← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1789/2019dismissed

Ashok @ Babbu v. Bahadurgarh Agro Industries Pvt Ltd And Others

2023-09-27Mr. Justice Namit Kumar25 pages





     

     

       

 

!!  # 

 $ $ %" &'("  "   )  "     

 " *  +,- .

/  / "  *

.

$$ /  /  )  "0  *!

1 - /  /  )  "0      %"

"      ) ""      !

  )

   !+  " )   -)$$  "        

     !+  "

 " 

2"".$ /3$ -/4 !+ " 

 5 

  " ) $-  

"/  !

- 

 "

" " /

/

!



 " !+" $

) " " "  6 

"

"   7 " 8 " 

) "  ) ""  " )  "0   $ %" &'("

 " )   !+4 + ) ) -      "

 "  "       +    "  ) - "8"  $ " "  )  "0  "  &



 "  

"'  " $

""

  9 

/ 4 4   

 !+ "  "

  " 

8$- "  



 

 )  "0 

 $ "" 

"   

) ) - 

$

"" 

 9 

4 )  4"  " " "

""  :

"







 

 ) "

") ) "+  )" !

 

  " 4" "4 - "/

$4"



!

" !

"+" $ "" 

:

"

" $ "$ ""  8$- "  

 

/

"0 /

+/0 1$;



 

   

  5"   

"/   $  "  ) )  " )"" 

+

+4  + ) -  )  "!+" 

"0 6

/"

/ )  "0  " 

"  5 



 " ) $"  "  +

"6 

" 4  "

"

!+"

" )  "0  0 1$;

!+

$ 

 ) + 

+"  "  - !+

 " 

2"".$ /3$ -/   

!+  $"

4$ $          

             

   

    

           

 

          

 

 

   

     

         

    

  

              



  

 



! "

#$%$  

  

                



 

 

     



   

 

 

      & 

  

      

                          

   &

 

 

      '!   (

 

   

  

 

     

 

           

   

          )      

  

           

 

      (    "     *   (

 

                    

      +   ,  -

(. +



/ 0  "  1     2

3         



 

 

      

                

  (         

 

            

        (                                   0

   / 4 5 0   64$ % 2,

3             

 4  

     +      

   

  

                   

             

        



 

         

 0

   , (

  0

          ,(           



 

  

      

            0 

    

( 

 +           

           

   0 

  

(            

    

  

 ,   

  

  

  

      #    (

     

 

             

 &                   

      

  & 

 +        7  



     

    &    

  

   



4  

   

  

 



       

    +           

    ! "

 #$%$/  

 

    

       0



                  



   



    

        

            

    

 

<

9 $$ $ ""     

/" )  )

 " "

"  ) ""  < (

    

  "  )       "

  "

" $  "

"   $   )  "  0   "      "

" 

 5 

 4  "

+" ) +" ) ) "   "

" 

"

"0 0  1$ " +4  "! " 

:    "

/ 4 / 4" ) 

+"  ) ) "   "

4"

0 &

""

'= " !-"" " )  "0 

   !8 " " " "  " ) "   

"  !

 "

  "  !8 "  "   $ 

) ) "   "

= " !-"" "8$- "  

 

/4 !+" ) ) -   $

" 1

 9 

4



   )  "0 /

+ 

$ !

"))

 "/" / "  7 "  +) " 8$- "!

$

"

$

  

$ !8 "  5 9

  "  ""  :

 ) 4  5 9

 = " !-"" ""   -- "

" )  "0  " " ) "  " 

"" $" )

 8$- "  



+! !

" "

 "/" /" 7 "  -"

"   "

 " ) "  "  "



+!

:

!+"

"/" / 7 "  +$  "  "

" 

$  8$- "  

  " 



) )   5 

 & ' " ) " / " /  "  -)$         

  -$  "

"  " ) " " "

+    )   " +

4%)) "  "

" /  )

 ) " 8$- " = >!

