High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25078/2011dismissed

Aman Kumar And ANR v. Ut Of Chandigarh

2015-02-11Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan7 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

*!(+,*!-!($ !.!(+,*!- #"&"&(#-'

/#-','

0"!"# 1!($&2!-1 #'3($#("

) 45 0+ 5 0

-#'#(") -!(&($#-0&(216$7%!"#6.&"16 -!2*##" !($1!.!!($- !*!($##30&(216 $7%!"#'6 -"1#3#"&"&(#-' -0,8!(",3"!6$$&"&(!9 6 - 1!($&2!-1

:1#"1#-"1# #3-"#-' 9%!9(#.'3!3#-*!;<#!99.#$"'## "1#=,$2*#("> <#-# #--#$""1# #3-"#--(" ? :1#"1#-"1#=,$2*#("'1,9$<#-#3-"#$&("1#$&2#'"> + 5 06

#"&"&(#-' *!( +,*!- !($ !.!( +,*!- '##8 @,!'1&(2 "1#&*3,2(#$-$#-$!"#$ A

((#B,-# C 6 3!''#$ <; "1# 9#!-(#$ $$&"&(!9 0#''&(' ,$2#6 1!($&2!-16 !

&-*&(2"1#-$#-$!"#$D ((#B,-# 63!''#$<;"1# 9#!-(#$,$&%&!9!2&'"-!"# '"9!''61!($&2!-16.1#-#<;%1!-2#'

,($#- 0#%"&(' A !($ .#-# -!*#$ !2!&('" "1# !%%,'#$3#"&"&(#-'1#-#&(&("1#%!'#3#-"!&(&(2" AD $!"#$AAC6-#2&'"#-#$!" 9&%#0"!"&(0#%"- 61!($&2!-16 ,($#-"1#'!&$'#%"&('

"&'39#!$#$"1!"&("1#'!&$ 63#"&"&(#- 1!'

<##('1.(!'!(!2#-(%1!-2# '#(#'&'( -!'"-,%",-#!($ -!$&(2,'# &('1-"4"1#*3!(;4 6.1#-#!'3#"&"&(#- 1!'<##('1.(!'0!9#'!(!2#- "1#'!&$*3!(; "&'

!''#-"#$"1!""1#-#&'(#7&$#(%#""1##

#%""1!"3#"&"&(#-'.#-# !(!2#-(%1!-2#!($0!9#'!(!2#- "1#'!&$*3!(;9!.

3&("1!'!9'<##(-!&'#$"1!".&"1,"#7&$#(%#6(%1!-2#%,9$<#

-!*#$"1!'<##('"!"#$"1!"(# "!<0!($1,6 -3-&#"- '

#(#'&'( -!'"-,%",-#!($-!$&(2,'#.!'3#-!"&(2 -*0 ' ?D 6!<&('A AA60#%"- 61!($&2!-1 # 1!$3,-%1!'#$%#-"!&(2$'.-"1 'C6?6? 67&$#<&99??

$!"#$ # "!<0!($1, &'',#$%#-"!&(%1#@,#'6.1&%1 .#-#$&'1(,-#$1#%*39!&(!("1!$!9' &9#$!%*39!&(",($#- 0#%"&( ? "1##2"&!<9#('"-,*#("'%"6 &('1-"4"1# %"4 " &' '"!"#$ "1!" "1#-# &' ( $%,*#("!-; #7&$#(%# "1!" 3#"&"&(#-' !($1!$#7#-.-8#$!'!(!2#-(%1!-2#!($ 0!9#'!(!2#--#'3#%"&7#9;&("1#'!&$*3!(; 1!7#1#!-$9#!-(#$%,('#9 -"1#3#"&"&(#-'69#!-(#$ $$&"&(!9 ,<9&% -'#%,"- -"1# 1!($&2!-1!($1!7#!9' %!-# ,99;2(#"1-,21"1# &9# 5#!-(#$ %,('#9 - "1# 3#"&"&(#-' 1!' 7#1#*#("9;

!-2,#$"1!""1#-#&'($%,*#("!-;#7&$#(%#!7!&9!<9#( &9#" '1."1!"3#"&"&(#-' !($.#-#"1#!(!2#-(%1!-2#!($ 0!9#'!(!2#- "1#'!&$*3!(;"1!'<##( ,-"1#-!-2,#$"1!"

