High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11968/2019allowed

Mukhtiar Singh And ANR v. State Of Punjab And Another

2023-09-04Mr. Justice Deepak Gupta12 pages

-#$& /

#0 1"+"#$&2

6/ %

" $-#

$: 5 $- $#

+3#$- % ;7 " 2"$.7 $- $#

$: 5 $- $#

+3#$- & <= % 2 >

& % %2%7!

? !" /-,#1

+% %

2"$.7 $-7 //

$: 5% %7 45"/-,#1

0# % %>% $- /-,#1

0# % >

@ ?#3

"#$+ - 5#, /5# 70"!

"#$6% %%/"+ #A +7 #%-

-%%

"#$+6/6'/6'/6 $-#0 / ."+

#!"1

"#$ :3 "

@/"+ "1

" ! / !#$.?"

7+ 5+

3#1

-"$.+

4 $ "$.

0#4% %

"$A

"#$? +!#-.

-#$ 1#43! "$ #0 +7 $= !

( +3#$- & "$ 5# 7 3

"#$+* 2B# 4 +7 - 4 - #$ '%%/ +3 ?7"177"+ $1!

C++#$> 47 $-"$1#$$", $1

77"+

+"+

!@/

"/> $ ," $-4 :"

> D 4 #(3

+"$ *7 -3 - 0#.

-E"!!

#07"+0 = 1774 $ ++"$ @ F/ 7# .7+ "-= 1774 $ ++ 7 - !

-@ G3"

- "$ % ? + !!

- +".$

#0 - 2 :"

2"$.7#$ E"!!/?

!+#0#.

-H $- ;7 2"$.7 ) -7 27@ 4 (3

+ "$ '* 7 - ?"

++ E"!!- +3"

;$#?"$. = 1774 $ ++7 - !

G3"

-"$% % "+1#$

-#$5 7 !0#03

!@/

"/> $

," $-4 :"

> D4 # 1 +

"$+ 0#.

@#0

E"!! #0 27"= 1774 $ ++/?7#"+ " 0 H $- $1!

1#43! "$ $ %

$ 0"1" "

E"!!$#

"$.

++ +$#+1"5 E"!!%# 1#$ @/ @ ,"1 "4+/ "$ +4 17 +"$1 + 3#3

@? +"$7

-5@$

!+ ++"#$/

+?# !-7 , "$7

+ 4 /5

5@? @#0E"!!/> 4 7 $-? + ", 3#3

@% "+0

3#"$

7 +5

$!#-.

- 0

- ! @#0 5#

@ +"$ //

7# .7 #11

7 - ;

$3! 1 "$ $ @/F%# #$!@ 7"+/ 1#43! "$ $ 1#$1 0 1 1"4"$ !1#43! "$ 7 -5

"$+

-#$"- "1 ! !!

"#$+?"

+3 0#.

@#0 E"!!

7"$-5@= 1774 $ ++/?7

? +$# !!

"#$+ . "$+

3 3

+ $- #$!@ > 4 7 $-/ -7 27@ 4/ ;7 " 2"$.7 $-2 :"

2"$.7?

".$ - + 11 -/ +"+ ,"-

$#%#

0#4 $$

% 7 1#43! "$ 0"!

- 5@ 1# +"$ 5# #0 1#43! "$ $ +3#$- #%/ 4 "$ -3 $-"$.0# !4#+ @ + $-

!@/ + 4 ? +-"+4"++ - +?"

7- ?$#$6%%% 6% 7

++ 54"

-0

= 1774 $ ++7 - 0# 17"!- $/"% %/> 47 $-+#$ $-3

$-$#$ !

. !7 "+7 - $@-"+3

#17 !!

, !"-"

@#0 E"!!"$ $@4 $$ %#

!@/ > 47 $-7 -"$+

- + 0#- 1!

"#$ #5 #?$

3#3

7"$-5@= 1774 $ ++#$ 5 +"+#0 E"!!-

%%F5

? + 4"1 5!@ +#!, -5 0# =#;- !

