High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/22435/2016allowed

Meenakshi Sharma v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2017-03-24Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh10 pages

Pooja Sharma 2017.03.29 11:13

!!"#$% %#&# '!(( "! )!*

(#(! '*"+#,#"-#"

(%! .!/ "-!"(

'!!"(

"*#0% /#1-2 #(! (%!/!(( "! !%3%#-4#+151'*"+#, .#+#"3%#0#21-2 #(!

%! /!!"( /!(( " %# ,!!" !- *"-! ! ( " 7 ' #" !#( #"( /#( 8,#0#"(!-( !/

-#(!- !0(!!- *"-! ! ( " 79

::: : '#('

! (#( "'

3%#4#"0#%1 #"0* 3!81 (%! # ( (%! #! #! (%#( # !#-

. 4# !0(!!- #0#"( !/ "-!"(

#"- % #&8 &!&,! %! ,# #// #( "!-,8!/

4#-&!-,8--( "# ! " ;*-0!1 #"0*2-! -!-#(!-9 %!!#(!1!/

#// # %!-(% *( 0#"( #"( /#( 8,#,84#8 "0

9 *"0/!"-!" 8 (%!,#/!(( ",! !(%

*(1#"#& #,!!((!&!"(4##2!-#(,!(4!!"(%!/#(!#"- "(%!

(#(!&!"(&#-!,8 *"! (%!/!(("

!4(%!0#-( &/ &!1 "(!& -!/#!-"(%!/!(( " 0#"( ,#4#&#-!#, *(! 7 *,!<*!"(8 &!-!!" !# !,!(4!!"(%!/#(!#"- 4(%!/!!"(/!(( "%#,!!"!-,8(%! &/#"#"(*"-! ! ( 7 ' #" !#( #"( /#( 8,#0#"(!-( !/ "-!"(

"(%!0 *"-(%#(%!4#,!"0%##!-,8!/

#"-

&/ &!4#!! (!-+*(( ,(#"#"( /#( 8,# =!#"!- *"! (%!/!(( "! "(!"-(%#((%!/!(( "! 4###*(!-,8!/

#"-%!4#02!"&! !,!#("01 4% %!*(!-"( #, ( "14% % !# &!/ (-#(!- 7 =!#"!- *"!*(%! "(!"-(%#(-*!( (%!,!#("01(%!!4#!2!!

,!!-"0#"-(%!"+*! #*!-( (%!/!(( "!4!! , #(!-4(%(%!

*(# *"- !/ ( *!- ,8 .#+"-# > /(#1 '#(## 4((!"

!/!!"(#( "4## &#-!(

'1 #"0*"(%!0#-,*("

# ( 4#(#$!"(%!!*/ "=!#"!- *"!# "(!"-(%#(,! #*! (%!

&/ &!1"

"2!(0#( (%! #!4# "-* (!-#"-(-#(!"

%##" %# ,!!" /!!"(!- 2!" "

# ( " %# ,!!" (#$!" " (%!

*,!<*!"( &/#"(&#-!,8(%!/!(( "!((%!!"-1!#"!- *"! (%!/!(( "!*,&((%#((%!!#!* !"(0 *"-( #" !(%!,# 0#"(!-( !/

( ! & ( " 4# *!- " (%! #! " 9 #"- (%!!#(!(%! #!4##-+ *"!- "(%!!<*!(&#-!,8!#"!- (#(!

*"!( !!/8 =!#"!- *"! !/ "-!"(

(#(!#4!#!/ "-!"(

%#2! // !- (%! *,& " &#-! ,8 !#"!- *"! (%!

/!(( "! =!#"!- *"! !/ "-!"(

(#(!*,&((%#((%!!4#"

/ 0!"(%!"2!(0#( "#(%!&#((!4# &/ &!-,!(4!!"(%!

