High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/21448/2014allowed

Bhushan Singh Rana v. Punjab Pollution Control Board

2015-04-06Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal18 pages

#$ %% !%! !

!"#

"$ ! ! &'

!()*(

! &! !) "!+()*(

!!& !, '

+!- &())-( #$ ....

"$% / & $ % !

! 0 1 +&% $! 2 3 4 5)6 ! 7 ++ !! 4

5)6 ! 7%%1 %&!! ! !+ & % !+% +&% &!- !$! ( ! &% %(

$8!!8 &% %( !

% +&% !

! 2

! 9

:! 5 !* !%

%% 7)( 4;

5 ! !< :!)=7 ! *% &!*!+ ( :!) +&%%% +!8 &! &% %$ +&%

#$ %% !%!&! % ! ! 93 %% 9+&%3!& +&% %% %%9%%&!( ( (

2( 4

#$%& '

( )( *

( + ) (

)( *

( + ) "

,. /

$ #+ "

- . ( '

0 0 '

* ( #+ "

,$!

' '

(

'0 '

,$ $1 #+ )

)

$-$-1 $%2-111 " / 3 3!

-*-2) "

#$%&) 0 (' 4 $$1&-111) )

'0 +56+(#7/

8 # #+

' #+ 9 0 )( ) ) :( # + ) 9 ;#

( )( ) )+ '0.$1&-111

)( ) )'0.$1&-111

) )'0.$1&-111

58'0 .$1&-111

( () 0 4 < $-1

-21&-111 " / 33! $- #+ 0) (

( ( $$1&-111# #+ ) ( 0 (' 4 -.1-11$) )

'0 +6 +(# 7/

8 ++ # "

7( # + 7/

8 # + 6+(

' ) ) )

( + )

('0 ) (( =

' )(

=) #

0' (0

' # 0 >)

( ( 4 ) '0.11-11$

) ( (0

' ( ) )

( ( ) (+

( () )

# + 4 < $$1-11$

" / 33&! $. #+ ) '0 8 4 1$12-11$ " / 33 ! 7/

8 +6+()

) 0 5 ) /

) ) + = )

: ) ? (0 ( @ ' = )

( '

' 4 7/

8 # #+ 0 ( (

(( + $% # + )

)

.$.2 -&-1$- " / 3 3$! "

#$%&)

0 (' ' + 0 4 1 12-1$$) )

'0++? #7/

8 # #+ >)

( (;

' ' () 75 ( ( )( +! ( ( ) ) (* 0 ( '0) ) '

!> # + 9 @ ( ) ) (*) # 4 (

( ( "

#$%&

( ( 12-1$$) 0 4 < .- $12-1$$ " / 33$! -1 #+ )

( '0 4 $2$$-1$$ ( ( )( )

) #'

)

#$%&)

# + , &$ %$--1$$ " / 33$2! ( ) 0

(' ' + 04

+( 5# 7/

8 # # + 7/

' ;

' .2/ ( ) ' ( (

+ + 0 + ) ( 4 $11/ ) (

.1 . 6 ' B

+C ,$D +C ,- D 0

0 ' '0 ) 9 # '

( +" + '0

) 0A >& ! !+&%(?@ !

$&!!4 ( ++ &!

! !

! 2

:!) ! +&% $ % $8& $%!* !

% 8( ! !!! &!%+!8*9&9 !+$!0 &+! (9 %$ !8 *%

4 :!) !"#$$%&'%()*+#,% &-%& %./ -%& (

' '0 0 # =

;

' ' ( 0

' ' '

(

(0;

(

= ' 0 ) ) 9) ( /

(

!0'#+&12/&'%#$#$$%&'%( $!, 9 (: 0 "

/ '033

!4 0

' '0E

'!0 ) (

/0 0 #

# ( 9 # 4

# ( F

(

0 0

' "

-! '

$!# 4 # '0

# 9 '

;

4 0

9 0

#( '

.!,) (0(

#$%&.G# -$%&! ' ) 0HF

(

0 ( G

()0 /

()

0 ' "

4;! 9 %%$ *$! +! ( &!*$!&! !

! 03.

4 5

$! 0 ) ) F

( ( ' '

'0)

0 ( ' '0) ( (

(

0# 9 (:

/ )

! ) 0 #

0 ' # )

( 0 # )

B# E

'! ) 0 #

0 ' # )

( 0 # )

+ # + ;

)

( ) '0

( )

$! .2 ) + #

'!)0 /

A + A

( # /

A A)

-!, 9 (: 0 ( ' '00 ' " J

B) ( (

(

0# / )

.! + 0#'0 #

-! 0

(0 ' J

( ) ' 0 ' #) 00' (#

)0 /

A A

( # /

A+ A)

."!,) (0(

.!# 9 (: 0 # ( ' '00 ' J

( ) ' + ) ( (

(

( )

$! .2 )

# / )

.4!,) (0( 0 0 )# '0

'0 + 0

(: 9 '0

( ( -1 0"

(

#$%%$ () 0

( )

" !

#$%%$#

#) ( '

( )

$! .2 ) + # ' '

9 (:

! + #

0' #0 '0)# ) #

) #

( # ( ' '

# 0 0 ' ) ' I A! % ! &!* +%8!

&!& $%!* %%

*$ ++ ! & $% 8( ! +!8 !1 !+!+ 4;! A! %!%

&&'( ) ' *'" '+,,- ./0 .

1023- !!$8 !$ +!%$! 4

/5+,+ +,/,% "

% "% 6)'

% 781

71% *'

% %1 A! % ! &!%! !!

:!) &!$B6 *

!( &% %( !

