High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7121/2019dismissed

New Senior Secondary School Civil Lines, Ludhiana v. State Of Punjab And Others

2019-09-05Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa6 pages

!" #$!#%

&& '' ($%$ '

') %* +'$ && $, '$

!"#$

%&'()$ ($%) $

') * ) '

$'-& ./ , ! " ')',''/ ($%) $

') * ) '

+, 1 ' $'

' ,'' $ ' '

23/44/254367% &458, $$ %* +

'9$)',''$ $+ ' ',

$%9 ) $/2 : ' ,"

' $, '$ /; ' < + 1 ' '9 ''+1)% / )) '$'

'% =%' '

'',''$

' $''%''"1 1 '&& )9''

"'/ $, '$/;'< "1 ,, )',$')' $! $ ,,' * >/?/4?3>!45/@/4??2!4?/>/4?>4 </A/4?3;

$,'" /$"$'9 " $

?B44/@/4??> , &26 8/% ' $$ ,"

'$+ ) 1C &45@;>&4??> '',''

4>/A/254;/# $,) '$ 9

)+ "$)'$%'4@/4/254@1 '1 +'

'' ,, '$6,"

'$8' '

/ '9$ ) +'

1 ! ,"

' $, '$ )

,''B '+)' %* + $$ 1'

')',''$ "1'9 '$"$/%

,''B ' $'

$ '9$ ) 9,%1

23/44/254367% &458 1 '1 ) )&' %$ ,$'1',''$ 1% '' C'%' $9$$1C &45@;>&4??>'

+) ,"

'$!

'''9 $)','' +$ " ') + )' ')$"$ ,$ '% $%) 1 $'+$' $ + '#''$

''/'$$%1''+' '% $%%9$'

$ ' % ' "''

1 $''

'9'$ $%1% '9,%1

&45 '$%$'

/ ' $+ 1% '' ,"

'$'9 $'9, '$ $''9 1 1'' 1:!:1)9: $, ' $$$ $ %')'

9$ %'/ $%%9$'

$ ',''$ $ ''$1'$' " $,$ '' $"$)',"

'$!:1 $' $/ '$

$$' '

' '

%9'$

+ , +) ' $7%$ &4' &2>'

19, '$!

"$// $!

1$'/'

+$$% '',"

'$+%'$% $,'

$+9, ' " : '+% /' '$%+9$$ $ + %$ $ '

' '$"$ ) ' ,"

' $, '$

$,$ '' 4??> '$'

$' $'

+ )% 9, $) '$ $ $$%' )' '1 9,$ ' ) $/2 : ' ) "% $ %

- %$ )','' $+ ' 1' ,

1$ "+9%' ,%$

%+'

!',"

) .-

/0 '1+2 3 1+ 4

' 0/5 3 1+ $$ 1 ' ' ) ' $ "1 '9 ' $"$/%','' " *% 19'

4>/A/254;

&</ %$ )'*% 19'% " " '

''','''$ )$'9 '

+ % ' 22<B22> )'$''%') $' $ 1''9 $ '+$'% + " ')'+ )' ')$" $,$ '%/' $$%1% '

''',''

/ ',% '9 ', 1 ,)'*% 19'' $

+$" ''1% $ $ $1 $''9 :1 $$ +1" ')',, $) '% *%$'$'

+11' $'9'$)' $$'03+ +/1 $'' *% 19')'C'%'!# $)

)4@/4/254@') 1'9$-&

!"#$ %#

&''((

) !

* %#

&+ ' %

-./0 +12"34,01"/4+"45- -6/0 +12"34,0-+40+"45-"4-2

5,#!

7(8%9 #''(( 1"/4+"45-81(

3# ''(( $ #

,! *: #(( ;

; #

$ 9 3#: (%, (< 87# #7

% =*:* 9

;## $7 $

*( 47 ( %##' 7 9

;

9" #(8 7# #7 %%*:#59 $ 3# 9 $:#9*

$ *7 #$ %#$ ;$ # " #(

7(8 !

(#''(( #( *:

#!(%#9* ; %#''(( '' ##0%!

(

$ #% - .*(#"!'$,! - #( *:*; %# $'' ##3 *!

( <% %

;(: 1"/4+"45-

1!%; -+40+"45-"4-2

1!%;> ' $ " ) '$ %'! +'

"1 + 1 '#''$

''' '

%, '') ''

'' $)'9 '

'+ 7 9 9'$+ 'C'%'!' %1''

*% '9 ''9'$/$$,$ $+

+ , $$1'

23/44/2543 67% &458/7,''$%%$) ' +'

:/ %$ $ $%1' ' *%$') ' ' ) '9 ' +

' 1 '

' ' %9%$ 9, '$ $' ' ,"

$, '$ $ 1 $ ' ' 1 :! :1 9 :!

$, $$$ $ $9$ %'/9 $'

$"'

: +)' ',

+$%+9'' + ))',''$ /)'$1 9

' "9'$'

, A)'''$'

'9') ,''$ +)' ,, 1'

'$'

','' $7% &?/

' % + % ' '

: ' '

' " '%1! ' '9 ' $ , $$ $' ,"

' $, '$ % %%$ '9$ +%' ' $'

) ' ,'' $ +) ' %* + $'$'

'',''$'

' ) '9 ' $ '

: %' ) 9, '$ 1 1 1:! $, ' '$)9$ %'/' ' )'9 ' $,%'" '%/" ,"

$''%'% $%%9$'

$ $+ 1 '' ')' 1% =% ' $'! ) ') 1=% $'' ' $'

1 '' 1 '$)9$ %' ') %'

/$% =% $ %' ',''$ /

''$%') $'

')$"$)',"

'$ $'

9$)) ,

%'' $1 )',, $) '%

*%$'/%'"' ) '% ,9$$'

'',''$'

" $" $ %$ ' ' " 1 ,,'%'

) 1,''

:1'7'9$',), $$1) $ )'9 '/ "'%1! ''9,' $+9

+ %$ ' 9,$$%,'$%''

%9'$ "+, +) ' '1 ''

"$// "1+ 1$ "1+$$% '!+%''

$9)' '

$)'%$ ''+$"

'$9

'9,%1 '

''// $'/ *%$'

,'''9 $ "1+ , $$ '' '1 '$'

''9, '$"9

$%+*'

'') $, , 1$9% $$$ %$'$ "1 +$$% /+% $1')% ''9 ')$"$)

6 ',"

'$'++

/ $1 $=% '%9)9,$ '$ !$"$) ',"

+1 1 ))'

'$+' $4?>4'4?3>

+'9 '9'), !4??>/ $' $ "+ 1'

'1'$$%"$/')$'$'

',''

+) ' 4??>'$ )/ ',''

"1 + 4>/A/254; ' 1% ) ' +1 '

+ $' ,"

'$ !# $) /$ 9

"1+ )4@/4/254@1 '1 +'

' ' !',"

'$) 'B,'' +)' ' 254@'$ )/%,''$'

)

), $$1)'9,%1

23/44/2543 67% &458/1 $' 1)% ')$"$) ',"

'$' 4??> '$ 9 "1+ $ )

' 2543! 9%') $/2 : $9,$ ' '+'9 $) )% /$ 9% '=% '"'

'' $)'$%'7$)'$'*%$ '% ' 22<)'$''%') $ 9' ' $'

' ,'' ' $ 9 $!

($%) $

') * ) '

%&*$ %:

C'$, :1B $ - $B C' ,'

+ - $B