← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6906/2020disposed of

Grewal Eye Institute Pvt. Ltd. v. State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission Chandigarh And Others

2020-09-21Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan4 pages

   

    !"# $#%&'&()  

 *#+!,-#('"&"."#/"0"$ #"&"&(#* /' 1"!"#('.2#* &'3."#'#$*#''!,2&''&(4 45!($&6!*5!($"5#*'

 #'3($#("'



    

      

        

       !

     !'#"!7#(.3"5*.65/&$#%( #*#(%&(6 23,!&(!("'81!($##395.(6#*!($15!:(!295.(6#* 5!$ &,#$!%23,!&("!6!&('";'3,,.(&%5#!,"5('.*!(%# 23!(-0&2&"#$4.*.6*!2!($&"':*!(%5!"5!($&6!*54!'+#,, !'*#+!,-#('"&"."#*&/!"#0&2&"#$41#%"* 45!($&6!*54 :# *#  &'"*&%"  ('.2#*  &'3."#'  #$*#''!,  *.2 4  4 5!($&6!*55!"%23,!&("+!'!%%#3"#$!($*#+!,-#('"&"."# *&/!"#0&2&"#$45!($&6!*5833'&"#3!*"-<4+!'$&*#%"#$"

3!-  !(  !2.("    '4 4

;

 "  %23,!&(!("    15!:(!2 95.(6#*!,(6+&"5&("#*#'"= >3#*!((.2+# 



?"&,, *#!,&@!"&(4&(!$$&"&("3!-&(6'

;

 !'%23#('!"&( * %!.'&(6  2#("!,  !6(-  !($  5!*!''2#("  5#*#!'  '.%5  ('"&"."# !,(6+&"5;'3,,.(&%5#!,"5('.*!(%#23!(-0&2&"#$4 +#*#$&*#%"#$"3!-'A4

;

"5#%23,!&(!(" 15!:(!2 95.(6#*!'%'"' ,&"&6!"&( ##,&(6!66*&#/#$:-"5!"*$#*$!"#$ B

 43!''#$:-

&'"*&%"  ('.2#*  &'3."#'  #$*#''!,  *.2 4    5!($&6!*54 *#+!,  -#  ('"&"."#  *&/!"#  0&2&"#$4  33'&"#  3!*"-  <  5!$ 3*# #**#$  !(  !33#!,  :# *#  1"!"#  ('.2#*  &'3."#'  #$*#''!, 22&''&(45!($&6!*54+5&%5+!'5+#/#*$&'2&''#$/&$# *$#*$!"#$ 

 1.%55'3&"!,;&('"&"."#5!' &,#$"5#3*#'#("%&/&,+*&"3#"&"&( .($#**"&%,#'

;

? "5#('"&"."&( ($&!4'##7&(6C.!'5&(6  &23.6(#$*$#*$!"#$ 

3!''#$:-"5#1"!"#('.2#*

&'3."#'#$*#''!,22&''&(445!($&6!*5 #'3($#("'4D!($A5!$!33#!*#$(!%%.("

!$/!(%#%3-5!/&(6:##('#*/#$.3("5#2 5#("5#C.#'"&(!*'#+&"5*#6!*$"2!&("!&(!:&,&"- "5# +*&"3#"&"&(4 *"5#*#!'("5!""5#3#"&"&(#*5!$#

&%!%&.'*#2#$-  &,&(6*#/&'&(:# *#"5#!"&(!,22&''&(4.($#*1#%"&(  "5#('.2#**"#%"&(%"4 B 0#!*(#$  %.('#,  *  "5#  3#"&"&(#*4  *# #**&(6  "  /!*&.'

E.$62#("'  &#         

      

<        !" #  $%F &#

 '    ( #   '

  ) 

       *   %+    ,      %-$F     . 

