Suresh Sood v. State Of Punjab And ANR
,-. /, !0
12, /,!%0
3,43.
6,, 31 78.4, ,9., & :;&
3 <
, '
& 3<=0.-2149
& & /00 78
& 0.-21,9., !$
<
0
>4,91..32#?
, @,4 "#..
!")A '!+0/,.. 32 14324..,,.324..8,) -1 2,+20!(?(B411.,C43*32D0 2 3 &/ >0 ,2 &/0 78 . 4 ,8,@ 92./,41
E,./.42=91,4F<=31 ),9. +0 ,.16=F3840&/0E4/E4 -,4112,G112,14&2990&/02= 492,0//4!%
!"8!
= 0 =/1112,G11214& &/022,.3,43.
)94+,.2,.E.,8>,/44EF 2 /, 244, . 4 112, =. 4 , / /,.8>4=-,92,,.,424,,4
244,.84/,,4E4.,91=.04,.,8/ 4112.,29
)+ ,2..8>.2,1494
@,, 4/ 8 2 8, 1 -, E 9,0 2=99,.49,1.8>49814, /4/,4112,G112,14&2990 E442=949,
4 4,8/ /,. E4 =1. 9,,H 4= )9+ E4.E42,,1.8>4= 4,/-.,1-, 9,1.8>4=1===/,4112,G112,1 4&2990&/ ,2..144. 1/14-,E9,G2=99,8>4=./4 9.1=
?
!$04E,-4.8>4=9>,1 4&2990&/E4.E4,2,,12. 2,@2,0/./E4244.=.2=9..
?
!$ )A '?+4-,4, 48,,11= 9-.. 8> 4 &29 90 &/0 9 4. , 9,441 &,0 780 1=/ 4-42, 8/,.8>43241&2990&/ 4/,.,.4,=E8/.-8>4 9,,4-/-..-/22.,4&299 =9>,2=FE84,.9,04>E /,F
"
!%.,..=./,4 /, 4=)9+
)+ ;. 2, 1 4 9 4, 14 .E E.,94/94,)A '!$. '!%+8>2./
1!!9/,
4 9'9. =0 4 &29 9 =9>,G2=99> !'
"
!%.=9.4//8/ 4/19I,,49.4,0/./E4249, )A '!(+..
"
!%E,=.4-,4,
%
"
!%09E,2=9.99244,8>1/ J !$ ?" 1
!% .2 4 112, 1 4 &29 90&/2./4==,,,8>. @>1411498>=-/4/8/.=9.8> 4,F/=9>,14&299114, ,.2.,49 2,,>.2,E,,.8>4,-. ...
"
!%)A
+08,4.2,E 2=9.E402=998/
?1
!%E, 81.8>49 $
!%1//=-.4.=9.
/8/.,>4144/8/E,=-. 4 9,./.
..!%
!%.32 %( 23>340/./41,.2.08 .,9/-/,9212=,092/,.4 /,FE 9,, 2=/FE84/,1
1
!%04=9>,14&299,.4/4 9E4.E4,=.42,,04E,4,48 =92.2=2,,1,,
)+ , 1 4 9 14 2., 4 !%
!"9'9.=049E,2.4 112 1 4 &29 90 &/ /./ 4, 9,..
"
!%0,921.=9/1/8/ 114,,49.4,.,42=.E,,14=/0
1!!9/,
4=9>,,..*..4=8.>K,24.4,8//, .,2920E4,2.4=1=/.14 &299=9>, /2..4,,= 841,.2././!?
!")A "+4 92 ;.2,14914,8=,4492 -,.4,902.2...0.9..,2@> 4,./,.1.4/,142=99> 8>1, E,22..8>49242,. E.,4.8,.4=9>,14&299. ,0 92 99. F. .. !
!" )A + ,==8449, 19,14F.0=9>, E,F1!$.>,..,22.4E.,E/99 ,42>.410,2.2=9..
!"E, =.492/./4,=2.1!%
!"022/ 412=12=9.F...!
!".4 92E42.2/>@>0/,.49, . 9,,
)-+ ;.2,149142.,4- 89,142,14 0112.32 1 43*32,=.0,4,/44E,> 1,=.E44=4==8 1324..,.324..8,>982920,, 232 )!+)+142 4,/4 44 9, 4==8 1 4',24..2,0 4 4 9,,142=99>==8,14,24..2,,K 4494.4FE./1,2412, ,142..
