Rajeev Garg v. M/S Des Raj Ram Gopal

  

  !"#$"

%""  ""&"

 

'()*+,-*./0/+122 (3**45(67 2222*)/)/+1*6 8*6090 :0'*0(3(;5+<(= 222*0<+1-*1)

(3**45(67 2222*)/)/+1*6 8*6090 :0'*0(3(;5+<(= 222*0<+1-*1) 

">? @#A> B!

C">""

&"

%  DDDD 6*0*1) 62E193F(=/(1GE-4+.()*,+6)H*<*)/)/+1*6 62(4/1-*6F(17(6GE-4+.()*,+6)H*6*0<+1-*1)  DDDD  ">""

&"

%I!B 2 JH/0 .+;;+1 +6-*6 0H(== -/0<+0* +, )H* (K+4*;*1)/+1*- <*)/)/+10 (0 )H*L 6*=()* )+ )H* 0(;* <(6)/*0 H(4/17 (==*7()/+10 +, -/0H+1+96 +, .H*M9*02 2 JH* <6*0*1) <*)/)/+10 H(4* K**1 ,/=*- 91-*6 N*.)/+1 
622
2 ,+6 M9(0H/17 .6/;/1(= .+;<=(/1)0 K*(6/17 O+02 OE
JP (1- OE
JPP )/)=*- (0 Q:0 '*0 (3 (; 59<)( 402 (3**4 5(67R (1- ,+6 0*))/17(0/-*)H*09;;+1/17+6-*60-()*-2S2P2 2 N9../1.)=LG )H* ,(.)0 +, )H* .(0* (6* )H() )H* .+;<=(/1(1):0 '*0

    

! " # $ # %&%' (# ) *"

#  )  *"

#  +, - .#$ )(# $ /" 0 

) -)1 20 3  /" 4

0 , #$ 

#)1 ),0 ( ) $ $ ,# )2 5$ 61 6#  /,) "( () ) (" $ .# )# # ) 1  

6# 0 8 0   , #  0

#  #  "#20 

$$( "9($

 &%%& # %%'

) $%005 "0

#

$"),  , - 2  "#2% : $

"9($ (# )$#  # !) ) ()# (#

#,   

 %%'0  ));$ </""(#
$ =% : " ## $)1 

# # " (#  ""($ ;  2# (#

(# -(

!$ )"

-";0 $  #, 3(#"  4% :($0 -1" # $!)

% % 7)# "(#$ "# # $   " # $ 1 -#

#$ ( , #$ 

#) (# ) *"

#   /"

) "9($  !)

)!# #  ""(#  -1 "#20 ! "  !$ # ( ) > $ ,# )2 -( #2  $ -# )) ,#

#  " # (  ) #"



)

%%  "#2 - #,  # ""($ 0 ($0  $

$ #  #  #-% .# $ ),) 0 ) #"

$ "

#  ( ,# ?

@ABBCD??

EDFD??

GHI??

JKH??

LMFNDCOBP??

QPDGBRH??

DAF??

QMSPH??

TGCI??

UCFI?

0

 & *

''% &% V() ) ) )#"

$  ?

JKH??

WAFSH??

@XPYDZH??

TGCI??

UCFI??

GHI?

?

JD[AS\??

@GXDCXMA??

TGCI??

UCFI]?

  *

& 0 !) # 1# #  " # (# ) *"

# 
)%%
% !$

) )) ,# #,  "#2 $ """($ 0 ! " !$ $ !

-2   ,
() % #4- : *()
() $ $

 $ #  ,)(#  #



"

#  " #

   

"

 #"

$

"%&"$ &"  # 

'&( ' )#" &( %!#&"$ #"  " #!!&#& #

*

'& 

*

$ & &" # ( ' &#&&+$ #"

&"" ,  ) " ' "

$$-

# $ , & 

"

#& ( &" 

,&

%# ." /0
"

1 *& % % #   2$  "$ "#% #

% #" (#+ '  #   "

 '

"!   

#

4!"#   #

"! %!#&# ,#"  # + &&

&"'# #"  ) " &"" $ ' # #  # ,#" "

$ , & &"

' * "  !&  &" !#

 ) " & ) "& ,

&"" & &" # ( ' (#+

'  #  # &&

&" +&(  , &((  ' &#&&+  # %

 &# ( $ , & &" &%!

%&""&

 "$ #+" ' &"%&""# ' !

&&    "

 &

"&

 5 #6&#& ' %#

$ & , ,  , & 

'

 # &# *&"&"  #

"#&"  &%&# &#&&+ ! # '#

' &"  ' )

7 &"#' 0

# " 8 :;<=99 >?@ABCBDE99 BF99 GAHIDH99 FBE99 ?C@DFF?G?HCGJK99 HLG=K99 BF9 FDCM@99 ?C99 LAH99 NGGBDCL=9 O

#+  ) #, + #

"  # # %#&#& + &% ,& # #.