1)  ". +

5 8

 5  ( ##95",

 $

 ##:;,,68,,

8 5 ()<'5"2,$3 )9 " ",  -

= ,6 4 %( ##293%>"

: / 0""4(

##)2 3"$"2$3<)   =

 !-"" ")   5 

  +

4"

"  " 4"

     " /  1  

 .

$$ / 

    

)  "  0      !-""

  " "  " "  

  !+  " )     " ) "     ) "   "  " ) "    ) -""

 5 

4

")

"

4" 4  )  " + " ) "  

 !

!+ )  "0  ?

"0   +  "

"  "

+ "  4"

 !

 " )$"

/" / 7 "  " ) "   " ) "   7 +/ " "  " ) " ) "  "- !

=

" !-""

" ""  ))  " ))

 "!+

$ "  " ) " !+-"

"$"

" )  "  " ) " " !

"

" ""



   )"

!

"4

" 

" 

" 4

 "0 

4

!+"

$4" "

" $ "

"0  ? )  "0  4 -

""

" " ) ) "

!   " !

 @4

>  

4

 " +"

 !

"

!+

0  0  1$;

 " "  ! "

 4  !

$ 

! " 



%%

$

 ) =1   "/  <    !    



 !"

"      @4

>  4

:

"

6 /"   )"

!

"4

" -= " !-""

" " "

"

/"

" !-""

" "   )"

!

"4

" 

"  ) "

"

!

"

 "" "

!+)

? )  0   /  " / 

 4  

   +  !+   )  0  ?

"0   ""  4

"" "   -- 

"+ "

" )"

  !

"4

"  ) "

      "  "

"   "

"    ) & )  "0  " '" "

+

"/" / 7 " 

" ) $" ) ")  

""

  = " !-""

" " 

  !

$ " "

" 

!

 " " )  ) ""  " 4+/

" $) & $ )  0  " '  "

"

"  "  

 " )  /!

$ 8$- "/" +  "  " 

 5 9

   

 !

)

 !+" / 4   "!

" ) 

"



= " !-""

" " ) "+"

) -  )  "+ "  $"" -

!- " )) "

 ))  -)$ 8$- "? 

 5 9

  " $



/ 4    $"" 

$

  

"



 

$" "  " ) "     " 

  $

     

/  4    "  !

) -""

"""

$ "     "" 

 "   !8 "  = " !-""

" " 5 9 

9/)  "

"

!

"

" $   "

)

 +

+ " "

) $/      

/  "   

!



"/44

  "  4  "

= " !-""

" ""   -"+" "  ) "  ) ""  " "  " ) " 4

 "

 "4  " $ !+

"0  "   )) "

!+

"  " ) "  ) ""  !

)

 !+  +    

"0 <" "/

+/    A  !!        

$  " ) "   )  "?

"0  "   % 



  

" "

)  "     %" ) " / 



/ " - " 4  "  )  "0   "

 "4  "

"

8   "  ) 

$  !

+   "   :

  6

/  



9 9

/

4$  4 )  !+"   

" "  

   

         

  

 



   

    

  ) 

$ " " - ""

/" "

-"

)) ) " $  "

") "

$"  $!

" +  7 " ) ) 8 "  ) "    5   ;

 "  $

"" 



9 

4"

  $ %" (-"

 ) "

 "

44

""

" -

"- "

""



 <!+" = + 3  - "  $"   $

3

+4 /4  "

"

" +

 %" +

/" 

!

!8 "- ""

7" ) 

$ "

!+" = + 3  - " ! 7 ""

4

6 - ""

4 

 )" = >!

1)  " 

!+" 1"

3  - "4

+- " +

<%" -

4

/ )  "0 $ ")!

 " )!

 " "  4) ) "   4" 4

! "

$

     ;

 " "- ""

- +!

 "

"

!

1)  " 

$

 ) -"  $) " $

"" 

%"

-

 )!

   " /   )  "  0  0    1$  ))    " 2 "  

%"+ "

" " " 

$



 ;



  -""

"

$ 

-

"0 " !



$

   ;

0 

- +



4 " 4 $ !+" 

"0  "  ) " 

 ? )   )!

