High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21374/2015allowed

Sanjeev Kumar Bhatia And ANR. v. State Of Punjab

2016-02-27Mr. Justice Krishna Murari5 pages

! !"#$#%& !'()(*+ , -%.!!/0)1(2 #%3%( 4 ! # #%!($ 5$ - ! )%.' 4 !$6%3!% & 78 --

(!$!% & (5#$29-2(1+3/" !

( 2!6! # #%!($ $0 2:9++ )%.' (-5!(1+3/" ! ( 2!"169#%%

! # #%!($ -%.!!/ 0)1( 2 # %3 0(#$2% 0)1( 2 # 2/! #9!3 2!6(!$!% 6! # #% (6(!((!$ '#9#% 3 !3 !'()(* + )%3!( -!" #%$ + (!;#$ !(!3 9#"! - #% # ;(+ 8)32#% #% "$! (!;#$ !(!3 2! #%$ %"! $6#%3!( -#%;2 99!;#%; 2 1!$20)1(5!(1:23!9$#%6(6!( *')$#%!$$%3#$ <%:% 269 -#%;2 66("2!3 2! "169#%% ( $9! 2#$ 9%3 1!$)(#%; <%9$1(9$ #;(+8)32#%%3269-#%;2

6(3)"!3(!/!%)!(!"(3 2!$#39%3"9#1#%; 2 2!2$$ ()"<3!9 2!9%3:# 20(#$2%0)1(2 # 2!( ! $

=6!($>*(3$ %3:)93!% !(#% ;(!!1!% $9! $#39%3:# 2!!6<0)1( :$ 93 2 6(#"! 2! 9%3 :$ 9#<!9* '! #%"(!$!3 #% ) )(! % ("2 + +%;(!!1!% $9!:$!?!") !3'*269-#%;2:# 2 0(#$2% 0)1( 2 # ;(!!#%; $!99 2! 9%3 !!6< 0)1( %3 !!6<0)1(%3269-#%;2!?!") !3%;(!!1!% $9!#% /)( "169#%% 2 2!;(!!1!% $ $9!:!(!:(# !%% 2!$1!3*+ 2!$1! #1! (%$6( ;(+!2$#9$ +#$ (#" 8)32#%0(#$2% 0)1(2 #$ ()"<3!9(!;(3#%; 2!9%3 2!( ! $

=6!($> *(3$ :# 2 !!6< 0)1( %3 !!6< 0)1( $ ()"< 2! 3!9 :# 2 "169#%% ($9! 2!9%3 2!( ! $

=6!($>*(3$$)1 $, 9"$:$99!;!39*6#3 0(#$2%0)1(2 #'*;#%; 2#$ 2)$!#%"$2"2!>)! $@9"$:$9$#$$)!3#% 2!%1! 0(#$2% 0)1( 2 # 2! "$2 1)% %3 "2!>)! 23 '!!% 2%3!3 /!( 0(#$2%0)1(2 #+269-#%;2%3!!6<0)1(2!99!; #% 2! "169#%% #$ 2 :2!% 1!$)(!1!% 2!9%3 :$)%3!( <!%+ # (%$6#(!3 2 2! 6(6!( * '!9%;!3 $1! 2!( 6!($% %3 2! 9%3 :2#"2 :$ $93 '* 0(#$2% 0)1( 2 # !99 )%3!( 2! $ (!! $ 2! "169#%% "% " !3 0(#$2% 0)1( 2 #+ !!6< 0)1(+ 269 -#%;2 %3 6(6!( * 3!9!( ($2% -#%;2 : ') 2!* /#3!3 2! "169#%% 2! 99!; #% ;#%$ 0(#$2% 0)1( 2 # %3 269 -#%;2#$ 2 2!*2/!#99!;99*)$!3 2!6:!( (%!* 9(!3*3!3

6!69! '!