/ + 3 #- -

- %% ($$

'* #$ 5 +"+ #0

1#43#4"+

-$$

% F% "+ !!

-0

7 +5

$!#-.

-?"

7 $

"#4# ", / +0 4"!@#0 "+ 45#"!

-"$ 1","!

"#$?"

0 4"!@#0

+%! 5# "$./"

"+1#$

. $-0 $. !7 -

+#$+/$ 4 !@/ @ 4/

$-7#! %0

7#0 $. !/

? +"$7

-5@ + "-

+#$+/ $ 4 !@/ @ 4/

$- 7#! % " 4 ? + 4 "

$$ ," $-? +5!

++ -?"

7#$ +#$/$ 4 !@/= 1774 $ ++/"% %/0

+%0

7#0 " 4/

,"4 "

$#17"!-? +5#$#

-!#1;%0

7#0

"#$#0"$7 ? ++ $1 -"$ $ 4 #0

$$ ," $-+ 5+

!@/3#3

@#0 " 4 $-

,#!,

3#$= 1774 $ ++/ 0

+%#43! "$ $

$#%#

@ . $-17"!- $#07#! / 7"-+#$#0 $. ! $- @

45#"!

-"$ 1","!!"

"#$?"

+ $- "0 4"!@ +/ + @1! "4

$$ ,"7 -$# 4 "

$-+#/ 1# !-$# "$7 7"++7 %2 "-1","!-"+3

? +- 1"- -"$0 ,#

0 4"!@ #0 3 3

+% ,"$. !#+ "$ ","! #

+/ 1#43! "$ $ .# !#-.

"$+ 1 + #1#43 !

+ $-

"0 4"!@4 # 11 ""!!

. ! $-"!!

4 $-+% +7 !/?7#7 - "$+

3",

1#43! "$ /?7"17? + -"+4"++ - +?"

7- ?$H $- +7 $2"$.7/

5# 7. $-+#$+#07#! $- @? $ #;

+ $- "0 4"!@4 $.!

-"$ 0 !+ 1 + % '% E"

7 !! 5#, 54"++"#$+/3 @ 7 +5

$4 - # +7 "$ A

"#$ !#$. ?"

7 !! + 5+

3#1

-"$.+

4 $ "$.

0#4% ' % $5 7 !0#03

!@/ ;7 " 2"$.7 $- -7

27@ 4/ 3 0#4 + 4 1#$

"#$+ + "+ -5@

1%/"

1#$

1","!!"

"#$7 +5

$- 1"- -"$0 ,# #0

0 4"!@4 +#0= 1774 $ ++ $- $ 2#%6'#0 7 + 5

$-"+4"++ -5@ 7"+".7#

#$ 6%%% "+ 0

1#$

$# 0"1" "

E"!! $-

@ "$.7 ++ $$ ++ "!@% % $

3# 0"!

-"$ #$5 7 !0#0

+3#$- 2

"++ 54"

> 47 $- $-3

$#%6#

4 :"

> D4 # G3"

-- "$.3 $1@#0 3#1

-"$.+H ?7

+ "$, "#$ A ;7 " 2"$.7 $- -7 27@ 4/ + ##- 1#$1!

"4#- 3 ++ -5@ 7"+#

#017 !! $"$ +3 #03

+,"- #-

-%6%/

+7 ,

"$1#!

4$#%#0 17 !! $% % #+

3# 7 +5

$0"!

-"$ ' % % 7 +7 $2"$.7/?7#"+ 3 @"$ 5#

"#$+/"$7"++

3!@/#33#+

"#$+5@3#"$ "$.

#? -+$

#0 !!

"#$+ . -"$.0#.

@#0E"!!#0 - +#$ $-3 @ -0#-"+4"++ !#0

"#$+% % 7 54"++"#$+4 - 5@=-%1# $+ !0#5# 7 ,

$- !@1#$+"-

- $- 1#-7 +5

-% % 7 4 "$1#$

"#$ "+ -#$5 7 !0#0 +3#$- #%5@ -1# $+ !"+ E"!!-

-%%F"+ 33 !@ 0#.

