← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9981/2019allowed

M/S Kay International Pvt Ltd v. Commssioner Of Goods And Service Tax

2019-11-04Mr Justice Jaswant Singh,Mr. Justice Lalit Batra3 pages

 

        

 !""#$%$&'( )  

   

 

 





 

  '(  *+

 ,,,  *+

 ,++  "#$ % &

!

'()*+,+& )-+./&)*+.0&))**,(-*/0 '()+1&,1/&.+)+&/*+/1&/-+1)&/,-)/(-*/+

!2&

3  $4$ #&

!

'(/*5,&//05&/-)+&/-++&/1+.(-*/+ '(+.5&)-.1&1+0,&.**0&0,*.&,.0+&,50-&1)+,(-*/+ '(1)+5&15*)&5*.*&/*-1-&++/0&/,.-+(-*/+ 62% &





42   &



'7-+1).-*/03 '7/5.5.&/5*-&.+00&.++1&5.1-&55+0&0/--&0/,-& 0/05&-1-0) -51---*/+ 

%$&

 

#$&

!

'(,0,-&1+55&1+0)&./-,(-*/+ 8

&

!

'(/+5.(-*/+ 

$ &



'70)1/-*/+   ! #$&

3  $ !

&





'7/+1/.&-50+/&/1-.+&-0,*0&-0,.+&-55,*&-5+/5& -500,&-5+*)&-5001&-5+/+&-0*01&-5+.*&-0/.1&-5,1*& -5,-.&,.,0&+/5)&-/51/&-/+*-3/-).1-*/+ !

#$&

 % &



9:

9 '7,115-*/+:

  6 $ &

; $ 78$ $ &



9:

'7115,&.-*/&0+..&/++.1&.),/&.1+*-*/+   &

  !

&

!

'(/*+05&+.-5&/*5)1(-*/+ " % &

!

'(/1-0.&/1150&/1..1(-*/+ %;

#$&

!

'(-+1).(-*/0&/5*-(-*/+  $";

$&

 7$ 8!

&

!

'(01+,(-*/+  8$

&

!

 '(/.-*.(-*/+  8 $ 4 &



'7-,0*+3-1)*)-*/+ <  #&



'7,115-*/+ $$ 8 $ 8$ &

; $  626

! 2&

3  6 $  &





'7-0-*)-*/+  $ &

  %$  &



9:

'7)+5/,3,*/,-*/+ 8$ $ ##&





'7++0/-*/+ 62

<$ &

  6 8$ !&

 '7-0,*0-*/0   # ; &< ! 2



& = 2   86!

& 



& 64  4$ &

 # ; $

 >!!&

7/ ) '()-+./&))**,(-*/0& '(15*)&/1..1&.-*/&.),/&5*.*&.1+*&.+)+&/-+1)(-*/+& '(.**0&,,/0&/.-*.&,1,,&1)+5&1)+,&,50-&,.0+(-*/+ '(/*-1-&)-.1&01+,&/*+/1&0,*.&)--)/&+)--(-*/+ '(/,.-+&/1-0.&/1150&/5.-/&/5.++&/++.1&-/*)0& -51//&-1-0)&1,0,&-*./1(-*/+-



/ ) '7/5.5.-*/+

/ , '7-/51/3-/+*--*/+&

/ ) '7-/++-&-,,0) -,,1/ -*/+-3

/ ) '7-+01--*/+  $% $&

 # 

42 7 " &

>?  '(+55& 1+0)&)+5/&,*/,&,.,0&,0,-&115,&0)1/&./-,&.+00&.++1& 5.1-&55+0&0/--&0/,-&0/05&+/5)&0+..&/*5)1&/*+/1& /*+05&/-).1&/-+1)&+.-5&++/0&/1-.+&/.*/5&/+1/.& -5001&-0*01&-0,.+&-5+*)&-5+/+&,115&-/51/&-/+*-& -,0*+&-5,-.&-5,1*&-5+/5&-5+.*&-500,&-0/.1&-55,*& -50+/&-1)*)3-0-*)-*/+ 

&

 2&

7- ) '()*+.0 )*+,+(-*/0 6

"$&

'7)+1&,1/&,,/0&115,&.-*/&.),/ .1+*-*/+ @@@ ,,. A 

 

&







!   / )    0"1!"#2&34$"% 5!+!0 &$&&0$  1%

,,   ++   5"67"1 ).   

  !

"  #$% "