? *#-#-!9!''#-"&(&("1&'-#2!-$%!(("<#<#9&#7#$1#-# -#6&"

1!' <##( !-2,#$ "1!" .&"1," !(; #7&$#(%#6 "1# -$#- $!"#$ D ((#B,-# 63!''#$<;"1#9#!-(#$,$&%&!9!2&'"-!"#

'" 9!''6 1!($&2!-16 -!*&(2 %1!-2#' !2!&('" "1# !%%,'#$3#"&"&(#-'1#-#&(&'&99#2!9!($"1#-$#-$!"#$ A

((#B,-# C 63!''#$<;"1#9#!-(#$$$&"&(!90#''&(',$2#6 1!($&2!-16&'!9'&99#2!91#!""#("&( "1#,-"1!'!9'<##( $-!.(""1#%1!-2#'1##" ((#B,-# .1#-#&(%1!-2#'!2!&('"

"1#!%%,'#$3#"&"&(#-'1!7#<##( -!*#$,($#-0#%"&('A!($

"1!'<##( ,-"1#-!-2,#$"1!""1#3#"&"&(#-'1!7#( %(%#-(.&"1'!&$ "!<0!($1,63-3-&#"- "1#'!&$*3!(; 5#!-(#$%,('#9 -"1#3#"&"&(#-'1!'-#9&#$,3("1# !,"1-&"; "1#(4<9#0,3-#*#,-"&(

D0,3-#*#,-"!'#'6 ?C6 .1#-#&( %#-"!&( 3-&(%&39#' .#-# -!*#$ ( "1# 3&("

#B#-%&'&(2=,-&'$&%"&(,($#-0#%"&('!($ "1#$#

-&*&(!9 -%#$,-#6.1&%1-#9!"#.&"1$&'%1!-2&(2"1#!%%,'#$!""1# %1!-2# '"!2# !($ -!*&(2 "1# %1!-2# 1# '!&$ 3-&(%&39#' !-# -#3-$,%#$!',($#-) E (%('&$#-!"&( "1#!,"1-&"&#'!<,""1#'%3# 0#%"&( !($ "1# $#6 "1# 99.&(2 3-&(%&39#'#*#-2#)

& 1# ,$2# .1&9# %('&$#-&(2 "1# @,#'"&(

-!*&(2"1#%1!-2#',($#-0#%"&(- 1!'"1# ,($,<"#$3.#-"'& "!($.#&21"1##7&$#(%# -"1#

A 9&*&"#$3,-3'# &($&(2,".1#"1#--("!3-&*!

!%&#%!'#!2!&('""1#!%%,'#$1!'<##(*!$#,"1# "#'""$#"#-*&(#3-&*! !%&#%!'#.,9$$#3#($,3( "1# !%"' #!%1%!'# && :1#-# "1# *!"#-&!9' 39!%#$ <# -# "1# ,-"

$&'%9'#2-!7#','3&%&(!2!&('""1#!%%,'#$.1&%11!' (" <##( 3-3#-9; #B39!&(#$6 "1# ,-" .&99 <# ,99;

=,'"& &#$&( -!*&(2!%1!-2#!($3-%##$&(2.&"1"1# "-&!9 &&& 1#,-"%!(("!%"*#-#9;!'! '"

&%#-!

*,"13&#%# "1#3-'#%,"&(<,"1!'"%('&$#-"1# <-!$3-<!<&9&"&#' "1#%!'#6"1#""!9#

#%" "1# #7&$#(%#!($"1#$%,*#("'3-$,%#$<# -#"1#,-"6 !(;<!'&%&( &-*&"&#'#"%.#7#-6!""1&''"!2#6"1#-# %!(("<#!-7&(2#(@,&-;&(""1#3-'!($%(' "1# *!""#-!($.#&21"1##7&$#(%#!'& 1#.!'%($,%"&(2!

"-&!9 &7 ("1#<!'&' "1#*!"#-&!9(-#%-$6"1#,-"

%,9$ -* !( 3&(&( "1!" "1# !%%,'#$ *&21" 1!7# %**&""#$

#(%#6&"%!( -!*#"1#%1!-2#6"1,21 - %(7&%"&( "1# %(%9,'&( &' -#@,&-#$ " <# 3-7#$ <#;($ -#!'(!<9# $,<" "1!" "1# !%%,'#$ 1!' %**&""#$"1#

#(%# 7 ""1#"&*# -!*&(2 "1#%1!-2#'6"1#3-<!"&7# 7!9,# "1#*!"#-&!9(-#%-$%!(("<#2(#&("<," <# -# -!*&(2!%1!-2#"1#,-"*,'"!339;&"'=,$&%&!9 *&($ ( "1# *!"#-&!9 39!%#$ ( -#%-$ !($ *,'" <# '!"&'

&#$"1!""1#%**&''&(

#(%#<;"1#!%%,'#$ .!'3''&<9# 7& ""1#'"!2# 0#%"&('!($6"1#,-"&'

-#@,&-#$ " #7!9,!"# "1# *!"#-&!9 !($ $%,*#("' ( -#%-$.&"1!7&#." &($,"& "1# !%"'#*#-2&(2

"1#-# -* "!8#( !" "1#&- !%# 7!9,# $&'%9'#' "1# #B&'"#(%# !99"1#&(2-#$&#("'%('"&","&(2"1#!99#2#$

#(%# -"1&'9&*&"#$3,-3'#6'& ""1##7&$#(%#!'&"

