Sarbati And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
!
"#$ '$()*)%+
, ,
-"./"#) %#0$.*
,,,,,,
1$.*2* -#"#$ ".3"+"
%#0$.*
,,,,,, $*4%+'$+#* 5 6 ,
- - .$*$+# ., 2+&")'
70"+8
'9%("#$
*, 4"*"+"
0":"+8
".3"+",
, , - 8
,
6
,
-"./"#) %#0$.* &);$'
.#)(;$* < %+*#)#2#)%+ +')"8 )+#$.
";)"8 +"#2.$ ($.#)%.".) *$##)+> "*)'$
8
>.".)"+(2@-2/ )9)*)%+";
&&)($.
)9);8 A)+ *0%.# 5%;;$(#%.
>.".)"+5B,
,
&2.#0$.
4."3$.
)**2"+($ +"#2.$ @"+'"@2* ').$(#)+> .$*4%+'$+# %, $+#$.
@2#"#)%+ ";;%##$'
9)'$ ;$##$.
, ,
C, ,
((%.')+> @$"*2.)+> )>0"
)*:"* -0.) "+%0".
6";
/)> %:+$. '$(;".$'
*2.4;2*8
)#* @2#"#)%+ +%# $+#$.$'
+"@$ ".3"+"
%9$.+@$+#,
# , , 8 ').$(#)+> $+#$.)+> @2#"#)%+ "&%.$*")'
+"@$ ".3"+"
%9$.+@$+#,
, # (;")@$'
, , 8
>.".)"+ *#"#$@$+# /$&%.$ @$')"
+%+/)*:$'".*8 /"(=:".'
*(0$'2;$'
("*#$ 4$%4;$ 9);;">$ "0/".8 "'%E) %#0$.
+$"./3 9);;">$* "44;)$'
/$&%.$ %&&)($ - 8 '$@"+'$'
;"+',
# <,, 8 "44;)$'
;"+'8 '$(;".$'
"&%.$*")'
*$+# 9$.)&)("#)%+8 :0$.$24%+ )# .$4%.#$'
')'
+%# )@@%9"/;$ %.
@%9"/;$ 4.%4$.#3, *#"#$ , , 8
>.".)"+ ($.#)&)("#$
- +"@$ ";;%##)+> #0$@ 7"+";
".;"
%2# ;"+'8 :$.$ ').$(#$'
'$4%*)# "@%2+#,
, # ;$##$.
8 '$4%*)#$'
$+#).$ "@%2+# , , 8
>.".)"+
C, , # "9$..$'
'$*4)#$ '$4%*)# "@%2+#8 @2#"#)%+ ";;%##$'
+%# $+#$.$'
+"@$ "((%.')+>;38 #0$3 , ,
/$&%.$ $0*);'".8 208 "+%#0$.
, ,
/$&%.$ $42#3 %@@)**)%+$.8
"(#)%+ #"=$+ #0$.$%+,
0$.$"&#$.8 &);$'
/$&%.$ #0)* %2.#8 ("@$ /$ ')*4%*$'
%&8 9)'$ ,,
:)#0 ').$(#)%+ $0*);'".
'$()'$ "* 4$.
;":, , # #."+*4).$* &);$'
(%+#$@4#
< 4;$"
,, 8 #0)* %2.# 0"'
+%# (%@4;)$'
:)#0,
2.)+> 4$+'$+(3 (%+#$@4# 4.%($$')+>*8
>.".)"+F "((%.')+>;38 (%+#$@4# %.'$.$'
/$ ')*@)**$'
:)#0 ;)/$.#3 "9");
#0$).
