High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7318/2001dismissed

Omesh Chander Aggarwal v. State Of Punjab

2023-09-27Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari11 pages

!"!#$!% &'(

#&'&)'*!% &'(

! +( , - + . .. /

, - + .

/- "!#$% & '(!)*'+, ,''-','(!)*' ., /0 '!",( (1'# ,''-(!)*'+, 2'--+'(!)*' ., !34& )& .. /

6 ,",,' (, /0,+ / '0*-'&,,'.7'*!-. /0 ,*,&.'&!#$, !! *89.,1'#+4& )&*(6:;; /,'. . , *'--! ' , <* . 6:;;<0 '! *= , '+'! !'! >:>;6::? ! , -)' ' # =',! '! '!( , , "!,'&'!#$!,'-$ *#!

!.+$'(*,'*.,'$ !*-''(!*@;/60.,<*.6:;;< /0 !*A&'!'& # &'! , !'",&.&", /0 .&,,/*$'!(-'+'!'B*,"'!0 +,*,',** 'A '!'--,& , ! , -)' 3," *,&( , . ",,'#-' 1*2)13

1*45#&)'% ; ,''.*'!*89.,<*.6:;;< #*'&'--$ #-,!6>>;6::C'!+,'.+'3 #-,!6D>;6::C('!,'.+' #-,!.,,! &;@>;6::C 8

! 6,",7*" +*.! !*@6/60.,<*.6:;;<'*!,!)- & *,&.'' 6('6(*B<<(','B,'!*,& +'.'&!#$4& )&!*;@'!+,* ;?/;0.,<*.6:;;<,.*'!*@;/60+' !69>66::9 @ .,'*..*'/0/ '0(,'+'! #*'& '! >:>;6::?( '" , *& ' '&/0( *.,**/07" ,'*=! -'! &'2!'26&'"

&7 28!

3!1#'!% *&)'"!3 7&# 28!

9!2626&'!#:";

C /0 ,-'!*-., /0*!,' ,",&.*8?/;0.,<*.6:;;<(,'.'* .*(,* .,'!*(*'+--')'-' $

.-#1*+"(,+,' !.9>!'$.&, )*.,'.'!*+)(,#&,',#'*, ! , '#) '$ )( '&*, '( * #*&")! ,',-!**!('$#1* #*& )! #" ! -( , .*' ! *89.,<*.6:;;<+' #-,!,+ ' ,-*'-$ ,.(, *!"''"!'! )'! /0

,(*+)! , , #1* +, * , *& ' '! , .-!, -,'& /0 +)( , /0 *-'& ,' , *$ . &'B" '*=/0 . , -'! '! . , '! '*=/0'&'!(, ,$# )!!'-'), 4'",'#) -', -!*;9'!;D. ,<*.6:;;<( )+,.'7'*!,'.

! "#!

" #

/)0 , -'! *- . , ., *!,'(*,'+'!/ '0+'&'!'.&,'+ $'-' "(*,'*..*'!*@;/60. ,<*.6:;;<69>66::9(+,*,* !*9., '!*=*(6?:@/,'..,*'--!',<*. 6?:@<0( '&*, '( , ' '+'! #" *! >:>;6::?( ,#$ #'*, *'! , &'!' *-! *663.,<*.6?:@<( )+,.'7'*! ,'.('!-'-$,& "!'+'!)'!('!(, '&#=',!'!'!4 .,'#)'"&, - '1!"& '!#$,*'-!'$

% & '

( ( !' ))* +,-./0*)1 ))2+ -./32)!'! '1!"&!!#$, <#- 7( !4 6::;/0;;6@ :#&$6"6&'"

&7 .!*26&'

&7 28!

,*2 &7 ,;

* 4 +,-#

5 6 + -

+,-

2!8, :#&$6"6&'"

&7 .!*26&'

&7 28!

,*2 &7 ,;

7&! #"# # !

' # % ,,

5 1 .