-#1 /+"$1 = 1774 $ ++/

##0 E"!!/7 - !

G3"

-"$%7# .7/"

"+1#$1

!@/

"/ > $ ,"/4 :"

> D4 # $# +".$ #"

E"!!$#

"$.?"

++ +$#+1"5 /5

1#$

"#$"+ > 47 $-7 - E"!!"$1#$$", $1 ?"

+ "-3

+% $ #

7 $-/!

-1# $+ !0#

+7 +

1#$

"#$+ "+ -"$

"#$+% % $$

"+ 1#3@#0 E"!!"$A

"#$/?7"17"+ 3#

-#$%%F5@= 1774 $ ++/5

7"$.

$#%F#

7"+3#3

@"$0 ,# #07"++#$> 47 $-%7 + "-E"!!"+3 3#

-5@?"

++ !@ ;7 " 2"$.7 $- -7 27@ 4% 6% "+$# -"+3

-5@!

-1# $+ !0#

1% = 1774 $ ++/

##0 !!

-E"!!7 - G3"

-"$ $-

0# / E"!!"$A

"#$"+ 33 !@ 0#.

--#1 % #?

"+> 47 $-/ +#$#0= 1774 $ ++/?7#5 "$.

0"1" @#0 E"!!/?7#4".7 7 , 0#.

E"!!% $-"+3

-!@/ + "-> 47 $-7 + !

-@ G3"

-%3

+ !#0 E"!! !+

$#$

!@/

"/> $ ," $-4 :"

> D 4 #(3

+#0 * +".$ #"

E"!!#+1"5 E"!!#

"$.?"

++ +%# 1#$ @/

@ 33 #5 ,"1 "4+/"$ +4 17 +5@? @#0 7"+0#.

-E"!!/

@7 ,

$- 3", -#0 "+7 3#3

@#0 "0

= 1774 $ ++/?7"17 @?# !-7 , "$7

-5@? @#0$

++"#$"$ 5+ #0 $@E"!!%++ 17/"

1 $$#

E"!!7 +5

$0#.

-"$1#$$", $1 ?"

+% F% "!!0

/#$ + 4 !!

"#$+ +1#$ "$ -"$ / +7 ! 2B# 4 7/ 1# +"$ 5# #0 +3#$- #% 1#43! "$ $ +7 $2"$.77 - 0"!

- 1#43! "$ #%#0 0# !

-2 5 ","+"#$ ! -"1" ! ."+

/ :3 /+# + # 3#+

> 47 $-/ -7 27@ 4/ ;7 " 2"$.7 $-2 :"

2"$.7% #3@#0 + "-1#43! "$ "+$$

("$ *% #?

/+ "-1#43! "$ ? +-"+4"++ - +?"

7- ?$,"- #-

6%%/1#3@#0?7"17"+$$

6("$ *%

$#%'#

'% "!! 0

/ E"!! ? + . -"$. 3#3

@ #0 = 1774 $ ++%-4"

-!@/+ "-= 1774 $ ++7 -0# 17"!- $/"% %/ #$ +#$> 47 $- $-

!@/

"/> $ ,"/ 4 :"

> D4 #%#43! "$ $ 7 +$# 7"$. #-#?"

3#3

@ #0 = 1774 $ ++ # 7"+ "$7 % E7

-"+3

? +

. -"$. "$7 #0= 1774 $ ++/"

? + 4#$.+ 7"+0#

17"!- $%> 47 $-7 -0"!

-1","!+ #$ 5 +"+#0E"!!-

%%F/5 "$.2 #%FF6#0/ - + I> 47 $-,%

1%J%#?

/ ? +-"+4"++ - +?"

7- ?$"$ =#;

- !

/,"- #-

-%%($$

'*#$ 5 +"+#0 1#43#4"+ G%K($$

*% %

-# +$# #37

"#$+7"3"+$# "$-"+3

$. !7 -

+#$+/$ 4 !@/ " 4/

$-7#! % = 1774 $ ++"+ +#$#0 " 42B# $. !H?7

+ +7 $ 2"$.7/1#43! "$ $ /"++#$#0 4 +7 -2B#7#!

