High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/878/2021dismissed

Om Devi And ANR. v. Ravinder Yadav

2022-08-16Mr. Justice B.S. Walia9 pages

!"#$$

%& $ ' !( &( ) RAVINDER YADAV '$ * !+!

(," !-./%($) $0$1/ ( !" %($2!03(,4+2

(3* !( $ %($5!6),(7 !84 4(9!$ :::

;< (9(!3* !

(!!8*(

+!8 8! 3 ( * !+!

(!! !/!+5// )/+ !

(+( 4!!=)(>? ++ $@$@#4 !!=)( > ++ ?$$@@A !+ !!=)( > ++#$$$ ;< *() /

!!=)( >? ++ $@$@#4 (2/ 3

1 $?B

@? 5 /+ .9 3 /!+ 5!( 3//!8!8 + /(!8 /!+ , )(!8 !+(+ ( !+ )! )(*/) ( /2!8B !+(+ (

/!+533,)!+(3)!C.0 )(9

7!+!)( D

@?BE4

// (32!8* +!

/+ !32!8F!*/ !32//8!3 9(@B4!+

30 2(!,!!39(@32!8// + )(*/) (4+ /(+2+ (+(++#$$@?@4 ( * !+! $A #! 3 5( * !4 53 3! !(+ ! * ! 3(

!!)+ . $!39(@43* !(!35(* !$$

,0()***/+

// (3

/+ !3+F!*/ 4 3(

(4 )!+( 0 ! A

3 )!C. 0 )(9

7!+ !)(

;< D

@?BE ( 3 (+( 5((G)(+ .* + *(!8 3 )(*/) (!+3*(, ./($3

// (2+ (+(++ ?$$@+ /(+ !+(+ ( !+H)! )(*/) (4.) 3

( + (+(5 +.93/(!+!!

,, !($ 3 (+(* +.93/(!+!!

,, !( !8 +3

(+(* +.93

// (++?$$@5 3/+ 32.! (83/9 + .9 3 /(!+ !!

,, !( !+ 3 5( !5 + , +$

(,! !++

!$$!!=)(>?5 )*3/+.9 !-./30)*(,

)(2+ (+(4!!=)(>++ ?$$@@A.93 /+!833(5 !

8( )!+5((!!8!( (!

533

383

)(53( 2+ (+(4!!=)(>++ #$$! 1

4( * !+! 3+.!+( + + +(*( !

3* !( *(/553!3( , !3

, 3 +

( *

( +

(+( 53/ 8(!!8 /.(9 3* !( *) ( 3 /,4 !+.453!?+9

,3+

(+($ ;B< 3 !

.! )+ ! 3 ! ! * /+ B$B$ !+ 3 5 .!8 +C )(!+ ! (G)

/(!+

(3* !( .) ! 2,.(4,5 F!.9 /(!+ 4(9!4 F! () ! 53( ((*/95 /+$ ;A< 7(!+ ( ( (+(4 !!=)( >A++ $#$ + +!8 !+ /!83 (*( ! /+ .9 * !( $

*( 2+!8 *

/!+ // + 3( ! A$$@# 3 /!+ 3 5 // + 3( 5 !

//+ .9 3 // ,! )3 (94

5( 2+ (+( ++ $$@ !+ 5 3( ( // + ! %(0!83 > 0,* , !B$B$@@?!+3 ,5

!!)+ !+

(5(++ , !8 3( * !(

;B< $$ (5(+!8

+ (+( * !( $3 .!+!+!3 (C !+( /+$!( * ! 3( 4/(!+ 4(9!

!!+ 3 !( $ ,!!+

// (2!8 /8/ !

!!=)(>@++$$= *

(,F!8./+ ( !3 (G) 5 ,+

,*/!

! 3 ( 5F

%( 3 $ 7(!+ 4(9!

!!+ 3!!9 4 )

!9 G)//8+!

,*/!

(+(!!=)(>++#$$!

1 $

+ +(*( ! !/(+9, 2+.9 !

3* !( 453!B, !3

( *

( +

53/8(!!8/.(9 3(* !( *) ( 3 /, !+. 53!?+9 ,#$$

()+. !=*(9

*( +

, *)/+ ! (+( !!=)( >4 3(

(4 ! 3 ), !

4 3

!,** ! 3.93.(

/, !)!+(0 !