5 +

- ,9:* +!: ,9:*-

" ;

8 /)0

,( , *! ,' ) . '&"-$ , -'*,! '*= *!" + -'+.-( $ , &'!'$ )('*'*;9'!*;D.,<*.6:;;< ',#*&"#'*,!('&*,'(! ,'$ ) / '0&'B"7 -'='3,"., /0($, #..,'!'$ )(',&'"3'"!( , /0 /)0 4 .,'#)*(,#&,''

)*,.,(*'-!'<A''", '&

",'!,'.1'#'!,<( !'6:D@3 3;9>(,'!*-'!,(,'.'*'*)!#$*;9. ,*(,#$'!,3+()!-$! -'*!'!., ,'' -!,4& )&#*&3,!('!(*' ,=&'3'**!!(,#$(,*,&.'&!#$, 4& )&',*'# 7*(,-'3 ,"*,&.,,'#-'.*,! -'*! ', .'&! /)0 )(,*!,',,.,' ,-!7!, -'!(# ,-'*,". '*= *!"( ,#$( , '& # 7& ! .& '*= &# 28!

#!1"&'"

2& <!

1""65'!% 8!#!6'172!# 28!

1<&$!

#16"!% *&'2!'26&'"

28!

=#62 9!2626&'

1#!

<!#!72 &7 $65&# 1'% 28!#!<> 28!> 1#!

#!?!*2!% 9 ,"!,' -'"' ! #'*,#"&'!,&'!'.,)!*/ '0(")! ,.'*&(,'! ,'!)!*/ '0*'"(''$ 1*( (,'*="',$+,+$'., &'B".,-)'!*-''(,&'B,'+'!(#+,, '!'+'!&'"3!!(,+,,'#) !. &(,#$,'+'!)'!(','"!+,*,+'' 1* D ,",,'#)'"& !#$'1!"& &'!#$,<#- 74 6::;/0;;6@(+,( ,'#7 -'!(,', ).,<*.6?:@<' '&!! !''' -*'#-, *!"!'+!,

<*.6:;;<,.(,*$.,!'+".''+'!#$ , --* **!( , +, + $' .& , !' . '*.'!*-''(&'!!*@;/60.,<*. 6:;;<('(* !*9.,<*.6?:@<(',+' =!#*& -!(,.)'-!'",'+'! ? +)( ) . '&"-$ , '+'! !-$ &'!#$!' !.+$'(*,'*.,-)' !*-''($,&'B".,'+'!(,+,&,'' ! +$'-' "*,&'B".,-)'!*-''(', !)','+'! : ,'#*&*& !,.'*&,'(* , -$('..!')(.,!,**!+ 3 66?D>36::?(+,*,,-'!

'*-#&,','! -$ '-'! !,'+ (,(&!(,' *,' )!*,&(+' '!-''-'"7 ' . -'!( +,( #*'& *-!! '- , ' . /0)(*,'#.,!'-! -$( '..!')(,'.,-'!+'' '&(.'!,' '& *!!**.--$ 66?D>36::?(#., ('! '-.-!'*)-(+,"'!7& ., -)' .-'!('!(+,'7 '1*+'! )3'3),'!'' '&',#"!3 !(.&, -'!(7* '**!'*+,-'+ 6> 4'!!(*,",'!&'!866>6::9( , '.'! 1* +' &'!

'#- =-$( *!!,'*#=-$,'!'' '&.-!', (>@666::9(+,"'!,'*=!-'!('!

(

#"&'!#$,4& )&(,-'!'-.! "''1* -'-$,-)' '*-.,-'!., '!'' '&(#*'&#1*!-'+.-'*=/0

=-$( *!! ,'* . , '#) !.&(,! !-'!&'!!-"'(,#$( *, !#*'&'!.&'&" ) ,'*=!-'! -'-$(+,,'! !(, -"'(=!#7*-!!('!A,#$(, ! **!',#*'&'#-$ *-!!(+,' !.+ $'(*,&'B".,-)'!*-''(,&'B''+'! 6; ,'#)&'!'"&#$,-'!*-., !')'-!-$&'!'"&,'#",'* +,' !.+$'('&'!'!,-)''(, ! !-'!&'!!-"'(,#$(+,,'! !-"'(,(=!#7*-!!*!!(.& , !.

