← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1572/2024dismissed

M/S Victor Cycles Pvt Ltd v. Sarvesh Kumar Jindal

2024-04-16Mr. Justice Gurbir Singh15 pages

        

    

                

 

  16

    !

"

# $# %

& '&# !(  #

()(

  ) *  

+,

 





- ( ."  /



,

#$ %& #'

 '  

 &( ( &)) 0 # - &

 & ( &)) 0 # & #



 

/  # - &

  

&)) 0 # & #

,   

''''

' (

  ( )



 &

 





%

  2&3 ' 4

, 

 

/) 2- * 4# !(  # 0(5

,,

"

'/)"

 -



-,

1 & $6# 5 "





% 5 1#

1  0( (  





, ',

*



, ,1"  )"

 6

,



,,

5  7$



%

& '&# !(   

8)"

 #





)) 

'1  '/)"



3  



1 

, 

0 " (

 

5     

, 

0 " ( 9( /)"

,, # 0( ( "



8)"

 6$

)  - &,,

7$ $  "

 8)"

$ :

-! 24 7$ 6   "

  $



9( * 3

,,

  

,,

 ,"



5    



$6  ;( 9(

'/)"

, 

58

3

,,

5     

$ ##'

$6  ;(# 5

*

$6  ;(

  

$ ##'



9(

'/)"

" ,,

 $  -



-,

1 &



  

 " "



",)  



!    ,,  5( 1

'

/)"

)

,  -



-,

1 &

" 

(

1 

*

"

5     

,





) 

(

  

5 0

, 

 

  9( (  5

, 

*

5     

0 " ( 5

  

5     

$ ##'#

$6

)) 

 ;( 0

 %

5 1 ( )

"



###' <

"

"



 ;(

(=  

*

  ;(

 ( -"

  ;(

 6



 ;(  6 9(#

 

"





 ;( -"

  ;( 0( (  

(=  

 (= 76 #



##'

#'



#

'

9*-4 - (= "

 (

, '*

# 0( ( 1 

,, 

1"

,

2&3 '4

"

* '> 2&3 '

4 :

%" 9 3



 

   ' #

"

##'

5

(0 



?

"

, '*

, '* 

,,

 

2&3 '4

 @ ;

%

;0)



" - 58

5 

'/)"





,

3

 9( '

", 

 , 

-"

  ;(

(=  

0(  )"



6

"

 

 

 -

< #

"

, : ,,

3 

"

5     

"



!    1 ( )







A5 -,"

  

)") 

 

   



 

 ,  ,   

!"# 

"$   

 $     % "  & "'

 

" "#

"

(  



(  !    ,,  5( 1

, '

  '* )

* ",

8)"

 , 

 

"

)(   9( , "

##'

 9*-

#

'

  51

0 51

  ,,

/)"

 " 8 

:

5  '(

'/)"

(  (0



 ;(   ) 

  ,,

"

##'

1

5 (  

)"

  



 - "

5 (0  

 -

< 

5  '(

"



/)"

 9( 



  , /)"



(=#

=

#

1   - < 

 6 &

"



"

 

5

;

*  %

5 1 ( 5"

"

1

8

, <

"

" "



0)



@ ;

""

1"

9( *    "

,  , 

5



 "

,  , 

) ) 



% (  ( 

5"

    

, 



(  )

()(



-

 -,

1 &

  '

"  

 

     

  

 

   



   



   

     

  

  

 



   



    

 

 

    



 

 

    



   



     



              



   

   

 

  

 

   

              

 

   !    " 

 $$%



%   &

!

"

'

# # ) * "#

 "

" "+ 

 "# "

$ 

$(#

(

A5 -,"

-



-,

1 &

,"

/)"

;

    

5

 ,"

3 

"

5   "



%  

"#  # #

+ ,  

"

"#

"

 ( -.   



 /#

A5 -,"

(

 

  



 ,

)*) 

,1"   , 

  7 $ 8)"

 

' & ' 







 (

)#    (     *  ++   

     *           - 



  

 (



  

 

.  (



    - 



 /  

          

    

    

    

  

 0' 



  

/ 

        

  

      

  

   "

 

 



   

  ' !            1 /      

 

   

  

  

  

  

        2

)  /

 

 *   

    

  

       

    3

   

    

   

          4 ' 

  

           '      (

    *   

  3



 

   

    *       

    0    (

    *  

  

   

  

 

    '3

 

    0      

3

        

    

  

   

)) 

   '  0     (

   

%



%



 # 



,

,1"  )"

 6

"

)"

 3

  

###'# 

0( (#

  ;( (=

 

 0 1"

 @ ;

% ?  !(

  ;(

(= 11

 &

"



 ;(  

" :

/)"

;

,

'  )"

 ,, 5 0

, 



0

,

  

"

   

1  9( 1  ,

'/)"

 

"

  11

 9( "

  ;(

     

1  '/)"

(=

  ;(  

 - <  & "

  ;(  

5 

()( (=

 -

<  )



#'

#

'

9*- 

- <  0

  

  )# 

@ ;

% ?  !( 2&3 '# :3'

11'* ,    - < 

  "

##'

5 



 

()(   (= 76 # 5

(

(= )

("



"

0)





1 5 

"

 

)+) 



"

 9(

,

11'

* ,    - < 

"

##'

 



"

(= ! 

