Nand Lal @ Anand Lal And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!
"#$# %&'
& ()*
*+
!"#$%&'$() $ *
+ &,(! !+-&
&&!"#$%&!'$)$"$ .$/ *+ ,-).
( ) $ +" % $ /0. $' ( 1$" $' 1
& $%"+(& '
"'$2+&( 3$' $ 4456"&"47 4/ .480 3 "+" % $/6.!9.9!9./!/.:!645!8/0&"8/7$'(1 &;
% $9.51&""" &$<$ % & $1 =&& &! % && &&"& %$2+ & )$%"
3& 3('$ !$( & $'
%$
& #"& >()& "$""&"./ .480!()& >"
%"$&))& '$( &" & 1$+? &2&&3 &!'$3 3( & %$""@&$(3+ $'(%$
)$"$ .$/ %$+ "$&))& ('$!# "$""&"4.
.480(=>3&"
&$( $))$+ = %$ ) &% ($'! )$ $' + # $&
+"
% & &3 &!&& &"&"85 .480!(& % #"!>( ! (& $ %" (& ( )& (&# "("
)+ &
%& = > ($+&=+"+ ' +%!%$% $$)+ (+
&&
!$ -% #&"3$& $'& 3& = $ %$% ($% & %$'
% &> 2+ "$ =$+(&)$) "$ $(&#$'
3(> (&%($(-+$)$%( 3($)$)=! 3( $ '&" =&"$( 3(%+"$( =( 3& =
( % # "
)+&(%$'
% >>$)& !(&# 3 $#$ '$($% & $"!$% & (& $=$($% =&+%( %& $ + '"$ 3 #$()& $ ( "
)+ =%$
!$'
%$+!%$
3 > (%& 3& %$2+%&> $>#! ( %
& "
)+"$$%& = %( #$$ =>$)& $("
)+ $'( %$)!%$2+%&"''% (%
& &%"$%&( ''%&"%$2+%#+)$($% =& &3 ('$!( &>)% )+ ( !#)+ ( &"
(A )+ ( ! % +"
3"&()& ='$%
& &% $>#! $$'($(% # "
)+$ B %$'
% $' >$ )& &'$ ( # $ %
& &)% ('$!( 3& = ) &= ) $$ #(%$'
% >>$ )& @> ((&"""&,$'+ 3(&(&"#
)&%$'"
)+ 2+&$% =& &3
C"
+ (%$ "& $$ #(
'
%$'
% >>$ " =)+ 3 $ ('$!#(%
& &> 2+ "$3 #"+3&"$(> ($'()& $"
)+
%$3 3( ) % ) $ =!("
& 3& = & $)$# "'$ %$3 3 ( %$
> >$ " $' & %
& "
)+
% $9.41 &A))$# $ ( 3&"
( % $$ $ =)$# "'$%$ )$+"
3"+ 3( & ! +)
%$ )$+"
3 #&&)) &$# $& &3 $># = #=&+&"%$)!
% $9.41 %&$ ($ )$ $=@>( (%$3 $ $&%$
>()& (&#@%& =@$ %$'
"
( % $ &$ =$($''%)% "+"("
&& 1$" (&& $ $$''%)% "$+ "1 #$($''% A 3 (1>"
$&&"""'$
$
! &, 3( A 3$''%$ 3($ 3&"#> $"& $')$$'
$'$''%& 3%$3 " # >$'%($ $3 %& &"#&% ( % &&"2+ ("'$ $$, 3 =$" % $9.4 1 $%$3 (%$
>()& $"
)+ +$
& & (&% =$'()$%"+)% "'$%
& & @( & 1$+%&$ )
"$&# =$"(%$))% "+"(& )$%"+ %("'$ #$, 3 % $/0.1 =( 3( 1$+ +! & $ #" & $#! ( > ( $' $ = )& $ (
/ %
& "
)+>$+ "$& >&= +''
% $
&&%
& &
# >$'()&! &$+ ''%@( %$"+%>$+ "(&# ' 2+&($% =& &3 ('$($''%%$
" =)$
#$ #" 3$#&%$&"
& $'$&%2+ 3$''
% & )$>$ >( A% 3$''
%)$>%&$ )
"$ %$
"
,> ! # ( $''% #$ # 3 $ = >$ ) #& )$! + ' % 3")&# =$'%(&&%$ #$ # 3%&+ 3 $& $$' ' $%&+ 3 $& $$')$)= =A"
3
(&$' $ $' '@ %&$ )
" $ %$
"
A%) ( & $#B
$"3&#$''%!( #=&$(&& $($''% ($+ " )
"$ %$
" =(1$+
%()$$'$'
$''% '$(1$+!&3& >$+ " #$ #(%$"+%$'()& $ "
)+!('$ '(1$+"$$)
(& $ %$
"
(()& >$+ ""$) &= %,+)$(1$+$+( &%2+ & $'&%%+" =+ # 3(&"
& $$'%
& -+ % " # ( $'&"
& $$'%
& -+ %$'$% (% C$ &&"&"$)( %," 3"$ ) &="+)$1$+ $+ #(-+ %=
$ >$+ "& >&= ( $'-+ %
'@(&(%$
>()& %$3 C"&"(% C & $$" &" %$
" $ ( & $' ( = $'
&"
& $$'-+ %!& &!2+&($$''%!>( %(( $'
$% ="$$)
$ %$
"
$D ( +) 1$+(&& ) =% & '
"( 3& )$ $$ %$3 3%$
3 (%&$'
!"&"(&$ #"&+"B
! "
#
$
%&'
(
"
)*+ ,
#
+
,
(
!("
( - "
-
(
(
.- -
(-
(
/
(
$
($
(-(
. 0
1
(
.
( *
(
2
(
(
-
(
- -
-
-
.
(
(-
(
(
( -
(
-
-
(
.
# "
#
(
-
(
#
#
-
+ ,
-
#
3 ()%&"$$'& &=$$'(A%) $# &3"
& $# %! # >$'()$$' + # $& +"
% & &3 &!
&& &"&"85 .480! &" )++&%$'($""&"./ .480 )&" =( 1$+!(1$+' (&$+'+ )+)$>$+ " #" =,) 3()$%"
3& # > ( $'-+ %! '( &%(" >()& &%%)"
%%$"
3 =! ( ) ) $ & $>"
$ "&"47 4/ .4803 "+" % $/6.!9.9!9./!/.:!645!8/0 &"8/7$'(1;
% $9.51&""" &$<&$ % & $1 = && &! %&& &&"& %$2+ & )$%"
3& 3('$ !
$( & $'%$
& #"& >()& &( = 2+&("2+&()) $ - *+ .
'
# E(()&, 3?&$"F$ E(( )$& F$