M/S Sham Steel v. Employees State Insurance Corporation

   

      

 ! "#$%$&'(')*

+ (,-".,#$$/ 00$//")#  1$2(3( .0/4$$(,#"#$)(32")&$ 202"#') $(0)%$)#

 *  56   , 7 6,  2$($)#*8 2)'/,-39/":%;&"#$:2#-$"00$//")# 2,-"#'":%;&"#$:22$(0)%$)#  <-$#-$2#-$$02#$2(/&"/)$=(0"0$2."4>$"//=$%#($$ #-$?3%@.$)#A
 >$2$$22$%##-$$02#$22)#  <-$#-$2#-$?3%@.$)#(-3/%>$2$02#$%')#-$%'@$(#A 88 88 6, :

6!

-$"00$//")#-"(&-"//$)@$%#-$2%$2%"#$% 

+:

0"(($%>4#-$ .0/4$$()(32")&$ 32#: -")%'@"2-: ')(-2# 5#-$ , 32#5!:;'%$=-'&-#-$"00/'&"#')'/$%>4#-$"00$//")# 3)%$2,$&#')+#-$ .0/4$$(,#"#$)(32")&$&#: B ') (-2#  5#-$  ,  &#5!  2  C3"(-')@  #-$  '.03@)$%  2%$2  %"#$% 

:."9')@#-$02;'(')( ,&#"00/'&">/$##-$"&#24 #-$"00$//")#:="(%'(.'(($% 2'$"&#(#-$&"($"2$#-"#)


:"?')# (32;$4 ="(&)%3&#$% >4 "#$".#-$'&'"/(2$(0)%$)#8

202"#'):&)('(#')@)(32")&$)(0$&#2:6&"/ '&$

 !

8
8 ")"@$2")%")#-$2)(32")&$)(0$&#2 -$"00$//")#%'%)# 02%3&$")42$&2%>$2$#-$("'%#$".'&'"/( -$/'(# $.0/4$$(:=-=$2$02$($)##-$2$")%=$2$3)%=29')@')#-$ "&#2402$.'($()#-"#%"4:="(02$0"2$%")%'#="()#'&$%#-"#  0$2()(=$2$3)%=29')@')#-$"&#2402$.'($(#="("/( 3)%#-"##-$"&#24="(&"224')@).")3"&#32')@02&$((='#- #-$-$/00=$2")%"(#-$)3.>$2$.0/4$$(="(.2$#-") #="(-$/%#-"##-$"00$//")#8"&#24'(&;$2$%3)%$2#-$ , &# -$&-"//$)@$##-$("'%2%$2="(%'(.'(($%>4#-$ ,

32#: -")%'@"2- -";$-$"2%/$"2)$%&3)($/2#-$0"2#'$(")%-";$ "/(&"2$3//4@)$#-23@-#-$'/$ 6$"2)$%&3)($/2#-$"00$//")#-"("2@3$%#-"#')#-'( &"($:0"2$)#"@$")%"%%2$((#-($$.0/4$$(="()#@';$))2 #-$  /'(#  ="(  @#  &3)#$2('@)$%  2.  #-$  0202'$#2    #-$  '2. -$2$2$:#-$/'(#02$0"2$%>4#-$#$".'&'"/2$(0)%$)#8

202"#')&"))#>$2$/'$%30) #-"(>$$)32#-$2"2@3$%"( 0$2#-$="@$2$@'(#$2#-$"00$//")#:)/4#-2$$$.0/4$$(=$2$ =29')@')#-$"&#24 ".)#'.02$(($%='#-#-$"2@3.$)##-$/$"2)$% &3)($/2#-$"00$//")###-$#'.$?')#')(0$&#'):"00$//")# 2$3($%  #  -")%  ;$2 #-$  2$&2% # #-$ #$".   '&'"/(    #-$ 2$(0)%$)#8 202"#')     0$2()(  =$2$  3)%  02$($)#  ')  #-$ "&#2402$.'($(:=-=$2$=29')@#-$2$")%#-$'2)".$(=$2$

 !

88 )#$%%=)>4#-$#$".'&'"/(2$(0)%$)#8 202"#')-$ .$2$"&##-"##-$"00$//")#-"%)#&3)#$2('@)$%#-$/'(#%$()# .$")#-"##-$/'(#02$0"2$%>4#-$#$".'&'"/(2$(0)%$)#8

202"#')'()##23(#=2#-4-$2$="()'//8='//")%"%;$2($ .#';$)#-$0"2#2$(0)%$)#8 202"#') -$"&##-"#

0$2()(=$2$3)%=29')@')#-$"&#2402$.'($(@$(#(-= #-"#  #-$4 =$2$  #-$  $.0/4$$(    #-$  "00$//")#   #  ="(  2  #-$ "00$//")##2$>3##-$("'%02$(3.0#')#>$')@(:)"3/#&")>$ 3)%  ='#- #-$ 2%$2 %"#$%  

+:  0"(($% >4 #-$ ,  32#:

-")%'@"2- -$02$($)#"00$"/'("&&2%')@/4%'(.'(($%

6, !

 


+ (?9(