5   





, # 



8)"

  9( ,

 , 

1     '

B5     

  

        '  

      0         

    

  

  

        

 

 

   

6      

 

0      



 

   

  

   0 

   

 7         

 

%



9(

'/)"

,, )

,, # ,,

8)"



  " !  

* " 

"

3  

0( (   '

B$$$ 

!

 0

! 

    )8

8  





   !  

   / 

   

     





 

49  ! 

 )8

8 % & ,,

 < 



 0 58

1 ( 5 ;

)   

/)"

51

),) 

"



 ;( 1 (#

, 

"

 



 3 

1 (  

   8)"

 6$#

,,

'/)"

"



)  - &,,

7$ $  "

 *

,

-&#

11'* " ,,

3



0( ( /)"

58

 -,

!  

 "



A5 -,"

9( , '* " ,,

 ,"



5     

$6

 ;( 9(

'/)"

58



"

##'

(   

5  



*

* ',

$6  ;( & )(

5 

/)"

   

,,

11

 5 

6

&,,

 -

 -,

1 &

 $

,

,,

  - ,,

"



",)  

%   

   



  %

"





1

5   "

  

 "

1"

# 

0 5 "

(  5 "



%

(





1',

#

(1# '

", 



24

 "

"

 

%  

)!) 



 

(

A5 -,"

,0

 -



-,

1 &



 

,   8

 "

=  -

 &

;

, ", 1

5

, 



"

 ,

,1"  %

 # 5     



 ;(



5

0 0;# 5

(



, 0

;

5     

 &,,

 -

  -



-,

1 &



  %

(

5

11 

3, 

# (

()



)(

(  5 

%      % " 

(

A5 -,"

 *

; 3 

"



"

 "

) 

(   5  "

3 

" &

(

 (



  

 (,



 

9( "



 5 0

, 



'

>( ( "

##'



#'



#

'

9*-#

 



 - < 

0( ( *

,  

5   "

  ;( 1"

"

 

"

 

/)"



)) 

- , 

;

0



"

/)"

#

3  

,   0



"

  '

&) $$   

   

 88888:2   



 " ;:( <  

 

 )888:2)#+8'7($$%

%

1 ( ,

0



"

1 

 

"

  ;( (=  - <   

,

)"

 : (0  

 

'1  '/)"

"



"

,

 

, '* '

11 &

"

  5



( 9(

" 

 '

 1 %1 (

,

,

(



1

)(

, "

"

(

;0)

( , 

 0

; (

1 9(

" 

) C

)

&

"

,

",) #

* ,

" 

"

5   "

$6  ;(  &

" #

/)"



58

5   "

$6  ;(

5

$  ;( -  )"

3

,  , 

"

 

"



*

,  , 

 



0 

 "

 #

3  

   '

&(         

 7 6   



   

)) 

  









    

  =2 &      

     

 

        /  

 "

  



 

 

  ( <   

   

         

 

        >  3 6  / 



>  3      

 " 

           ?

  

20

 

  0       

  "

 

 ( <           



     



  /  

 *      

 0

 ?#   @  A   

         

 



   

  ;: (  <  ;

    

"



 



 ;:(  <  *     

 



)888:2 

;:(  <        

 

  /     /  

 

   )888:2 

( < % B

      

0

A 

   98)8 4

 * 3

   

  =2 C' 



   

 

1 



 

)) 

" ;:( < 

 

  )888:2 )#+8:2'7(C  *



   A 

 



 

    

     

           

:A 

7

 

       

 

   



:7  6   

 A 

7

   



     

        

   



:7  6  :

  







   

      

:A 

 7

 B

   

   (   8) 

,? ! 6  6 3

(*

)4  8 4  

   

:A 

 7

   

  

:A 

 7

         

   



:7  6     

   

   

 

     





:7 6     

 (*   

:A 

7

     

 

:A 

7

 B

 

   





:7  6    





     ?  D

/      

:A 

7

  (1?

6

,*03

? 

  

 , ,   

 (

    

  (1?  

#2*  >

 

 (1?  

 ;    )  (1?     

:A 

 7

              

 

 

 

      





:7  6        

 6

, *03

6    

   



)") 

(1? 

 

:A 

7

       ;

             

 

   

 

    

:A 

 7

    

 

    (

  (   *         

 



 

 

    

 

 6

, ? !   6   6 



6

,( 3

5   

  0          

 





:7  6   6  

   



     

:A 

 7

  

E  "

  



 

  

        

  









  

6

,? ! 6  6 3

 

6

,( 3

5    

    

     

:A 

7

          

  0



         

, 5           

  

   

 

  6

,'

 6 3

! 



(  D :

1 ( F-(  A D :

( A * 8 +*533 ##

, ? !   6   6  3

 ! 



; ( G(56  *

 -?

 1   

  88H   3 3    94)  6

, ( 3

5   ! 



?-A - @ /*5888(39% 6

9(

,

(

"

$6  ;( - 

5   "



) ) 

$6  

 "

0

"#

 

, 

   "



,,

 -



-,

1 & % 

)

1

 01 

, 

 9( 

(

"

 "

"

    - ' . 

/016(!"

 8

>( ( , ;

)  D7

>( ( , 5

D7