High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1419/1997disposed of

Tonney v. Krishan Singhtc

2019-03-18Mr. Justice Satpal28 pages

!"# "

$%&'

" ("()**+&,)- .

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

/(,0

$%&'

$ !%$ % $

/(,0 "

&+3!4 &5 5 45 44 & '

" $ !%( "

) $ !% ( * + ,-,.,-/.(,..0 ( 123.(,..0

4$ !% ( ,5/ * + ,-,.,-/.(,..05 ( /51 123.(,..0

$ !%( "

$ !% ( , 6123.6,..0

" 7 $ !%( "

$ !% ( 8 %%

99999 45 44. (* +6,-,.6,..0

: $* +6,-/26,..0

: $* +6,-/,6,..0 :

$* +6,-//6,..0 : $* +6,-/16,..0 : $ * +6,-/-6,..0 ! : $* +6,-/;6,..0 ! : $ * +6,-/<6,..0 "# : $* +6,-/06,..0

: $ * +6,-/36,..0

: $* +6,-/.6,..0 : $ 6123.6,..0 $ !%$ % $ :

" $( (% ,0 2- ,..0$ # " %% #$

( (

= # !% %

> ! ?

! $ %

% ( # ! #(

% # ( $ % % ( /22, ( % # !# 6 % % ( %( ((% % % ( % (% /< ,..;#,'12&" $$ $

$ $ $ $ $ 7 ! ! # 6 1.1/$ ( @% $ % # !#" $%

% ( A %

6 $ % # 4B6 ,2<,$ !# 6 $%( % $ $ # % $ $

$ 7 ! $ $ $ " ! ( $ ((

C %%#

) 4 $ 2< 2.

,..;

%% ## ( +&

$ (

$*> & $ 6 $ % # # (

% %% $ ! ( %

D! % ( # % % %%((( %% E

% !#

& <-(,..;$ % # % (* +6,-/36 ,..0( #% ?

(% % %%((

<;(,..;$ % # % ( * +6,-,.6,..0( #?

(% $% % %%(

# #! %%

<<$ % # % (* +6,-/06 ,..0 ( # ?

% %% ( ( ( ( ?

(

<0<.(,..;$ % # % (* +6,-/16,..0* +6,-/.6,..0 ( #

% %%((

&F $ % !

<3(,..;$ % # % ( * +6,-//6,..0( # $%%( ( (

02(,..;$ % # % ( * +6,-/-6,..0( # !

% % ( ( #

0,(,..;$ % # % ( * +6,-/;6,..0( # ! %%(

(( # %%

0/(,..;$ % # % ( * +6,-/26,..0( # (%%( (

01(,..;$ % # % ( * +6,-/,6,..0( ## %%( (7 ( (

3-(,..;$ % # % ( * +6,-/<6,..0$ ( # ( ! " % %%(( " ! ( %%

6123.6,..0#( #!% % #(

( G (%

% %

6123.6,..0 ( #% %(% #

# % (%(%%

#!$ ,, % ( % #% $

! %

%% E # !(

! > # !#

( % % $ % #% ? ( > 0( <-$<<$<3$02$0,01$ ( % %6G # (

% $ ==$# == > (

# !#

# %( % % $ ( % % 0( > ( # ! %% E %/< ,..;

<-01 ( ,2 ,2 ,..;% 3-( 2;

,/ ,..;

> (# ,..; %6G #(( (% ( ( ,..;6,..< % (! /< ,/ ,..;(%

( $% # !!## % ( % ! % (

(% C # %%% (% !(

$ ! #( >! %( ! % # %

G%# ! #

= > # # %( E (% # % $ % % !# % % > ( # % ! %

" ! $ %

%%%

% $#%

%#$#!%=%

#% > ( $

# ( % %

%# (% %

% > ! !(( %G % ! % # (%%# % ! #( # %(

# $ ! % ! % % 4( % % %# ( ! 32 (

* $ #% % %6 G $ ( $

C %( # % ! 32 ( % ! % %

! % (%% %%( %$# ( % (% ! $ %# !

123.(,..0 3( #G

! ! %% (

<<$ % # % (* +6,-/06 ,..0 ( # ?

% %% ( ( ( ( ?

