← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/24187/2013allowed

Rishi Raj Gangotra & ORS v. State Of Punjab & ANR

2015-01-29Mr. Justice Satpal7 pages

   

 !

"#$# %#&# ##   

 !

"#$# %#&# ##   

 !

"#$# %#&# ##   

 !

"#$# %#&# ## # % # # % # # % # # % #







 '() ,( !

-.

/01 2,(,0 !1*)(3#* 2!

% -.

'() ,((* ,'0!

-.

/01 2,(,0 !1*)(3#* 2!

% -. %(,0 %0  *4 %(,0 %0  *4 %(,0 %0  *4 %(,0 %0  *4 5  5  5  5   #4

6$72"

272# 77  #4

6$72"

272# 77  #4

6$72"

272# 77  #4

6$72"

272# 77 !00*,4 !2'008(9#:;

(,0(*:

<2%(:=(9#:;

(,09 ,'0>0,, *0 !2 0=(9%# 9!1*)(3 "2$'(,,9#:;

(,09 0>

 72# 779" 72# 779" 72# 779" 72# 779"- (.

   

 '( 300*0:

1*:020 ,   ,'0 :0 8*( ! 0:10  ?1('*+ ,'0 

:(,0: 1*:020 , *

9 5#9!0+,00:(,!

 02,(, *(8(3(:9 %, ,  #8,(  (*:  (  ,'0  *0?10*,(  > 00:*+ (*+  ,'00 89  *  ;0=    ,'0  8> 80  :(,0:

   -#**0@10  ! .  0*,00:  *,  30,=00*  ,'0 *0(*:0>

 '(300*0:3A '() ,((*:'(*:0(*' ,( 0,,*+ (:0  :0  :(,0:    :0 (*+  ,'08   ,  30 > (80: 0*:09 *,0*:*+,, 300+((> >0 > 0:10 0*;(+0: 1*:0 20 , * 9 ! '( * 300*  =0:,138,,0:,'(,,'0(:>0,, *0=00 * 0=B0((*:* , *A(,,'0,80 (0+0:> (8(, * 31,( (,,'0,80 0+,(,   ,138,,0:,'(,,'08(,,0'(:300*>( 0: 30 0,'00:(, *(*: * (, *0*,0 ,' 1, (*:,'0:>1,0'(300*0,,0:(8 (3A'0,08(*:

*:, *    0,,080*,  =00  0:1 0:  *,  =,*+  *  -#**0@10! .,=((+00:,'(,>0,, *1*:0 20 , *$ *:1((+0# ,= 1:300:*,'0

1,    8>0,0*,  )1: , *  (,  #8,(  (*:  /(:0;

,(= 1:+*,'0>0,, *30'( >0,, *0

 30*+,'0 0*0(!

=0#,, *0A'

:0,=(( (+00:

30,=00*,'0>(,0,'(,>0,, *0:3A0>

 2'('$((1*:0,'0! ,0 , C 80* 8% 80, / 0* 0# , = 1:30=,':(=*3A'0 2'('  $((  = 1:   '(;0  * 3)0 , *  ,  ,'0 ?1('*+    ,'0   

    :(,0:     2'0  = 1:

>0(,0     '(;*+  ,'0  (:    (*:  (*A  > 00:*+ (*+,'00 89?1('0:2'0= 1:0 :'0,(,080*, ,'00 ,90(*(:(;, +0,,*+,'0 ?1('0: 2'0= 1:'(;0* 3)0 , *, ,'0?1('*+ ,'  (+(*,(,'0( 10:>0 *#, ,(18 D 99E =(  ,  30  '(*:0:  ;0  ,  0> *:0*, 

 *  ;( 1 *,(80*,('(300*:0,(0:*,'00,,080*, ,138,,0:,'(,,'0(:0,,080*,(;0:(, '(1,8(,0A300*( ,0:1> *3A,'0>(,0,'

1+'(, *0 ,(+0 !

 =(0:(+(*,0> *:0*,

='0*'0,0:, 3( F 1, 8,'00,,080*, *

 (>0,, *1*:020 , *$ *:1((+0 # ,9  59  '(  300*  ( =0:  (*:  8((+0  30,=00* *0 

  '  ()  ,(  (*:  0> *:0*, 

2'('$(('(300*: ;0:3A81,1( *0*,>11(*,  ,'0  (3 ;0  80*, *0:  0,,080*,  "1:+80*,  :(,0:

 '(300*>( 0: *0 :(#**0@10! ,1,'0* 80:,'(,,'0>0,, *1*:0,'0 ! ,0 , C 80* 8% 80, / 0* 0# , '(

* 0300*=,':(=*3A0>

 *,0  (8 1*,    D 99E  ,(*:  >(:  ,

0> *:0*, 

 28,  2'('  $((  2'0  '(   0:  '0 (:(;,  :(,0:    (8*+  ,'0  ( ,18   0,,080*,:(,0: ,(;00:*,'0(:(;, ,'(,'0'(* 3)0 , *, ?1('*+ ,'0(: ?1(( ,'0  ( 10:  >0 *  *  ,08    0,,080*,  :(,0:

  70(*0: 1*0 ,'02,(,0='0(8*+,'0 ( ,18    0,,080*,  30,=00*  ,'0  >(,0  138,  ,'(, *0 

  (*:   '(;0  300*  :0 (0:  > (80:

0*:0(*:,'>0,, *'(300*0: *,'030'( ,' 1+'!