/#(! =!#"!- *"! !/

*,&((%#(!/ "-!"(

(!#-8( &/ &!#"-(%! &/#"(%#,!!"&#-!+*((

%##%&14%!!#1"

* %" -!"(%#!2! *!- >!#- (%! #0*&!"( #-2#" !- ,8 !#"!- *"! (%!

/#(! #"-%#2!# 0 "!(% *0%(%! -!/#!-,8(% *( 7 #"- (%!- *&!"(#2##,! "(%!! (!*#" ! "

( ! & ( "1 #! #&!*/ %!#"0 ,! !(% *( " #"- 4"0 -!4#/#!-

?=!#"!- *"! !/ "-!"(

!!$ (&! ( 0!( "(* ( ""(%! #! ((%!(&! 0#"("0,#1(4#&!"( "!-(%#((%!

&#((! %# ,!!" &/ &!- ,!(4!!" (%! /#(! #"- (%!

"(!&-! ( "*!-,8(% *(4#&#-!#, *(!,*( *,!<*!"(81#0#"#-/*(!%##!",!(4!!"(%!/#(!

"2!4 (%!*,& "&#-!,8!#"!- *"! (%!/#(!#"-,8 "-!"0(%!"#(*! !" !1(%!/#(! #!-! (!-( #//!#,! !(%!!-#( "#"- " #( !"(! (% *( "

" /**#" ! ( # !#- -!1 , (% (%! /#(! #//!#!- ,! !(%!!-#( "#"- " #( "!"(! (% *(,*("

*(* !*(%# &!#(%!/!(( "!4#!* (#"(( 0 4(%!/

,! #*! % "-* (#"-%##&!"( #*!-( %!

%!# (!#("0( -0"0

.#"-0#"( #"( /#( 8 ,#( !/

#!"

(-/*(!- (# "

(-/*(!-(%#(,! #*!

&/ &!#2!-#(,!(4!!"(%!/#(!1(%!"(!&,#0#"(!-(

4#&#-!#, *(!,8(% *( "7 %!!#(! &!-/*(!# !,!(4!!"(%!/#(!#(%!/!(( "! 4!4#"

((!#(!- / /!8#"-4#02!",!#("0

( "8"+*!4!! #*!-( %!,*( -*!( (%#(%!%# ( # !#, ( "14% % !# &(%!&!- # !/ (4((!" &/#"(4## &#-!,8(%!/!(( "!( (%!/ !

#*(% (!,*("

# ( "%#,!!"(#$!"(%!!*/ " (%#,!!"#!0!-(%#( !/

%#&*!- " ! ,##"-(%/!(( "%#,!!"

!- #" !#( #"( /#( 8,#0#"(!-,8(% *( @"-/*(!-81(%!!#!-!!"(/##&!(! 0#"( ,# #"- #" !#( ,# (%#,!!"%!-"2# *+*-0&!"( > "A,!

(%!/!B *(#4!# (% *((%#(!+! ( ,#"#"

",##,!

#!#((%!"(#(#0!#"-(%! #" !#( ,# 0#"(!-1%#2!( ,!

"-!!-#"--!#(4(% "-!!"(,#" !(%!,#0#"(!-1(%! #&! #""

(,! #" !!-"#&! %#" #&#""!4(% *( "-!"0#(

4%!(%!#"8 *&(#" ! #! (%!!( % 4(%#( %! %# &*!- (%!

" ! ,# +*&/!-(%!,#!(#"/" /!%#2!# ,!!"#- - 4""+*-0&!"( > "A,!(%!/!B *(" #!

! #$4% %#!#*"-!

?@"-!%#/(!CCC

1 ! ( "7!&/ 4!(%!>0% *(#4!#(%! *( ! "( -! (#"8# *!- /! "( ,!!!#!- ",# ! ( "7 !&/ 4!(%!

