← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6513/2001disposed of

Munshi Ram v. Deputy Commissioner And Others

2015-02-02Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul10 pages



    

 



 !" #$ %%%%% &'"'"&() *  &+ ',$$" "&(- #!&.&(/#(!0'!&(  %%%%% & +.&') *   1% 23

 4 

  23

 4 35

             !  "   !  #       

 ! $ % &'

& ()*    &+, '

())-(.  %%%  35

- "  

     (    )  /01

 2  (   3 

  45 6)

7 $89 

#%&

 1 ( &  (             *

 455  

 :  (          

  88(  #%&

( &  ,55

  

  

   68;7;9(             

  "     3   

 

#       ,

* 

 <*     3  = 5(%

* (

   "      7= #%( (            

      

  *      <*       3   

 = #(% 

     = 5(%     

  

 



  &

  "    

   455  .   = #(%  88(

   = #   

  

 880  ( 

= 5(%

   85880)(

      (    

               

        (      #88(

  

                #    

 ( 7

 

 (    

   

     

)

   (

3  (  

  

 > "     

  

3

*      1       #88          )

7 $  2    *



   

  *    *    % &

  

 

     "    % &

   

 

 3

 *    4   

  ( 

        *      ?

 8888(   % &

1 

   

%   

) ( 880?  (888"   

  



     

 3 (        *

(  3 

6 

 (  3  

* 

 :(    (  &

     

     

     *  " 

      # 6)

7 $9  

% *

  '

 *

 ? % % )

( &

 

      1

(     ,      

   

  * &  (

    ) ( (   

   &

 1  ,       

 '', * ( 5(    $

   &

(   

 



     &

 1   ?

 5(    &

 1 

  * 

 

*     5   ( 

 

  455 



*      

 

 (   



     ?

 

  ,      (           

  (*   /6)

7$09(

  &

1 

 

    5(

 $

 "(           

     "              

 '&% %)

( &

 1 ( &  (           5 6)

7 $89       (

     

     

  "     (      ,        @  

A  

  

3

     "  

     6)

7$89         6 94 ?

 1   

  

* (6

91 

 

 3        6

9            

3 (*   6)

7$9(

               %&

 1  ?

#(       #       " (    

 

@4?

1 A  

  

 3     % &

    (  

    

        

 

 *      

     

 



 

 

  ?

  *

  ( # 5  

*                  #   5(  *  

     *  

  2      



= 5(%    &

1 

   85880((    = 5(%  

  348B5880(  

 ' : ,  $ ( &   *    B6)

7=9" 

       

  '

C( (      1          #88(         

   



* 

7 )             

  #88 

  (      

 

  , (       

     (  



     #88

   

 

   .  -*  (  

0088#885(

3    



    

 = (% '

 C .*(    

 

 

&

1 ( , 

) (( 5', *    $

&

1  

  2   

      &

   * 

2  (  @4?

A #88     5 $

&

1  "

 

 

  

 = 5(%(       

  3( 

*      

      4 ?

1   #88

  

 * 

8     

 (  #     

 

 3

   '

  (    

 

 

    (   

              = 5(%   * 

  

     85880 =(     = 5(%  

   &

   3  B5880  

  (

       

     (       

 



*

(   #88 +  

       

  7         #88        

 3  

 



*     2      

4?

1    

  

 3    # =(   (       3          5 

#  '   5/   .  &

) (80#(   

  

(    ,    

9 ( 

  

1 1

            5



#(





(    (

   

 "'



455 

#      

       (        

      &

(  

     

   * 

  ?

 ( ) )*  - (.        7       #88    

 

7         ( 

    



  

 

  7     

     .*

     

     



                 

  7        #88     

      = 5(% *



  

 85880   (       

 ( 



   

  *    * ( * 

 (     , 

    

   



1

 

  ) 

 (   7

 

 

     (  



  

  *    *  *    (             

 

   *          #88 ) 

*  ) 35

*     

&:( #(, -   ,