Gurcharan Singh @ Channi v. State Of Punjab
./.
.
!
B5#""$ # 6#((
'
"#$% &
B5#(*$ ,# "#$%#( "#$%#( "#$%#( "#$%#( "#$%*+$
"#$%*+$
"#$%*+$
"#$%*+$
) ) ) ) #(# ") #(# ") #(# ") #(# ") ($ ) ($ ) ($ ) ($ ) 2./. 2./. 2./. 2./.
)
)
)
) 2./. 2./. 2./. 2./.
7- 5
7- 5
7- 5
7- 5
-
-
-
- 58+,*
2,6$ "#%$"
"#*#""$ #5 5 #9
" :
+2
& '5 ;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;;
;;;;; - - - -251-4 251-4 251-4 251-4
#(# "*#""$ ('## %+#, ?0$%"#
./.01# +#
0<$%"#5554(## #=
"$%# + +"$"# # #2
(# '# $5 , "#, , .05/5./.>2 # ("##, %$ "# # $%%# #( *
'+# >14 $% "#
$" (
(3$"$*
'("
#("2<?>1%$($" @ "741 .C$%"# #
" ,,#,+ "#$ 42 "$+#
:
2("" ="(
'5 .5
# $%"# A# #("$ (" ""#*#""$ #(
(#,$%'
# *#"
" 6$+6 ++# #, #$6#3 $% // =+$ 9( $% *$**3(= % %$9 "# *#""$
, ( $
(#,5
. 05 -# #,$ (#+%$"#*#""$ # ("# "#," ""#*#""$ #(
("$,3( #.05/5./.>5-# #,$ (#+ #," ""#*#""$ # '## % +(#+39*+ "$"# A#("$ 5-# #,$ (#+ (%"# ('9""#," "9
"$3*$6($ ($%"# " 6# $"(*+$(+3 '## $9*+#, :"2
, "(2 "# *$(#"$ (# (%%#( %$9 ## ,#%#"(5-# #,$ (#+ ("# "#," ""#" +(,#+ 3#,
,"#+ '+"3 "##$%
$" '# % ("# #, *$ "# *#""$ #5 -# #, $ (#+ ( %"# "# "#, " " "# *#""$ # ( (%%##, %$ 9$# "
/ 3# 5
(2# + +(* 3#,%$5 5 -# "#$ (#+ ($**$(#,"#*#(# "*#""$ '3 " ""# ++# ( (#,
(""#*#""$ #(#$(
"#
,2"(2 #,$#( $",#(#6#"#$ #(($ $%"## + +5-# "#$ (#+ (%"#('9""#," ""# ("
"'
+*+# ('
#,'3"# $($% 0C$%"# "2
,"(2"#( 9#$ ""$'#,(9((#,5-# $ (#+(##=("$*+ #$ #$,("$,3#"% "#, "#,/5/05./.2 $""$, 32:("
=# #$,5 >5 6## ,$ (#+%$"#6 +* "#(
, 6# $ #"$ "# '+##$,($%"# 5
# *#""$ # :
#("#, $ .05/5./.> :##
%"#
:
( #,$"
, ++
:
(*#(# "#,$ .5/C5./.>5 $"
0*$(#"$ :"
#((#( 6#'## "#,2'" # ('## #D * " "++, "#5 #6 +$ ( (#, " 6#(#"$,#'
'+#((#(2: ++'# "$
"#,*$ , "#$(#$%" ($",$#( $",##9 **$* "#"$,#+6#,##* "$"#(#6 +$ (2 ""(("
#2+#(""9 *#&,#"#" $" "
'+# ('## '$ "%$:
,"$ , "#"#
0 +=#+$$,$%"#*#""$ '($ %$9"#*$#(($%&("#$ "#%# :""#*$(#"$ #6,# #5 55
# " + ( ,##, *$ ("
, %$++3 "##$%
$" '# ( ,,+#,*$ "#*#""$ #5(*#("$,3#"% "#, "#,/5/05./.%+#, '3"#+# "#$ (#+2"#*#""$ # +# ,3(%%##, %$ *#$,$%/3# 2/9$ "
,/, 3(E( $"($:
"$'#
3$"# 1(45
"(6#:$%"#9 ""#2"# $9*$(#, 0C$% "# "("
,(,+"#, + "$%"#"+#.$%"#$ ("""$
5 5.5
( $" &, 9# " ""+#, ( 8+:
,# 6#(( "# $% 8+:
,# 6#(( "# $% 8+:
,# 6#(( "# $% 8+:
,# 6#(( "# $% & & & & ' * ((#, /C /C /C /C./. ./. ./. ./. 1./.>)
)//.<>4F %"# #+3 *$ "# "$ ,#,# ,$% "# &, 9# "( $% "# 7'+# *#9# $"
((
8 "$$ 6(5 $9# #352 "#$% 1<?/4 ?F',+ #9
"+ 36(5 5
=1<<.4 ..>F 6#,+ 9
' = 6(5 "# $% ("
$"#2 ./.104 19
+4 <F $, (+9 ! ((
6(5 "# 1 $% #+4 #*$"#, ( ./.0
0F 9
+**# $5.>G././, "#,/C5/.5././""+#, (H""
(:
(+
' ( 6(5 # "# $% I#(" #
+JF H "( ,= 3 ! *
6(5 #
"# $% I#(" #
+J2 *# + -# 6# "$ **# + 1+54 $5>>0/./.. , ..5/?5./.. ""+#, ( H$
+9
% = 6(5 # "# $% & "JF9
+**# $5<$%./.., "#,/>5/?5./..""+#, ($* 8(
! $* +(9 6(5 $%
, = , 3 6(5
"#$% ,3 ,#(2./.1419
+4C.F (#+,2"() HC5?5
# " "$ (*##,3
, #D*#,"$( " + ( $" $ +3 6"
+( %# ,"$*#6# " ,#
,$**#((6# F"$9"
D#"3
,$ $9*
( (:#++ ("$"
9* 9# '+"3$%
(#,"$,#%# ,9(#+%2'""##(
$6# ($#"
"##("* :
3%$ (*##,3" ( " '## #*# "#,+3 " "### "* ("
,"# "$,#,# ,$%"#
'$6##%##,"$ *#9#$"7(&, 9# "( 6#+ ,,$:
(##($% ,#($ ($*#
* #:6("
($%% + "(5 #$ #*"$% (*##,3" +( "$"#"+#.