>0% *(( -! (#"8/! "4% %#,!!"!!#!- ",#

*"-!%#/(!CCC

(%! -!,!#!(!-#"- &&((!- ( *( -81 ! (%! / 4!( #" ! (%! ,# 0#"(!- ( #"

# *!-/! "5!"!#8(%!0 *"- #" !#( ,#1 , #-81#!(%!# *!-&*!%,!(8,8"-*0"0" &# &"# # (2(81 "(!!! 4(% (%! *! "2!(0#( "1 #((!&/( ( (#&/! 4(% !2-!" ! 4("!! 2 (%!#(!" 4("!! "-*0! " &# # (2(!4% %4 *-%#&/!&

(%"2!(0#( "2(%!! $!%

- %!!"0( #"

(%! *"(82#((!&/((

&#$! %&! # ! ,8 0 "0 *"-!0 *"- ,!

&"0 *"#2##,!( (%!"2!(0#("0#0!" 82#((!&/(( /# !

%&!,!8 "-(%!!# % %*!(8!( %!!0 *"-#!

*(#(2!#"-"

(!B%#*(2!D > "A,! (%! */!&! *( " " % &' ! !

() $

1%#%!-(%#( (%!0#"( ,#(% *0%"2 2!!B! ! - !( "#8/ 4! (%!

*(1,*(* %!B! ! - !( "%#( ,!&#-!"#+*- *&#""! #"-"

(##&#((! *! (-!/!"- "(%!# (*#&#(B (%!&#((! %!/! # ( 14% %%#2!( ,! "-!!-,! !0#"("0,#1%#2!

,!!"&!"( "!-"#"

(%!+*-0&!"(((!-# *!

(

+,$- $

.##14% %#!# *"-!

?#E%!0#"("0,#(%! *(%#( $!!/"&"-"

( "8 (%! "#(*! (%! # *#( "1 ,*( (%! !2!(8 (%!

/*"%&!"(1 (%! # *#( " !"(# # "2 ( " #"- (%!

"#(*! !2-!" !"*// ( (%!# *#( "

,.!# "#,!#//!%!" " (%!4("!!,!"0(#&/!!- 4(% (%! #//!%!" " (%!! ,!"0 # (%!#( (%!

&/#"#"(% *-# 4!0%4(%(%! *("(%!&#((! 0#"( ,# E%! ( "

( !B/! (!- ( %#2! (%! !"(! !2-!" !

!(#,%"0(%!0*( (%!# *!-,!8 "-!# "#,!- *,( ,*((%!! *0%(#4#8( ,!#/&## !#(# ( (%!

*("*// ( (%! %#0! - 2 (8"/ ! *( "% *-#4#8,! "-!!-#"-( "8 (%! !!&!"( 0!"*"!"! (%#( %# %#2! ( ,!

"-!!-"(%!&#((! 0#"( ,#1#"-"(%!!2!"( (%!! ,!"0 &! - *,( # ( (%! 0!"*"!"! (%!

/ ! *( "1"(%!"

&# *! !2!"(1(%!# *!- !"((!-( #" -! ,#D

&#8""/ !

0&* $

. 231$> "A,!(%! */!&! *(4%!-!#"04(%#"

#// #( " ,#%#(#(!-(%#( !(#"# ( #!( ,! "-!!- 0#"( ,#1(%!8#!F(%!"#(*! # *#( "#"-(%!!2!(8 /*"%&!"(" #! "2 ( "#"-(%!"#(*! *// ("0!2-!" !F !# "#,!#//!%!" (#&/!"04(%(%!4("! #//!%!" (%!#(( (%! &/#"#"(F#"-/&## !#(# ( (%! *("

*// ( (%! %#0! %! " !/( !(("0#-!#"*"+*(!-1!0# /!2!!

-!( (#8-!!"( & #" !"0#" -! ,# "(%!0 *"-(%#( (%!# *!-%#-& "-* (!-%&! ,! #*! !B(!" ! &!

*/!2!""0 *&(#" !4##"("0* % #" !#( "E%! "-!"0

(%!/!(( " #" !#( ,#1(%! *(( "-!(%!0#2(8#"- "#(*! !" !1 #!#0#"((%!# *!-1(%!/ ( "#"- (#"-"0 (%!# *!- (%!!#!2!8! *#!0#( "#0#"((%!