+$'('&'!'!,-)''(',. &'B"''+'!(*,'*.,' !*-'' 68 =-$ , &'B" . ' '+'! +, '-$&'!'! !.+$'(*,'*., ' !*-''(,*!'#-'!A=!# *!(',-)'*& ".'*(,#$,'+'!*' #&!#)'!,'+'!*'#=',!'!'!

,(,'"&+,"'!)*.* ,',-!=' #-*'.,.*' / '0(&3-(')!''!"., -$(.,! , #$, !(,','!*+! ,-'!+'!'-#*'&)'-!-$)! '--.,&

,(,.*'/0/ '0(''!, -$(#*& !-$ #-,! , + ' <4!' 7 < '! < '''< *)-$6D>66::C(;@>66::C'!86>66::C('!(,' , * + '- , * '- *- '! !*'- ..*(. '",'&,*#'!(,#$(,, -)' &'!'$ '$ ) . , <* . 6:;;<( , #*&#'*,! 6C ,-'!*-., '-'"!,' ,+'*$&.*;D.,<*.6:;;<(&'B ).3,"., (','"". ,#..,'$ )/ '0('"!#&'!'$( ,&.*@;/60.,<*.6:;;<+)(, -'!*-.

, *'+-- ),'#) * 69 ,'#*&")!,.'*&(,', -$('..!')(,'#&!,'=' -*' +'#&!#$, ',.,.&-'.'3 ,"*,&,.(+,'=.,'! +' =!#&'!#.,',**!(+,'(,'! =#*&"&'!(,#$(, '!&! +')'#'!,'!*-'& -'-$,$' ! '"(,',+''$)-'.*;D.,<*.6:;; 6D , '"& / '0 +, "'! 7& ( .& '*=)3'3),7",'*=!-'!, '*= '- '&'#- . 1* , ' #*& *& !,.'

*&(,'.&''!".7 6A6' ' !!+,**! 366?D>36::?()'-!

,(,'--#),,'.7'*!*!',. *&&!"7& . /0 )'*' -,'--#7& ! /0 7& .#- ,'--#'--+! *!")#-+% - . -

= - )" !

"!" '*&* 6? =-$(*,7& /0+'**!'#--$ *-'<<**/0('!(+,' '-., -$( '..!')(#*&)'-!(,',,., +,*, +.!#3*-'**'!"'#-,*,&( ,,')#7& !+)(,)'*'-'!+,*,.&! ' .,*,&,'#!-$'*=! 6: ,.( '- , -)' !*-"/0( )3'3)( , -''#-**/07", -'!','+-- .!!( (,-)'*/0,(, /0'- *'B7& /0,'#) -'B ;>

,('!". ''69., ' #B(, **'')&,', ,",,''** !, *& '#,'.-!'.* !*6?. ,'*& . *& ' '! #$ , '! *= --*(','!' -*','#.-!+,, ! *#!!*

;6 ,..*.,'#)(,'(,#$, **!'!&!'** ,)'-!$.,-'*,"., '*= *!"('!,#$,$'', !.& *,'--"",)'-!$.,-'*,".,'*= *!" ;; +)(.$&., -$!'!;?>C;>66( .,!,+ #$, !(**!*' 3D>:>36::?(,$-'+.-')'-'#-$, /0 * 3,"(, ( !&'$ *! -'+.--$ *!,'!*-'& 6'13 &#%!# &7 286"

&)#2 ;8 4'.&',(,.!&,+ ( ,'&#"*& --$.)-(,=!#!&! +,*,.(,'&!&!+,*. C>(>>>A3 '*,., #.,+,! !#$,&+,, ' . , @)'?1< 1'% 1#>1'1 658 &)#2 A93&>!!"

!371#!

""&*6126&'B ;@ ,& "!.*'/0'!,*=, '+'!'&''!'!'..&! ;C *,&'*'-.,'#!*!!(,('--, !"' -*'/0(.'$('-'!/0! !.

:.. /;

:/- ;

B')", 8!28!# "9!146'5#!1"&'!% (

!"& 8!28!# #!9&#21<3!

(

!"&