High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/15728/2021allowed

Davinder Singh Chawla And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2021-04-09Mr. Justice Arun Kumar Tyagi8 pages

!"#$%"&'('#)*+,,

* -. , /

0 !"#"$"% &'" () ****

0 1 . +)'")","- ()".).)& '('./

"!'!'#)"2( 3')%"2/')455 67 )% 8 ) 2""!

0 92 )"&(# '012 () (

3"#' %4567+()8) 8/(9").(

:5442:46 " ,;#" < '"# "." #"%

."3 '3 #" '" ==>0 ( 2:4> # " 8 ",## . "' & !" # & 8 '2=)";3" #3 ;3'%2::6"

$) '7=6() +$),;) $

' 12 ( ) / " "## '9"# .".()"3 ?(#;" )")("'.&.(#.()

")" 2(# '3 #" ' 2=()";3" #3 ;3'%2::6""3

" "

$) ' 7=6 ( ) ) $ 33 ("'"#('33()",&" ((' ("#"

")'"%) $

& :5442:46 #."..& (3)",&@" ) )"&(# ) (9").()"3"#.$)"## '9"# . "

#;("

&"'' ;() % "& .);"%

# ";"")""

" "''

',)"#(( 4@ " &$("(#(.)"'(' 2' ,'"; )"& )" #" # ( ) "

#" " #" )"&.).))' " #() )",3 )")

$$.#; &

:5442:46,"')() ', ' ") $ .&); ";3()"

""',() (3) "( ,#'"( '#"3"##) "(A (

""' )(% ) 3 (( (3 3""# ##."#; " ) 3 " "## ,9 . ".()"33";,9") )))" %#" " #)",3

)") ",' $ & :5442:46"(A ;() (7: ";(3

'#"3")3 (( (3";##."#;" ) 3";, 3 ' " ( ) ,3 3"

,; #"

#() " #" " #" "#(

)#&"' %"3()' &$)")3

:5442:46(((33""###."#;" #",# ,9") $)"##,9 .".()"3 '12() %$)') & ( ( '#"3""." ",' .%"

" @

% &

$ '

()

%* %*( %+( %+, %- %.

%.% %.( %./

%.+ %., %.- %..

(** (* (%+ ((.

(/.

(+* 0

(/ -+*

$ %

$ (

$ 1 )"#93( '12() ( "'" ,#'"( '#"3"".""",' "

'#".)3" B(( 3";,33"C " @ +/ "'($""(",;) '

) )" ( $""("".") '' +

!"" # $ %&'/ +/ )3," ,() )")

"." $)3 $"" $" )"

",' )"

,''"#.)3#()" )$""("'# ,A' "." )3 $&% ) , "- & ' ) ." ,( . "

'#"3" '12+4/() +

!""# $ %&'/ +/ ) '")'#"3"""3" (','")#'"-.()

3, "( )") )"",' ''"#.)3#()") $"" ( "% &#; % , A' % "",# #.' + (

) * !

+, '-./

/&& 01

2!'--.# 3$4+

5#6'7// +&/ )9 "" #"'("

""'3, '( ) '#"3"9.') "

"') "") '( #"' ')

"3,#)"7:'#" ";(3)

" ( "' "

+ 8 8

)!'-&-#3$& 9

5 ! ""46 # 4#

//-6 +/

)) ,$"'" () '#"3"" ) '( "()".

# )" ); ";% ) "'' '" ,

" B(( " )

'#"3")", "." +

4;56!

