Davinder Singh Chawla v. State Of Haryana And Another




    
 

 !"#$!%&'&"() *+ +

 

      
     )  ,- + .


/  
 !"#
"$"% &'" ()  ****

/  
0 - +)'")","- ()".).)&  '('./

! & &"(!12&($!1  .&(34  456 )"  (# 

  '012() ( 3"#' %4567 +()8) 8/(9").( 4::42:41 "

,;#" < '"# "." #"% ."3'3 #"'"  165=(2:4=# "8 ",## ."' & ')3 " #& 8  '471>404>402( ).",#3'%4114"

$) ' '7?6( )  +$),;) $"    '12() /" "##'9"# . ".()"3 @(#;" )")("'.&.(#.()

 ")"  2(# '3 #" ' 471>404>402().",#3'%4114" $) ' 7?6 () ) $"33 ("'"#( '33()",&" (('("#"

")'"% )    $"    &     

4::42:41

 #."..& (3)",&A" )  )"(# )  (9").()"3"#.$)"## '9"# . "

#;("

&"'' ;() %  "& .);"%

# ";"")""

" "'' 

',)"#((  4A " &$("(#(.)"'('   2'  ,'"; )"&)" #" #() " #"

" #" )"&.).))' " #() )",3 )")

$"$.#; & 

4::42:41,"')() ', ' ") $" .&); ";3()"

""',() (3)

"( ,#'"( '#"3"##) "(B ("

""' )(%)3 (((33""###."#;" ) 3 " "##,9 .".()"3 3";,9") )))" %#"  " #)",3

)") ",' $" &  4::42:41 "(B ;() (7: "; (3

,#'"() '#"3")3 (( (3";##."#;" ) 3";, 3   ' "  (  )  ,3  3"

  ,;  #"

#() " #"  " #"  "#( )#&"' %"3()'  &$)")3

  4::42:41(((33""###."#;" #",# ,9") $)"##,9 .".()"3 '12() %$)') & ( ,#'" ( '#"3""." ",' .%"

" A


  
    

          
    

    

 

                 

               

         

    

     

 



          

   


!

     "

    

 

         

           

   #
   

 

   





  

   

 

 



  

#
                  

 

  

$

#


  

        

                       

   
%  &             

     

   

          
  $ 
     '

  

  

      
() 

      $ 
         

  %* %*( %+( %+, %- %.

%.% %.( %./

%.+ %., %.- %..

(** (* (%+ ((.

(/.

(+*  0


(/ -+*    

   '

 

  

     '

  

 

   

   
/!

   $ 

%      

   $ 
(    

      $

  
1 )"#93( '12() ( "'" ,#'"( '#"3"".""",' "

'#".)3" >(( 3";,33"C "  A +/ "'($""(",;)  '

 

    

      )    )"     (   $""("".") '' + 

 

  

   !"" # $ %&'/ +/ )3," ,() )")

  "."  $)3  $""  $"   )"

",' )"

,''"#.)3#()" )$""("'# ,B' "." )3  $&%  )        ,    "- & '    )  ."  ,(  .  "

'#"3"  '12+4/()  +   

 

  !""# $ %&'/ +/ ) '")'#"3"""3" (','")#'"-.()

3, "( )")  )"",' ''"#.)3#()") $""  (  "%  &#;   %   , B' %     "",#  #.' +  (

)      *  !

+, '-./

/&&  01 

2!'--.# 3$4+

 5#6'7// +&/ )9 "" #"'("

""'3,  '( ) '#"3"9.')  "

"') "") '( #"' ')

"3,#)"7:'#" ";(3)

"  (  "'  "

      

  + 8  8

  

)!'-&-#3$& 9

+ 



    5   !  ""46  #  4# 

//-6 +/

)) ,$"'" ,#'" () '#"3"" ) '( "()".

  #  )"  );  ";%  )  "''  '"  ,

 "  >((   "  )

'#"3")", "." +     

:

4;56!

"'%46 # 4  

6'&&" +9 





5  !"'/4.6 #

4# 

6%%"6 +&/ )'#"3")", )3" #" $    '  12 +2/( )  

,#'") '#"3")",( ,#'#;

"

   3  ' '  #"'  (  )  $   &##".$)'))"'' "#; D) )"3)","((B 3' ' " ()))3"

$)'))"''

 "#; 3' ' #"'( ')$&##"." )"("' ;()

'#"3")","((B 3' '

"() A) )),A'#"+"/A +'/ '12+2/+/() "'E'& "  E'&%$)')3")")$#

,&"# ,#'"() '#"3"# "##))3 ( ,#'"" & .!!