$- +7 !/?7#7 - 0"!

1"4"$ !1#43! "$ ($$

*"+ +#$#0 4 72B#7#! % +1 $- $ +#07#! "% %/ 7 $- 4 +7 -

1%7 -0"!

- 1","!+ . "$+ +1 $- $ #0= 1774 $ ++/"% %/> 47 $-/

1%/1! "4"$.+7

/?7# +3 1 +

+/7 -4 "

-24 %

$$ / 4 "

# " 4 0

7#0+ "- @ 4% 7# .7/ + "-+ ? +"$"

" !!@-

-#$%%5@!

--!%","! -.

(2%",$%*/ :3 /5

1","! 33 !#%#0 0"!

-5@> 47 $-

1%"% %/- +1 $- $ +#0= 1774 $ ++? +

$#%#

!!#?

- $- 4

1%"% %/- +1 $- $ +#07#! ? + -"+4"++ -#$%%5@!

---!%"+ "1 -.

( 1;

" ! /1#3@#0?7"17"+$$

%7 +1 $- $ +#07#!

7 - 0"!

2 #%6'#0 . "$+ :

-.4

-%% ($$

* ("$ '*/ 5

2 7 + 5

-"+4"++ -5@ 7"+#

#$6%%/1#3@#0?7"17"+$$

("$ '*%2#4 17+#/23 1" !=

"#$(","!* #%F#0? + !+#0"!

-5@ 17$ 4

1%/"% %/- +1 $- $ +#0 7#! . "$+ :

-.4

-6%%#0 7"+#

2#%6' #0/5

2= ? +-"+4"++ -5@ #$C5!

2 #

#$ %%%#3@#0 #- "+$$

F("$ ' *% % "+, @"43# #$# "1 7 +5

!#-.

- 0

4# 7 $@ +0#4

"#$#0 E"!!-

%%F%2 "- 7 +5

$!#-.

- 0

!#+"$. 1","!!"

"#$0#4

#0--!%"+ "1 -.

" ! / $- !+# 0

7- ? !#0

1#43! "$ /?7"17 7 - 5

$0"!

- 5@ +7 !/ 1# +"$#0 1#43! "$ $ +7 $2"$.7% % 7 +/0#4 0# + "--#1 @ ,"- /"

"+0#

+7 $2"$.7 !#$.?"

77"+# 0 4"!@ +"% %/- +1 $- $ +#07#! !#+ 1","!!"

"#$ 3 #$C5!

. "$+ 0 4"!@4 +#03

1%/"% %/ +1 $- $ +#0= 1774 $ ++%7 1","!!"

"#$ "$

"/> $ ," $-4 :"

> D4 # $- "5# > 4

$#%#

7 $-7 + !

-@5

$ 4"1 5!@+

-%> 47 $-/ 5# #0 + "-3

+ $-?7#? + +#!

0"1" @#0 0#.

-E"!!/7 + -@ G3"

!@/

"/> $ ," $-4 :"

D4 # $ 0"1" "

E"!!$#+".$ #"

+$#

"$.

++ +/$#+1"5 E"!!%, $

"$.?"

++ !@/ ;7 " 2"$.7 $- -7 27@ 4 $# 0"1" "

+#0 E"!!/ + ? +3

"$"$. 3#3

@#0= 1774 $ ++% 7 +5

$!#-.

4# 7 $@ +0#4

"#$#0 0#.

-E"!! $-

## 0

-"+4"++ ! $-?"

7- ? !#0 1"4"$ !1#43! "$

#$ +"4"! !!

"#$+ $- !+# 0

0 4"!@#0 7 - !#+ 1","!!"

"#$5 0# "+ 33 !!

,"- $$

("$ *% % 7 A

"#$ "+ ?7

"$ 0# + "- 0 1 + $- 1"1 4+ +/ +7# !-5 A +7 -#$# % % = -1# $+ !0# +3#$- #%1#43! "$ $ 7 +

3#$I2 %> 4 !27", :" #; $ ; ,%2

#0 7 +7 ) +%J (* ("4"$ !* / I ; +7 7 $- ,% 2

#0 "4 17 !

