High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/12250/2025allowed

Satpal Singh v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-28Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

# $% 6#5+$ ) # $% 6#5+$ ) # $% 6#5+$ ) # $% 6#5+$ ) &!&+ > &!&+ > &!&+ > &!&+ >0 0 0 0

?-#

$ #* * 7#*+&+ # $% & '

?-#+ $ 6#

) ) ) ) *#+# ) *#+# ) *#+# ) *#+# ) 3, -

3, -

, , , , +- 7*## " : 0 67$5 # %$*

$ #*- *- .

*## !"0 & ' (- ;;;;;

;;;;;

, , , ,0 - 1,4 0 - 1,4 0 - 1,4 0 - 1,4 - *#+#

$ "+ (## % #6 & 6#* #5 $ @> "* . !*/ &*/+" "

1%$* +"$* 2 34 %$* !* % *#!&

$ #* 5+# (#* !

! $- 6 #6 =-- *#!+ #*#6 %$ "# $%%# 5#+ & +"( # & 6#* #5 $ + A=A> $%

*5$ 5 *& &!+ 6 +.5"$ 5 &(+ 5# #+ 5 0 B> 1%$* +"$* 5 340 $

5# $ " &*0 + *5

- -

"# !*79# $% "# <&# $ +

$ #* + 55&+#6 $% ( (# ! 7$ 7#6 !

7$ 7 !

$$+# $85

+0 -#-0 *96$ .6*$ $5"

$*6# 1C== !*9+4

#!#6 *#5$7#*#6 %*$ $9

$ #*-

,#* #6 5$& +# %$*

#* "+ #*

$ #* * + 5&+ $6.

+ 5# =-- - ,#* #6 5$& +# %$*

$ #* "+ %&* *

+&(9

"# 9 6 $*.

*$7+$ + $% 5 "7# $ (## 5$9

#6 :

"0 6 "&+0 *$+#5& $ 5+# +&%%#*+ %*$9 "#*# 6#%#5 +- ,#* #6 5$& +# %$*

$ #* "+ #*

+ 6# .#6 6

"#*#$% 5 $ (# %+ # #6 &

$ #*- ,#* #6 5$& +#

"+ %&* #*

$ #* "+ +&%%#*#6 5*5#* $ %$* 9$*#

" D .#*+- "&+0 *#!& *.#6 %$*- @- ,#* #6 # 5$& +# "+ $

$+#6

$ (.

*!& !

#! $ + *+#6 ! +

$ #* *# +#*$&+ &*# 60 "&+0 "# 6$#+ $ 6#+#*7# "# 5$ 5#++$ $% "# *#!& - ,#* #6 # 5$& +# "+ %&* "#* +&(9

"# +

# + (**#6 (.

*!$*+ $% #5 C $% 5 0 6 "&+0 "# +9# $&!"

$ (# 6+9++#6- ,#* #6 # 5$& +# +##/+

5# $ *#5$*6 5&+ $6. 5#* %5 6 #6 C->- $&* 0 :"5" + /# $ *#5$*6- -

"7# "#*6 5$& +# %$* "# *7

* #+ 6 "7# !$ # "*$&!"

"# 7 # *#5$*6+ $% =-

$ #* :+ **#+ #6 $ =-- :"#*# % $ :+ 5**#6 $& 6 5"

:+ #6 $ =--@-

*$+#5& $ :

#++#+ "7# (## 5 #60 $& $% :"5"0 = "7# (## #89 #6

6 #- "# *7 5$ $ + *+#6 * !7# *+# $ 6#( ++&#+ +"

(# * $5 #6 & $ 6&* !

"# 5$&*+# $% "+ $&* 6$#+ 6##9

$ 6# 7# 6##

"#+# *7 5$ $ +0

!#0

*#'&65# " !

!( # "+ (## (*$&!"

%$*:*6 $ 65 /# "$$6 $%

$ #* (+5$ 6 ! %*$9

*$5#++ $% '&+ 5# $* #*%#* ! :

*$+#5& $ #76# 5#-

=--

+ 6##6 *$5*+ ! 6 %$

"#*#$% 5 $ (# +66 #6 &

$ #*- + #* 5&+ $6. 5#* %5 # 6 #6 C->- % (.

