!<(# #& #%(!& #8'(.!#&#.!#& 0!& 65!-8' '!((0 %+ (%!+#%(

C'(0# 0(8' ' !#5( +(% +&- &'(0+0 ( &'( #&!#& !(- !#5(&!&(%!+#%(

'( 20!#& (% !.!#& &'( ! +(% #((% & 5( &'

+.'6 (A!2#(%- # +%#. &'( !0( & 8'(&'( &'(

20!#!#&'!(%!!( 1 + 20!#& #(!(

! #'( +&'

+%! (A!2#(&'(! &8'(&'(&'(( !#6!26%0+&(5(&8((#&'(! +(%!#%&'( 20!#!#& !#%&'( 20!#!#&2+&5( (!6& %&'!&&'( 20!#& +#%& 5(!( 1 +-&'(#& &! & #85(&!<(# !.!#&'2#!

%!# (8&'!8 &'( ##1!# (5(&8((# &'( 20!#!#&!#%&'(#1(&.!&#. ((&!5'(%&'(# ! & #5(&!<(#!.!#&&'(#1(&.!&#. (#!

%!# ( 8&'!8 '(.!1&6 '!.(!#%&'((A! & ( &'(! +(%2+& 5(0 0(6 20('(#%(%$( (!(&-&'(!(&#. ( 2+&( %&'(1!%(! #8' ''!1((%& &'(!(& &'( ! +(%#&'( !(%!6 #(A (0& #! !(-&'((! #

+%5(( %(%22(%!&(6!&(&'(!(&- &'!&8'( %(!#.8&'&'(5!!00 !& #-&'((2!<!#% 5(1!& #

&'(!(&#. ( !#! 5(0 0(6(1!+!&(%56&'(

+& & 20(!&1( &'( +& & !(+6 !#% 8&'

2(& + + 0( # (1!+!&( &'( ! & &'( !( '( % (& #& .!#&5!2+&5((A( (% #&'(5! &'( !1!!5(2!&(!!#%&'(! & &'(0!& +! !( # !( 8'((&'( +& &'( #%((%1(8&'!&&'(! +(%'!

#(%&'(#1(&.!& #!#%'(+6

0(!&#.8&'&'( #1(&.!&#.!.(# 6!#%# &<(6& !5 #%-#&'!&(1(#&- +& %!#&( .!& #'

+%5(!1 %(%.(!&.# 2#6- '+2!& #!#%%.! (!&&! '(%& !(&(&(!%&

2!#6( + #(?+(# (# & #6 &'(! +(%5+& &'( (#&( !26 !#% !& &2( &'( (#&( 22+#&6 & 0( 0(% # &2!<(!#6%&# & #5(&8((#!(&!&!0(

#1 & #&!.( 0 &

#1 & #&!.( 1'((# "+& !& # (!%#.#& #,) &'(2&!& #2(#& #(%# #,)'(0(#&&+%(

# , 2+& 5( .1(# & + 0!6 '(( #

(?+(2(#&&'!&&'(! +(%2+&2!<( +&!C0( ! !(D &'( (A( ( &'( 0 8( & .!#& !#& 0!& 6 5! ' 1&+!6-(%+ (&'(!+&!60 8( #((%56 #, )& !%(!%(&&(0( #((<#.!#& 0!& 65!& !((2!#(#&&(%& &'(0(+20& ## (# (9( 8#.& +52&& (&!#&!#% #%& # #'((% 256&'(! (0&!# ( #%& #8' '&'( +&2!6%((2&&

20 (-# #%(!& &'(!+!# (&'!&!(&(%-'( '!5((#!.(% #5! 1 '( 0 0( +( ! & # !# !00 !& # !#& 0!& 65! +.'&& 5(&'!&!&((1!+!&#.&'(!1(2(#& !#%! +!& #!1!!5( #&'(( %&'( +&# #(% & .!#&!#& 0!& 65!&'(#!##&(25!5(.!#&(%!#% # & (5(+(%& &'()+5 ) ( +& &('(!#.&'( )+5 ) ( +& &'( +&2!6(&'(("( &&'(!#& 0!& 6