#1!!9/,
44/.2...224982-E ,.,4, A9..>1 '!G =4,.//4 0E44 8/>A914.> )-+;.
,1494,1.L<,4; 4E* , - 31
* M
!) + )=+
K L884- 317M
)#+ )=+ !!KL<.9 7 &47- F=4.M0
?)!+ )=+ "
.L,4E
93/4- 31 .,4M0)
!?+! 3%!
0,99 4,2, )-+J44,,8=,,,09>,=.@,44 @,
49>1.8>4,9.'30,,8=.4 12=91-,/0244,.>81. , .=. 4 F. . 32, ! "G!$
E, 99.-. !!0..!
!"E4= 4E.. ,142,,.8>49 ,.84=12.
$
,9., $0 02=9,14 0.. 1>9>49 ;.2,99/8411 4,,9.,0>,8=.4 4,8/4>/,..
44244,.>81..4,=14 4>112,=.
%
4-2,..,8=,,,1844,.,.4- 9,.42.21>
"
4,8./.8>4 ,.16=F3840 &/0E44.2=492,/E4-,4
$1!!9/,
112,G112,14&2990&/0///1 42,.E.,8>49=/0E4244.F 9241121&2990&/
?
32 )!+)+143*32.,,. ' L)+>,,=.,E44= ==81324..,324..8>92 E4982-EK''M
, , 2 1= 4 8-,. 9-,0 4 8,2 /., 1 4 112 . 32 )!+)+ 1 4 2 2 8 2,,1., L!+>,,=.,E44= ==81324..,324..8.
+>92E4982-EM
L,46=- 31 F4.M0
)#+
)=+?%?04,84.8>4I839=4 872 1 4 2 , 9,4 -,0 E4 12 ./,0 4=,.4,,=/,4-8,214,2> .4,0 42,.. 9,4 2,1 99 2, /, -8,21,2>1,44>8/92 2==> E,144.4 L4112.32 )!+)+142E..24 /.1,.=.E4 4===81324..,324..8
,,=.,9,E8112 .42,,,24,=.,221 -2=8//324..,324..8 M !!
4,04,,=.9,E.8 112.420,,,24,,=.,221 -2=8//324..,324..8.14 4 =9 F> /. 1 9-,, , 4 4 ,
%1!!9/,
=.,4.8>92E4/982-E 42, 814I839=04/,18,/1= EE41E,18./ 4E,4==81982 4=12..E,4.448,2/.4E., E.L>92E4982-EME=.
4/',44AE,@,4.8>4I839=
L/ 4- 31
* 4,M0
?)#+
)=+!"!02=9E,1.8>=81,24.. 2,,422,.8,.4=E44=14,2,0E4,/ ,E4422,.E,==814,24..2, ,24..844>,.=..E4 4=42=992E4982-E ./4 8,2/.,1112E=,,/042=9E,@,4.8> 4I839= 3=-EE,F L,4E 9 3/4- 31 .,4M0)
!?+! 3%!
49,2,0,2.44 ,.14 6=F384/E4-,112,./.4 //,1 2,.E.,8>49 E-04 .,- 4E44>14112,G112,14=1=4 2=99>8/.,24..2,,24.8, 4 ,/49E,==81',24..2, 449FE4>14112,G112,14 &2990&/0E442=9,142,0 8/ ,24.. 2,, ,24.. 8, ,.,0 4 /.
2.F92E412,14&2990 &/48,21>9829,
"1!!9/,
!#
> 8-0 /./ 4 ,= 2.0 92 2.2.2,,>@>.2=422,42, .E.,4.8,.8>49.,0>4F. -. !!..!
!"E,,8=.8>492. 32!
"G!$
029>1E424,A
, 4, 8./.E4>124F.,921 ,=2.
!$
,,@=1,1=42.494 /.2.1!%
!"094.1.-,E9, 2./ 2=9 9, /, 4 112,G112, 1 4 &299.44.84.8>4==. /E4.E4,2,,
!%
L31>. ,-,4 47;M!((
% #0I839=..E2/.,,E44 49E,.32#?