=0 #,, *0A'

:0 70(*0:  1*0     ,'0  >0,, *0  00  ,

:0  * $(32*+'

$(32*+'

$(32*+'

$(32*+' /01 2,(,0 !1*)(3(*:(* ,'09 2,(,0 !1*)(3(*:(* ,'09 2,(,0 !1*)(3(*:(* ,'09 2,(,0 !1*)(3(*:(* ,'09

-.-.  (*:<1=(*,2*+'

<1=(*,2*+'

<1=(*,2*+'

<1=(*,2*+'/012,(,0  2,(,0  2,(,0  2,(,0  !1*)(3(*:(* ,'09 !1*)(3(*:(* ,'09 !1*)(3(*:(* ,'09 !1*)(3(*:(* ,'09 -.-. , 138,,'(, ,'0  (:  >0,, *0  30*+  > (80:  0*:0  =  *

80*,'0=(A ?1('*+,'0(:  $0,'(,(,8(A9,(>>(0*,,'(,,'08(,,09 =' '  (0   8  8(,8 *(  : :  '(  300*  *(A 0,,0:  *  (*  (8 (30  8(**0  30,=00*  ,'0  >(,0 !0,, *0

(*:0>

'(;0300*+(*,0:,'0

 :0 00    :;

 0  '0  0*,0  (8 1*,    D   (   :10 =(:0>

*,08 ,'00,,080*,30,=00* ,'08,(*:>(:, '0'00,,080*,30,=00*,'0>(,0  3; 1A+0*1*09(;0:(,;

1*,(A(*::1A( ,0:

1> * !0,, *0

(*: * 



 '(;00>((,0A '(0*+0:  :0:(,0: 

>(0:  3A  ,'0  0(*0:  ,(  1,  ='003A  ,'0A  =00 :0 (0:> (80: 0*:0;:08*( 

  ,,'0>0   (0,'(,,'0> ; * (= 8(*:(,0:  1*:0  20 , *    !  '(;0  300*  ; (,0:

*(81 '(,(8(,,0 0 :,'(,,'0(:>0,, *0 =00* 0=B0((*:* , *A(,,'0,80 > (8(, * 1*:020 , * !31,( (,,'0,80 0+,(, *

,'0 '00 09,' :0*(*A (00+((*:

(30, 300,(:0 ** 8(  18,(* 09,' 1,= 1:0(*  8?1('*+,'0 *0>0 ,, (>0 *:0 (0:(( > (80: 0*:031, F00>*+*;0=,'00*,0( ,(*:  18,(* 0 ,'0 (09,'0( ,18 >0,, *0

 (*:   30*+  :0 (0:  > (80:  0*:0  *  ,'  (09 = 1:* , 80*=(A ?1('*+ ,'0 (+(*,,'0 *0  '0  8(,,0  =' '  (0   8  8(,8 *(

 : :9'(300*(8 (3A0,,0:30,=00*,'0>(,0'0 '(* 0 *; , ,'0( 10: (00*:00:, ,(A 30(F*,' (0 *,*1(* 0 ,'0> 00:*+*,' (0=30(*0@0 0*1,,A(*:'( *A0(:, ,'0 =(,(+0 ,80 1, '0>(,0=(*,, 31A,'0 '(, '0,(*:0*:(?10,1, ,'010*1 ',1(, *, = 1:30*,'0*,00, )1, 0, ?1(','0(:  (,'0  ,'(*  30  *,(*0:  3A  1 '  *:0(, * 1,'08 09,(*(:8,,0:> , *,'(,,'0>0,, *0 '() ,((*:'(*:0(*' ,(=00*

0=B0((*: 0;0*(,,'0,80 0+,(, ,'0  :(,0:      '00  =(  *  >13 (, *  *  0= B0((*:  * <1=*:02*+'(*: ,'0;01 2,(,0  <1=*:02*+'(*: ,'0;01 2,(,0  <1=*:02*+'(*: ,'0;01 2,(,0  <1=*:02*+'(*: ,'0;01 2,(,0  !1*)(3 (*:(* ,'0 !1*)(3 (*:(* ,'0 !1*)(3 (*:(* ,'0 !1*)(3 (*:(* ,'09 -. 9(;080830 $0* ' ,' 1,'( 30;0:9 G'0 8> 809*(8 :0* 0,A9 ,'0  *0  ?1(  * *    '(8 *A  (*:  :0A 30'(; 1 ,,'0 1 )1, 0(*:,'0 > =0  1*:0  20 , *     ,'0   :0   8*(! 0:1010:, 0*'(* 01 '(

8> 80  =' '9  *  ,1*9  0*'(* 0   ,'0  ((8,A(*:0:1 0 , *9,'0*,,1A 9G*0,'

1 )1, 0H '1 *,*1(* 0 ,'0 :(,0:  (*:(*A

 1,'0 > 00:*+   (*+  ,'00 8  9  * ,'0  ( ,  (*:

 18,(* 0     ,'0  (0  =  * ,  0;0  (*A  101 >1> 0'(* 0 *; , ,'0( 10:(030(F  <00>*+  *  ;0=  ,'0  (3 ;09   

  :(,0:  

1*:0  20 , *  9  5#9    !  0+,00:  (,  !

 0 2,(, *(8(3(:9%, ,#8,((=0( *0?10*,( > 00:*+  (*+  ,'00 8  (0  '003A  ?1('0:  *0?10*,A9 :0:(,0:  ( 0,(:0 !0,, *(09( :*+A9( =0:

5 

5 

5 

5  -72# 77.

-72# 77.

-72# 77.

-72# 77.

#*

> "

%  "

%  "

%  "

%