Saudagar Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"#$"# SAUDAGAR SINGH ... Appellant %& '
( ( """ ) * +,* " (% (" -
% (" -"". &/0
!
" #$ %& #% '
( ) * + #&, %$ #% - ("" #% %$ #% -
"
(
" "
+ .!/ &0#'
#% ,0 '
%1 #% 1 2 + #-
, -, ' #%/34 ) $'% # ! "
"
/
5
5 / ("
"
5
(5 6 ) " " "
"
" "
(
4
5
"
(
-2- "
"
"" "( 7 84. + ,, %'
%'
#% , 5 ,#% ,&' 19$/ , - , '-%' - 4) 4 /
5 5
( " "
" 5 "
, !
"
5: );/
:
" . 3 );/, / 5 "" %
#% 1 2 5: ( () 5 "" #% %$ #% - 4
/ , - , ' #%/3 4) 5 "
"5(
( " - ! :
" < ( 3
.
;/ = . 3 )6/ ' ;/#= "
"
;/, )
"
;/1 " / 5
, ,) ) " " 5
/ 5( '
4 :
"
;/ = ) + "
;/#= " ;/,= "
;/1=
7 ) 6
-3-
;/->5 ( " ;/1? & @ 5 " (
) * +
" 5 5 (
2 5 + ( 2
/
5 : / (5
2 "
"
6
$ A
)
;/# . 5 5 5 ( ( 4 . 3
("
" ( "" 5 "(
" 4
5 5 ( 5 ( 5 ( 5 "" "( / "
(
" 6 " B:
;/ 03 5 (5 ,5
" 5 " (
6 " ) " 6 / 5 "
3< (
-4- 5
6 ( ( 5 ! (
6 (5 5 ( 4
5 % 3 " 5 "
5 /
5
!"
#
$
$
!
5 5
2 ( /
-5- "" >?
! 5"5 ( 02 = >?
! = >? ! 5 5 ( "
= >?
! " 5 5 5 5
(
" >?
! ( " = >?
! 5
" # !
5 ( 5 ,5 ! .
/ ( :
" % %1 #% , ! "
;/# . 3 7 )6 / ' )
/ 5 " 6 ,% %1 #% , # -
5 :
#%%
4
(" ( !
-6- / B:
)#0 5 5 ( 5 / 5
" 5 ( ( " ! " 5 ( " 4 ( 5 5
5 ( ( 5 " , 4
/"
" ""
/ 5 5 ! 5
4 (" / 5 (5 " 6
" 5 "
- . /
5 (5 " 5
(
/"
"
" 5 "" ( 5
/"
"
/"
"(""
" 6
%- %1 #% ,5 "
-7-
(
5 ) 6 5"
"5 5
7 #& %1 #% ,
"
<
(5 )6 5 )6 <4 5 5 5
"
#9 %1 #% , 5
)6 ' )
" 5 5 5"
"5 ( ! %- %1 #% , ( /
;/-
5 "/
:
" " %'
%1 #% , 5
" #
$ % & ' () '* + #
, & ' () '* - &
*
' ) !
'*
. / 01"+0"- &
'
'
7 " "" , - , '4) 65 " " " ( ( 5
D E , - , '
-8- 4) 4"
( D ( 5
" " "
""
( ( " ""
E 5
( ! /
5 " %'
%1 #% , " "
5 "
" (
(5
" 5 " 0" "
5 "
( !
/ " " (" 5
"
(
" " ""
/ !
0 & "
" ( " 5 "
" ( " , -, '4)
-9- $ " ( """ 4 ( " "
(
"" /
6 " / 5 " 5 "
( " " !
/"
(
/ :
! " "
!
( (
( 5 !
5
,, (
,(1 , ! "5 (6 ) 5
2 ! 6F
" ) "
% &
% '
(
) *++'
"$"2% .+-$"%
&
$% $%
3 $%
$%
4 & 5
-10-
3 3
4 &
6
& 7
&
4 &
'
& &
&
&
3 4 &
)
) 8
9
4 &
*
&
3 :
; $"% < ; '6=">.1*&"1" $"?%
&
-11-
@
&
$"% $">-.% #=2"" ' ->A $+% '6=">.1 *&"1"
@B C
3 $"%
'C
* C $+%
4 &
C
@
5%6
@ @ @ @ 6
4 &
3
)
$% .+-$"% &'
) 4 &
# =
@
!
@3 @
@
3
&
=C $+% 4
3 * C $.%7
C
4 &
3
!
4 & C
$"%$">1+%&=">- +0"$+%$">1-%&=."A$-%$">2"%-&="+0$.%$">2+% 6&= "0.
-12- )
! & 6
4 & 9 ' "-2
4 &
#% 6F
") "
,
- "
'
.*+* /
* *'
"0* 9
-?A & *&
4 &
0* 6 9 : $+0"0%>&&"A>
&
-?A & *& 6 "+"> B "+3
&
4 &
C 3
C
C
3
!
D !
C)
$, 9 !=
-13-
E* $">?1% - && +"> 9
$">>0%.&&"?
* E*$+00-%"&&?2"
<
* $+00.%"0&&2>> 9
E*$+002%> &&?-"
E* =,
$+00?%"-&& "0+ = = =$+00A%1&&1-1 '
$+00>%"0&&+02 * !
= '*$+00>%"2&&>A =
4*$+0"0%+&&..1% "-6 :
; '6=">-.*&++?
*
&
B$6'.0.%F 4 &
$"% G
7 $+%
!
7$-% 7 $.%
G
". 3
& $ 3 : '6= ">1.&"
9
* C'6=">1?& +"2 H' '6=">2-& +00 :
9
$">?0%+&&.10
: $">>A%1&&."+ 9
*$+00+%.&&A1 H C3 ! $+00?%-&&?11% "1 6 & : !$+00?%.&& ."1
& B $&& .-+ .+% $"% '
$+% 3 & &
* ">?-
-14-
$-% , I
J I J I J I J I
!J
I
J
$.%'
K
C
$1%6
"2 6 H # E*$+00A%"0&&.10
&
J
3
-15-
"? 6 =C < $+00>%>&&-2A &
C
&
B$&&-?.
+0%+0F
"A 6 E* 9
$+00>% . && +?"
&
& C
C 4 & 3
B $&&+A2 +A%$ %3 4 & J
$
%3 4 & J 7 $
%3 4 &
C 7 $
%3 4 & JC
C 7 $ % 3
&
4 & 7 $ %3
&
& 4 & '
&
/ $+00>%"0&&.0" ">3
-16-
C
3
J
6
$
% 0**
+0
B "+03
!
D
3
$, =C
: :
/
' $">A.% . && 2-1 ; 3 L ))'
' H < M ">>+$+%&&-"+ 3
= M * &&; ">>. $-% && 221 H /
4 * $+00"% " && 10"
' $+00>% "0 && +02 H
9 : = '*$+00>%"0&&2-2%$
% 0* 6
&
:
& *
$">>>%+&&"0
9
0 6 , C
: !
-17- $+0">%1&&.-2
&
-?A& *&
4 &
3
&
& ">1+
6 -"
B "-" '
&
E G $">?A%"&&++A6
& 4 &
) 4 4 &
&
C &
&
"0 B $&& +--% "0 L
4 &
L
4 &
G
3
G
-".6 :H = '*$">?>%"&&-11
&
C !
4 &
C
C $
% # 4
( ( "
( * +
!
-18-
(" (" .% (" -0 * !2# , ; 0 G0+ ;. G0+