 " " + ) " "- B 

"0  " /

$4" )  0 /  " ) -" ) " $

"" 1

"

" $

"" 1



 "" /)

" " 



  

"0 0  1$)

 "

 $

"4 - ) -  )  " 4  !



"  5 

 4

4" ) + " " )  -  

"C"

+/" "

"

" 

"" "

+ 

"$" 

 "  "    /  1$ 4$-

" 

$

  " "  / " 

"/ " !

 B

  

/ "

" "" + ?

 " ") ) "+   "

 -- / /"  

  " 4+" ) ") " 

"4   ")

 "

/!

" )   

" " +  "  " 



$$" 8$- "  

  

1 +

  "  " 

  !8 "   )"  " "

/" +  "

!

-""

" !

" )   

"0 

  !

$ " " "  "   ) ""  "  4 "

 " + ")

4 ") " -"

  1 + "

"

!

$) -  )  "/ " +"

 $"" 

$ $   !+" "

 ") 

8$- "  

 9 

)  !+ "  "

  .$ &. 2 '/3$ -/"



=    " 0 1$  " &

1" 0 ?

' 

  

"  4"   7

 

) - "  8" /  4    

 " "  "  "  4  

  !+ =       "   & 

"'  $ "  0   1$ ;

  " 4 =   

""

" " ) ) "

!   " !

 @4

>  

4

"

- 

"0 ?0 1$;

4 " " "

! "

 4 !

$

! " 

 @4

>4

:

"

6  8$- "  

 9 

"

"

!

$!

 " )"

4 ) $!

"4

" 

"  D "

!+

"?

"0 " ""     )"

!

"4

" )

  "  

"   "/   )  "  0  ?

0 ?

" ? " 

"

 ) 4""

"

"!

"

 "" "

!+)

? )  0  

") " "

 )     



 

 

  



          



  

 

                    

  

 

  ! "# 

  

 

   $      

"  )  4""

  "

" 

  !+  

0  "    %&&&&&&&&&&&&     

  " 

   

' ( 

 

"    

     

 





       





' (     &)

  



   *  "+

  

   

     """"""""""""

 6 / "

 /

4

!+ )  0  ?

"0  /" /" 4  7 "  8 $ "  "   

"   

"    "

 )

   !+  "

" "  " -- 

"+ "

"6 $ "  + !

 " )

 !+" " ) "  + "

"  " "

"0 ?

" $""  8    "  "    )  "     

"  "

   ) -

)  "" "

+

  9 B " "  -- 

"+ "

"  "/" !

 -" ) "

"4  "

" ""       "

"  #      )

$   ) "+    "  !

!"""

!+"  "  "

"$) "+ !+"  " 4 " !

)

  +" !

"

"   " " 4 " "  -- 

"+  "/ "

!+  "

" ""     "

"/" "

"

" !

/   "!

!"""

!+"    + " ) "+"   

+ $ " "

"

" )

$ 

    "

4$-)

- "?" ) "  " +" "

"

"

"

"6 ) "   "!

-""

"    

!

/  :)

    -""

  -    

4  2

"  

$ 



 "4  )" 

4))

  !

 5 9





     4          "     - "

+   !

 4 )   "  )     "   

"  " 

  

  +/

4"

 " " 4  



/

" 

"4 ))  " 

 !8 "  5 9 

"" /4"  - "  -"  )"  "

  !+  "  "   ) "+  (-"

"      - "     !

:"

  + ))

 "

- "  )) )  5 9

 -""

+/! ""    "!

 

  8"

" "

6 = >!

1)  "  ?

4 @   >    5  6 4   ( ##3:,$$)  

" "

4  ")  ) --

 - 0 )   !

" "

!

" " 4 4 $ < % $- "   )"

/  -

" " 

  !

+

  !8 "  5 9 

 !

+   - "")

" 

+ "

   !+" ))

 "  !8 " - )

 

/

4""  ""

"+E"   "

" ) "  " " 

"-

  )  !+" ))

 "4  "!

  ""

) " 

4   

       

                 

     

      !  "       

 

  #   $     

9

$  $  %     

    

  

 

           &   

   '

   !    $     

  ( )  $    

$         $ #   $       $ *    

       #

 +  , , -    

    .        