#((# +* "$%"# % + ""$+%#
,+'#"32
"##,
,*#(#6#, ,#$ $ ("""$ 5 # " "$ (*##,3 " + '# ( :" "# " + #("
9*$(#, " "# "9# $% "# #(" $% "# (#,
, $ (#A#
: $ #( ++ ("
#(2
9#+32 "# ("
# $%
A32 " +2 **#
, #6($ ($ "
3 *$(('+# *#&,#" "9 3#(+",#"$9*#9(('+#
6$, '+#,#+ 3( # "# "9# $% "# $99(($ $% "# $%%# # "++ "# 9
+ *$##, $ (99 %
+"32 $+, '# 6#"#,5 # (*##,3 " +2 # +3 #
,A=,(*$( #( #A $%9
+&(*,# #5 # $6#$:,#,$",$=#"(2"## 636$+9#$%:$=
,"##(+"
*#((#$ "#*$(#"$
,"#$+#2 ,'"
'+3=##*("## "# 9
+&(*,# +9#
(9 ,#("#((
,("
5 $:#6#2"(
$"'#
#D(#%$=##* "#(:$,$% 9$+#(
(#,%$
,#% "#*#$,$%"9#5 ",$#( $"(#6#
3#,""$"# 9
+ &("# (3("#92 "# " 9 =#( %$ ( , ("
"# $% %% (5 #
"## $% (*##,3 " + ( ,#, "$ 6$, $**#(($
, *#6# ,#+ 3 '3 9*$( $ "# $"
, "# *$(#"$
$'+ "$ *$##,:""#" +:" #
'+#,(* "5 #
"##(#6#( "##%$+,**$(#5("+32"*$"#"("# (#,
("$**#((6#*# + 9*($ "F (#$ ,+32 " #+#6#( "# (#, $% "#
D#"3
*'+((*$ ,#"$ #($+6#,9
+ #(
,+ ("+32"*$"#"(
(" "# (= " " #6,# # :++ '# +$(" $ 9#9$#( ,99#, '3 "# * (( # $% "9#2 "(2 9* "# '+"3 $% "# (#, "$ ,#%# 9(#+%5 " $#(:"$"( " ""#$ (#A# #($%*#" +,#"#
# 6#5 (#,2 *#(9#,
$# "2 "++ *$6# $"#:(#2 # ('&#"#, "$ *(3$+$
, *3( + ,#*6 ( $% & ++%#2 ( ++3 ,#$ #$($ (5 A ++39*$"
"2"#',# $%,#"# (
(#,%#A# "+3% ++(# 6+3$
$# "9#9'#($%( % 9+35
## ( 3#"
$"# (*#" $% "# 9 ""# : ,#(#6#( $ (,# " "( ("
#5 # ++# "# *#(# " (# #+ "# "$
(#, '#
#+ "$ $99# + A
""3 $% $
, ,#"# "2<?>5I+#$ (,# +*#""$
(# 6$+6 $99# +A
""32"#$" ("$=##* 9 ,"# $(# 9# "#, 0C$% "2<?>:9
"#( " " $"(
" '
+ "$
(#, $ +3 %"# # "# *'+ *$(#"$
%"# ( "(%#,"(#+%$%":
$ (: # #
'+# $ ,( %$ '#+#6 " " "# (#, ( $" +"3 $% "# $%%# # #,G ++# #,
," "2#( $"+=#+3"$$99"
# :+#$ +5 #(" # " $($% 0C$%"# "2<?> 9(" '# 9#"+$(+3 ("
K#,
(" "# '
=,$* $% (#,7( % + ""$ (*##,3" +5 # ""$+%#
,*#($
++'#"3
$"'## ,##, "$3'3 :
"#,,#+ 3( "#&, +*$#((2 * "+ +3:##(,#+ 31(4( #"# ""'"
'+#"$"# (#, $ &("%#, ""## ,$%"#*$(#"$ '3 $ # "# (5 ,6,
$" '# =#*" '# , '
( %$
$,
"# *#$, $% "9# '3 "
= #% # $(+ ,,$:
0C$%"# "2<?>5 # +# (+ "# "(:(,$92 $,#"$# (#(*##,3
,"9#+3,(*$( +$% "# (#( ,#"#"2 (*$6,#,%$"#$ ("""$ $%(*# +$"( 0$%"#"5 $:#6#2"($"
$"" #+($ 7(