#* #6 # 5$& +#

$ #* "+ *#6. +&%%#*#6 5*5#* %$* #*$6 $% .#*0 > 9$ "+ 6 B 6.+0 E + $ +"$:

$ (# 7$ 7#6 . $ "#* 5+#A -

"+ 7#: $% "# 9

#*0 "# *!$* 9 $+#6 & 6#* #5 6+ 6 !"

"# * # $%

"# $ +

6- =--

"+ $&* '&6!9#

#6 + F& : 6#* 7#*+&+ # $% F& : 6#* 7#*+&+ # $% F& : 6#* 7#*+&+ # $% F& : 6#* 7#*+&+ # $% & '( & '( & '( & '( ++#6 =@C@ =@C@ =@C@ =@C@@ @ @ @ 1))=B4G % #* *# . !

"# * $ 6#56# 6 $% "# '&6!9# + $% "# $ 3( # & *#9# $&*

&++ * F" $$ 7+- $9# #5.-0 # $% "* 1B>4 >G (6&

#"9 . 7+ -- ./ 1BB4 G 7#6 & 9 "/" 7+- # $% "*+"

* 6 $ "#*0 @1 4 1*9 4 @B@G $"6 &+ 9 H &++ 7+- # 1 $% # "4 *# #6 +

G *9

$-@A 6 #6 C--

#6 + I"

+:+ + &("+ 7+- "# # $% J#+ # ! KG I

+" 6"/*. H 7+- "# # $% J#+ # ! K0 #5 ,#7# $

# 1* -4

$- 6 #6 ->-

#6 + I$"996 9 % "/"

7+- "# # $% &'* KG *9

$-=B $% 6 ->-

#6 + $ F*+" * H $ *&+9 7+- $ $% 60 6 /&* "&6"*. 7+- # $% 6". *6#+"0 @1@4 1*9 4 CG "+ "# "&+) IC->-

"# *!"

$ + ##6. 6 #8 + $ . +%#!&*6 *#7# & 6&# 6 $

*#++7# 5*5#* $ G $ 9 8# . 6 5$ 5#* 55$9 . !

"# 55&+ $ + :#

+ $ 5&* *9#

"# (

. $% 55&+#6 $ 6#%# 6 "9+# %0 (&

"#*# + $7#**5" ! +$5#

#*#+

7 ! :. %$* + ##6.

"+ *!"

@ (## *# # . 5 & "# *#5#

+ 6 "# * $ 6#56# 6 $% ($7#*#%#**#6 $ & *#9# $&* 3+ '&6!9# + "7# 6 6$: +#*#+ $% 6#5+$ + $ # ! & #: 7+ + $% %& 69# *!"

+- "# 5$ 5#

##6.

+ 9 !9 "# * # + #++#

* %& 69# *!"

%# 6 .0 !&* ##6 6 *#+#*7#6 & 6#* $&* $ +

$ - "# *!"

$ + ##6.

(#! + :

"# 5 & *#+

$+#6

9# $% "# **#+ "# 55&+#6 6 5$ +#<&#

5*5#* $ :"5" 5$ &#+

!#+0 9# .0 "# + !# $% $ 0 <&*.0 0

# 6 *#7+$ +$ $++(

*#'&65# 9. *#+&

6&# $ 9 #*9++( # 6 7$6( # 6# . + 5#

9# $% "# 5$99++$ $% "# $%%# 5#

"# 5*9

*$5##6 !+ 5$ +&99 $ %

.0 5$& 6 (# 7#* #6- "# + ##6.

0 #* "#* ! 6 <&5/ 6+ $+ *# + # <& $ $% 5*9 '&*+ *&6# 5#- $7#*5*$:6#6 $&* 6$5/# +0 "# "#7. 7$ &9# $% :$*/ 6 "# *#+&

*#++&*# $ *$+#5& $ 6 "# $ 5#0 6&( . /## "# # *# 5*9 '&*+ *&6# 9#5" +9 & 6#* + *#++ 6 + * - $:#7#*0 5 $ (# #85&+# %$* /## "# +:$*6 $% 9$5 #+ " ! ! $ 55&+#6 %$* 6#% #*$6 $% 9#-

6$#+ $ +#*7# . 5*#6

5*9 '&+ 5# +.+ #90 * 9/#+ %$* +6 + # $% %%*+- !&* ## $% + ##6.