 <  

8

=

>(!'-7/ #3$'/&+ ))  "' ;( ) '#"3")","

"##;  " "#;$ "

''#".) #"'$)') )  "''   "#;      &",#;%

'#"3")", $)('  )""')())' () '#"3" 3";,"((B  3' ' " () ))3"

$)'))"'' "#;

 %3' ' #"'(')$ &##"." 3' ' "() A )"  ." . ,#'"3";,3"

)()' ;() '#"3"

"# ' ;$##,9 $)) '#"3""# 9 , )$ "

 +&/ "3()&.((')",'

,;) ") "" 3 ( ,#'" () '#"3" +  (   

!

'-%#3$-&%/ +&/) .) '#"3")"3"-"

"3    $.         )"  )

'#"3"$" #; " '( ";

 "  3"   '(    '  12+2/+/ ( )

 ')"3$.,;) 

   ,  ''#&  & '  )"  ) 93( '12)"&,'3 # $) " )") '#"3"$" ')

";+ (   

!'-%#3$-&%/ +B/ )  '    '(   '  12+2/  (  )

() ,#'"("'#"3""." "",' "3" ";;A'3 #"' )$)'",' ""F.#";G"

   )  '#"3" " . ,9)"##; .!!  0  1

   

2 !

7 '--.#3$'7/ "  

 =

!

'-%%#3$/'6    

:

4;56!"'%46

# 4  

6'&&$")# ,;) )"  )"""'' )# )"&"("

;"

"%7: ";'#" ''";" ) '#"3")# , ) 3" & ,;#"$)"'"% '#"3"()  $" 2::12:40(27:12:40" & 3 

 2?:52:40  )    $"   (( 

#"'(7: ";"3"   '12() $".&) " ) ' ( ,#'"()

'#"3"$""#(##$ ) $")# )"& ,$.#; " (( " )3  $"9")  +9 

 

5  !

"'/4.6 # 4# 

6%%")'"$""

E ,;)"#  &  :0:42:47("'( '#"3"  ' 12() (:=:72:40, (7: ";)"

#"



(3) "( ,#'"##:=:72:40 )" "'"$" "

E 47:72:40$)') ") $" "

(( $")# ,;) )") '#"3" $" "'' "'$)) '  ',   '12+4/() ,;.&.3" "; (7: "; (3) "( ,#'"() '#"3"##) "()".

(B )'"("

""'() " )")3("' )":=:72:40) "

E )'"47:72:40( '3 #.) (7: ";'# ," "'3 #"'(

) &( '12+4/() '' .#;%) 

'#".) " (( $""  )("'() '""3#")() '"( ",&) '"&  :=4:2:46

'#"3"     '  12  (  )    $"       ,

".") 9.) "

",( )      40442:46  )  '#"3"  $"    :=442:46) $".&";333 ( ); ";(3:=442:46+) "$)')) '#"3"

3( :=4:2:46$" /##40442:46+)

"  (B  (  )  "

""'  ,(  )  /  "  < '"# "."    #"%  ."3  &       40442:46 "

E )'"(#;45422:46" )4::42:41( "$".)"

""'() ). )"";

(); ";)"

#"

 &  4::42:41

 )      ,    "  < '"# "." #"% ."3'# B )3'3 # ) (); ";,;3 #;"

E.)'"40442:46 45422:46 " )4::42:41("$"."

""'()

" $"3" "#;9 ) '#"3""." ( ,#'")("'' "'$)) &( ' 12+2/() ,;.&.); ";3) (3)

" ( ,#'"  (  )  '#"3"  ## )  "  (B  (  ) "

""' ,() )#" < '"#  "."

#"% ."3("#  (##$)") $" $.#;    &   3    

8 4::42:41,"')() ', ' " 3 

4::42:41(((33""###."#;" #",#, 9") &$()",& '%) "##$

3 4::42:41 " ,;#" < '"# "."  #"% ."3'3 #"'" 165=(2:4=#

"8 ",## ."' &')3 " # & 8  '471>404>402().",#3 '%4114"

$) ' '7?6()  9")

"#.$)"##'9"# .".()"3

$&% )    '      ,( #" < '"# "." #"% ."3$) ($- "    ')     )"##  ,  #",#    ,  3"    < '"#

 ;0,E' (."("' ";>.#","#%(";+

*+ + +

/  
/ )"#    

)) "-.>"

>

)) ",#

>