%!(("<##B3#%"#$#7#(!""1!"&(&"&!9'"!2#"!%%#3"!99 "1!""1#3-'#%,"&('"!"#'!'2'3#9"-,"1#7#(& &"&'

33'#$"%**('#('#-"1#<-!$3-<!<&9&"&#'

"1#%!'# 7&& ".7&#.'!-#3''&<9#!($(# "1#*2&7#'-&'# "','3&%&((9;6!'$&'"&(2,&'1#$ -*2-!7#','3&%&(6 "1# "-&!9 ,$2# .&99 <# #*3.#-#$ " $&'%1!-2# "1# !%%,'#$!($!""1&''"!2#61#&'(""'##.1#"1#-"1# "-&!9.&99#($&(%(7&%"&(-!%@,&""!9F

,-"1#--#9&!(%#1!'<##(39!%#$(#!-9&#-!,"1-&"&#'

"1#(4<9#0,3-#*#,-"&(

DD ?0,3-#*#,-"!'#'6AG

C 0,3-#*# ,-" !'#' ??G

0,3-#*# ,-"!'#'?DG

" #"

DD 0,3-#*#,-"!'#'ADG $

0,3-#*#,-"!'#'C?C!($%&

0,3-#*#,-"!'#' ? .#7#-6&( '

%!'# ',3-! 6"1#*!""#-.!'"1-,219;%('&$#-#$ 5#!-(#$%,('#9 -"1#3#"&"&(#-'1!'!-2,#$"1!""1# "-&!9,-"1!'(""!%"!'!3'"

&%#!($"1!"2-!7#','3&%&( *,'"<#"1#-#"3-7#"1#!99#2!"&('9#7#99#$!2!&('""1#!%%,'#$

-"1#3,-3'# -!*&(2"1#%1!-2#"1!'<##( ,-"1#-!-2,#$

C "1!" -3-7&(2"1#%-&*&(!9%('3&-!%;,($#-0#%"&( 6 '*##7&$#(%#'1,9$<#3-$,%#$ !* "1#7&#."1!" - -!*&(2"1#%1!-2#6"1#"-&!9 ,-" &' -#@,&-#$ " 2 "1-,21 "1# -#3-" 39&%# &9#$ ,($#- 0#%"&( ?- 6"1#'"!"#*#("' "1#.&"(#''#'-#%-$#$,($#- 0#%"&( - !($"1#$%,*#("'39!%#$( &9#1#39#!

"1#9#!-(#$%,('#9 -"1#3#"&"&(#-'&'"1!""1#-#&'($%,*#(" ( &9# " '1. "1!" "1# 3#"&"&(#-' .#-# .-8&(2 !' !(!2#- (%1!-2#!($0!9#'!(!2#-&("1#'!&$*3!(; !* "1#7&#."1!".1#(#7#-"1#-#&'! -!,$6&"&'("

(#%#''!-;"1!"!99"1#!33&("*#("''1,9$<#$(#&(.-&"&(2"&' @,&"#3''&<9#"1!"(#*!;<#3-#"#($&(2"<#!(!2#--0!9#' !(!2#-!'.#99!'"1#- ,(%"&(!-&#' "1#*3!(;6.1#-#!'1# *!;("<#'1#-# -#6&("1&'-#2!-$6"1#-!9#7&$#(%#"<#9#$ <;"1#3-'#%,"&(&'!9'"<##B!*&(#$ 1#-#&''"!"#*#("

.&"(#''#'6 &( .1&%1 !99#2!"&(' 1!7# <##( 9#7#99#$ !2!&('" "1# !%%,'#$3#"&"&(#-'1#-# -#6!""1&''"!2#6&"%!(("<#'!&$"1!"

"1#%1!-2#'!2!&('""1#!%%,'#$3#"&"&(#-'1#-#&(!-#2-,($9#'' !($"1#-#&'(2-!7#','3&%&(!2!&('""1#3#"&"&(#-' "<#&(2'6$(" &($!(;2-,($"&("#- #-#.&"1"1# -$#-$!"#$D ((#B,-# 63!''#$<;"1#9#!-(#$,$&%&!9 !2&'"-!"# '" 9!''61!($&2!-16 -!*&(2"1#%1!-2#!2!&('""1# !%%,'#$3#"&"&(#-'!($"1#-$#-$!"#$ A

((#B,-# C 6 3!''#$<;"1#9#!-(#$$$&"&(!90#''&(',$2#61!($&2!-16

$&'*&''&(2"1#-#7&'&( "1#!%%,'#$3#"&"&(#-' %%-$&(29;6"1#3-#'#("3#"&"&('"!($'$&'*&''#$

+ 5 0

'=8'