( % %$ $ #/; C # %(% 1$222?6 $ % (,?1 (,< ( ,$./$222?6% C # % % %G ( ( (

C %( # %( %# 1$222?6 % # " (( "? 7

* $ % %%(( %# % %! #((

C %( (! # %( % %( % %%(( %##

# % # (( #

% #%

%((% ( % %

% # /; ( ! %%% C # DG &6/- %6G ( (

(

C %( # ! % % !

" ( "? 7 >%6G DG &6 <-DG &6<;$ % ,.3-6,.3;,.3;6,.3<

#( ( % ! >%(%#

1$222?6 % (,?1 #%

% > ( (4=#

#$ $%

> ( (4=# 56 5,7/(,6 -(,/"(7-*,8, ,8, * -(,.

$'$*9*7'$ (,3 (,< #

( ,;$222?6%%%((

G( , /

" #$ % &

#$ %%"

&' ! &'

(( $% '()'* & +,-

)''

)'. %$"

()

* % ,

/ 0

>%H1$2221'

(2 )

)

%( (-2I %%(( % ):.$<22 ) ;

-2I J11$<22?6

(,3 11$<22;,3J<$2-$322?6 -

* G ,;$222?6 ;

C( ,;$222?6 <

C ( % , -2$222?6

C(( % / -2$222?6

, 7 (!%%

) 34 4 4

& 56 " 7 +,- ')5 '**5 "4

*+,

4 / 8 9

" ))4 '5(

:46

/ %(

(,< *.

; 55

, 7 (!%%

) C %( ( %( % $ % # # G ( % #

,$;22?6 %( ;22?6 > # % # % ( C %( ( ( %(%

/ 8 )) 4 9

4 " ;

/ 8 , "

" " / 8 '6

/ " $

(

/ 8 !

/ ).='**6 !

=*'**68 ># : ? " : @ !

" & + ,$ $% %(-$.

% $%/)

%00"

" $ $ 12 ? " !

" #$ & !

$ $$ + %$

3-2I % (( %%( ( % < '= '. , ( ,;$222?6%%%(( G ( ,

" #$ % &

%%"

&' ! !" #$%&'('( )))$% '()'* & +,- )''

)'. %$ "

() * % ,

/ 0

>%H,$;22 '=

%( (-2I %%(( % '= : 0$/22 '= ;

-2I J/;$/22?6

(,3 /;$/22;,3J-$;1$<22?6 -

* G ,;$222?6 ;

C( ,;$222?6 <

C( % -2$222?6

, 7 (!%%

) 34 4 4

& 56 " 7 +,- ')= '**5 "4

#( % (% ( # % %%(

(( # %% E C ## ! (% " % 7 $ # (( # $ ( $ ( ( # DG &6/< &61, % G % (( % (( !

AB % / !

4 "

4 4 !

AB 6% 3 8 " !

" "

4 4 4 9 4

4 "

< " 4 !

4 C;A ).C;A (' ==

>(%% %%(%$ % G ( ,;$222?6 %% ( (( $ ;$222?6 % ( % $ % ( 3$;22?6 %%(G % ( 13$;22?6 % 6% 56 " 7 +,- ''* '**5 "4

*+, ! -

7 ! # ( # 6% $ ( (%

$ < 3 $ % ! C # ( 02$222?6% %%((

$< <;$222?6( ( $3

C % ( # E% # # #$ % #% % % (4=#

*$% %(

%340"

$ $ > % #%

C %( # )=% % %%((% %% $ % % ,../ % )=%,2 $>( % %( ; )=%

;$22$222?6 % % ( 02$222?6 <;$222?6( (

% ! 34 4 4

, 56 " 7

+,-3')(')*'**5 "4

#( #%%( ( ( $/3 A %# ($ % ,$222?6 # # A %# ;22?6 $ (,< ( .<$222?6;22G,/G,<

" "

4 ;

D ! "" 4/

% "

4 /# / " & +,- ')=

'**5 / 8 !

! '6

? " : @ !

" & + ,$ $% %(-$.

% $%/ ) %00"

" $ $ 12 > ( ( 4=# !

$ $$ + %$

$-2I % ( % #(( >! ( (4=# 56

5,7/(,6 -(,/"(7-*,8, ,8, * -(,.

