High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20338/2017allowed

M/S Rallis India Limited And ORS v. State Of Punjab Thro Insecticide Inspector

2022-04-20Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj19 pages

!"#$%$

& ' ( ! ( ) *****

!"

$ $

%& '

( ***** ! ( )(( *

+

, -

(

(

/01

"

"

"

"

(

#

1 + *

"

" 1

40

6 78

9 ! & -

: 9

; , <

+

(

##

5+858

4

1

/

/01

45=8

/4

(* ,

""

40

6 78

& " 1

40

9 ! & -

:

# (-

"

(

(

#

/01

(

=

"

.

,

/

;-

( = "

"

7.

& -

>

+

(

+ + ,

#"

6= +,

- ?

& 5(

" &8

+

#" "

+

#"

+ , = $& ( >

=/

#

-

6-

=

# (- ,"

" @" + (

+ (-

@" "(

6

!

" #

$ "# # % & # ! '($)*$') +

',- # ! . #

/ # 0

1/23 1

! 3 " #

! 45"

6 $0 6 #6 7 #

$ "# # % & #

!

!

)8-! " # 91

3 ! 1.

:/3

;

0 ! -! & +)-)( ":') +

" . #:') -

" $

. % #; ! " $7##< ; = :

+ "

4= , "

6"

- = , "

"

( /01

/4

+

(# + "

,

"

6

(- A

#

"

"

-

, % " :## , "

BB

"

( 10

/

;-

0 "

,-

##

# , :##

+

(

< "

BB

< "

BB.

:

"

< "

BB.

(- # , :##

+

(

) @ ( -

>

0

=1

"

@ ( - (- "

#

0

"

- ?

&

##

# , :##

+

(

"(

"

( "(

"

+

"

#"

. #

,

, =?&

?&

+

#

"

"

=

# " # 9

0 % . #

0

! )+$)($') +1.

:3 #

#

:

!#

:

+-9 9 4

58

/01

,- (- # , :##

+

(

# #"

,"

" @"

+ #"

@" =1/714

// 1

"

*

#"

@ ( -

< (

##

"

"(

"

+

"

#"

#

,

,

?&

?& "

,- #

"#

+ #"

6

(

+

$ 7## ;

->$ -* - # ''*

:)))'

4

! $ 4

#"

! )))'- 1?

/

7 # 0

6#!

2 $ 6#! 4 2

)

! + # )))) #

@#" % #3 /

, $; &# 7$ # #

#

& 17 #

% & 3

7 $ 7 $) !# # "

& 17 #

# $7## ; #

+1!313 * = '( ++

.

(>=" $ # #" $ # :

/

"

(

+ #"

## ( ,

( ""

##

5+858

4

1

/

""

(- ; , <

+

(

40 ,,

(

# & @

(

#

" -

,

##

*

-

- +

,

#

C

#

( ,

(

"

A B:

##

: # # "

#

#

# "

# #

!

C #

-

C

# # "

" #

! #C "

@

"

.

# # #"

#"

# #

#!

#"

" " #

"

C # ##

@

"

C

@

"

.

C # # "

C

"

#

"

#

@#" " #

C

,:

3

## # " "

#

D 13 "

C 13 "

#

'*C 3 "

C 13 "

"

.

" #

, "

#

E

" F:

1 3

("

"

##

:

# 13 :

#

13 :

# 13 # 1!3

+ #

" 7 %

1'3

## # " "

#

"

#

.

#

D

## # " "

# ##

!

#

-E

F" "

D 13 "

.

C 13 "

#

'*C 3 "

"

.

" #

1'3

## # " "

# ## !

# >E

# #

F "

#

.

?

# DG

"

#

*E

"

F:

1 3

( ##

##

#

0 #H 0

D 32

D

13

## !

#

"

:

# 13 :

# 13 :

# 13 # 1!3

+C 13

"

C 3

## !

#

#

C 13 ##

'*C 3

'* " "

C

13

.

#

'-E## # D 13

"

"

##

"

"

C 13

@

"

## #

"

":

F 1'3 2

"

" #

##

# '>E ## #

"

"

F 1+32

"

.

" #

"

#

## #

13

. "

+E "

##

"

":

F

13

@

"

E ## #

"

"

F "

.

#!

## ##

@ !

#

I #

#" #

"

0

" D 32

.

"

"

"

#

" "

## "

##

#"

## ##

#", :

##

"

## "

.

! #

## #

1'3 " :

1

.

