← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9891/2000dismissed

Ishwar Singh v. State Of Haryana /- Reserved

2016-11-30Mr. Justice Darshan Singh13 pages

  

     

!"#$  

         

     

  

      

 

                 %&' '()*)+,

-  #,.

/# 0

1  

 !   " # $     !  %

& # $$&   ! " !# '  $  !  (# "  $    ) ! *  #   $  ! "

!# ' $    )+  , -

. )/,/ 

1   2      ##    . )/,/  000  #    

     

      

 2 . )34+  /,5  #      

  

 

 

#     7 (     ('

(  

 ( 

#

#((7#   

   # (7    4    # ( 08 ( # 9 

 

   

   /5:     #   ## ;        "



   7 *(7 /5/   $ # /,4          9 # (  #'    /5: #  

   # 7       7 '

 (

 # ( 2 

 #'    /5: #    ( 34,,     00/3 ) 7 (

  

+5 000  7    # (  

  7   00/3  7          <7 '

 ##

 7         +      = '

  7    + //0   ) 4  (  #' (   5//0      0//    )  +   ( ##

(   ((   =   00//3 ##  (      ( ( 304/,,

7 

(

      ( 

   #' 

  #



$  /,,   )(7 /,/ = (

  

+05 000    00//3          

   4 //  #  :0+//  !

      

>

   ( #'  7

(  

   #    

   # ' #  

    

   3 $     >

        7

     

     = '



  -(( 1 # /5: -?/5: #@1   (

   % 

/ /55     9  #'    (   (    # 9#

  ! #    A    ; "   #

7#   #'   *(7 + /,:      # (    <= ' (   

(      #' 7    (

A  /08 9  7  ( 



(    # :             #'  /5: #  (     7     $A = 'B    -(( 1 # /,,  #   /5: #  (      $  4 /,5  9#

     (  

  

 #        * ; "  ## 7 #

7#  (#  0    

  #     4

  9

 9  (  9#

      

(7      ## 

   #'  % 

/ /55      9     

  (   #    ##

 ( ( (

  08 9 7 % 

/ /55 5  #

     <= '   5

   #'  *(7 + /,:  7 ## 7      (    

 7# ,   ) 

 

# . )34+  /,5

     (      7     (



   

   

 # (      = '

    (     #' 7 7 ('

  (      (   *(7 + /,:  

 

      (   #  

(       /  /5: #  (     #

/,, 

 #  7 

   #  7#      (    

   

A  ( 4  0  (    9

  # 9#

  

    #    #

 7(     

  # 7 ( 

     #'

     /5: # 

   (



##     (#     #   )  +  #   (  #'    /5: #  4    (  #'  )(7 5 //0  . )/+:  //:  # 7   )

##

 (    )  +  #'    /5: #     (   C7 , //: 7

     7

   

  9   (       = '  >





    # #

  . ):33  //5  # 7  %

 #'   >

     7  ##

    (    #'      7 (     C7   //      ##  ! 0 //, 

#  

 /,:<,5     #7#   %

  #

7#    # #  (  #'   #  7  4 C7 0 //3   <= '

  #  ##     #'  ! 3 /,, + $

 7   ;

 # (

       #  > !#

   # . ) /:  //:

   ##

   C7 0 //3           #' ( $  /,,  )(7 /,/      (    # 

 7  #

 . )34+  /,5   7        7    =

 (   = '  

 ( ('

 (    7       

 #   #  $ # : //  #'   <      ##     

  # # # (

(7;C7 /,/ > !#

    

  & (     = '       C7 0 //3 

  (        



   !

*    = '   



000 C  7      

# 7

> !#



    <= '

      %  05

-

000       #     C7 0 //3    #   #        %  / 000 3   7

((

      # . ),++/  000 ##

     C %# 0 000  * =       

    # #   

      '   ( ##  7 (#(    ' (      ((

     C %#

+ 000   %#

5

000    C7 0 //3     .             7     

 . )/,/  000        7  : D7

  # 

# %      7

  #

 (  ##   A     

!

*    = '  #  

(  ## 

     #<'

 #    <('

   <  

  

 

   



 

 

!

 

   ! 

     ! 



" 

  

  

 

   

          

!



     

   !

      

  



           

 



 

 



     



 

    

 

    

 # $   %

 &   '()*

+  ,(

 '())    -  

   

   ! 

 !

         

    



! 

 ! 







. / "    

 



'23  



   

'()*  







 '4 '(5)  





     -  

  "

/  !  ! 







'2    

  1 

 1     #  



 

  

   

       



!