$'$*9*7'. (,0 (,< #

( ,;$222?6%%%(( G(

/ 0

>%H,$;22 '=

%( (-2I %%(( % '= : 0$/22 '= ;

-2I J/;$/22?6

(,0 /;$/22;,0J-$/3$-22?6 -

* G ,;$222?6 ;

C( ,;$222?6 <

C(% , -2$222?6

, 7 (!% %

) 34 4 4

& 56 " 7 +,- ')) '**5 "4 *+,

4 / "

/ ?

' )")=4 9

" " ; / ?

4 " '

( '. =

)6;');'.

3 "

" " 4

> ( (4=# !

$$ + %$ %%

$-2I % ( %#(( % (# % $ % (,?1 %

%((%# # % /3 (%% $ ( $ (,0 (,< # ( ,;$222?6%%%( ( G( ,

! ,)

! ,

/ 0

>%H-$2221'

(2)..5

()

(-2I%%(( % ():,/$32/ () ;-2I J--$32<?6

%( (,0 --$32<;,0J0$<,$02/?6 -

* G ,;$222?6 ;

C( ,;$222?6 <

C(% , -2$222?6

C(% /- -2$222?6

, 7 (! %% ) 34 4 4

& 56 " 7

" 4

+,- ') '**5 "4 *+,

A 4 % / : / " !

4 9

" 4/ 4 !

4 "AB 6 !

8 > # : ).='**6*'**6 ;

"AB 6 "

8 > # : ;< C;A 'C;A ' (.

" "

4 4 4 " '6

& 4 7 ).='**6 *'**6

"4 < (.

/ " " 4 4

; 6

")6

& )6

" " &

556

)6E E6E6E)6 3 4 4 4

& 56 " 7 +,- ')6 '**5 "4 *+,

/ " 4 , 8 "54 9

4 !

:, 8 54 ( <& A

% 3" C %( %% #( ;$22$222?6 # 4=# *$% %(

%340"

" $ $ ( $ ( -$12$222?6$! #!( 02$222?6 #

6/ 3 4 4 4

, 56 " 7 +,- ') '**5 "4

*+,

A 4/& 8 @ "

".64 /& 9

9 4 " " "@ "

" D " "

4 ; @ "

" ? " !

? "

: @ !

" & + ,$ $%

%(-$.

% $%/) %00"

" $ $ 12 > ( (4=# !

$ $$ + %$ %%

$-2I % ( %# (( " (0# ! ( ( 4=# 56 5,7 /(,6 -(, / "(7-*

,8, ,8, * -(,. $'$*9*7', ' ( ,;$222?6%%%(( G ( ,

! ,)

"" 4 !

" #$ % &

#$ %%"

&'! &'(( '()'* & +,-3 )'')'. %$"

() *

% &

/ 0

>%H,$;22 '=

%( (-2I %%(( % '= : 0$/22 '= ;

-2I J/;$/22?6

(0 /;$/22;0J,$0<$-22?6 -

* G ,;$222?6 ;

C( ,;$222?6 <

C(% , -2$222?6

, 7 (!% %

) 34 4 4

& 56

" 7 +,- ')'

'**5 "4 *+,

4 < !

"44

" D /4 " " " "44 D 4 "44

/ "44 ; "

/ D ; 4A 4 "4 4

9 "

+ " " / "" 3#F3 '.' AB (% % "

AB ( " 8 8 13 # "44 / " , /

" " "44 !

+ " !

D / " " "44 / + C;A, " AB (

" AB (%

; " C; 'C; " 4C; (C; / ; /AB ( / ; "44

AB (% " " / B C;A,AB (% "44 / 4 / B (@ % "

; D / " " " /B ( "

/ 4 /

" 4B ? ).='**6 "B 4

/ 8 G 4 / " 4"44 "44 4 "/ /

" /

" / ;

"44 / B ? " / / " " "44 " / D "

D " 4 4 "

4 "

/ " " " "44 D 9 4 4 " 4 4 " " "

4 ,

4 , 56 " 7 +,- ').

'**5 "4

% ! ! %% ( &,)- .

45 44

A ?

B? A #'