5!!00 !& #2&'(#&! %( .!#&#.5!'(

+&8 +% (&!#65((#&&(%& 20 ( #%& # &'( .!#& !#& 0!& 6 5! '( )+5 ) ( +& &'(

20!#!#&8 +%5(!&5(&6& 2 1(&'(!2( +& !# (!& 2 %6#.&'( #%& # !#& 0!& 65!!& !#6 &2( 5(&6 .!#&(% 56 &'( +& 2+(% '( !#& 0!& 6 5! .!#&(% 56 &'( +& '

+% %#!6 5(

#&#+(%&&'(&! &'( !( 1 &!(&&(%(.!0 & #&'!&&'( +&8' '.!#&&'( 5!! '!&'(0 8(& !# (&'(% (& .!#& !# (!& 5! !#5((A( (%(&'(!&&'(#&!# ( &'( ! +(%-&'()+5 ) ( +& &'( 20!#!#&- ##%#.

#(82!&(! +2&!# (!&!#60 #& &2( 1 #0++!# ( &'( %( &'( +& ( &'( 9.' +&- # (&'(! +(%((!(% #!#& 0!& 65!56 &'(&! +&-&'(#&8 +%5(+#(! #!5(& 20(&'( ! +(%& +(#%(5( (&'(&! +&!#%!.!#!006 (.+!5! 1 (& #1(&(%#&'( +&#!2!&&('

+%5( (A( (%8&' !(!#% +20( & #%(0(#%#.+0 #&'( ! &!#% +2&!# ("+&6#.&(A( ( 2!6-&'( % (& #1(&(%8&'&'( +&+#%( #,)'

+% ! 5((A( (%8&' !+& #!#%0+%(# ( &+##( (!6 & &!1(5(6 #%&!#%+5"( &&'(8%(0 8(!#%% (& #

#((%56&'((.!&+(& !.

+ %( ( 20 (% 2&!& #

#(A5(.+%(#( &!&"! <(& 2+! !#5( 0 1%(% .!#& (+! 65!5( !+(! +2&!# ( !#% &+!& # +&+( !## & 5( (!6 1+!(% &'( .!#& (+! !#& 0!& 6 5! #

# #!# (8&'(.!&1(#&(#& #-&'(.!#& (+! !#& 0!& 65!'

+%#( (!6%(0(#% #&'(! &!#% +2&!# ( (! ' !( AE('!! (0 %+ (0!! &'("+%.2(#&8'((# &'( +&%(#(!&(%&'( 8#.! & !#%0!!2(&(&'!& #((% & 5( &!<(# #& #%(!& # 8'( %(!#. 8&'

!#& 0!& 65!

!'(#!&+(!#%.!1&6 &'(! +!& #!#%&'((A! & (

&'(! +(%2+&5(0 0(6 20('(#%(%5( (!(& 2!%(F 5'(!#&( (%(#& &'(!00 !#&# +%#.&'(! &!&

8'(&'(&'(! +(%'!0(1 +6+#%(.

#(20 #2(#&

#1 & #56! +&#(0( & !#6 .#>!5( (# (F '(0 5&6 &'(!00 !#&& (( 2"+& (F %'(0 5&6 &'(! +(%@<('

%& (0(!&2!