   

    +  ,( '()) 6 "

 .   



  

  

 

     

  

 

    







  ! 

 

 

   

  

 -#

!





 

  





!

 

!



     !  

    

 

 

 

 

  #



 

     

     #

 !



 -      



     

    

 

 





 

 

   

    #

 

    

  

  

   #





 

          

     

 #  



  6 

/

 

 -#

    







   7- ' 

!

  

 

  

 

+  ,( '())



    '((8

  , 

!

 

 







  

 





  4 

!

 

   

  !

    



  9   !    



 !

     

! 

       



    

 







    8  

 -#

 

  



      



 !



 

 :

5   ( ( #

  9   7 (# ,      7

# 7  = '    ## 7  

           /  # 7    (     # 7  

. ) /:  //:    # 

  7    7 <

 

     7  (  7 

 #  7      

     

= '     # 7 <

   #      . )/,/  000   . )34+  /,5  #   

  7  

0    !   " # #   #     !  %

& # $$&     < 

 <  ! " !# ' # 

  #   !  (# "  $    ) 2 ! *  #  # 

 #   ! "

!# ' $    )+  , 

 #

     (       #  (

   7  = '      ##    

 ( 

     # 7# <

  (     

 # # #  

(##

   7 (      (      7

     #    

  

     

 #  (       /,,<,/    =      $'



 )    //  -E2 1 050        (  

9  /08          %#

/ /5+      #   = '    (          7 ## D    ( #  

  %#

/ /5+   (     

  #'  : F   # ,08    7 ##  7  (   08 7 (  ; "   #       #     # (

   % 

/ /55     # #

08   (   = ' A#

   (    % 

/ /55 5:   #'       7

 ' (  ! 3 /,,   4              ( ! + /55  ! 3 /,,    #  #   # 7 /,, #    7    ( 9 (

 A  /0 0  /,, #    (

(( 9#

  !    

 A    "    (      ! 03 /,,  = ' 7  7   

  $  4 /,5  9#

  (     #'  (





   7    $  4 /,5  7#  ## < #  '45'(5) 0 '45'(5)

1 ! #

1 ! #

1   A    ";

1 $ # 0  6A   " *   ;'

 & (     & 

##  

  7    

! #

##   = ' A#

     #7# 7

% 

/ /55  $  4 /,5  ++        (  (  +        "  (  #' 

    ! , /5/ ! 0  /,3   $ # 3 /,:  #  C   #  7 ##      7

 "(   = 

  " = 

         "(  (  ! 0  /,3 7  

       >7        "   

 

(       "    

     = 

   7  

  ##   & (    # (#    9     

   & (

 /,,  = '   



     # ( (   (  

 6(#      ##     (  (    

#  #  7  G    $  4 /,5    9#

  (  

  = '   #

     (  #'  

( 7 /, /,:  = '  A#

   

   (

  #

 ##   7 

 #

#    

#

H 

     % 

 



   $ /,4  ,3

 # 7#     7  #   = '      

    #  (  

(  # 7  (         

   7 A#

 7

( 

*' $

#    F  - 01 :

 5 3   7    7

  #



#

 = '

(  

 (    (  7

 

  '    6    ## 





   7

       (

    7 

 #      7 #

>      *

#  (  7 A        #

#    #  (#      (   #   (



4    (   #   

      7  7'   #   (7      

  ( % 

/ /55  //3  7 A#



     !

*    = '  ! +      $

A $<    # A#       

 



 #

   = ' 

      (      #

   7  

 9 7 (       (

      (       

     (



 9    7 (  7 (    

A    9

3  #  7   #     #

7#



  (     #'  *(7 , /,  $  5 /,+ (7 + /,4   %# /,:

 

    7      6     #7#    /5:

# #   ##  ( 7 ( ##

  #

9#

  A   (       # 7  



# 

        

     ( # 

 )  >

  (  (  #'   #     = '     

(   

 

  

:  #           

  

   # # 

 7 

  (

   ( # 

         

  7     7

 # # 

  G<< G   ( #;   # 

     

 #  #     

# # (#  7   # #

#  A (       !

*    = '

    # 

  #  (  # .   (          7 

  0 

   ;$    ##    (   (   #    #                (#   

  7  (        7 7# 

   >   9 7# (



      

#  # >  *G   > (   7  7      #       #    7  )  # 7 (  

 (  

 (

  7 #  

 

      (#(   # #  

       7    7     

(   (    7    7   (     #   ##  #   > (         # 7  ( (   > (    ! " #

5 =      (  !

1   $

-     ( > <  =

> <  ! ;