Roshan Lal v. State Of Haryana And Others

-1-

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH 118/1 Date of Decision:- 22.11.2024 


....Appellant(s)

Versus

STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS

...Respondent(s)

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE 
 

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJIV BERRY Present :

Ms. Anu Chatrath, Senior Advocate with Mr. Nikhil Singh, Mr. Ratik Kapur and Mr. Shourya Mehra, Advocates for the appellant. Mr. Vivek Chauhan, Additional A.G. Haryana.

Mr. Gagneshwar Walia, Advocate for respondent No.4-Subhash Chand.

***** 
 

. J. (Oral) 



 






!"


#
"
 





  !


%
 
& 


 



 ' (


"

%
#


%
 


# 
*
'



!

'
* +, -.

,

%
 
/


       0
1

'
 






#


2'
3 

-2-






*



%0 

 "

 0










 















%0  $
#





 



'


!


#


 

  









 



 

#



!
"
#

& "
#



& !
 

#







 
 














2
 
 '

3 
#


' '
 
*

!

'
+,% ,


 
/  

      
&
 
) 
*

  
!"
 $

5

%
 
 !"

 $



$  

6$

$
#

!&


$ 
!"



' 4 '


#,#

.

#


'


6$ 




  '
#






'




*
'
  
'
 
#








,6$ 

 &  $



'



 




!

'
#

&  

$
 
'


 0
& 
&

'
  &"

! 

'

 
3 
#
 
*



$ 

 0


 


3 
#





'




 '
!#

'

 
) 
* 


 
#

 
&
!


-3-

2
 0



!"







 '
!#
 
*
!"


2' 3




%0
 '


!"
 


*
2
 &

#

3  

#7, 8                           !" #      $      %

     !" #     &                 $     

 '        

 $                                        

     $             $   !" #      

$    !" #                   '      
 "     '

  (

'



#,# 
 
*

 #
!"

 
 

$ 

!
 
'
 #

'
 7, )* #          $     $              $  
 + 

,  -      $           

    

.

#         

-4- /  #          01    

   (


$




'
#
!

#,#
 
"

&


 0





 




 


!"




*



 
#
 ) 
*




'



#

 0





#

 "

2
"
!&

$ 


 0
#&
!"





'

 
3




#
 3

'



%
#

 
:



& "
#
 



  
$"
!



#



'



& "



# 












)

 '
#

!&
'

$'


  

 '"
! 


 #
"
#
!"
 $
2# 
#





$'





#
 

!"



'



$
#

 
3 
#
 
*







:



& "
#
 





,6$ 

 0

!



# 


'




!
 "

$
#





'

&
!"


*


3




!
 
!"
 





#

$

-

2

'

"
"$ 
& 

#



 
 

,
 

#






!&

 
$"
! 





& 

$
#


 $
 



!"

*,


; 

-52
 '

: 

!"




*

$
#

 

%
!


#&
#



#


 

 (SANJIV BERRY) JUDGE 22.11.2024 S.Sharma(syr) Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No Whether reportable?

Yes/No