        

                  

$!

             $    



    

    



     

 



 / # $   

  

       

                           

                 

   

    0 # !                 

           

<

.        '   

          (  '        

$!           1 .  

   $   $$ $ 

   

     

     )          .       $ $                  2            !       $  

!   

     $ 3

        

              

    

 

      

    

     



     

 



  

 

    



   

      !     

   

  



"#$%&&

 '



'

( 

 = >!

 1)   "   ,

  8  =  .  ##'5",

$



#< 0 F/ 

  # !           !   !$  %&

'

 ( 

 )*



!   "     

    +   +

    !  

  !

   

'

 , 

 )- ./                    

     ) 

  !

     -      !

      - ./ 

      

     !

 

     0 

      !                   ! 

            0    +    



  ! -!1!

 * (* 2 00

 / 3  

/         !

   

 

    !

   !

  !

   !

   !    !  

'

 , 

 )- +

     !    -!   ! 

*   "   

  !

    

          

   !

           + 

        

    :

:

:

:

4 

   

 

   

* (2 00

 / 3   /

 !  

 

    0                  + 

           !       ./     

        





  !



 ! 

   

        0#

%" /"/!



4



$4"5 9

$"

"

 " !8 "  " "  ) "

  !

 -""

"   / 

  !

 $" "

+    "$ "$

4 "  ( 4"

 " "

"+ 4

B  "

  !8 " 

5 9

" 4 " " $  !"" $

4  " "" "

!"""

 -    4

? !8 " 4   !

/  " 

 $

1  ))



!

!" " -"

  $

1  ))

  "!

4

? !8 " 4 - " +!""  ) 8 4

!



!

    

"     "

 -

 !-   "  )) "   ))  -)$   

 " -  +-)$ 8$- " 5 9

!"4"  " "

 "

 $

1  ))

 :

"

+

"  "4

4)

+) !" 

 "

  5 9



  

%

 $

 5

+5

$

 

     4  



          4        7 ( 

&  $

    

   

  &  

         

     (  

    

      





0 B (        

     

 (&       

(

 

  

   CD B%  5

$

 4 



  <5( 

    0

 $

   



             5   

   E F(          EE(

( 5 F

 +

$

   

 E



  FA 4  

 44 .5.    

                     $+  

       $ 6 !             #       

         $ 

     # !           !        )

 .   $           $    $

6  # 2 "      $" 

 

$   

    6    $ #  $   $  2    

    "   $   

       $ 6 "

!   )  ** 

      

 

     "

  



)   

    

  7 #        2     $( 

!     2   

            . * 

!

    2       $       *  

!     2           $  $    

        

 %"

"$ +/)

" )  

5 9 

  6

" )  

"" ""

" "   4   -""

" 

? !8 " /

1)    " 4

"  + -  !+   "

+ 

$  "     " ) "   "  !

 "

 

"" 

"" ) !

-"

" 1)     +

+ 5 9

/4 )  4   "

/ -

!- " )) "  ))  

))

 "

 ) 4 " )  + 

 

+   " !

  "

"    !+ ) "+   "!

-""

" -

 " $   4

!

/"

" 

/ :)

8"

 - " 

=  +)

  !

"   !



 " $ "

4

 "

) + "

 "

)  

4"

") -)$    6 /"  ) 8   " ) "

/

!

+

-""$" 

" "

 /!" - 4

 ") -"" -" 

 $

1  ))



 5 9

9

 "

 "

"  )  4  -"" 

5 9

9

   #! 9"

9* 





 

  !



   

   

     $5       

    

                

     

     



   

 

 





 

       

    )  / 

      

 

 

 

   !

#

 ) )   5 9

9/4 " 

 !+" "

 " -    

"  )

$ 

 -- " 

/ +  )

 

"- +

 "- +   +"  



 



" )

44

  "  4 >")

&" $



  ") "  7 "   +) "+'C  :

-)

/ /  &)

'

" $ "2 G

/"4 -  $$ !+" $ "

 "/

/ "

 "*;    +" 8$- " "

 "

 

 /  

 = >!