"44.%4.)"#$ .$@$')$* "((%.'"+($ :)#0 ;":, , + "&%.$@$+#)%+$'
().(2@*#"+($*8 &);$'
.$;)$& *8 "* +%#)($'
0$.$)+"/%9$, , $".', , # ("*$ .$*4%+'$+#'$4".#@$+# 0"'
)+9)#)+> ;"+';$** 4$.*%+* *")'
"'9$.#)*$@$+#8 <,, #0$.$"&#$.8
>.".)"+ ($.#)&)("#$ ),$,
-
+"@$* &%;;%:$'
)**2"+($
, ,
C8 *")'
:.%+>;3 ("+($;;$'8 9)'$
, , 2.)+> (%2.*$ 0$".)+> #0)* 4$#)#)%+8 *4$()&)( G2$.3 42# (%2+*$;
.$&$.
.$*4%+'$+#'$4".#@$+#8 (";;)+> 24%+ ;"+';$** 4$.*%+*8 0$ 2+"/;$ *0%:
*2(0 "'9$.#)*$@$+#,
, + 4.$*$+# ("*$8 <,,
8 >)9$* )+#$.$*#$'
.$"')+>8 .$;$9"+# $?#."(#* .$"'
"*
! "# " $ !# ! " %#& & # &
' ( ) * + +, + -
.
/ +# &0.+ 1' ( -
2 ' '
) '
.* # *
*+ + *
*
.
(' . 3+ * - 4"
4 4
,
44".$+#;38 #0$.$ .$&$.$+($ *")'
<,,
2.#0$.8 4$.2*";
)@42>+$'
:%2;'
*0%:
-8 ".$ 4;"()+> .$;)"+($8 #0$+ -2.4;2* "#:".) -0.) 0">"# "@ &%.>)+> *)>+"#2.$*
>.".)"+, 0$ .$;$9"+# $?#."(#*
.$"'
"*
!%1
% 4 4 & 6
7$8 ( 9 . ' +
*
+ 7& + '+'
*
* + ,
6.+ # . ' :6#;
. <
0
(
11 ! "11 " $ !11= " %11& & & $ > " "&
&4> 4 ?#
7& (
/ 6.
"11 & &11 = = $11& 4 %11 = > $"
"$
&4> 4 ?#
7& & (
0+ =11 >. 11 4 & $11 = !11 ! "11 !1 !11$ $"
"" "%
&4> 4 $ ?#
7& $ (
4
"11 " "11!" ! %11 &
#!4 > "= ">
&4> 4 $ ?#
7& / ' *
7& .
, 6.
+ . 7$
'. # .
*
+ + . ' :6#;
. <
(
11 ! "11 " $ !11=
"%11& & 11 & $ >
4$4! 4 & (
/ 6.
"11 & &11 = =$11& 4%11 = >
$" %
4$4! 4 & & (
0+ =11 > . 11 4 & $11 = !11 ! "11 !1
!11$ $"
%!
4$4! 4 & $ (
4
"11 " "11!" ! %11 &
#!4 > %$
4$4! 4 &
<
)
' 7$+ %
4$4!4 & ' .
7$ + .. , * * . #.
*
, 6. 1
.
-' 9 :'; 5 <, 6$".+$'
(%2+*$;
&");$'
.")*$ @$"+)+>&2;
".>2@$+# .$&2#$ (%+#$+#* "/%9$ $?#."(#$'
8
>.".)"+,
".$ /$+$&)# ";;%#@$+#8 /$ &."2'2;$+# "(# -2.4;2*
"#:".) -0, 0">"# "@,
&");$'
.$&$.
@"#$.)";
*0%:
%9$.+@$+# 0"'
(";;)+> 24%+ +%.
"/;$ *0%:
#0$3 ".$ $+#)#;$'
.2;$8 4%;)(3 %.
)+*#.2(#)%+* %9$.+@$+#,
%+*$G2$+#;38 &)+'
E2*#)&)("#)%+ (;")@
, $*2;#"+#;38 &");* *"@$ ')*@)**$',
C,
$+')+>
*8 )& "+38 *0";;
";*% *#"+'
(;%*$',
-
, ,
*E=* 0$#0$.
*4$"=)+> .$"*%+$'
!$*
% 0$#0$.
.$4%.#"/;$ !$*
%