High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRWP/2317/2024allowed

Ranjit Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-04-18Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil18 pages

!""#$%&&

' ()* & + *+ ** ) ****

!" !#$

!"% &'

+,$"- #."/!01 & ()*

" , !- ". //0 ,1- 2, " % / 3 "

" #.4%#

04 5

.. ."#% & '

(/*

"!.! " . ". .. #.4%#

6 04( 7 .8*

.. ."4% &' 5. + # . ..4,1$5)9 #".#.4:3) ;< /;/).! 5 .

.! +"

# $ ." "

. # $"# /;/;

- 2 -

- ""++,! - #.=#4% &' . % &'5 # 4/;// 1 ## 5# +> /) ;) /;/& . "

= % &' "4 "

. 4 ..4 "="

(3*

? ". " 5 ..404 !".4

# #4

. ". 1! .. ".# 5 . > ! . "#. - ". ! # 5. 8##.4 > 2 ! " . @ ")A9;".# "4

(&*

? ". :

! "0 24 ")9<0 #

"4 #5%# " ! "4 :" """ .

? ". # ! " #

#.4

> .! # #." . .

- 3 - ! 5 # % & ' ."#"4 .

- ++ 1 ! #.4 7. 8 ! "0 24 ")9<0 % &' !. .

"4 #"

. ." ."

(<*

!" . ##" .% &'

- " 2!

&' #

);

;0 /;)0 .#.4%#

;9 ;3 /;)A

" .-4 #. % & '

- 5"

.4#.

% 0#.4

>3) ;< /;/) 4

.#.4"

&' .- 5"

."/;/)

(0*

1 "/;/)..)) ;3 /;/& ! - " 5"

. " % & ' ! # . 4.! !#.# & 4 2 ! "# !" % &' "4 . ('*

!" " 8 . ..4 ! .

- 4 - .." #%#

. "

./;)'"

.# % & ' "

B#.4 , # 4 .

@C<C/;/& @ ";) ;A /;/&- "4 .4. .#

;< /;/& (A*

2 ! ".. =.. ."# .!#4!.. #

% &'"

B#.4, # 4 #. " .

#.""!..4.!#4 #! % & '

B#.4 , # ;A ;) /;/& 2 , =.4 . )) ;3 /;/& #. # B#.4, # ." ." # , # !" #$ %&'' ( )( *$+ ($ #&&$ ,'-. '/ " )'

;& /;;9 .. # 4 2

, 0* 12 '& ""' ,'3 -43")/ ;/ /;/&

(9*

, .. # ,!)3 ;3 /;/& @"! .. ." # + @ " # )< ;3 /;/& 5"

# .4"4

( *

- 5 - ();*

> ! !.. # 5"

. , " " ".! #.." % &'#,. #"

( *)A ;& /;/&

())*

! .4 ". 4,

-" 1 # 2 ,

# ! #

. "! # " 5"

# "

. # . #. # !...! ! 5. # "

. "/;/3 .4 ),.

()/*

2 . ".

" ()3*

,. " "

# .!4"." # . "4 .. ! " 4 ,:"

" . .

()&*

" ! :4#4 1

"#4

.4. ." " " " ": ".# . "4#"

..."5 $!

( 0 ) '"+ 6

- 6 - "- "4"

.# "." , ."

"4 ."7. .87.. .8

7 . .8= "4 ."

#. ! ,"5 # )( ( "" , '/ 0$ '"+

. 6 ()<*

1 # .% &' "

."4# 4#4..4 2 4 " )9<0 @ " )A9; "#4 ()0*

1" " @ " " "#4

# .4

" :" "

" + " " =4 @ " :" 4 "

##4 ()'*

@ # . . 1 "

#.4 ! @ , ! .=4= ,#4".:" :4"" "

"!." 1 .4 :". "

"4 # .. # :" :4 " " :" :4" " " . "."

.". #""

- 7 - . .

1 .4

# ".". .""#.

()A*

! " :4#4

""#" "." 4#4!. !.. "! 2

, "

"4##4!- #".4"

. C . . "4 ()9*

. 2

,:# ""4 # " . ! "

" # " . 7 . .8 1"

" #

. !"..44" . .

.! . #

(/;*

"4 # , 7$ 8' '/ 9 :

-3;

. "# 4,., ".

.- "4"

# "4 . ! 4 " ". . " # " .#.4 . . "

".4

- 8 - (/)*

#.4 "" .". "..4 . 2 , ".4 #. " + " # "# #""4

. D@. "

. # "D .4.##

# "4 .

! """#" "4.4"# ## .4! !.." .. . (//*

. 4"- # "4 "

"..4" !#". . - "4 ". 4 # # !.. ""#"

. " "

. - "4 + . "

.4 "" "#.#!"" #" .