# *!-1%,#&#8,! #" !!-!2!"%!%#" (&*!-(%!,# 0#"(!-( %&%!!"

#, *(!*!(%#( " !,#0#"(!-( (%!

# *!-1( #""

(,! #" !!- ( #",! #" !!-(%!!$!%

- &*! (%!,#%!!#!!2!## ( 14% %#!( ,!!!"4%!

-! -"0(%! #! #" !#( ,# (# ( ,!$!/("&"-(%#( "-2-*#,!(8 #""

(,!# !"(*#(!-( * %#"!B(!"( !!2#(!-(

* %#%0%/!-!(#14% %4 *-,"0"#"# %8 - -!"(%!

!(8%!/ /! ( 0!#(!+*( !!<*!(%#(#4#"- -!% *- /!2#"# 2!-&!*%!! #""

(,!#"8#(%&!( # &*# B"0(%!/##&!(!"/! !!B# ((*-!( #" !(%!,#

"! 4! & 05 $

#61> "A,!(%! */!&! *( ,!2!-#*"-!

?3#4!*"-!(

-" &"#+*/*-!" !#"-%#/(! CCC

(%! -! &"#' !-*! "(#"!#, #(!

/ 2 "!#("0( 0#"( ,#3#0#"(!-( #/! 4% %#,!!"#!(!-"#"

,##,! !" ! %#,!!"

"2 (!- #" !" !#(!(#%!!! ( 0#"("0,# ( !!#!(%!# *!- &"(!"&!"((% *0%(%! *(4 *- (!(#" "(* (2! "( 2!%&(% *0%(%!*!(! #!(%!# *!-!!#!- "% 4", "-* % "(* (2!

"( *-(,!!B! !-(% *0%(%! "-( " (%!

, "-! *!- &%&%!(!#&!#""0 (%!4 -?,#D *!(8D

" #!1(%!/! "( 4% &(%!,#%#,!!"0#"(!-!(%! (!( "(!!!4(%(%! *! +*( ! #((!&/(( (#&/!4(% !2-!" ! 4("!! (%!#(!"4("!! "-*0!"&## (2(! 4% %4 *-%#&/!&

(%"2!(0#( (#1,#0#"(!- #",!

#" !!-%!!+! ( ,#(#"- "!

("01,*( #" !#( ,##%#% -!,! #*!((#$!#4#8(%!,!(8 #""-2-*# 0#"(!-#"-"

(( ,!0%(8! (!-(

"!7 *''8

1# ! 3 $> "A,!(%! */!&! *(%!-#*"-!

?%!#4"!0#-( 0#"( !*# ,#2!84! !((!-%! *(0#"("0,#% *-!B! !(- !( ""

#+*- *&#""!#"-"

(##&#((! *!% *0%#((%!

(#0! 0#"("0,##-!(#!-!B#&"#( !2-!" !#"- !#, #(!- *&!"(#( (%!&!( (%! #!"!!-"

(,!

*"-!(#$!"1(%!!#"!!-( "- #(!"* % -!!# " /&# # ! " *-"0 4%8 ,# 4# ,!"0 0#"(!- /#( *#84%!!(%!# *!- %#0!- %#2"0 &&((!- #! * !" !"8 -!-!2 - * %!# "4 *- *! &"

#// #( &"- (# "! !#8 (%!

*(0#"("0,#( "-!#& "0 (%! *&(#" !1(%!

4"0# ( # ,! !0#"("0,#F(%!8#!

#%!"#(*! # *#( "#"-(%!!2!(8 /*"%&!"("

#! "2 ( "#"-(%!"#(*! *// ("0!2-!" ! ,.!# "#,!#//!%!" (#&/!"04(%(%!4("! #//!%!" (%!#(( (%! &/#"#"( '&## !#(# ( (%! *("*// ( (%! %#0!

7 !!

