Harsh Chopra v. State Of Punjab And Another
!
"
#$ %
!"#$ %&'()$%$' " *%
& '()(!( *+%,- "
( '( !
.+%%/(((+
#$( '( ()( /+%,- " %
(0( %$' " *% % +,
$ "
/% % !-
230 ( 4
."5
." (67% %2(8(0793 %!-
27:+2;3 +.
% / -!
+*/+ - / % %//
$5
-%
.
"* "-** <
= 0>(
5
?. .
%$4-*/
%
(0 %
,
.
-** -% ( ?,+ ?
,
"- $/+"
//4
,%
/*
4/,%
% +? -
"* -** (
*+
,@
?"
$44
-
-%
.? /%$ "
/=- % $ "-" +
5
%// $5
-%
.
"**4$ 5 %
"#
-(
, %%% %8(2(0700% - %
$" //5'.
A 4'.
"-%
*
+-
%%$" //5'.
A '.
?/% - %
( - *+ / % '+ //
% %97(6(0700 (B
/
=%
.
/ *
" -*/
!
, + -- %A
-%% 9;(2(0700/ .?
*
"! # -%% 06(2(0700(
*
+/ %'+ // -/ %%
,
%
-** ,/
/4 -- %
- %
A-- % , $ %-/% -/ *% "" %
-( C %!
- /
-
"*!* @C/ $*
/ ? -- %
-+?,+ %
/-- %!*!
.= % % -
5 *$$ %( ,%/ %- /"
+ % -%
$4/ %'+ // ( $ /"
4, 230( ((? /% ? . *4*@ -%+*4$ -4 .
,""- 4% % % ,
$ " - " 4 ?
- %"#
-(!-
D07(
5 //4/,
"- %
+? -- $ -% "
-*
." "" - % /%( )
, ? """ -//.%/4-**
% "- $
,* -$/4
/% % +
"- *
/-
? /%$"
/=- ( E$/ ! *
*$"-
-/ %
.
B.S.Joshi and others ,State of Haryana -.+ '/0+1/+ 2"//?%$4
// --"3/,4-+'5.- .+6 '7/89-.+: ,%/
?
,/,%
- %
/% /?( "
+ E$/! *
Gian Singh ;State of Punjab and another '/0+1/+ " %/
?
/ /?
/%$4 ! * "5
.
"
State of Haryana ;Bhajan Lal:
'/00 '
(
:9" # %.*
% %&
!
"
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ , #
- +
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
( $
(-(
.0
1
(
.
(- *
(
2 ( 3
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
4 /4
/?
/%$4 E$/! *
/ "# %.*
. +
?
,
%
-** + -
-%
.? /%$ */4 $ "-" %$4//?
. %--
4"
$45
? /%$-
%"
#
-+? - * /4 $#- /.
/ -
% !-
230( / + "
% -
%5 /4"// ?
*$
%*
/%$4# % - /-%
% -+
(67% %2(8(0793 %!-
27:+2;3 +.
%
/ - !
+ */+ - / % % // $5
-%
.
"*5 %5
"
-** (
%$ %5 -- %!* !
.( %/ 4
//*
$ %$4 *
-** *
-%%$" -
$/?(
%//?%( %$' " *% %&<$
/ -@4 B @
.A %& A B $/& A