> #3#"$"#*$" "#,,#+ 3(
,(3("#9 " #%%# 3" "%(" "#"( +# (+ "6#**$(#5$"$%+ :(,"3'$ ,"$# (#" "",$#(
$"'#$9#$9*+" 6$+
,6, +7(% + "(2
$":"("
3" $
("
""#5I+#,# :"'
(# $6# #,'3"# $($% 0C$%"# "2 <?>2 "# $" 9(" ("=# &,$( '
# '#":## "# +# (+ "6#
""$'"#9#
#$%, (
,"#( $(
" "$%"# (#, %
,#D*#,"$(" +5$+$ 2:"$"&("% '+# (#2 (=( "
(%$9 *#" + ,#"# "$ * "6# 9*($ "2
$"$9#
""#" +"$"#* *+#$%&("#
,#A"35
$2"# #A6$ %## #(" ":##"#" + % +#, "$ $ +,# :" #
'+# "9#2 #(+"
*$+$
2 " 9+"
"#(
(" "# *#$( % + "( $% +%#
, +'#"3
"#, ,# "# + :
,2 ( (2 $
+ +'#"3 $6#, "#("
""$3#9'
$# "#, 0C$%"# "2<?>$ ""$'#$ (,##, (*#% "($% 6# $"# :$,(2
"$%'
(#*#"
"$$99# +A
""32$ $ ,$% ,#,#+ " +2
$"'#( ,"$'#%#""##,'3 0C $%"# "2<?>5J
%%#"$( 32%"#,#"# $%"#*#""$
,#" +(
$":
"#% "(
,9("
#($%"# C5
6#: $% '$6#2 "# *#(# " *#""$ ( ++$:#,5 #""$ # ( $,##,"$'##+# (#,$ # + +2% $"#A#,
3$"# (#2$ ( % '
+G(#"3 '$ ,( "$ "# ( "(% "$ $% "# -,5 $ #, " $"G"3 (" "#5 $:#6#2 ,,"$ "$ $ ( " " 9 3 '# 9*$(#, '3 "# $ #, " + $"G"3 (" "#2 "# *#""$ # ( ++ #9
'$ ,'3"#%$++$:
$ () 14
#*#""$ #( ++ $"9((#"#+'#"3
"#,5 14
#*#""$ #( ++ $""
9*#:"
3#6,# #2$ +$ ,$9# 32, "#" +5 14 #*#""$ #( ++ $" '(# "9(#+%$
3, "#'#%$# "#" +5 164 #*#""$ #( ++ $"$99"
#:+#$ +5 164
# *#""$ # ( ++ ,#*$(" ( * ((*$"2 %
32 :" "# +$"5 164
# *#""$ # ( ++ 6# ( #++*$ # 9'# "$ "#
%%#G
$%$ #,$+#
++ $"
# ( #++*$ # 9'# :"$" *$ *#9(($ $%"#" +$"G ++ (" "#5 164 #*#""$ #( ++ $"
39
#"3"$,#+ 3"#" +5 164 # *#""$ # ( ++ ('9"2 $ "# %(" :$= , 3 $% #6#39$ "2
%%, 6"2'#%$#"#$ #," +$"2 "$"##%%#"" "# $"'## $99(($
3 $%%# # %"# '# #+# (#, $ '
(# "# #(%$ ,"$'#
# %"#( '# # #,$ "#*#(# " 2$ "#'
(($% ( %%, 6"$$"#:(#2"# "#(9
"#,"$9$6#2 %$":"2 %$
#++ $% ( '
+ : *+# 2 '" $% $(#2( ++'# "$
"#,*$ 9#"("##$%5 ?5
(# $% '# $%
3 $% "# %$#( , $
, "$(# :9 3'#9*$(#,'3$ #," +$"G"3 (" (,#"#, ##
'$6#$*$ ($:
3$"#(%%# " (#2"# "#G$9*+
++'# "+'#"3"$9$6#
#++ $%'
+$%"#*#""$ #5 <5 ,##, $, +35 /5
$" ( ,##
'$6#( ++'#$ ("#,
#D*#(($ $* "#9#"($%"# 5
# "# 9
(# ( '## ,#,#,2 *# 9(#++
#$(
**+ 2%
32( ++ +($("
,(,(*$(#,$%%5 1
-
-
-
-4 2./. 2./. 2./. 2./. 6 I#"#(*# = G# #,) #(G $ I#"##*$"
'+#) #(G $