Mangal Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab
!"#$$%
&" '(& $
& &
)
!
"
!
"
#
!
"
#
" $%!
&'!
****
& &+$
!
" #
(
# )*
$ !
,- #( ,. / 1
#
2 #
.
!
# !
,- " + % +
#
#
2 #
.
"# # %3
#+ !
#
4 !
(# 55 / 6&
14 4 #"
# !
,-
# !
,- .
#
$( $( &" %
!
/% 8
- (
# 9(#: ; .<7= &"
# %
'' # !
,- !
%
+
$( > = $ ?
?
'
!
" > ( ( # ( ( '' # !
,-
1 !
%
(
(
3 @7 % -
7 %
%
7 $( > ?
$( (
!
/% 8
" + #-
, +!
110 7 " %+ #
##+ (
(
!
( (
(!
%:!
> 9( %:
% (
# %+ 7
( % #(
% -
" +
+
(!
#(
(
" (
% +
%
7- !
6C(( !
#+ (
"
-
%
7
(
%
( + " #
##+ 6" !
%
( !
. $ +!
11*!
" #
!
,- # (-
( !
,- % ( " ((
= "
# !
"
% ( (!
#
%
(+
( #
(
%+
+!
#(
" > (
# %!
% (
+
#
(
#
" 7- !
6C( !
#+ ( B +!
!
( (
!< 7- !
( %
%
. #
7- ( !
"
!<
% #( #- " %
E
% # ( (
#
/ %
%
#-!
#(
( %
(+ B+ #-
%
= !
%
( #+
" ( $( > %
- (
# 9(#:
"
*3 ( '' # !
,- = (
( (
# 7 - (
#
(( ( #
% !
2 % > 5 (
- # # G
"
(!
.<7= &"
" (
( (- (
# ;
(!
9.7= &" :
( ( 55
# !
.5 #
+
( (
+
# #
## #!
## %
% >
22 (
% %
# !
,- !
( (
# = (
"
#
(# 6C(!
#
$ # !
,- !
%
(( (
$ !
,-
!
(- (#
"
# )
%!
( #
#
2 #
.
" (
# + % # +
"
)4!
%#!
+ + #(
0 2 .
" " !
# C( (+ %" % 0 % + C( "
#
6 #( "#
(
(!
( + , + ##
(# # .
> $( > 9## :
+
(
( % 9# #:
% "
(( $( >
( . + " (
+ (
%+ # &
#
(
(
. #!
+
C( " !
# &D 7 &D * B
% +
#
#
2 #
2!
.
"# ( +!
" (
(
"#
#
) B 9## :
(
(
"#
# #
*
%+
!
#
"
B
5 4 .
"
!
"
# 1 E
+ ,. # " + C
( B +
( +
(-
# # +
9## :
+ % #
% # # (
!
%#!
+ (
> % +
% 9# #:
&D " !
%
#
" " (!
%
+
(
D #
# # # +
, +
###
#5
#
( ( (
(
"#
#
!
) "(+ # "
+ "
# B
+ +
#
#
2 #
2!
.
"#
# "# ( "
( +
%
%
+ #
( , #
" "
!
# "#
#!
3
D0 $ ?
?
!
%
( $( > (
" + #-
# %+ " ( ( B %
%!
% (
# %+
+
(!
+ (
"
!< # %+
# %
( %
"
, " # 6C 7!
"
!
,-
# %+
( %+ B # ( !
,- % ( (
4
# %
"
#
6" !
%
(
" (
## !
%
!<
% #
7- ( (
" %
6" ( (!
%+ 7 "
"
#
#!
#-
%
6" ( + 5
(
%+!
# +
(
" %
(
"
"+
( ( 7 " 6C $!
(
#
## #
B 7- %
( (
(
D* "
#
" #
D0 $ 6"
!< #
"
D0 $
% # (
#
#
1 (# "# #(
(
D!
D
D4
D & > (!
6=!
'' # !
,- $(
4 +
=
- +!
%
# + C 7 55 6C
7=!
!
,-
D &>> %
1 !
& B # ( ( C(
+
$( $(
$
320 ( .
+
+
( 6+
%
(
( (
#- ,
E
% #+
#
(# 6C(!
#(# + B ( % ( ( % 2
#
(# 6C( 6C &!
"
6C #
( (
#
#
+
, " # +
( ( 6C B & B
D4
D
#
6C "
#
#
D
( > !
