State Of Haryana And ANR. v. Ranjana Devi And Others


   





 


 "# !#$ & &  '" "#  () "*#( ++#,, "% -#(%.%  / #- !"*#(% #%+ "% 012340'5 6*#"*#(#+("#(% 4$ ,#7%+ +#(%8 )9# ,,7#!"  %##"*#/.!:8# ";

9#(# #((#!""*##+("#(%( ";

&6*#"*#("*#/.!:8# "%*.,!9#(#+("#!

"*# :#%";

(#%# "1'*(  .( - % ,<< () ("*# ++#,, '*( = > %5.8 (<<!-$ "# ((#%+ " 
  = !#"* %/.!:8# "<

!"!

%+%#  ++# ,!

(#$"#!9) '" "#     ()  :

%"  "*# 7 (!  ! "#!   &

 + %%#!  9)  '*(

' 7 "<  0"( $$ "  , 8% ( ,<   % (  - !#  7* $*  $, +#"

,#!.

?&2 0"(=#* $,#%$"@

%*("2"*# $"A7 % $$#+"#! ! %.8 %?<?&<

27 % ,,7#! "*# ++# , $(%%29/#$"

%7#(# ,%!

(#$"#!9)"*#$, (# "*#  8.

" ( ,)%" "#!"*#$ %# "% %"* " BC

B "

 (7 , "7 *" %*%.

#(#!

 8"(-#* $,# $$ !*#

%.$$.89#!"

%+ " , ?

B" % ,,#:#!"* "*" %* 7 %:

:"7 (!%>,

$ (9# (

:(#:

%"( "

2&& 9#

!( -# 9)* 8 " 8!#( "#%+##! ! "*#$((#$"% !# "*#( ! 6*# "*#$ (9#

: !( -# 9)*" %* ++( $*#! (7 , "7 .% 9# (

:(#:

%"( "

2 &C  ()  !7 )%7* $*7 % 9#

:!( -# 9) :8

!#('

:*(#%+ " " -#()* :*%+##!

 ( %* "8

#($ 8# (8"*#++% "#!

(#$"

!*

%"  "*#  $ (    &&   %   (#%.,"    7* $*  *" %*  %.

#(#!

:( #-.% ! 8.,"

+,#

#%  *" %*  (#8

#!  !8 ""#! 

* 7, .(%

:8# % ( ("(# "8# ".+" ?

B7*# *#%.$$.89#!"*

#%'8" / #- 7 !7 !
.

8

(% *" %*$, 8#!

"9#!#+# ".+ *" %**#)* -#%.:*"$8+# (.+##% , $% (8"*#!( -#( !7 #( "*#9.%

-,-#!

"*# $$ " &  "

$#<(#%+ " ++# (#!

,#!7( ""#

%" "#8# "   !  $ "(-#("#!  "*#  ,,#: "

%  8 !#  9)  "*#  +#"

#( ""( 9."

:"*# $$ "(#%.,"

:

#%"*" %* !%.9%#D.# ",)* !# "*!.#"* %( %* "!(

"*#9.%" % ,,#:#!"* "*# !(-#  "*# -#* $,#  "   8!#( "#%+##!  (8  * : (*  "  % ( 

BC

B !7*# "*#9.% ++( $*#!*

(#8 : (% ". "#! " %"

$# "*(##> ,8#"#(%  (8 (7 , < 0 (."

 ($ 8# (8"*# ++% "#!

(#$"

*#$ (7 %9#

:!( -#  " * :*%+##!

 ( %*

"8

#( !"*#$ (* ""*#9.%*#!( -#( "*#$ ( ! 8(#+#(% 7*7 %$$.+)

:%# "

"*#$ (%.

#(#!

#%*#$ ( 7 %9#

:!( -#

 ( %* "8

#(9#$ .%# "7 %$ (()

& +++)%"( 7 !"*#!( -#(7 % ,%!(

:"*#$ ( " * :*%+##!.

!#( "*##

#$" +++)%"( 7$ %.8#!9)* 8 %7#(

:(#%+ "* %

.("*#(%" "#!"* "*#7# """*#+, $#%" "

(8#!"*#+, $# 9.""*# $$ "# )

:"*#( -#(8# "%< %7#(

:(#%+ "+( )#!

(!

%8 %% , 8+#"

C #%+ "%  !& ,%$ "(-#("#!"*# ,,#: "

%8 !# 9)"*#+#"

#(% !: -#"*#% 8#-#(% "*# $$ " %7 %:

-# 9) (#%+ "


(8 "*#  +,# !

:%    "*#  + ("

#%<  ,,7

:  %%.#%  7#(#

( 8#!12 @A6*#"*#(*" %*% * "" ('

:*(#% '* -  : (< % (%.

#(#!:( #-.%

-#* $., ( $$ BC

B "*#* :*7 )

"*# (#   (7 , "7 7

:"( %* "!(

9.% 2 &C9)(#%+ " :8

!#( '

:* !*#%.$$.89#!""*#%#

#% ?

B;

 @ A6*#"*#("*#+#"

#(% (#"*#!#+# "% *" %* '

:*!#$# %#! !"*#) (## ",#!" ) <

%< (87*8 !"7* " 8.

";

 @&A #, ? *#( ,< ,,7#!"*#$, "%" 8# !"*#+#"

(8 %?? "*#0"(=#* $,#%$"".

%?&2

"*#  0"(  =#* $,#% $"  !  ,,7#!  "*#  $, 8  +#"

 "  "*#  #E"# 8# #! 9-#

##,

:!

%% "

#!7 "*"*# 9-#% !7 (!<"*# ++#,, "2 '" "#* %!

(#$"#!"*#+(#%# " ++# ,7*#(# %"*#$, "%* -#!

(#$"#!