,4.8,.@,44
E,4.,. '
L?
4A2,14A'.>9E.2
%4 49E,.32#?
14.1= 2.0 4 1E/ 2/, 1 2,, /- 8> E> 1 , E4,249E2.8A2,.49-8,14 92,,1>4E,,24.,17,204/4 =>89,,8>.E>92,02>.1.. ,112>24,..1A8/.'N"=>.F.,12,, E4,249E,4.8A'2,.
)+E44/,=.4 ,1= 94 2=90-14>F412-.229.4 >.9=122,>112=F2, /,422,.K )8+E44/,4 ,1= 9.4 =,01>022=9>/4
..,2,2/H8 11207,1>/-,/8>92112,.32
?1!!9/,
!$%)!+14.A29..1&/,E44 9-E132!$$) +14.K )2+E442-./,=.4 :2=9 .4-.222.,9914,=..,2,4 2==,,1>112.=F2,/,422,.K ).+E44/,4 .2,2/H8 11282,>'2/H81120-,/, 9=. 8> 92 112 E4 . 1 &/, , 2=9..32!$$) +14.K )+E44/,=.4 2=9,8,.
.4>=98848,,1E4249.9,2 - 24 7, 22, 4 4 , ,112 /. 1 92.//,422,.K )1+E44,A9,,/8/1.>149-,, 14.422.2).E4242=92./, ,.+4,.221492./,.G E44,,92129-,4.422.20 9-./1122,.,,14/-214//-.9>K )/+E42=92./,=1,>..E4=1. .GE4492./,=2,>,.E4 =-1EF/-/2422,..E4-E,9 4=.9-.9,/./ M !"
4914,2049,2,1,E44 9=,, )+0)2+.)1+1.8-
!?
91=8-038O34O3=6, 31
.,4* , B=99 ##1
,/1 ;
)=+ !$ 1
D .2.. ?4 /,0
I839=01F/19=,..E 47;I,2,),9+1@,4/14 2=92./, 144.,.
% 4, ,/0 E E. F 8,- ,=4/ =9
J4- 22,. 2=, 81 4 -F/ 4 4 49E,.32#?
14.1= 2. ) + A.> 7,.2 . 2
% 1 4
(1!!9/,
, / 4 4 2= 92./, @,4. ,,>4/.4,2492./,=1,>1-, -A, ,. E4 4 =- 1 EF/ -/204,2422=,2,4E,.>F 4 E42.=2,>
J,>,82,242=9.2.,92./,4 22,.E4=-1EF/9,-/202 44E.,44 G2=9,->E.1.E4 4 2,,> 9./, 4 2=9 E. , 4 4 -=,=.4 G2=9,2444>.,2,4 2,,>/.,2,4/.112
410E87,/414F4 -=, =. 4 G2=9 1 4 99, 1 ,2/E4442,,>/.,2,4/. 112.,2,. 1-,-A,92./,04 E,.>F=>4./22=,2, =//1=42.142,-.8-4-=,.0 1.80E4.2.22=,92>.8E4 ,
4E4A2,/,7,.2.32#? 14 2
%14,.,2,1> 4,/12,8,=9E.F224- 22=,2,./4G/,142,,E, 4=,22.42,1-,/
F1,242,4.
&9 ,4-8/,.
-9.1= ,482F/.1,2422=,2,4 /,1=9 ,,,=,=92048>2/4 ,, 1 EF/ -/2 1 9- 9, /./ , /.
M !(
=4.,2,,,8-014/,E, 12=A142,0,4.4-14/,4
F412-.229.4>04>. 2,112.49-,,13*32 4
2>99,84,19,-./,490 E44.1.9,/,4112,G112,14&29
1!!9/,
90&/=./ -42=99E,1.
E4/8/.=9.114,,49.4,0,,-.1= A, '!$. '!%0 E,=-. 8> 4 112,1 4 &2990&/
,>0 4 9, 9 , 48> 229.
22./>0 "#0..
!")A '!+0/,.
. 32 1 4 324.. ,, . 324.. 8, ) -12,+20!(?(B1,4411.,C4 3*32D0 23&/>0,2&/0 78. 4,8,@92./,41048>@,4.
/,!%0
) <
+ 3 J44,.G,9F/ , J4498 ,
!!1!!9/,