+7J("4"$ !33 !#%#0/- 1"- -#$%%* $- I "2 0)$%,%2

#0#0 !7")$%JL"4"$ !33 #%'#0M "+"$.#

#02= (1!%* %''6#0N/- 1"- -#$ %%O #1#$

$- 1"4"$ !1#43! "$ 1 $$# A +7 -#$

.# $- !!

"#$+ 33 #5 #01","!$

% % $I2

#0 @ $ $- +,+7%7 : $= !J

'6/#$C5!

2 #

! "--#?$1

"$.

"- !"$ + + #?7 $

$#%#

"$7

3#?

2 "#$6% %+7# !-5 #A +7

% ? +7 !- + & I%%$ 1"+ #-"$ @3#?

"1!

"$7

3#?

2 "#$6#0 #- #0"4"$ ! #1

0#!!#?"$. 1

.#"

+ #0 1 + + .", $ 5@ ? @ #0 "!!

"$+ 173#?

1# !-5 1"+ #3 5

3#1 ++#0 $@#

## ?"+ #+

$-+#0:

"1 / 7# .7"

4 @$# 3#++"5!

#! @-#?$ $@3 1"+ /1!

!@- 0"$ - $- 00"1"

!@17 $$ !"+ - $-"$0!

G"5!

"- P4@" -;"$-+#01 + ?7

"$+ 173#?

+7# !-5 1"+ -& ( *?7

"#$+4 - "+ $0#4 "#$

3# #

1#43! "$ / $"0 @ ;

$ "0 1 , !

$- 11

-"$

@-#$# 3"4 0 1"

1#$+

$@#00 #4 ;

1 +

. "$+ 11 -H (5*?7

"#$+"$ "+ $0#4 "#$

3# $-#

" !+/"0 $@/ 11#43 $@"$. %% %-#$# -"+1!#+ 1#.$"Q 5!

#00 /:

"0@"$. $"$, "#$5@3#!"1 #00"1 2 F'(*#0 #- G1 $#- #0 ."+

7"$

?#02 "#$FF(*#0 #- (1*?7

$1#$ #,

- !!

"#$+4 - #<1#43! "$

$- ,"- 1#!!

-"$+ 33# + 4 -#$# -"+1!#+

1#44"++"#$#0 $@#00 $-4 ;

1 + . "$+ 11 -H (-*?7

"#$+"$ -#$# 1#$+

1#.$"Q 5!

#00

1#$+

#$!@ $#$1#.$"Q 5!

#00 /$#"$, "#$"+ 4"

- 5@ 3#!"1 #00"1 ?"

$ #- #0 ."+

+ 1#$

43!

2 "#$FF(*#0 #- ( *?7

"#$+4 - #1#43! "$ +# 5+ $-"$7

!@"43#5 5!

#$ 5 +"+#0?7"17$#3 +#$1 $

17 :

1#$1!

+"#$

"+ + 00"1"

.# $- 0# 3#1

-"$. . "$+ 11 -H (0*?7

"+ $ G3 ++!

. !5 $. 0

-"$ $@#0 3#,"+"#$+ #0 #- # 1#$1 -1 ( ?7"17 1"4"$ !3#1

-"$."+ "$+

-* "$+

"#$ $-1#$ "$ 3#1

-"$.+ $-B#

$#%#

"+ +3 1"0"13#,"+"#$"$ #- # 1#$1 -1 / 3#,"-"$. 00"1 1"# ++0# ."

, $1 .."

-3 @H (.*?7

1"4"$ !3#1

-"$."+4 $"0 !@

-?"

74 ! 0"-

$-B#?7

3#1

-"$."+4 !"1"# +!@"$+

-?"

7 $

"# 4# ", 0#?

;"$., $.

#$ 11 - $-?"

7 ,"

? #+3"

7"4-

#3",

$-3 +#$ !.

%J % $ #3"$"#$#0 7"+1#

/ 1 + 0 !!+?"