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

'(#" #%; 2! ;(!!1!% $9! 3 !3 ("2 + %3 % 2!( ;(!!1!% $9!3 !3("2+ :# 2(!;(3 2!9%31!$)(#%; <%9$ 1(9$ $# ) !3 #% 5#99;! 196)( :%+ !2$#9 %3 #$ (#" 8)32#% :$ "9#1!3 2 % 2! '$#$ (;!3 %3 '(#" !3 ;(!!1!% $9!3 !3* + #% /)( 5#%30)1((!;(3#%; <%9$1(9$ 9%3+!!6<0)1(%3 2!($ (#!3 ;(' 2! 9%3 ! # #%!($"9#1!3 2 2!* 2/! #9!3 6(#/ ! "169#% ;#%$ !!6<0)1(%3 2!($ (2/#%; '(#" !3 2!;(!!1!% $9!3 !3 ("2 + +("2+ %3* + #% 2!*!( 2! 3! #9$ 2! (!$)9 2! "(#1#%9 "169#%% 2$ % '!!% #9!3 ') :# 2 2! $$#$ %"! ")%$!9 ( 2! 6! # #%!($ %3 2!

"169#%% 2/! "(!

)99* ;%! 2();2 2! !% #(! 69#"! #9!+ $!!% 2! 3")1!% $ %3 2! $ !1!% $ 2! :# %!$$!$ %3 2! "$)9 (!6( 6(!6(!3 '* 2! #%/!$ #; #%; ;!%"* (!;(3#%; 2! ")96'#9# * 2! 6! # #%!($2!!% #(!(!"(33!$% #%3#" ! 2! (%$ !( " )9$)1

$, 9"$ 2!6! # #%!($ :#99'!3!' '9!#$$)!3)(#%; 2!")($! (#9 :2! 2!( 2! ;(!!1!% $9! (!9#!3 )6% '* 2! "169#%% :$ " )99*!?!") !3 ("%$#3!( #%2!"")((!%"!#$ 2!*!( % 2!'$#$ 2!"")((!%"! ("2 + 2! :$(!;#$ !(!3%

!'()(* + '* 293#%; % #%>)#(* :# 2) 2!(! '!#%; %* ";!% !/#3!%"!(!;(3#%;(!"!#6 1)% '* 2!6! # #%!($2!6! # #%!($( 2!"169#%% $!!1 2/!% <!%%*$ !6$3)(#%; 2!9$ $#?*!($

(!% ("!1!% 2!#(9!;9(#;2 ""()#%; (1 2!;(!!1!% $ $9! 2! 1$ + 2!9#'#9# *+ # %*+ :#99 '!"1'#% #% "#/#9 %3 "(#1#%9 % )(!$ !6$2/#%;'!!% <!%'* 2!"169#%% #993 ! $!!< 2! (!

)%3 2!1%!*( !$ '9#$2 2!6*1!% 1%!* 2!6! # #%!($A 6! # #%!($ 2/#%; .#%!3 #%/!$ #; #%+ # 3!$ % 66!( '! "$! ")$ 3#9 #% !((; #% $ 2! 6($!") #% 2$ !$ '9#$2 2! "$! % 2! '$#$ 2!3")1!% $:2#"22/!9(!3*'!!%6(3)"!3'! (! 2!69#"! %/#!: 2!'/!+ 2!6! # #%#$99:!3%3# #$(3!(!3 2 #%"$! ((!$ 2!6! # #%!($ 2!*:#99'!(!9!$!3%'#9 2! $ #$ " #% 2!((!$ #%;

#"!($)'.!" 2!"%3# #%$ 2 2!*:#99 .#%#%/!$ #; #%$%3:2!%(!>)#(!3'* 2!69#"!%3 2 2!*:#99% 16!(:# 2 2!!/#3!%"!(216!( 2!#%/!$ #; #%#%%*1%%!(

2#%;$#3#% 2#$(3!(:#996(!.)3#"! 2! 2!(9!;9(#;2 $ 2!6( #!$+#%""(3%"!:# 29:

9#"! #9!(! )(%!3

!'()(*+ , B-C $%.*