"

"

# "

#

"/

"

"

/

"

###

#"

## ##

#"?

# DG

D 13A "J "" #

#C 13A

J

#

>- +

#

("

##"

"

*

#

+

#

,"

" @"

+

, -

## ( #

+

,

-

(

(

, # -

,

"

(

(

"(

,

,

-

'

(

+

+

, C

' ,"

! "" ##

$% .

,

(

#

(- ,

58

- ;

% ,

+ +

(

,

"

(-

"

6 7 #

+

,

. #

, (-

(

,

(

# "

-

(

* -

(

#

- +

(-

#

'

(

,"

"

(* ,

(

(

&

,"

(

#

,

"

- # (-

-

##

, % " :##

> + $ +

% < + . " -

,

(

"(

, "

(

( # +

#

"

5858

-

"

(

( ( (

(

+

,

,

(

3 3

" K

##"

#

+16313 =

.

(>= #

'( .

(>= ## !

+ 9 9# ##

"

#

"

#

'( #

+61 * =

.

(>= "

##

++

# ! #

##

++ .

# ! #

##

++ .

3 3

'

+ -

#"

"

#

'/

"

+@#"

##

" "

-L L " ##

@##"

# "#

#

.

(>= 7# #

7# (* =

#

-

"

("

,

- ' ," (- 0

,

"

' ," (-

& 4 .

(

+

#

'

"

(,

(-

+

,

(-

( "

-

"

*

"

"

( "(

#

-

!"" ## $%

(

+;

#

$

#"

# #

#

#"

M

# ##

0 #"

#

# 1 <

&' $

""

!## $% (!

(

' # H #" # #

##

# # $6 &

5&

. % . # # 0

G

H

(()13

% %

$4# % ##

5 '))'1'3 7%7 1% #3 ->

5 #

" .

% #

#

" % & 5 #

##" / < "

) $

!"

## $%

' ;

#

#

.

(>= # !

#

## #" #

$ . #

"

" "

5

+ '-)-')) # ##" #

#

#

+

A+

#

'-)-'))

#

#" =9N H >9 ?% & 6:)(

'))) ?

"0

'))' -))0 ##" #

#"

#"

:

" $G ;O

" $ G ; O

"" 5 ##

5J + ;

#

# #

#

#

+

#"

,:

+ +

-

#

##

" "

5

#

"

### #

# # # # ##" #

>

#" #

#" ##

$

, *

#

# %

#" # #

#

#

#

#

* $

!"

## $% "

* # !

# ! =. )> '') ) 5

/ 6 #

#

,:

0 # !

G PP

!

# #

## # "

.# @ "

@ 1

+>9 ; #

3 # # !

# !

## # G PP ! #

# # ##"

#

#

"

H "

## # #

##" !

## #

13

## %# *( )')+'))*

+1!313 * = '( ++

.

(>=

-

# '*1-3

7# (* # $ 56

% #

% O #

6 #

## @ #

@

"@ <

+

#

' ,"

9( "

+,$-.)$)/0

/1

1

"

4=

9( "

,

(

-

"

-

(

"

-

( "

(

(

(

6

L(

.

#

"

#" ;1% #3 ')')

#

% " "! # ## ' . ## Q /

##

/

. ## Q% "

##

#

% " @#" #

% "

#

#"

#" ! 7 ""

#

"

' . ##

! '') ') + 2

!

#"

@#" #

5

' . ## Q /

#

/

% "

.

++ .

#!

#"

#

% "

##

% "# ##

#"

## ##

/

## "

#K

++ .

! #

' . ##

;

% ##

' . ## Q /

#.

" @

. ## Q % "9 & . #

"

"

7

+

,

.

(

-

##" (-

,

" ,

- 6

( .

('

"

#

+

,

"

(

# "

,

( * -

( ,

"

"

(

##

"

-

E

""

## .

"-

-

, * -

(

- (

(

E "(

-

#

"-

"

5+858 # "(

, "

(

.

-

#

5+8

"(

+

(-

<

4

"

"

"(

# # <

,

1

#

,

,

,

(

4 " -

/

(

(

"

"

" "

##

( :

- ,

#

-

(

E " &

-

,

(

#

"-#

,"

' ,"

#

,

' ,"

"

" 1

40

6 78

9 ! & -

.

: 9

; , <

+

(

##

5+858

4

1

/

/01

45=8

/4

(* ,

""

40

6 78

,- * *

! ( ) /#012

1"

2

! $

, R $ 2

# , R $