' !#+%  ' #+ #% ' % +  #

" '

%  '  # # ' &" # ( $ & ,   & !# $ ' #+   

&#&&+$ &"

 + #. !#&$

&

#"

' #% ' % + "#&(  

& '  # # &" &"''&&     )   # &

4

" #%

#(  !#& '

%  # # + # #(

%  %# ,&  # #.$ "

" " #

%  #* %%& # ''

 # " #$ ,& 

6&  #+ 

*&"&" '  &" 0$ !&"

,& &%!

&"%  ' P#

% , & %#+

    

!" #! "!$" %    !$ "

%& # " $"'& !" ("  )! "

 "!*$ !!"!

$! "

++ ,,+&+

-

" $"'& "

( ,    " ( . !"!

, ! #

! %"

% "   "!$" !

 !"!", !#! ) +!! "!$") !



+! /

( " ,  " "+ ! & $&

 # " $"'&

" $

 %  ( % .

%  # " , % # "

!

%& # % ( *!)!*

!$ ! !!*  "

 # " $"'& 0!"! "!

 # "

$!, # !# % ! ( "!% % " ( .

*

!* "

&  # "$"'&

&, !/ 

$ "

 #

&$" $"'& !+  % . " , % # "

!

%& # %  " , 

" $

 %  (  " "+ ! & $&

 # " $"'& !"! #!# #" $!,#"

!!$1 2,+ !1 3 " ,& ,  # "!

$! 4( " +!

(!+!5 %

+* ++ # $ (+ ( " +!

(!+!1 78796:;;<=><?6@A6>BCDE=F<?96

 G# " ,

 $%%!!*

 ##$ &

$! 

$%,  )  ,

 "

" !% " ##$

$%%!

! $"

* #



 , !(+  " $%,  # " $&$ # " (& !

# " $%, 

++

" $%, 

"

++ ( %  ( *&!+ # " ##$



"

++ ( +!

(+  ( , $

* !

 ,&!

"

$$ !*+  )! "

"!* $ ! ! "!

&( $!

"

++



 ,

 +!

(+  ,&!

"% !# " , ) "

" ##$

$%%! !"& "!

.+* "

" "

 $!



++ & !+!*$  , ) " $%%!

! #

&$" ##$ 0 )! #& " "

" 

,

 %! 

H!

$ #

$%,  ( )!

& # "!

"+!*

 ##!$ %,+% ! "


+ I) % J  I) %

#! $!

+ $ ,

!  $ ++ ( "


+ I) % " J  I) %

" $

 %  ( "

"

++  ( +!

(+ # , $&! & "!

"

, 1

 K!"

 !*

"!* $ ! !

&( $!

 " 

 ##$ & "!

L$ "

( $%%! (

$%, 

 ! , ) "

" ##$ "

( $%%! !" " $  $!) $ #

 !(& (+ 

 *+$  " ,

#

 !

$ % *

$ 

 " ##!$ # " $%, 

&$" !

$ % *

$ 

 " ##!$

"

++

+ ( %  ( *&!+ # "

##$



"

++ ( +!

(+  (

 

  !

"

#$% &'# %( "!) "

 

*+ $, + $ -$   

#!  ) + " )

.

!#/ 

- *  ,0

#   ) +0 +   

" ) +%, % 1 

) " )  .

2 34563778722 936:872 .# " ;  ) " <    +

# - $ !   ="

!  ">! = " )  -  - $

="# 

  " ">!

" ! -$ " - ?  % ;  ) " < '   !"  +

# - $

 )  + $0  .$

.

!#0 =" =" " ))  = ++  =

" )0  

-# ) "  ! ) " -!

 ) " + $% @" )) 

; 

" = ) " ">!%  # =!# ". - " ))  "!



) " < 

 

 " .

% A

#$ !  ;  "  # - $  ; 

 )  + $0

 !  "  

  = "

% @" + $

 -$     B!

 % C"

" = ) " ">!0 " " ! ) ="

"

+#

 )0

"   0

-+ " 

# ))   " +

  + ))  -$ .

 ! ) " # # )   -$ " #

# !% ; 

 +

.

 -# " +#

 !  " + $ #

= " "  =" =

" "

 

-# ) "  ! )

-!

% A

"

 ! )  .

 ! - $% =.0 "

 .

  " )  ; 0 ="

" -# "   . " " ))  = ++  = "! " ?

=#  " "   '  ## !

  . " ++

) !" )) %

  

  !"! #$!% &# & ' #$ (#  '

#) & "% &  # *)&#$  $$#&&#& ( #&)+ , , -$ & '

$& ). & )#/'!$$& '#$$&  ''! '% &# & )#/'$% # & )) '&&#$ $ # /0$

## & '%/$& # & /. )+  (    "% & )#/'$%. () #$ '

$&&#$

#& #$#

,  & . )#/'!$& (  ! ( $ & '&&#$ . "$ & &#   $&# % # & )#/'$%. ( / $ ))  "

& & )#/'$% ( $#&

 $.  $ &#

& ( & '

$)'! #$ . & )+   $ "$

($ #$ $ ))# $& ! "% &,    &&  # )#$ &#$ "#  &
#

& 

$ & /$&$"!&% #&)#/'!$&, ,     $# !#$ 1 23411 56738291 ,  :

/$& $;

<=>>?@;;

A@B@;

'

.

