← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7369/2019dismissed

Narinder Pal Singh v. Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench And ORS

2025-08-26Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri6 pages



         

  !"#"$%&'&(   

          

   )%  *+) & , ,) ,,  *+) & ,-.,,

  !

 "# $"" %&" '$($  ) *$   %(+ "++ '$($  ) ,$ $"$-"+ %&" *  .

 "/% $" %&" *  0"1 22222  ,) ,,  /&0 +1   $    $&$"++( $" .1 .435'6!1) "78$"+9"%7"+

$"("$&$ $"("$'$"**":7"+;) 78 ,$&$ $&+"9*$ $",$+,-($ ,$$ %99" "++8 &34 $"("$ " (9(,$$&"*+-"$7** "8!&"+* $   *  !&9!+-  $" 7 &+ "$"   ,$

&"($"&"+*"& ,$&$&"($9 /& .

"&+"

"(7$"+**$ 79 $"$&"3< 3==3,"*$9(*$

!.!

+" &"(8 *  ,$ $ 9"+   "  (% $ 9 +8*$

8(,$%&&"7$7* ,(% $($"*$&*$$"("$9"

%$ %99" "++8 &34 $"("$ % "3?

.44.("$ $+78$ " !

&9!+-  "&+79$" &+"9($7*"* ("$&"*+-" $"9, 7(6*$"7-,$ "$

"

"&$$7"+*$("*7**$ "8*

"8!&"+78"($9"997*$&"*+-"*$ *

  ,"  9(    $  "  &"  *  +-  7  $  $"("$ 9""&"78$"4? .435'6 !0)$"&$9(9(- +"&*$&"* ,$ $"*$+-"$("+"

+&"*+78$ ," 9%".1 .435'6!1)(%(+78 &$"++($"4?

"&+*$ 79$"& "++$ A &,"&9 +A"$9(*$ ,$ $"*+- $"9&+$"%7"&"$* $

"78$7"+".1 .4357""$ 7 """ "*$&"*+-*"++"  *9$ "$/$ ,$*$ 9$&" "&+"

"(*$ 79$"

!0!

$($$ ,"(""$

7$"9,"%9" "*$&"*+-"$+ (%($%&,%"9"&+$ $&"*+-""8(% *9"- (%,$ &+"*&"(%78$$"("$9"4? $ ,"9(*$&"* ,$$"*+- $&+"97( "78$ $"$7"7"" "*&"* +-&&   "&+79$"$7"+ "$ "*"

&"($"("%$+78$"&"$

"((%"("$"4? $&""%"+$

 "987&$98$"7"%"+78$ $& $ &+"9*$ $"$$+7"" "* $&"*+- 9"87&+ >$"%$"+"&+*$ ""$"%( $($$&*$&",$$"7+""& < $&+"9*$ $"$ ,"9( ,$$"*+-7" $+*$$"("$9"

"3= .443'6!0) $+%" "*$"+"  !

B

%"+$78&%8&+",$ $   "9  *  +  $"("$ 9"("($ *$%+" " "$%+"!&9!+-" !&9!

+-   ,%  $  "9  ,++  $"%    7  +8 & "$&9+"**++,(

!1!

$ &7 & C$"&9"87"- "&&(+8 @ 7" "+*$"7%,+$,$"$ ,"("" !&9!+-7$"9,"%9" "* $&"*+-*,$&$&,"(%$"9$ +"7+8 "&&&"$"%"*, $+(%( $%&$"%%"9"&+$ $ &"*+-""$"$ "9($&" *+-"(%$7**$ "8* "8!&"+$ 78"($9"" "*$&"*+-*9$"8$,""

 "" ++$%&+""9 $&+"9*$ $" ("*$ $"* "9"9(&& $9(&"+8"- +"& $ "99*$+"789("*$  ?

C$ $+"3= .443$"7&+"*78$ $"("$  9"    4?

 ,$  $  $"("$ 9"$""+"$"$9(9(*$

,$$"*+-"$"9,%9("$ +,%"9  & $A*9(*$ *

!&9!+-"7$"$"(&$"++(" $$"*$ 9"($78$ $""&& $ "9 C$  $    ,$&$  "  7(  +  78  $  +" &+*$ 

$"$,""9(*$&"*

!<!

,$$"*+-"$"9&"79(&& *9( $+$"%7"9,$&$,"9" $* &$,"9( $A*9(" = C$ %*"9*$"-*"(9$"$

,"9(,$$"*+- $8&"+8(% *9$"$ ,"9(,$$&"*+-

&"&+"98%""7%$+-,$""+"8 ,-($"&" $&+"9*$ $"$$"7(% 8%$"++&"* *9$"$,"

" &"7"&& $"%""(*$+-

,$""+"8,-($"&" # (%,$"+8$"$ $""+"8 "7%8""("$" *9$ ,$&$ $&,-(++9","%9" "*$&"* +- (9"*"8*&78$A"$

"78$7"+".1 .435'6!1) $ , 9"&&(+8 0 ,) ,,1   0-.,,

1 232# /(    >$$ "-(E" F >$$ "7+ 

!@!