← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/6962/2026dismissed

Union Of India v. No87982 Ex Ag Era 4 Navy Joginder Paul Handa

2026-03-09Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi,Mr. Justice Vikas Suri7 pages



      

!"

#!"

$ %"

"!%!

!"



         

#

$ %&

'%!

!"



   #$%#$

# !

$ %& # %!

!"



    &% # '$ 

 (   )*(  + +( ++  )*(  +,-++



() $ * '+**,, -#  * .& .- /

0&1 )22)324   5#,*+*-#  * .& .- /

0&1 )336)3240 ,7, & $ #,8,*+%,*9-#  * .& .- /

0&1 )3:;)324  <<<<<  +( ++  ./ *0   :

=> ,"

-?

!! "! /*/ ,

?



&1 )22)32-&1 )336)32*"&1 )3:;)32

 04 8>*A++"

*  B.B " ?

 *+

1 , A /.

* "A ./ !* *"/ *9 / AB  A -/*A * 7 *9 /+&1 )22)32



 !

- A,*..

7  +!7 ""

"*

"3 3:

3;0 C ):4!* "8> )+ "A %8*.-  7*.  = A,-  &,*"7*,  0, */

   /  "    * D%8*.E4-8>?,A,- :,*8

*..?

/ B*."!

/+ "*> "*

/"A,*7 /+ BA 

: 3 ::/./



* "  A .  /   !

  8+    A

:""  +++:3> */ BA -?,A,* A" !  /7* - /B*."

A." ,*B

7*

 - %8*.,* ?7.> 7*

/./ + * */B*."!

/+: 3 ::

/./

A - 7* *.7? ,./ + * *  :B"

+!7 ""

"*

"3 3:

3;0 C ):4 A

;

* "A ./

/ !.*A  .*A !

 A "*

":2 3 33 A

" ,7,  F / :3> * BA /7* ,*8

" *?*>? ,-8

*" A * 8 +*"

*!!.A*8.

.>!!

B .>-, A -

 ? -A  :

 "/+ BA *.+ /B

A*"

! *A /*" A -, ?." 

 0;4 

,*B , *".

* "A ./

 *",*B

7 ,7, A* /.

? ,,*8.

* *A

%, / 7 B*A ?,A,,*8

* "8>.

* "A /  !

    *    A,*..

7  7*  /  B*."  !

    +++ BA " F "/:3> *,*

 "8> :- ,*..8  A *!

 

"!A!.

/.*?

 E8.

#! & /"*

 



"*    



  !"

A"

""



/*//A B*."

" / BA ! A+!.

/:3 > */ BA -, G,  .. "/ 7*  %,

B* !**7*!,/ *"5"7+ * *"

()  

            !

  "# $ %!

&' "  (                 )    ' 

 '

$ %  *+  

!+&'

   ,        - !   

. %   + $* 

#% $/ 0 # 2#3#

 # 1  **    %  +*   &   !*+ * 

 + !!*  +  *   

    %       $ /  #

"  (  - !  

       $  

 0 *  #% $ / 0 # 1 # 1   ** 

!   

+  + !  !+$*!

+  *  !

 !

+ %

    *  



$ &       - !   

 $ !   

+  +!  !+$*!

+  *  !     !* %  . + %      

+   !

+      %

      *   



$ '  4 

  - ! 

'     5 !  + ***  !  

+  ** !  

** ! - ! 

  

 +!   +- ! 6

   

 !    %

   *  6    ' $ % '    



!+&)  4* ' 

        - !   

   %  



$*   !* %  . + %          

 

+   ! *        + *       !!      %  !! 

$    !        !

  4   

! !! 

**! !

5!!  7$ +

** ! !"8 ,  !

!   %  *    2#3#

 $ $

 064     $ . $  $   !

  +     +  9  :!

!

 %;" 3# 3# 1'<=>

  ""# 

$ %!&' #

     $ $ !      $%     $   &'%()  $ (  ) *  '+'%"     +'% !,  %% -**%$-%$      )  %    $$ ' (- %(  % (!'+'%

/  $$ )%(! %   0  %'    ) %'  !2$ 

  -$%!  '-3$       '      '

'* *    4 '    %52(  '

'* *   ! %% -  *(-%      .

      2  

'+'% /   +'% !,   - $ *%)&'%()  $ (

6 ?

 %*     

$

$ !

 $



. +  

$  %  +* 

!

 

       

$$   **   %  " ,  *      *   . +    

 *   !"8

A -  *  !

   

"  !A!.

 /  .*?  

"   "0"

,!

@ A* 0!*4- ?

.. *8., /B*."

*"+8.

! A+!.

/:3> */F*./>7 BA

& F .>- A

*

 **.

"

/ %8*.7* 7 /*B/

 024 :"

B"/+  *"A*  *



%,  F   /   *!!.A*8. >  /    A   "*

:2 3 33-?,A,,*B

+*"

!

* B /+3

3:

3:-,*8

* "8 / ,&  %, *" ,**. *">8

A"

&"*

= A,/ ,&  &1 

/3;"

A"

" 3 3:

36 "     7

*8'   9*"  A +!   A  B*."!

 ?..8 7B .> //A -?,* B*."*

" */

3:,* *. *">8



*"

 * "A ./

,*

*8.

 8 *"/*A *.!  A -  A +!

B*."!

?..8 7*

".> //A B*."*

"*/

3:,* *. *">8



*"

- 7* /8 /*B/  8>

%8*.!

/ .>B*."*".

7*.*" 7 B*A * " ! ?

8>

,**. *">8



&"*

= A,?,.

!*7 "

"*

"3 3:

36&1 

/3;

"*    7

*8'  9

 -  "!

A*  A "*

:2 3 33* +*"

*!!.A*8.

-

  A*A ? ,  A  %,* 7- *7+ *

 A "*

":2 3 33,*B

+*"

*!!.A*8.



!

B .> A*  8  *AA

"    B ?  /   /*A   *"  AA+ *A   + 8 /



* "A ./

,*

*8.

"!

 04

*"!! /.*?,*B78



 E8.

#!

& /"*

  A* 0!*4

:3

'

!7B ? /*A *"AA+ *A / ! A*

*?

..*

"!A!.

/.*?

"

  A* 0!*4-

/+: 3 ::7*

 :8>

%8*.*.7? ,8 /./ + * *-*AA"*A .*?

*",*8

7, .>7*

"9

!7B ? /*A *"AA+ *A /

! A*

:

 *7+ ,*8

* :;

7"+*"

 /*>

/ A 8> ,& 

"

 "*

"3 3:

3;0 C ):4 &1 )22)32H "

 "*

3 : 3;0 C ):4&1 )336)32H*""

"*

"3;

3 3;

0 C ):4&1 )3:;)32!* %8*.

%, ! ?

* "+ "*AA"7.>

:

, A!>/ ,"

8 !.*A " /.

/A

A* / +( ++0  /,-++

0 (12

.!

!"

  1,

!

*97G *

1,

 ! *8.