Lakhwinder Singh v. The Financial Commissioner , And ORS.
! " $
'()) %* "+ ,
-)
.
/ "0 (1
.
. 2"&
(1
.
$
0 (% (/ "+ ,
4
1% % "
( % 67 " 8
"
"
9"
&)"
7 '(:"
* ;
10 ;
'(:"
* $
'()) %*0 "+ , ,
8
))&
!%% "
0
&
",
1 .
0 (&
8
)"
"
&0
0
))%
,
)
))%
& %% (&
1
7 < '(:"
*0
1 ) &)
&
0
= ;
) 4<
%
)) , ;
10 ;
%%
))&
" &"
1%%
"
1
&"
)
6 % %
0 &"
< <
1 ")%% 7 <
"0 " &
",&
8
%
3> & & &" 6) %
9"
& 8
4<;
)
1 &"
)
)"%
0 &"
" ;
10 ;
, 1
" ) " &" 6) % 1%%
, 1
% )%
%
3>
& % 1%%
))%
))%30
0 0 1
&"
) 0
< <
1 ") %% 7 <
"%
9"
8
"% &0 %" 0
4<0
" ,
)
"%
))%3 8
% , 1
%
","% &"
" %
% & 0
"%
))% < <
&"
1
0 < <
%30
%%
&
%%
&" 1%% 0 %%
&
%%
1%% 0
1
%
3> & ",&
0
))
" ,%
1 %"
&)
1
%% 6
1 ) %
, $
&
$
% , 1
))&
& ","%
))%
%3 ")
" +" & 0
, 1
+"
"%
% ,%
" 3
%
0 &)
1
%%
"0
0 "% ( 1
%%
$
% 1%
<
"%
",&
%%
7 <
))
"
4<;
)
,
0 ,3 %&
%
%
%
))
"0
)) %
4< "%
1 & 8 "
",&
0
%% 0
4<
"%
1
%
,"
))&
%
"0
&)" 1
"
%
%
"%
"
, 8 )"
)"
"
&
))&
0
))%
0
"0 9"
))
&)
1
&
-) 4<
%
)) ,
, 1
" ) " &" 1%% &"
1
&"
)
% ,%
6 % %
"%
&"
< <
1 ")%% 7 < 8
, 1
% )%
%
3
& % 6&" 1%%
)1
))%3
8
% , 1
" ", &"
:
% %
0
1
"%
< <
"0
3 &" 0 < < 0 ,
)0
$
1
%% ,
)"
1
&"
) 0 &"
< <
%% ")%% 7 < 4
6
,
3 "
& "
))%3 "0
$
" )
%
0 0
%%
8 0
))%
"
,1 "
0
0 %"
4<0
"
))%3
,
"%
))%3
&
?>,%
1 @
%
A
)
!"##$#%
%
"
( "
,1 ) " +" &
"%
?>,%
1 @
% &
))
) % 0
",&
0
))%%
%
,
%0
&"
% ,%
" 3
))
& &)
, 0
,
)
( @
%
A
)
!"%% %!&0
%
" !
7
"
# $ ! %
&
'
()
%
*
"!
+ ,, - ,../ '
# ,, , / ,../ 0
"
1
"
,2 3, ,../ & ! %
"
*
"
4 ! %5 "
%
5
'
( !!""
5
6
!
"
71
!"## $#%
8
,1
%0
"
B %
, 1
" &0
% ,%
"
& %
1%
%3 & ( %
< %
A
C0
& ?>,% ( @
1
0 , 1
0
& 0 +"
"% "
))%% , "
% 0 1
"%
))%3
,
1%% 2) 1
,1
"&
+" &0 1
$
&
%%
&" 1%% 1
%
3> &
",&
))&
" ,% 0
0
+"
"% "
"% )
&
))%3
&" "
"& %
"%
%
%
4< %
)) , %
0
+ &"
"
" &"
"
1%%
&
," "0
4< "%
1 %
))
1
%
1
))%
)3
"& 4
"
)
4<
3
%
%%
"&
, "&)
+"
(
3
0
$
)) "3
%%
))%3
)
%
1 ") % 2) 1
,1
"& 0 1% &
!""
% #$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0