(
# !
,- # 6C " (
!
,- (-
( !
,-
" =
# 6C 7!
% (( ( (
# % ( + ( 6C /<
" +
" 6C& " $( > (
( (
D .<7= &" ." =
# # = 1 !
#
55 6C
$( !
%
'' # !
,- %
= C +!
$ !
( # ( ( 6C $!
( ( 6C $<!
( ,. 6C $<
## # , " 5 6C #
+
# ,
+
( ( 5 6C
" #
## #
6C #
( ( ( -
# " ((
6C !
9=:!
% 9=:
#
9= : , !
# (
" (( 6C B!
6C ;
6C
'
!
D) .
( !
D1 7 $
D %
( % + ( + %
" 6C , 6C >!
6C 6C /9% + %:!
#"+
D2 &( & ( # 6C '
## # # ( =
!
(
&D " !
# &D 7 %
# % +
>
+
( /
#+
+ # (
$( > " "
+ #!
## #
- #
4 (
"
(
13 (
"+ +!
%
"+
#
( $ D0:
(
D0 #
"+# " !
+ #(
'' # !
,- #+
C + 6"
( # C( #"
(
( ( $ ( .<7= &" '' # !
,-
1
%
( 6C $ ( 6C $< (
(!
(
55
# ( (
# 6C $
( ( "
4<13 ( " # !
( %
4
" +
"+#!
# "
4 = C +!
( ." =
# 6C $ ( "
(
+ (
+
( (
(-
+
(#
+ +( 7 -
% % H C
! . ,.
C +
+ .
"+ # "% (
,.
+ C + + # %
# I ,.
"
"
( # 2 / % C
%
#
(
5 %+
%+ #
- B
" #
+
#( " (
( / % " # !
(
D0 $ (
# (+ ( ( %
%+ # (
D0
!<!
7- (
" #(
%
"
% #
( 9 D):
(
#
#
(
(
+
+B # (
( +
" !
+ # " "
(!
! #
+
(
% ( +
# &
# ## (# !
" ( #
" % ( B+
"
# ( 6" ( % # "
2
((
(+ .
"
(!
#
% % % (
"
#
2
.
( # # "#
% + #" #
(
%+ 6C#
"
"(
/
#(!
% + (+ "# (
6" " # &D &D % " +
+
(
!
#( +!
+!
#
((
#(!
(
C
/ !
# 0 B
"
(
%+
#
# # (
"
# %+
/ "
( " # (
D0
D*
##
!<
/
(!
%
# (
%
# (-
+(
+ + # (<- %
% #!
0 (( #!
#
#
" ( %
#
%+ -
# B
D0
(
+(
!<
/
+ # ## #
7
#
"+
*
"#
# #
( ((
(
%+
#
#
#
2
.
( B % H
H
#
2
.
#
. 6"# #
+ ( #
H
H . #!
# 6C (
( $ "
!
,-
( ((
(
%+ )11* B (
(+ , +!
110 6C $
( ( " ( ( %
(
%+ 6" %
(!
" %
(+
( 7-
(-
% 5
* !
#
(
# %
+
(
% H
H 6#
%
#!
## (# % "# # 6C
+
(
%+ %
+
(
- "#
!
#
# +
(
%+ H
H # %
!
#
3 "
# $
" % !
/ 4
%
"
3
!
"#$
% &
& & &'
&
!
"#$ )* !
++"$ ,
-
(
&
(
.
&
&
&
& &
) &
-
& &
&
/
&
&
%
&
(
( 0 &
&
&
& &
%&
& %
#
& !'
%
3 /
&
&
1
&
! &
&
!
++" $
,
- +234
!
"#$
)* &
&'
&
&
,
& 0
&'
G
4
9 :
%
3
!
++"$ ,
- !
"#$
)*
5 0 &
&
%
*
0
& &
*
6 &
*)*
) .
" # !
% "
( / , +!
110 7 # %
#!
% " +
(
"
#
# + %+
( (( #
%+
- #
B #
-
=
!
## (# 4
!
/ (
.(
( # ( C#
!
/ A / > ## B (
( ( +
C B+ #5
#
( (
1 (
B+
#
+
+
#"+ !
/
7
+
## E -
+
( #
( ( (
(
" (
(
# +
(
#
# (# #$$% ,
& &- ) .
B
JK D
(
&J K