&'( (# (F (E'((&'(! +!& #'!1(5((#2!%( #68&'&'( 5"( &

#"+#. '+2!&#.&'(!00 !#&56!(&#.'2 '(F 20! & .!#& 65!0!& +!6# !( !.(2!.#&+%(!( &#.!1(6!.(#+25( 0( 0(F . '( +& 2+& (1!+!&( &'( (#&( !1!!5( 2!&(! !.!#&&'(! +(%1(6 !(+6'( +&2+&! (!6

20('(#%&'((A! & ( &'(! +(%#&'( !('( !( #8' '&'(! +(%20 !&(%8&'&'('(0 #, !#%: &'()(#! %(-&'( +&'

+% #%(8&'

(1(#.(!&( !(!#% !+& #-5( !+( 1(20 !& ##&'( !(!2!&&( #<# 8(%.(!#% # (#F 'E'( #%(#.&'(0!6( .!#& 65!-!

5!!# ( '! & 5( &+ < 5(&8((# &8 ! & - #!2(6- #

0("+% ('

+%5( !+(%& ((-!!#%+#1(&.!& #- !#%&'(('

+%5(0(1(#& '!!2(#&-'+2!& #!#% +#"+&(%%(&(#& &'(! +(%F '( +& '

+% #%( (! #!5( !00('(# &!20(#. &'( 8&#( !00('(# &'(!& & &'(

20!#!#&F "1 &6#0 ( +& #'

+%!8!65( #%((%!#%& #6 &'( ((2(#& .(#+#(#( &'!& '! '!1( & 5(

#%((%#&'(2!&&( .!#& 5!!#%#&'((1(#& &'(( 5(#. 2( % +5& ! & &'( .(#+#(#( &'( 0 ( +& #-#&'(# 2! +( (1(#&-&'(! +(%# (#&&(%& !# %( 5!

% +5&# (A5(.+%(#( &!.'&"! <(& 2+! !# 5(0 1%(% .!#& (+! 65!!#%# !&&(20&'

+% 5(2!%(& 0 1%(.%!#%#(A5(.+%(#(#&'(0( &9 8(1(- .!#& (+! 65!'

+%#( (!6%(0(#% #! &!#% +2&!# ( (! ' !( $6 #%(#.&'(+52 #2!%(56(!#(% +#( &'(0!&(!#% #0(+! !(.!& #(1((%!.!#&&'(0(&& #(!#%

: ! &'( #&(#& # !(% 56 (!#(% +#( $ - #% &'!& !#& 0!& 65!!((-8' '# && 5(.!#&(%#! +&#(2!##( 5+&+#%(&'((A (0& #! +2&!# (0( #!00 ! '#.&'( +& + '((2+& 2(8&' (!#'!#%% +#.!&'(! &8&' +& !#6 # (!2(#& #&'(0((#& !(-&'(0(&& #(!(!%2&&#.!5 +& &'(<# 8(%.(!#%.#!&+( #&'(1 + '(5+&&&'(6!('

8#.

&'!&&'(6!(.# !#&!5 +&%(0 &!#%8&'%!8! &'(!2 +#&'( +& %!#&( .!& #!00(!& 5(#( (!6 20(&(!#%(( &1( #1(&.!& # & 8( (&&(% !8&'!& &'( +& %! #&( .!& # ?+!&!&1(62 (( &!& (#&(%&'!#?+(& ##.!+0( &-8'

8( (# # (%8&'!!1 +!5( %(+#%( #,) # !( &'( +& %!#&( .!& #%(#(%& &'(#1(&.!&#.!.(# 6-&2!6 (!1(2!#6

0!#%.!0#&'((( &1(#1(&.!& #5(#. !(% +&- 8' '# & !(%

#1(8 &'(!5 1(- !2 &'( #%((%1(8&'!& +& %! #&( .!& &'( 0(&& #( #( (!6 & +#(!&' &'( !2 !#% !+%+(#&! & # &'(0(&& #(!#%2!#! +(% %#.6-&'((# 2(&#&'( #&(#& #!(%56 (!#(% +#( &'(0(&& #(!#%&'(0(&& #5(#.%(1 % !#6 2(&'((56%2(% !6- 2 3

E'(&'(0(!<#.=(! #(% G( E'(&'((0 &!5( G(