)( 4@4 (*( ! /+.9* !( $ 5 (C + 2+ (+( !!=)( >A ++ $#$53/ !

(*( ! ! 5 /+ .9 * !( $ 3( (/( ( 53! 3 *( +

, *)/+ ! (+(4 !!=)( > $$ ? +9 , #$$$ ;?< 7(!+

( 3 * !( ! 3 3( 3!+

!!+ 33 // ,! ,+ * !( $ 5 !

//+ !+ + (+(5 !

)**/+ * !( $!

(5 3*9,!,+ .93* !( $( )!++ 3(!+* !( $ , F!

5 .

) 3 !

3 // ,! !/9 , 3 (*/9 !+ !!=)( 3+3( $ ;#< 7(!+

!!+ 3

/!+ // + * !( $ ! $$ @ 5 !

3//!8+ .9 3 !( !9* !

(2!! 1

;A< ;< 32

! +(+3 )., !

/(!+

)! /$ ;< +,+/94 *( (+(4 !!=)( > ++ #$$ (*( ! !++#$#$# /+.9* !( $5 +( + .+ ++!

(+!

53/553!3(, !3 ,3+

( *

( +

(+( 53/ 8(!!8 /.(9 !( *) ( 3 /,4 !+.453!?+9 ,3+

3 (+($7(!+

(3* !( 3 !

.!./ 3 5 !9(*( ! /+.93* !( 3(3!3(*( ! ++#$#$#453 33 9 5 /+.9* !( $ !/9$ + ).3( !2(,!3(G)

,*/!

(+(!!=)( >5 82!! ( 5F

%( 3.)*( ,32(,!4 3( !

),!(9 *(

! ( * 3( $ + 4 /8/ !

(2+ !.3/

3* !( ++$$$$B9( !+ AI, !3 .9 !+//8++

(G) 5// ,/,8(!+ 3* !( / ( 3 /,4 !+.$ ;@< 0 !4

)( 4@(+ )!+(" J $K

)( 3//!!9*(

+!8

!,*43( !

5!, 3(5 4 (3=*(9

*( +

! 9( , 3 + ! 53 3 3

!,* //8+ 32.!

,,+$L ;< *() /

0 ! .+ (2/ 3 !

)( )3 (M+ !*(

+!8

!,*43( ! 5!,

3(5 4 (3=*(9

*( +

!9( ,3+ 3 3

!,* //8+ 32 .!

,,+$ (+( 4 !!=)( > ! 1

( ++ #$$ !+ 3

( + 5( * ! 5 + * +

.9 +( !8 3 ( * !+!

;?< + + (*( ! /+ .9 3 * !( !

(+!

53 /5 53!3(, !3 ,3+

( *

( +

!+/.(95 / 8(!+ 3* !( / ( 3 /,4 !+ .53!?+9 ,#$$$ ;< +,+/94 5 !/9 * !( $ 53 3+ /+ (*( ! ! ++ #$#$# 53 3 5 +( + . + ++ !+ /.(95 8(!+ 3* !( / ( 3 /,53!?+9

, #$$$ !( $ 5 !

8! (9 (*( ! ! ++ #$#$# 53( /8/ !

4 !!=)( >@ ++$$$$B9( A$?, !3 .9 !+3,8(!+ !( ,F ( 3 /,2+ (+(++#$$! 1

$ ;< 7(!+ (/ )* ! 3 +

)( !

!"#$ %& '(')*+,-+ *(53 34

(5// )/+ .+!

)(32!8 F!*/ , (3!9(. F43

!,** !5 + , + !25

0 !

)( 4@$ ;B< +533

(,! !+* !4/(!+

3* !(

!!+ 33

)( ,* 5(+)!+(( /?

! )

!+ ) , )!*(

+!8

(+(

)( ++ #$$ D!!=)( >E ! 1

$3,( !

/ !8( !+ !+ + ++ .9 !-./30)*(,

)(!# % .

/$ $$ 0 1

! 2 *3

4 !/! / 5*$ !

!-./ 3 0)*(,

)(5 +/!8533G) ! 535 3*( +

( ) , )!

!,**(

+!8 !3. F

;#< 8( )!+

F %8M! ! + ! ++ $$ 32!8 *)./ 3+!( /)3 (+.933(+**//!3(!!,!83 )+8 53 3+ +/ 53 3 !