.. "". . ! #" (/3*

" 0 2 4 " )9<0 ""..4. . "

. 2 ! "## # ""#"

! . "0 )9<0 "5

- 9 - - ,"

$ '/ 1

!'<

# $

& '

& ' (

( # (/&*

: E. F " &("*#4 7 8# "0 )9<0 " " ". !G # "# . # . # ! "0 " &("* 1"..4 # ##

# 4 " (/<*

!#". &' "/;/))) ;3 /;)& !-" "

- 10 - .4 &'

!# .! "

.4 4 %# . " . /;)'

2 ! " ! "

-4 % &'"

! "4 "

#.4 #.4"

.%#"/;/3

# "

. #4: # .4 ! !# #5%#

+ "

.. . . "4 1 ! "".4 "4 " = ""#" "

" .

."# 2 . "

. 2 .4

#.4# . . . . . . # "

. .4 # + % & ' #. "

. . . ..- . " # 4. .. .- 5 - "

. "4 # .4 # 4"4##= - ! . . ..

- 11 - "..4) * 5

# ) * + $

#0"

#121# (/0*

"/& @F ")A9;."..4 .4 $

! H "

# .- . " "

# .

"=I (/'*

"4 #.- . " "

# .

- 12 - (/A*

1 ..

. "4 .4- , .

4" #4. "

." #-

. ..! - "4

.""4 B "

4 . .4 2 #

"4 .

"!."..4 (/9*

" "

"4 % &'! #-..

. 1"#4""..4" 4

#4 "

.! #!4 ! ..5 "

.F # .# (! # .. #* #. ! "4 . 1 , . ##..

.. , "

. . . . ! "4 .. :#.4! ! "# #. "

(3;*

1 "

. #.4 . ". % &' #. 5.

- 13 -

# . " " "4 #.4 ! % & ' ! #.4 # ?". % &' # ""## . 2 ! " # . ". # .!. .4 # "

. . - "

. .

? ". #4 #.4 " 0 24 ")9<0. . . 4 # , # 2 # ###

. ". . . .! "4 "

. 2 .# - "" + + ,! - " # ..-" . .4 #. & ' .. #5%# 4 #. "

%#" #. # ""

"#"4 1 .

" ..4# "

. #5%#"/;/3 .". % &' "

4 2 !"

4 "#"#.

- 14 - !.." # 8!# !% &' = . !"! .!.#+ + #

+ " # 4 .".% &' "45 .. . . " :" ".//0 ,1- 2, (3)*

'"= " (* # ,

." =#.4 " ".//0C//' ,1"4 # . . #.

4 .. . 4 4. :4 #4 ! " " !.:"."

4#4!4 . !.."! 324#5

# 6

- 15 -

20#

! #%

- 7

# (3/*

#, % ( 12> + .

3 - . . "0 24

" )9<0 " . # !" #"

""! . # " 0(*. " #

: EF .. ! # . . 1 " # .4 . . ".# "0(* )9<0 "

- 16 - (33*

= . "

. ""#"

. "

. B# . " # !"4 .". ,4 -# ##

." # .. . + " .4 " ""#" " , ! . "

0 4 .. 5 . "0 )9<0 "

(3&*

1 =4 "4 :" ". F F. .

:""

" # ""

#". . #..4 . "

. + ## " , . .

. "

. # 4 #4 .4 4 4"."#.4 - ." # !"#.. . E .F# - #.. . .# " .. 4". .. " " , "

. ""#" " "

. . "

. " ! 4 . . (3<*

. . . - 4#. !! .

- 17 - . . J!4 # . 4 ..4 - .""

. (30*

1# #. "0(* )9<0 " . #4 "

"."".# . #."

. . "

1.4:#" .."4!4.="4 ".# "4 ." " ."". ".#

. #."

. . .". ! . . ###" (3'*

"4 5"

% & ' #. " . . . . 4. " " " .

. #. #4 ! ## .! " ." .!" . "

""#" "4 # "

. .

.. (3A*

#5%#. # !4 ! .! !. B ! .

.!" ""#" "

& ' !. - " "

- 18 - .4 " & '- " .## ! #

"4 .#.4 ,=.4 .. " "4 . ! 4 % &'

(39*

1 .. 4 - " . " . "#4 "# ":" #"

.5%#

#4$.

, ?@' 9

( , ! @# #A .4.B

# (&;*

"" .4 )A ;& /;/& 8#8 +,$"- #."/!0

."/

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No