1)  "6 " ( ## "$"2$3 9' 

 



# )   

        !     "    



6

      1





     1     !    -         !   ,              

!!

   !

   -      "     

         



       



 1   !      

  "     !

      !        

  !

             7



                  !

   

    ! 

     



    



          

    



      

      

 

     

1  



   



     

   

 "  !  



 !1  !   87  5  

           

     

     

    1       

     

 + !

       !  

 -  !   !



!  

  

                       +   +    

    

  

1!  

        "    - 

         

 - 

! 

  

 9   

 !

        

   !

  / 6       !

  6

  

     !

   

!   !   

  !



    

7 7 

        

  1 $ !  

   

   

         



    

  !    

          - 

   !       +     

1!  

   "     

 



 2 00

2 (    

      

 !

   

       

    

 +   !

     :   

   1  $ !      





 -/ ; 

 

  

   #  6

8$- " !

 !+= H!

1)  "> -5 #:2 3,$$:<  ) )   5 

/4 " )

4" 4"  + 

"4 "" !

" )  &" 

-

)

'02  +!"

7 " " !

  $ " " 

"/" "  " ) " - +!



"- +!

" ) 



)

" "C  :

-)

/

" $ " / 2/

   -  "- /    4 "  "  4" 4    "/  "   

 

" "  "" " )  - )

4

 $"

" "  " "   4 " " 

"& "'

 +!"

7 " " !

  $ " + "  $

"" "  %" ) " /

"  "

+

"  4"

 !

))

 " )$"

/" / 7 "  " ) "    6  "

"  !+"

  

" 4" $ " " !

"+ )   5 

" " "  +

 4

+"

!



"  " " 

) 

$ " " !  + ) )  6 

4" " " /" !



" "" ))

 "

 5 GG%%%

 5 

 -" +" " ) 

$

4

&1

#$  % &'

( )**+, $ ./'   

8$- "

) !+" . +

G &) '

+

"" " "  " ) "    )) "

  !+  "

"    "  4      " +  )

  +/ -"

" 4  "

5 9

  /"  " "    "

  " ) "6 +/.$- " 6 = "  &) '4 !

 

!+= H!

1)  "/  "  ! $"" "  "  "C " +/"

"   0 9/""

" ""

 !+2

1"

I4  "

  " 

"  -)

8 "    "  7 "    /  "   "     ) -""

" ) " /4

" ) " /- - 

$

" "

+ " +"

 ! "" "

 $ "" 

 "  "$ "$ - $"

 " C " +/! " " "

   4

  4" )  4"3  -

" "+ "4 -

+ "



 !8 " 44  $""

!



" $! " -  3  - "/!"

"2 ) "- "/ 

 $!

!+  3  - ) "- "4 ) -""

" !

" )  

   " ) "- "  3  - "4 ""    ( "

+/%-) "  5 9



4  "    4 )  !

 " 9 C" /  "  8$- "    "   ,    -

 2

3 

) !+

  

" 

  "

!

" "

" ) " C"

+/" .$- "" 6 &) '4  "  " 1   +/(

!   ) +

10  9

4

     9

&  "  0    .$- "'/" - ""

4  !

  / " (

"  " ) " % 0   .$- "/"- "  " ""  )  "   "! $""

"  "  " + " +

46/"  .$-  " !$) " "  )  ") "

+ " "

"

<

  +/ 0 /"- "  !+"  "" ""   !

$) 

)$ 4

  )  " 10  9

) -""$("  "

" - "!

 "!

4 " /  "  -)

+

"    /" ) "  ) -""

" 

" "    < 1-

+/8$- ""  / 0"2

3

  " !

" "

" -"

 "   %   4   " $ $   - !  / "  " " " 

  

8"  "



 """  % /" ) "  ) - %"

-  



  9 9

/)  !+" "/"

 1

4

  



-  +



) /" /" ))

 "  "

" -

+

 "  

:) "  +!+  "$ "$  + 4  8 - " ,  .

 

   1 B " )

$?

   ;

?0 B "  ) "

!

 ;

?0