, ) ( 2+! )!+ 0 , ! 3 .

53 3 !$$4 !%($%!

C6),(0(2 2!+%($ &(0!834+2

4*( !8!383

)(

//3.+4 /+ % $**/ ! $

533

// 5!8*(9("

"# $ # $ $

# % &'( $

"# $ ( % ! ) * +

! ) - $ .! $

# # # ) ! $ # $ ) #

# /, 0 ! $ &12&2'( 3 * # '2''&221 (4(5 (1 (6 # ,

) * +

) !

;< + "

" # $ % + "

" ! #

- # &7

$ 08 $ ) 9 : #

;A< 88(2+ 8! 3 )!

4 3 //8+

!,!

( !2 F+ 3 C)( +

!-./ 3 0)*(,

)($

( !-./30)*(,

)(4(8),!+2!

+.9

(3 **//! 5 3383

)(32!8!+ !/9 (

)( 9(

3 //8+

!,*4 3 53 / *(

+!8 5( .((+ .9 0 !

)( 4 @ 53 3 3+ *( (.+ *( +

!9(

(!!8!9*(

+!8

!,*4 . ) , ) 3(5 53( ! .3/

3 83

)(4 )., ! 5 3 .!8 ! ! !+ .9 3 83

)( )!+( ( /?

! )

!+!+38!

!,* .!8 **/ ! ++ $$ /+ .9 %($ %!

C 6),(0(2 2!+%($&(0!834+2

!+383

)(3+

! +(+3**/ !53! !9(!+3+F! !.9 )!8 !

3 )83 ( = 9( 4 5 53! ,$ !-./ 3 0)*(,

)(

)!*(8(*3 $AA

!!. /$ * 4!/! / +6*7 *+//

;< ,-5$ /2!=(

3 , (*( +) + )!+(" % ,#

# "

# ;

# #

# &2 #

# # #

;?< ! 3

(,! !+ . F8( )!+4 !-./ 3 0)*(,

)(3/+33,*)8!+( /32!8.!*)./ 3+ !$$ !+383

)(32!8!+ ) , ) !/9 !$A$?4 3 ,5 3.9/,

!9(*( (.+)!+(3

)( $

(+!8/94 3 **/ 5 // 5+ !+ 3 ,*)8!+

(+(5 +$ ;#< *() /

(,! !+ +

!-./ 3 0)*(,

)((2/ 3 ! .!+3(.9 /!8

! **/ (.93

)( )!8 ) , )!

53! !9( , 3+ !53 33

!,* //8+ 32.!

,,+$ ;< !3! ! 43 )

!. . + 32

()+ ! %9 !

,*/!

C)+8,!> (+( 4 !!=)( > ++#$$ ! 1

;@< 453( 3! !* !3 .! /+ !B$B$$$ (

/ A9( (

()/

)

!$ ;< ! 3 ), !

4 3 *

( !!8 *(

+!8 8! 3( * !+!)!+(0 !

)( 4 @>( /?

! )

!+4 !

,!!./!+

(+!8/9+ , +$ (+(

$ ;@< 3 8 /(!+

!!+ 3 ! 25

// ,!

/!+

* !( $!2(32!8 .!!,+ 3(4/.(9.8(!+ * !( $ 3//!8

39(@$ ;< 7(!+ 23,!/9+ *) !

! )**/9

(+(.) 3 3 3 !

.C ! 3 *(9(

/(!+

( 3 !( ).C * !( $=*/!!8 3 ( !

( +/9 !

3//!8!8 + (+( !

(+!

53 /5$ +/ ,! !4 )/+. *! * !( $ F )**( *(*(

+!8 !

(+!

53/5

3//!8!8

// ,!

/!+ + 32.!* +!39(@.9=*/!!83+/9$ ;<

(+!8/94 ! 25

3 * ! !

+ .

2 53/ + , !83! !* !4/.(9 *(9+

( 8(!+ * !( $ F ) *(

+!8

3//!8!8

// ,!

/!+ + 32.!* +!39(@.959

**( *(*(

+!8 !

(+!

53/5.9=*/!!83+/9! F!8(+( !( * 3( $ $ #$$ <% ;

+. 3 =.> ;

# 3 =.>