← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/20611/2017disposed of

Islam And ANR. v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2023-02-28Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta5 pages



    



 !"#$# %& '() (*+,- $.

/ 1( 2

# %($ 3($)$

 ! (* 1($ $5 %0% &  67 8 4 9



($% & (8

/%#$1 )(# $8 %#:

 %;

(,0< "

$! ( # %($8 (8

(<%9)/ (== (;

.,, (*  9

 ,8  

*(  #%  1#$  5 # %  #$   >) $1    8-  0

8?8,  (=#$ (0 

.#"  4

# %  91#@( 0,  #$ (#"

 /)%

 (,)%0(4"

# %+,++,-A-,-?, ! ,'$#0$4"

B 1#%$#%( .$"

,?A1(#% !

((!((0 $C "

1" %$>)% .5( "0#%=$ (#$#%= 1(!( /8 8 $  5(  5( $") # %  "

$,  % ?8?8  %$5"

( 3#5#% 9)/ (,%"1 (=,#%#%=4

!!, /)%  (,;

$= #%=#%1#$5(#<

(!( /<#..

=( #* ;

;

(0$<#..

= E;

0 #..= /#%#%=8 ' ) 858/8,1$ ; 1( ($ ( ..*$% (<#..

( #* ;

.

00;# 1#..= ./#%#%=/

(# .8 % 1$#=% .=#<%'* 1#/,  ( ( ..*$  $ 550  %0  1  0(#<($  1( !  !.0  ;

* <#%= 1<1#".$ 1(8%$5"

3#5#% (( %=0 1(0(#<($!( / <#..

=( #* ;

0(#< ( ( ..*$ 15 .#"$

# %8 1( !

(, ( ( ..*$;('#%=0(#<% ;

(0$ 15 .#"$

;# 1" /5.

'1#%0 1/#%1#$"

(8$ 1*"( $$0 1'

((#"

(<#..

=( #* ;

10(#<($,;1 1 (.#(!.0 ;

*"

/

1(,! ("#'.* :5 $$$$# % ! ( ( ..*$ %0;% #%<#..

 /'

*5)(8$5# !! ( $, 1*" ).0% ' "08.. 1(

($;( !/ :C4 % .#:

D8 /5.

!)( 1(0#$". $0

 % %F 0 *,#888?8, %#%>)#(#$ ' ) ($,1"

/

:% ;

 ) 1( ($, ; '. %=0

1 E# !<#..

 /'

*5)( %0 %'. %=0 4

.#/4G .# $$ %8 -8

;

$(=#$ (08%<$ #=

# %;

$"

((#0 ) '* . "

.5 .#"84

/% $ !;# %$$$;((" (008 ;

$(< .0

% (/ :C4 % .#:

D'

(#%=(=#$

# % 8 B?;

'#%=0(#<%'*4

.#/$ % !.# % 1$ /;

$ ;%0'*1#/ '#%=5 ;( !

(%*1 .0( ! ()%4G  /.8 1( ;  ($ (#%=(=#$

# % $8 +- %0 -A-;( ;%0 '*5 # %($$.

/ %01' '91 %($5"

#<.* 1$ /,

(.< #/;('#%=0(#<%'*4

.#/4G 

$1#0H %0 3 :#. 4G '( 1#/8!

(" /5.

# % !#%<$ #=

# %,!#% .(5 ( )%0(4"

# %- (8 88;

$!#.08 B8 #$" % %00'*.

(%0" )%$.! (

(=#$

# %%)/'( !% % ! (#$0#$". $0#% 81(

($ / %* ($ !/ :C4 % .#:

D %0$ 1 ; ($#% >)$ (! )%0 '#%0).=0#% ..=0 #<# * !#..= ./#%#%=, #$% ' (% ) !( / 1(" (08 #$!)( 1(" % %00

$5( 1#%#%="

,%  )( %

!!%"5)%#$1 F"5 )5 % #%= / 5($ % 1 (#@0#% . <(%/%  (

14

 <(%/% 8 #$$)'/#

#% 1#$"

$#%<$ #=

<#%='%"

((#0 ) '* 1. "

.5 .#" % 1 <#%= '%!#.0'* 1" /5 5($ %,$  0$(<$ '>) $108

.# %"1 $'%5.

"0)5 % 1E)0=/%  !I (/.

/<84

 !

=% 8 )

 (* J, -- (#/#% B %0 I

(=

4#%=1<84

 !

)%E 'J  8?+AA !B,0"#00 %8-8A A8 55 $#%=  1  5 # %,  #  #$  $)'/#

0  '*  .

(%0  4

" )%$.

;1( $(.

$ ;  (/ ( !!%"$, !;1#"1

 %#$" =%#@ '., 1"

$$1 ..'0/0 '" =%#@ '.%

;# 1$

%0#%=

1( !!%"$ (% " =%#@ '.8 % # %#$

!!%"$5)%#$1 '.)%0(4"

# %-A- %0  (" =%#@ '. %0 $ , 1(#$% '

(

%")%0( 8  <#%=" %$#0(0 1$)'/#$$# %$ !'

1 1$#0$ %0 <#%=  5()$#%=  1  (" (0,  1#$   )(  #$  !  1  <#; 

 5 0$(<$ $)""08 8  :#%=

# %$ ! 15( $")

# $!

"< .),.

 '  $$)/0 

 #  #$  ($  !  1  5 # %($,  ;1#"1  ;( #%< .<0, 1 )=1% (=#$

# %%)/'( ! ($#%0).=#%=#% #..= ./#%#%=,#$/% # %0#% 8 ;<(,# #$ 0/#

( ;%($ ! ;  ($8 #$% # %($,;1 1 !.0 ;

*!( / 1$5 '*

:#%= 1#( ($!( / 15($ %$,;1 ;(05) 0'* 0(#< ($ 15 .#"

# %8 +8 $  $

0  '*  .