#  $ &  # '

& ( $ &   && !! # )#$ &#$ # #$C"!  * '

/
#

&. ( (& $ &# D  $&# % # )#/'$% (# ! " !"! # '

#) &#$

$ *)&#$  (&# & & )#/'$% "$

 $  $ )) , -& ( #"  &&. EF# /$&$$ '

#) &#$

$ *)&#$ .

 $$ # )#/'$%  $ ))   /' & . #$!% &$ )$ & #& )&  # #$ " "

& $ &

$& #$ & &# )&#$ # ) # !"!&%  & /  "$&'

!&$&'

# #$&!FG-&(

& !&  EH, I''!%$ & #)& $ # & )& )#$&

)&#$. (  # & )#$  #'$#$ && )#//#$ # #$) "% & )#/'$%  $ J'

 )#$&#$ '

)$& &# && )& & ) # !"!&% # #& ,  . & (# E (!!  & )#/'$%G '' $ $ & *)&#$ /0 & "#!

&!%

$/&0"!% )! && ($ & )#/'$% )$ " '

#) &. &$ #$!% & ' #$ /$&#$ $ & #&

  

 !

"

  # $ ##%

&  $ !'% % $ (% % (# $#)

% %%  !

# $ # $ $ '(%"  &   ( % %  $  *%  (  ") +#  #%%  % ,  *

  %!" %  ( %) -$ % 

 % *$% $ ( ( % ##*$% %) . ) +% !* #  #  % "

, * !  $    %

% $ # '%%% $ (  %

% /%  # $ 0, %% #  '(%"  % 

 '(!) -$ $  # ##% % % "   $ % $ % % $  $ % # !

  "  $

' $ %

(

 % $ (! % #)1 ) -$  !2 345672 *  % $   #8 9:;<88 =>?@A88 BCD88 E@AF8 G:H;A88 IJK88 L@HDM8

  /

, % *$$, $ ( # $ & '% # $ $
  $ % $ $ (% % ((

% %  %%  !% %  % # $ '(%", *

   % $

''%%  % (% (

%  '( % * N  $,

#  $"    $ ((

%) /'  ", %8 OPAFA:Q;@88 JA<88 R;:HA<88 BCD88 LDSD88 TU@A<;VC8 ,

.

. /

W, $ 

 * N  " !% $, % " $ ((

%X $ % '(   % 

 % $ '(%" %' " Y Z% X! /
 % !) [) * % %  

, % *$  $ # $ $N *

, $

, $ '( % *$  (  $ ##%

% /%   *$ /%  # $ 0 * % '%% #

*%$ %%8 9:UU@A8\AHA8

( ) ) %]  -$ / ('
  % $   #8 SD88 \AF;PAFA8 ^F;CP:A:88 BCD88 RD88 _P`aACM8

  /

WW $ $ $ $ ##%

% /%  Z+ 0 ( %

(#) -$ %%  (  % *$ % 

) -$ ##%

% $ /% (  # % '' % " "

   

   ! " #"$   %&!

 !&
  "!



 !" %' (

& !) &! "  *" +  !"  ",&! " ,* '+"  # %- - . %&% % !! / !  01  ! 2  

"* " # ! ! 3 456789:;33 <9=33 >=33 ?:5<76;@A:BC3

  /

 + ! ! " % + D1  #" 

,* ' #! & !&  " 

"+

,*%!  &! "  **%%  "    ,! ! #%- . **%%   "!&  

 " E!  

,* '  

    !" #% - $+ !  #" !

,  #! & "$  

,* '   !

,*%! !  *$!"  / ! +  !&
 " !  ! %! &  

,* ' % #!& " 

"-F G- 1 % #%

%"! 

 #  !" 

 ,! ! ! &  *" !   / !   + !& ! &

,* ' " 

" !" !,*!$+  %' 

 

&!"

 " # #& !  &     "  $!

!" %!#!%!'+ " !" *"% #'  "! *$!"! -  $!#%'+ 

 " !

"!  !"" #' 

,* '  !"

 + !

 * " *'

, 

,*%!  "*  + !   #"%$ !"%

,  %&% %!#!%!'- .

,*%!  " $ ! "!  %' &! "  *!! +  #! &  !""!& ' !! !

! &*!

!*%

  ,* '- H- .

"  *" 

"  IJ*" !  J*"!! %    ! #$+ !"
 !" *"  %  

,*%! " ,! ! #%-

 

  !"# !$#

"

$%&

& '"(

'$(!

 )$#)*
+,

& )*
+,, & & -,

# %

# #(($.$"&"#& &-, " "/  # &  * ! $$'$!

$0  # $"&" /

'& $   0 $0   '$'& '

# 2343516738973:;<1 =89>?1 3@A@BC1DEF1DGDE1 H ("

I  "#! J.K" #$&  L#K)$ I  ""!$" /   L#K)$