# 6#6 $ 7$6 $

*#++$ 6 *#7#

6# . (. 9 $+ ! $ "# $&* 6 *$+#5& $ $(

*$5##6 :

" *#+$ ( # 6+ 5"- "# !&* ## +#*7#+

"*##%$ &* $+#- *+

#5 "# 55&+#6 ! +

*#++7# *#

*+$ 9# G +#5$ 6 .0 *# #7#+ "# 55&+#6 $% "# 8# . 6

&( 5 +&+ 5$ 6&# $ & *#+$ 7#6 5*9 5"*!#+ 6 +

#5 ! +

"# *+/ #76# 5# :

(# $+ $* 9#9$*#+ 699#6 (.

++!# $% 9#0 "&+0 9 * !

"# (

. $% "# 55&+#6 $ 6#%# 6 "9+# %-

!$#+ :

"$& +. !

"# 5$ +#<&# 5#+ $% *# 6# *# !*7#- 55&+#60 *#+&9#6 $5#

*$7# $ "#*:+#0 *# +&('#5 +.5"$ $!5 6 ".+5 6# *7 $ + $% ' %#0 &+&

& 6#* $ #*$&+ 5$ 6 $ +- <&

. 9 "# (&*6# $% 6# +&5" 55&+#6 %*#<&#

. %

+ "#7 . $ "# $5# 9#9(#*+ $% "+ %9

"#*# + .# $ "#* + #5 "# 9

#* :"5" 6#+#*7#+ 5$ +6#* $

"+ + !#- "#

#! $ + 5+# *# 55&+#6 (# ! 7$ 7#6 *# $ 5$99#*5 <&

. $% 5$ *( 6 & 6#* 0 B>- J"

# 5$ +6#* ! (

5+# 7$ 7 ! 5$99#*5 <&

.0 "# $&* $ /## 9 6 *!$&*+ # &9#* #6 & 6#* #5 0 B> :"5" 9 6

+ 5 !*

$ 55&+#6 $ . % #* "#* !

*$+#5& $* 6 % #* "7 ! + +%#6 +# % $% : 5$ 6 $ + :"5" *# *#+$ ( # !*$& 6+ %$* (# #7 !

"# 55&+#6 + $ !&

. $% $%%# 5# 5"*!#6A

#!#6 6 0 "# + $

/# $ 5$99 . $%%# 5# :"

# $ ( "# + * !# *!$&*+ $% #5 0 B> 9&+ (# 9# 5& . +5*& L#6 ! +

"# (5/6*$ $% 55&+#63+ %& 69# *!"

$ + ##6.

"# *!"

%# 6 #*+$

5 $ (# *# 6#*#6 &! $*. (. & :** #6 6# .+ "# '&65

*$5#++0

* 5& * . :"#*# +&5" 6# .1+4 + # "#*

*(& "# 55&+#6 $* '&+ %#6

"# # 6 $% *$+#5& $ (. 5$!# *#+$ +- 676&

5 $ (# /#

(#" 6 (*+ %$* $*6 #*$6 $% 9# (.

/ !

*#%&!# *!$&*+ 6 6$: #5 0 B>-

#!+ &*# + :+6$90 $*6#* $ # +&*# + ##6. 6 9# . 6+ $+

"# 5+#+ & 6#* "# 5 0 "+ *$76#6 %$* "# 5$ +

$ $% + #5 & 6#* #5 = $% "# 5 - $:#7#*0 "+ $&* 5 $

&* +$ 3+ #.# *5 #6 6# .+ 6 +.+ #9 5 #%%5# 5.

%*&+

#!+ 7# &* $+#- $&* : + 6& .($& 6 $ # +&*#

6$#+

(#5$9# 5$9

7$ $ $% 676& 3+ %& 69# *!"

+0 :

"+ 6 ! .

" ! 5$ #6 + #- J"

# 6# ! :

" (

$ 5+# !$7#* #6 (.

"# *!$&*+ $% #5 B>0 "# $&* 9&+ */# '&65$&+ ( 5# (# :## #!+ 7#

$ 5&*( "# 9# 5# $% 6*&!+ 6 "# +5*$+ 5 *!"