( # /   0   

12(      3/4.5'56-5%++7F 8  ( #   /  * 8 



# (  1 

9 #  3/4.515%+7+5 %- !($ & :  ;    '

  ) 

'   *(   

# (  1 

9 #   %7  00" 0)1<.=<!$ *  5!' '.:2&""#$ "5!" "5&' .*" 5!' 6" E.*&'$&%"&("#("#*"!&(!($"*-"5#+*&"3#"&"&(4#'3#%&!,,-+5#( 1"!"#('.2#* &'3."#'#$*#''!,22&''&(445!($&6!*54 ,!%7#$E.*&'$&%"&(&("5#2!""#* +#/#*4!2("%(/&(%#$:-"5#'.:2&''&(2!$#:- ,#!*(#$%.('#, *"5#3#"&"&(#* *2"5#*#%*$4&"$#'("%2#.""5!"1!"#('.2#*

&'3."#'#$*#''!,22&''&(445!($&6!*54,!%7#$E.*&'$&%"&( &("5#2!""#*4*!"5#*'.%51"!"#22&''&(5!$$#!,"+&"5"5#!33#!,

&,#$:-*#+!,-#'3&"!,*&/!"#0&2&"#$45!($&6!*54:# *#&"4 !66*&#/#$  :-  "5#  *$#*  3!''#$  :-  &'"*&%"  %('.2#*  &'3."#'

#$*#''!,  *.2 4  4  5!($&6!*5  #"&"&(#*  &"'#,  5!/&(6 !33*!%5#$"5#1"!"#22&''&(!($(++5#("5#/#*$&%"5!' 6(#!6!&('"&"4'!-&(6"5!"&",!%7#$E.*&'$&%"&(&("5#2!""#*4$#' ("  2!7#  !(-  '#('#  /#(  "5#*+&'#4  "5#  3#"&"&(#*  5!'  6" #

&%!%&.' *#2#$-3*/&$#$.($#*"5#('.2#**"#%"&(%"4  B4 !33*!%5&(6"5#!"&(!,22&''&(:-+!- &,&(6!

*#/&'&(3#"&"&(!($'.%522&''&(%!(%#*"!&(,-,7&(""5# ,#6!,&"-!($3*3*&#"- "5#*$#*3!''#$:-"5#1"!"#('.2#*

&'3."#'#$*#''!,22&''&(445!($&6!*5!'+#,,!' &'"*&%"

('.2#*  *.24  5!($&6!*5  5#  C.#'"&(  +5#"5#*  "5#  1"!"# 22&''&(,!%7#$E.*&'$&%"&(&("5#2!""#*%!(!,':#,7#$&(" :-"5#!"&(!,22&''&( 5#  E.$62#("'  *# #**#$  "  :-  ,#!*(#$  %.('#,  *  "5# 3#"&"&(#*"5!"&(%#*"!&(#/#(".!,&"&#'+*&"3#"&"&(%!(:##("#*"!&(#$ :-"5#&65.*"4$(" &($!33,&%!"&(""5&'%!'#4(!%%.("

$&

#*#("  !%"'4  %&*%.2'"!(%#'  !($  "5#  %("#G"  &(  +5&%5  '.%5 :'#*/!"&('5!$:##(2!$# 5#*# *#4"5#+*&"3#"&"&(%!(("3*%##$ .*"5#*:# *# "5&'.*"5#'!2#&'$&'3'#$ *#,#6!"&(6"5#3#"&"&(#*""5# *#2#$- !33*!%5&(6"5#!"&(!,22&''&(:-+!- &,&(6"5# *#/&'&(3#"&"&( 1&(%#"5#3#"&"&(#*5!'3.*'.#$"5#2!""#*:# *#"5&'.*"

*!:."?2("5'4"5#!"&(!,22&''&(2!-,7&(""5# $#'&*!:&,&"- %($(&(6"5#$#,!-&( &,&(6"5#*#/&'&(3#"&"&(4&( !%%*$!(%#+&"5,!+  

      5#"5#*'3#!7&(6;*#!'(#$

#'; 5#"5#**#3*"!:,#  #';