! "!#$$ %!&'# (#)**)+),

+& -,).*+)**)+/,.01, #"- %&

2-')**3+), +& -,1*3+)**3+4,//1 (%!!

&!&,!3!" % > "A,!(%! */!&! *("!

- "

!% 2#3 !1

&#-!(%!

4"0!!&!"(#-(" ( ""-!""0(%!"#(*! !B! !4%!

#" !"0,# ?.!+! ( " ,# 4%!" ,# #//!- "! (%"0F #" !#( ,##!#-80#"(!-<*(!#"

(%!1 (!#! ( !+! (#,##// #( ""#"

,##,! #!(%#"( #" ! #,##!#-80#"(!-"* %# #!#" !#( ,#

! !#8"2 2!(%!!2!4 #-! "#!#-8&#-!#"- #",8#"-#0!,8/!&((!- "81,8!# */!2!""0 *&(#" !1(4 *-,!"

"0! "-* 2!( ##(#(

# 4(%!# *!-( !(#"%!!- &-*"0(%!(# &/%#*//!-D

"(%!/!!"( #!1"(!&,#4#0#"(!-( !/

#"-(%!#&!4#&#-!#, *(!# &/ &!4#!! (!-,!(4!!"(%!

/#(!%!!#(!1(%!/!(( "!

&/#"#"(4#%##!-,8!/ "-!"(

#"-/%8 #"+*!4!! #*!-( %! (%#,!!"(#(!-"(%!

/!!"(/!(( "(%#( "-* ( !/

4#"!2! -#( 4#- /!(( "!#"-% %-!"%!/!(( "!4#*,+! (!-( &!"(# *!(8 #"-4#/%8 #8##*(!-# "2# * # "

2 !4##!- ,8(%!/!(( "!#%!4#"(!!(!-"&#(& "###" ! (# #"

#!0#( "(%#((%!/!(( "!4#/%8 #8##*(!-,8!/

4% % !- ( %! !- #, ( " !/ ( -#(!- 7 !(8"0

/!0"#" 8 (%!/!(( "!%## /# !- "!

-#""!B*!'

4(% (%!/!(( " /8 (%!=.-#(!- %## ,!!"#""!B!-4(% (%!/!(( "#""!B*!'

14% % , #(!(%!#!( "&#-!,8(%!

/!(( "!%!=.%#,!!" , #(!-4(%(%!*(# *"-!/ (-#(!-

""!B*! '

*!- ,8 .#+"-# > /(#1 '#(##1 4% % % 4(%#((%!/!(( "!4#/%8 #8##*(!-#"-(%!#(!"!-#, ( 4#(%!! (%## &! "!

-(%#(#4((!"!/!!"(#( "4#&#-!

(

' #"0* " ,*(,! #*! &/ &!"

# ( "%#,!!"

(#$!"(%!!*/ "

(4!!((!-#4(%#(,# " !0#"(!- #",! #" !!-"

#! (%! # *!- %# & "-* (!- %&! &! */!2!""0 *&(#" !4##"("0* % #" !#( "%#2! *!- "(%!/!!"( #!1"

(%"04##- "&!(4%!0#"("0,##"-(%!,#4# 0#"(!-,! #*! (%! &/ &!#2!-#(,!(4!!"(%!/#(!,!"0(%! &#(& "#-/*(!,*((%!!#(!(%! "-* ( !/

4#"

(

-#4(%(%!/!(( "!1%!4###*(!- "2# * # "102!"

&! !,!#("0!*(#"(8%!4##, (!-*/ "

"2!4 # (#"- *&(#" !#4!##4/ ( "# !B/#"!-#, 2!1(%!/!!"(/!(( "# 4!-#"- -!-#(!-7 0#"("0,#( !/

!(#-! %!/ !#*(% (!#!

-! (!-( (#$!!/

" *( -8 (%4(% # % 1 + , /

+# E%!(%!/!#$"0:!# "!- G! E%!(%!!/ (#,!