"# 55&+#6

$ %* 6 #8 - *$ $ !#6 5*5#* $ 0 :

"$& '&+ %( 5&+#0 *+/+ * +%$*9 !

*# 6# 7# 9 *+$ 9# $& 5$9#

* 5

# $% '&+ 5# 6 #<& *!$0 "# & #<&7$5 %#*# 5# + :"#*# % $ 5$ 5 &6# :

" *#+$ ( 9#0 *#+&

$ !#6 5*5#* $ 0

#+ ! +

*#5$&+ %& 69# *!"

+ $% %# 6 . !* #6 & 6#* : 60 + +&5"0 5$ 6 $

$7#**6 !

"# + $*. #9(*!$ 5*# #6 & 6#* #5 5 0 B> $&!"

$ (# 5$ +6#*#6 + #* %5 + $% !7# 5+#- :$*6+0 !* $% ( 5+# !

$ 5$99#*5 <&

.0 $ !*$& 6 $% & 6&# 6# .

0 5 $ (# +6 $ (# %#

#*#6 (. #5 0 B>-K &%%5# $ +.0 %&* "#* 6# $ $%

$ #* + & 6#* + $ :** "# %5 + 6 5*5&9+ 5#+ $% C-

7#: $% ($7#0

$ +

$:#6- #

$ #* + $*6#*#6 $ (# *# #+#6 $ *#!& $ "+ %&* +" ! ( A+&*# . ($ 6+

"# + +%5 "# ,6- 5$ 5#* #6 A& . !+ #- $:#7#*0 66 $ 5$ 6 $ + 9. (# 9 $+#6 (.

"# 5$ 5#* #6

A& . !+ #0

$ #* +"

*#9 ($& 6 (.

"# %$

$: !

5$ 6 $ +) 14

$ #* +"

9+&+# . !* #614

$ #* +"

9 #* :

" . #76# 5#0 $* 6$5&9# *.0 6&* !

$ #* +"

(+# "9+# % $ . 6 # (#%$*#

174

$ #* +"

5$99 . $%%# 5# :"

# $

$ #* +"

6# $+ ++ 0 % .0 :

174

$ #* +"

!7# "+ 5#

"$ # &9(#*

! %%5#*A $% 5$ 5#* #6 $ 5# 6 +"

5" !# "+ 5#

"$ # &9(#* :

"$&

*$*

#*9++$ $%

< !+ #- 174

$ #* +"

. 9 #* *.

$ 6# .

= 174

$ #* +"

+&(9 0 $ "# %*+ :$*/ ! 6. $% #7#*. 9$ "0 %%67 0 (#%$*# "# 5$ 5#* #6

"# #%%#5

"# "+ $ (## 7$ 7#6 5$99++$ $% . $%%# 5# % #* (# ! *# #+#6 $ (

5+#

$ #* + %$& 6 $ (# 7$ 7#6 .

$%%# 5# % #* "+ (# ! # *!#6 $ (

0 $ "# (++ $% "+ %%67 $* $ "#*:+#0 "# # + 9 6 $ 9$7#0 %$* ":

"0 %$* 5 5#

$ $% "+ (

:"5"

#0 (& $% 5$&*+#0 +"

(# * $5 #6 & 9#* "#*#$%- >-

5+# $% (*#5" $% . $% "# %$*#+6 5$ 6 $ + 6 "$+# :"5" 9. (# 9 $+#6 (. 5$ 5#* #6 A& . !+ # + 6*#5 "#*# ($7# +"$: !

+&%%5#

5&+#0

#A5$9

$ 9$7# 5 5#

$ $% (

$ #*- B- *6#*#6 55$*6 !

" ! +6 "#*# ($7# +"

(# 5$ + *&#6 + #8 *#++$ $% $ $ "# 9#* + $% - 5# "# 9 5+# "+ (## 6#56#60 # 6 ! 9+5#

#$&+

$ 0 % .0 +"

+$ + 6+ 6+ $+#6 $%%- 1 , , , ,4 &!&+ > &!&+ > &!&+ > &!&+ >0 0 0 0 9"7* J"# "#* + #/ !A*#+$ #6) #+A J"# "#* *# #) #+A