7"$

3 4

+#%(.*

# 5#, % 6% 3 0#4 5#, /"$2 !"5D27 !

D2 !"49+%2

+7) +%L"4"$ !33 !#%66#0 "+"$.#

#0 2%=% % ("4"$ !* #% F #0 O - 1"- - #$ 7 / / #$C5!

2 #

/ 0

;"$.$#

#03 4

+! "--#?$"$ 7 : $= !C+1 + (+ 3 *0#A +7"$.#0 #1"4"$ !3#1

-"$.+

7 !- + & '% 7"+ + / ?

?# !- !";

# #5+ +#4

7"$. "43# % E7 $ 11 - 1#4 + 5 0# #

"$,#;"$.

"$7

3#?

2 "#$6#0 #- #0"4"$ ! #1

( * # #-"$ @ :

"+-"1 "#$ "1!

' #0

#$+

"#$ # .

# 1"4"$ ! 3#1

-"$.+ A +7

++ " !!@#$ .# $- 173#1

-"$.+ 4 $"0 !@0",#!# # , "# + # "$+

- ?"

"# 4# ", 0# ?

;"$.

/ $"$+ 171"1 4+ #

+ -

@ #!##;

"$ ?"

71 $- !"

4# 1!#+ !@% + @+#5 #$1 1"- #3#1

- . "$+

-?"

7 $

"#4# ", 0#?

;"$.3 +#$ !, $.

1%/

$7 ?# !- $+

B1#43! "$ "+, @?

!!- 0

-?"

7 !!

$ ++ @ 3!

-"$.+% 7 1#43! "$ $ ?# !- $+

+4 - B1#43! "$ 17 @-"+1!#+

++ @"$.

#1#$+

-#00 % 7

0# /"

?"!!$# :

$# .70# #

#!##;"$

+ 4 - "$ B1#43! "$ !#$ 0# 3 3#+ #0

$#%#

"$"$.?7

$ ++ @"$.

#1#$+

#00 -"+1!#+ -#$# %$0",#!# +#, "# +3#1

-"$.+/

+ -

@ #!##;"$ #4 $@#

$-"$.1"1 4+

."$.0#4 1#-#0 1 + #, $- 5#, , + $-/ "0$

-5 /?"

1 $-1"1 4+3 "#$ @ -"$5

!"$ +% 7 #

?7"!

1"+"$."

"+-"1 "#$ 2 "#$6#0

# "1!

'#0 #$+

"#$$

-$# "1 "

!0#$!@ #

#0 1 +

"+ 43#?

;

"$ # 11# #, !!

1"1 4+ +!

-"$. "$"

"#$B ."+

"#$#0 1 + +?

!! +

" !+1#!!

-"$ 1# #0"$, "#$% ;

0#"$+ 1 + #$7 $-% "3!

+7 ,

$ ."+

#, 3 "#-#0 "4 % "+"$ 5 1;.# $-#0+ 171"1 4+

."+

"#$#04 "3!

+ ++ +"43# /

"$.

"++

#0 ?

;"$. , $.

#0 3",

# 3 +#$ ! .

+ !!

-%J F% ,"$.$# "1 0 1 + $-1"1 4+ +#0 1 + $-

. !3#+"

"#$ + G3! "$ - 5#, $- 3 4

+"$?7"17

1 $5 A +7 G3# -5@ #$C5!

2 #

0#4 "4 #

"4 / 7"+1#

0"$-+ 7"+1 + #5 A +7 -%+ 17/ #%-

-%%/ 2 "#$+6/6'/6'/6 $-#0 / ."+

#!"1 2

"#$ :3 "

@/"+ "1

" ! / !#$.?"

7 !!+ 5+

3#1

-"$.+ 4 $ "$.

0#4/"+

5@A +7 -% #

"#$+ !!#?

7# #1#3@#0 7"+#- 3! 1 -#$ 1#$$

-1 + 0"!

6/ ( >

* + "

+#$ -B+3 ;"$.& +B# E7

3# 5!

& +B#

$#%#