%%9 DE &!+D( 9 %% $ + $ %8

1 C ! (%! % ! !& $+

:!) $&!* &% ( ! ! 4;! !F!

:!)( &% %!%809

9++9 09%

0 %&!*++

A! % ! !&!% & 9 88 $

*'( &"

+,,:.50( & ;-A! %*9 4 :!)!

!%%9($ ! &! &!* +!++

(9 !(!+

:!)( !9 >*9 :!)( &!* ) **!!

*! !+% ! ! ! !(!+ 4;!

! @! %%(>9 %%0%9 *!++ +&%% * %G9 ! &!$ +*! %8%$% ! + &! &% %H>&! +&%(+&% %% 2- !$! ( !( &% %( !

&! ! ! !&$% ! 88$ &% %( !

/ &! &% % 9 &% ! 22 44 9 &! 9 8+ ! !99!6&! > &! +&%( +&% %% &&! 8 &!% !$ ! !+ !9 ! &% %(9 9$8#

(B6 *C

!( &% %( !

& ! 9 4 +%!%8 !&&! 8 &!% !!$8 +&%9$8 !# (B6 *C

! / ++() &%B!( !

; ) ! !# ( B6 *C

!9** &9!%8 &!

/ !+% 9! % 6 & &!* !

!+ 99!& +8+ !

>&! +&%( +&%

! !

%% !B6 *C

! &% %(

9! * &&! &!% ! $8 !+ ! 4 44;

! / +&% 9 ; + !9$8

'- %(B6 *C

!( &% %( !

>&! +&%( + &!%

!$ ! +$! !!8 9

*$$8 &! > % ! &% +&%( !9 !&!$+*! %8 %$% ! &! &% %(9 9 $ !&! $8

! &! !0 B6 *

! & 9 ! &! $ !+ !&$%&! !+

! &% % 88$H )&!

:!)!1 ! !

++ $8 &!+ -*!+( E &!+ %%$+$

%8 / ! ! 9 6& ! E &!+ &%

9 ++ 9 09%! 6! %&!*++

@!%8( &! %% ! DE &!+D ! +&% *!! +&%& %%8 &! E &!+ !&$% !88++ &% % >!! *! %$%8(+&% *!& %%8 &! +9

++9!&$% ! 88$ &% %!!

!&!!& * +&%*+

!B6 *C

!+ C%8!%*!+ $+&! +&% 2 ! !&$% ! $ &% %88$ / *!+( * + +&% ! +!( $ + +& $% &$% ! + + 9 +8 % % &! %*!$ ! !&$% ! $ +&8 !%* + ! !( +0 &! !%9 %$$ &! %9

+&%8$8$B6 *C

! &% %(!1 !+

4 :!) !

:! ) %8 +0 &!++ %8 / !& !&$% &!%0 &!9 $ !!&$% !

++5

! % !7 / ! !(!%$%81 &!$ !

+0$% !!8+ +&% &! ! !&$% ! $ &% % 9 & 8 8 +!9 ! !% &!+ ! / 9 !!&! &%

(&%%89 ! !*! %$%8> *9 *!++ +&%% (&!$

%$ E &!+! &8B6 *

!9 %+0 +*! %$% !8

%8( &% &!$& $%!* ! !(&!!+ 4;! !+ $$% &!6&! %!%89 :!

)&% 9 G

$ 0 ! 4 :!)%8 +&%+ $8 !!$8 !G

!!$88 !&! ! !/ !+

) E &!+ %%$+ $ %8

$8 98 %% / ! ! 9 !

9++9 09% E &!+! 6! ! %&!*++

/ % $9 !

4 :!)9%$! 9

7'.'

0 ! % &!* :!)

* *!!

*! &!* !+% ! ! ! !( 4; ! ! &!6 > * ! ! $+ $

+&% 1 %0 +!% *!+!!!*! %$%8 &! &!

! $ &% $ E &!+!1 ! !

:!) /

! &!!& *%*

! B6 * C

!( 9 !& ! 9 > $ !*!+ 6 DE &!+D( *! %$%8$ & &! B* ! 0 *! %$%8 &! 6 $ !!&$%&! !8 8 $ &% %(& *!+! !1 ! $ + +&% 9 +! &! !&$% ! &! %!

! &% % & *!+!!1 !$+9 & % $ ! !&$%8$8 &! %+&! +&%& +&% 8 +! > *9 !( !% +&% *!8! (+0 !$$% ! !+6+

I &&%( +0 ! $1 &! %% !

$ %%8 / !*!8 *I* &&%$%8

4;! 9 $&&! % &%

4 :!)E &!+ %%$+$ %8

:!)$898 %% %8 9 ( $&! &!*

9 ++9 09%! 6! !

;

%&!* ++

)$!!

:!) & &!* > !% %9( $ ! %98 &! &!* +!++

/ !&&!$! %$9

4 :!)

&!* :!) * *!!

!+ :!)(9 !( &!*

! %%

8&%!%%%9 $ 8& &!* !!8 / # + !% &$8%! % ! &! /5+,+

+,/, %0$ 8 !6/ *! !!*!8 >*9 &&! %$9 !

4 :!)( :!) $&% *!!

*! !+% ! ! *9 :! ) / ! !(*9 $ ( 4;!

&%$ + %%8( % ( &&%$%8 4;! !1 ! &!* -*!+ $ ! &! & $%!*!+

:!)! / ! !( !&!&% &!$ E &!+(!%$%8!+

:!)$&&%/ &%%9 +&% $! 2 34 5)6 ! 7J ++

!! 4 5)6 ! 7 %% $1 &!! ! !+!1 . "$0 !=$

8 1-%+,/3