"*#$(%%29/#$"

% (#

B * -#*# (!,# ( #!$.

%#, ("*#+ ("

!* -#: "*(.:*"*#(#$(!% "*#$ %#

4# ( #!$.

%#, ("*# ++#,, "* %%.98 ""#!"* " $$(!

""*#

"*#"( ,"*#$, "%* -#

,#!"+(-#"* " $$ (#%.,"

: 

 !# "*     *" %  7 "*  9.%  9# (

:  (#:

%"( "

   2

&C  () ( !7 )%9)  :8

!#('

:*(#%+ " 7#-#(<"*#

"*#( ,"* "!#+# "% *" %*!#$# %#!

(## ",#!"$, 8 8.

".

?&2 "*#$" "*#9 % %

%"(.$".(#! (8., 

$ "#!

"*#%#$ !%$*#!.,# %7( :*#( , * %" >#

$8# !#$# %#! %%C

2+#(8 "* ! %%.$*"*#)# (,)

$8#$8#%"%

2*#$, 8+#"

$

"9# $$#+"#! %

$8# "*#!#$# %#!7 %8(#"* %C <

2+#(8 "*%.++("

"* %$ ,# ( #!$.

%#, ("*# ++#,, "* %(#, #!.+  ."*( ")

        

 
      !!" #$%  #&%  ' (")  "*#"*#(* !$.

%#, ("*#$, "%* %%.98 ""#!"* "

$8# "*#!#$# %#!$ 9#" >#  %%C <

2+#(

.8 !"*# 8.

"$ 9#$ ,$., "#! $$(!

:,) " %%.98 ""#!"* "

$ %#"*# 8.

"%+# "*#8#!

$

!"*#(8 %$#E+# %#% %" ># (#$(!<

"* "$ %#<"*# 8.

" 7 (!#!9)"*#( ,7.,!9#/.%"

#!"

.("*#(%.98 ""#!"* " 8.

(#%+#$" $ %("

.8< #( ,#E+ %#%

!,%% #%" "#* -# "9## :( "#!7#-#(<"*#,# ( #!$.

%#, ( "*#  $, "%(#%+ "%  % 

(  # .:*  "  $ $#!#  "* "    $ %#  ( $8+# %8 !#."

 * -#$ !#(#!"*#%.98 %% %8 !#9)9"*"*#+ ("

* -#: #"*(.:*"*#(#$(!% "*#$ %#7 "*"*# ( 9,# %% %"

$#   *#(# %

:(#".

#!9)"*#( ,"* "$, "%* -#

,#!"+(-#"* " $$ "* %" ># +, $#!.#"( %* ! !(

:     !7 )%  9.%  9)   :8

!#(  '

:*  (#%+ "    *# $  ( %#!  9)  "*#  $.

%#,  (  "*#  '" "#  "* "  +#"

%  "

9,#

$ %#"*#

$8# "*#!#$# %#! %8(#"* %C <

2< 9.""*#$.

%#, ("*#$, "%* %%" "#! ""*# ("* "

$8# "*# !#$# %#!8 )9#" >#  %%C <

2+#(8 "*<%

$ %#"*# 8.

$ ,$., "#! 9)" >

:"*#

$8# "*#!#$# %#! % %C <

2<  "*# !#+# $) "%$8#%"% ?<???2+#(

.89)!#!.$"

&(!

(#%+#$" +#(% ,#E+# %#% "*#!#$# %#! %+#(%$*#!.,#!

'#$"

?&2 "*#$"  *#!#$# %#!7 %& )# (%  :#'<9) ++,)

:  "*#  8.,"

+, #(    B<   %.8    %C<

<

2  (.

!#!    " %C<B <

2*#$, "% (# ,%*#,!# ",#!"$, 8%

2

(#%+#$" ,%% #%" "#<,%%  $ %("

.8 #( ,#E+# %#% %+#( '$*#!.,# '#$"

?&2 "*#$" & *#,# ( #! ( ,* % ,,7#! %.8 % <

2

(#%+#$" 8#!

$ ,#E+# %#%7*#(# %"*# 8.

"%+# 8#!

$ ,#E+# %#%

% * :*#(% !#  ."*( ")

       & * 
+
   ,    !$-#$%  #& %  ' "(. "* %$.("* %*#,!"* "7*#(#"*#"(# "8# " %, :(,%% *# -)<  "*#  $8+#  $

"  9#  >#+"  $

#!  7 "*

 "*#  , "%

?

+(#%$( 9#!9)"*#%#$ !%$*#!.,# '#$"

?& "*#$"'<

$ %# "*# 8.

$8+#  %" >#

" $$.

"<"*#%.8 %?<?&<

:( "#!9)"*#( ,$ 9#/.%"

#!"*#(7 %# ,%<"*#$, "%

"*#+(#%# "$ %# (#7 !7 !8

(! .:*"#( "*#!#$# %#! *#  8.

"* %9## %" "#!"9#+ !""*#7 !7 !8

( ! .:*"#( "*#!#$# %#!-#

"*# ++# , "*# ++#,, "'" "# $$#+"#!< "*#'" "#7.,! "9#

 +% "(#$-#("*# 8.

"*#(7 %# ,%< "7.,!9#.

("(!#("*#(#$-#()  8.

"+ !" !7 !8

(! .:*"#( "#( +#( ! %8 ))# (% C  - #7 "*# 9-#9"* ++# , %7#,, %$(%%29/#$" (#7 "*." )8#( !"*#% 8#%"

!!

%8 %%#! - #7 "*#+#$., ( $ ($.8%"

$#% "*#$ %#<"*#+ ("

#% (#,# ""9# ("*# (7 $%"% $+) "* %/.!:8# "9#%# """*#"( ,.(" (%"( $"

$8+,

$# #
 %

/01 , 3$  !$( &