(%0  4

  " )%$.,  5( $") # %  !  # %($#$'#%=$ )=1 )%0(4"

# %  %04"

# %B ! "

?8 1#%#%="

( 0$ $)%0(& I8 =%#@ %" ! !!%"$8K " )( $1

%" !

%*  !!%"  5)%#$1 '.  )%0(  1#$  "

 (  %*  ().$  /

1()%0(F"5 )5 %" /5.

#%=/ 5($ %

1 (#$0#% . <(%/%  ( 14

=% 8- )

 <(%/% 8J 8 $$)/#%=

# #$)%0( 1" %$5#( "*;# 1 # %($

($;(#%0).=#%=#%#..= ./#%#%='* 10(#<($ 1( !,# #$ %.* 1" /5 5($ % 1 (#@0#% . (

 <(%/% ,;1 " ).01 <!#.0 %0;# 1 ) $)"1" /5.

1 )( #$0'

((0!( /

:#%=" =%#@ !!%"8% (/.

/D$"

$$)5(

,$#/#.

(;( 1!

$81#$#=1  )( 1.0 $)%0(& I1)$,

# %$ #%$ (

1*;( #%0).=#%=#%#..= ./#%#%=8$5(4"

# %B ! ,% 5($ % $1 ..)%0(

: %*/#%#%= 5(

# %#% %* F"5 )%0(

%0  #%  "" (0 %"  ;# 1  (/$  %0  " %0# # %$  !

(" %% #$$ %"5(/#  ( ! 5( $5"

#%=.#"%"8 )( 1(% 5($ %$1 %$5 (  ($ ( ("

)$ ' %$5 ( 0 ($ (0

%*/#%( . 1(;#$ %#% "" (0 %";# 1 15( <#$# % !

8 $5(4"

# % ! ,;1 <(," % <%$ 15( <#$# %$ !4)'4"

# % (4)'4"

# % !4"

# %B ! 1"

,$1 ..

'5)%#$10;# 1#/5(#$ %/% ! ( (/;1#"1/ *F

; * ($ (;# 1!#%;1#"1/ *F ₹A,G (;# 18 ( 0$ $)%0(& I =%#@ %" ! !!%"$8  " )( $1

%* !!%"5)%#$1 '.

)%0( 1#$"

 ( %*().$/ 0 1()%0(F"5 )5 % " /5.

#%=/ 5($ % 1 (#$0#% 1#$ '1 .!  '*  1  % .   <(%/%  (  1  4

 <(%/% 8J 1)$, $5(4"

,% " )( $1

%"

! %* !!%"5)%#$1 F"5 )5 %" /5.

#% ;(# #%=/ 5($ % 1 (#$0#% .!8 4#%"#% 15($% $, $1 ).01 <'%!#.0 )%0( #%='* 1 (#$05($ %, #% >)$ # %  #$  .# '.   '  >) $10  $  1   )(  "

%%

:

=% 8B )

" =%#@ 1 !!%")%.$$ 1(#$ " /5.

#%='*

1 (#$0  5($ %  ;# 1  (= (0   " //#$$# %  !  !!%"

5)%#$1 81 1 (#$05($ %#%$

0 !!#.#%=

" /5.

#%=$ )=1 (=#$

# % ! #%$ 1#("  "")$0,;1#"1" ).0% 1 <'%0 % #%<#; !4"

8 "" (0#%=.*,  1$  5 # %$  (  .. ;08    8  0

88?  )%0(  4"

# %$  -?,  ++     (=#$ (0 

.#"

# %  )..

 #$ (#"

/'

 %%F)(   %0  ..  $)'$>)% 5( "0#%=$ (#$#%= 1(!( / (>) $108  ;<(, 1 (#$05($ %; ).0'

.#'( * #%#

5( "0#%=$ #%$ # %($)%0( ,#! 1(#$ <# .

# % ! %*5( <#$# % ! 1$ #0"

8J 8 4#/#.

(<#;1 $'%

:%'* "  (0#%

%"1 ! 1#$  )( #%

(=

4#%=1D$"

$$)5(

8 1  " % # %  !  .

(%0  4

  " )%$. 

 " =%#@ '.

!!%" #$ .$  / 0  ) ,  1 $  %  /(#  '"

)$  $  % #"0  ' <, # %($;(%

1$5

# %$ #%$ 1/

1; ($

( !" %$5#( "* 0 #..= ./#%#%=8 :#%=" =%#@ %" !$)"1 !!%"

#$'

((0)%0(4"

$5( 1.= .5 $# $ ' <8 -8 %  <#;  !  ' <  0#$")$$# %,     8-,  0

8?8,  (=#$ (0 

.#"  4

# %  91#@( 0,  #$ (#"

 /)%

 (,)%0(4"

# %+,++,-A-,-?, ! ,'$#0$4"

B 1" %$>)% .5( "0#%=$ (#$#%= 1(!( /,

(1('*>) $10>) # %($8 ;<(, 1 (#$05($ % ; ).0'

.#'( * #%#

5( "0#%=$ #%$ # %($)%0(

,#! 1(#$ %*<# .

# % ! %*5( <#$# % ! 1$ #0"

#$5 $0 ! "" (0#%=.*8

'() (*+,-   9



(#

   L1 1(( $ %0G$5 :#%=& $G L1 1((5 (

'.&$G 

=% 8A )