"'%46 # 4

6'&&" +9

5 !"'/4.6 #

6%%"6 +&/ )'#"3")", )3" #" $ ' 12 +2/( )

,#'") '#"3")",( ,#'#;

3 ' ' #"' ( ) $ &##".$)'))"'' "#; D) )"3)","((A 3' ' " ()))3"

$)'))"''

"#; 3' ' #"'( ')$&##"." )"("' ;()

'#"3")","((A 3' '

"() @) )),@'#"+"/@ +'/ '12+2/+/() "'E'& " E'&%$)')3")")$#

,&"# '#"3"# "##))3 ( ,#'"" & /""

>(!'-7/ #3$'/&, )) "' ;( ) '#"3")","

"##; " "#;$ ''#".) #"'$)') ) "'' "#; &",#;%

'#"3")", $)(' )""')())' () '#"3" 3";,"((A 3' ' " () ))3"

$)'))"'' "#;

%3' ' #"'(')$ &##"." 3' ' "() @ )" ." . ,#'"3";,3"

)()' ;() '#"3"

"# ' ;$##,9 $)) '#"3""# 9 , )$ +&/ "3()&.((')",'

,;) ") "" 3 ( () '#"3" + (

'-%#3$-&%/ +&/) .) '#"3")"3"-"

"3 $. )" )

'#"3"$" #; " '( ";

" 3" '( ' 12+2/+/ ( )

')"3$.,;)

, ''#& & ' )" ) 93( '12)"&,'3 # $) " )") '#"3"$" ')

";+ (

!'-%#3$-&%/ +A/ ) ' '( ' 12+2/ ( )

() ,#'"("'#"3""." "",' "3" ";;@'3 #"' )$)'",' ""F.#";G"

) '#"3" " .

: ,9)"##; /"" 0 1

2 !

'--.#3$'7/ "

'-%%#3$/'6

4;56!"'%46

# 4

6'&&$")# ,;) )" )"""'' )# )"&"("

"%7: ";'#" ''";" ) '#"3")# , ) 3" & ,;#"$)"'"% '#"3"() $" 2::12:40(27:12:40" & 3

2=:52:40 ) $" ((

#"'(7: ";"3" '12() $".&) " ) ' ( ,#'"()

'#"3"$""#(##$ ) $")# )"& ,$.#; " (( " )3 $"9") +9

5 !

"'/4.6 # 4#

6%%")'"$""

E ,;)"# & :0:42:47("'( '#"3" ' 12() (:>:72:40, (7: ";)"

(3) "( ,#'"##:>:72:40 )" "'"$" E 47:72:40$)') ") $" "

(( $")# ,;) )") '#"3" $" "'' "'$)) ' ', '12+4/() ,;.&.3" "; (7: "; (3) "( '#"3"##) "()".

(A )'"("

""'() " )")3("' )":>:72:40) "

E )'"47:72:40(

'3 #.) (7: ";'# ," "'3 #"'( ) &( '12+4/() '' .#;%)

'#".) " (( $"" )("'() '""3#")() '"( ",&) '"& 47:52:46

'#"3" ' 12 ( ) $" ,

".") 9.) "

" ,() :54:2:46) '#"3"$" 4>:52:46) $.&";333

(); ";(34>:52:46+) "$)')) '#"3" 3 ( 47:52:46 $" / ## :5442:46 +) " (A ( ) "

""' ,( ) / " < '"# "." #"% ."3&

:54:2:46 "

E ) '" :5442:46 ( "$". )

""'() ). )""; ( ); ";)"

& :5442:46

) , " < '"# "." #"% ."3'# A )3'3 #)

( ); "; ,; 3 #; "

E. ) '" :54:2:46 :5442:46 ( "$". "

""' ( ) " $" 3" "#;9 ) '#"3""."( )( "'' "' $) ) & ( ' 12+2/ ( )

,;.&.); ";3) (3) "(

'#"3"##) "(A ()"

""' ,() )#" < '"# "." #"% ."3 ("# (##$)") $$.#;

& 3 :5442:46,"')( ) ', ' " 3 :5442:46(( (33""###."#;" #",#,9") &$()",& '%) "##$

3 :5442:46 " ,;#" < '"# "." #"% ."3'3 #"'" ==>0(2:4>#

"8 ",## ."' &!" #& 8 '2=()";3" #3 ;3'%2::6"

$) '7=6() 9") "#.$)"##'9"#

.".()"3

$&%) " ' ,( #" < '"# "." #"% ."3$) ($- " ') )"## , #",# , 3" < '"#

;1,E' (."("' ";B.#","#%(";, +,,

0 / )"#

)) "-.B"

)) ",#