← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/11839/2020allowed

Jatinder Pal Singh Alias Sunny v. State Of Punjab

2020-08-19Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar33 pages



      

 !"#$%$%    *+ ,- ".-

/    0-1 2 - - -

34  - 0-1 $  &'&'55('$%$% 2",    0-1 2 - - -

34  - 0-1 &  67&  --8 &



              ! " "##$%&"'('(

)*+    ! " ",,$"'('(

-

. + /0



*    

- 3/8 9+# 1* 

*2!

  *    

      #& (, '(#$ -  

'

  *  0       /   

       3  43!5 ##$#& (, '(#$*  

 %(,67'#6$#6&3    .

 5 '     !

  %(' #'("

3 '( (, '(#$  1    

*  2 

          ! " "

##$%&"'('(  43!*  *

  8       *    ! " ",,$"'('( 1

*''

(, '(#$   (7 (& '(#$

    0  * 0

80    0  1 

*($ (# '('(#$ (% '('(  

9(6 ('

'('(  *! " ",,$"'('( 0   



*     0+* 

*    8        *  ** *     *  * 8    *     *   #:

(% '('( ! " "##$%&"'('(0    0 1 

*   0    *     "#&   ;

    '('(

8      ! "#(766"'('(

*  

% 0    *             0     8      0       *#7 (7 '('( /  '$ (7 '('(     0 <  * 8      

 0       9'$ (7 '('(   5=  0   >      0  *0    <  > 0  

<    ('

(, '('(                 0        (:

(, '('(* ! " ",,$"'('( 0    0   8      5=  <      9(:

(, '('( 5 = >   #:#       0  '%1 '('(   8      *0  0

  0        0     0   8    *    *     ?  0  8  * / #, (, '('( 9      *0 0     0 



*   0

   0 

/ 0          9', (, '('(     0

0    *        * / 0  8             *       *   

* * ;

 0    *

43!  5 ##$    #& (, '(#$   *       0 +* 

*2  =  "0 !

 8  *-

 *  0 !

            =        - 5 #:%:  

9#& (, '(#$0 ## ((   * !

    !

 -  



* 

*      

*   1 !

    0 #'

%(  *0    0 *  0 !

 -     0>   ,"$0    000@ A   !

 8 5    1

*  -  0   

  0 *0  -  * 

B    0!



     /  -          0!

  *    -   

 8 0  ;

    *      * *1

*        

/   0!

  *    

 

 *  * 0 * 

8    !



  8 (:

#7

8 *43!  * #$%(  #& (, '(#$    0 ##(( #'%( 

  0 +* 

*   #& (, '(#$ 8 *    *  43!5 ##$ #& (, '(#$      -    0 

/  01

*+  

*2 5   @*A   *              

 *!

 *   1

*  * *0 

 !

    8 

:

         ;

 B  *  0 **0 +  

*25      

C     ! " "#$,', 0- * 0  =

!

< 0 $ (( #& (, '(#$ 8                     00   0  0 !

       *

 +* 

*         

'# (, '(#$ 8  #& (, '(#$*43!* * *    * +  

*25      43!

- *

  1

* *000   -

  0    - 

  *              0  000 +* 

*      /  0 !

#& (, '(#$    8          8                  0      

     

,

 0         

  

*   

3 0 *        43!5 ##$   #& (, '(#$      0  /     * 4  #( #7 '( (, '(#$*

*  :

%(    

-0 

  0      8  

    * *0    8 *+* 

*       *  = =     !

             0          '# (, '(#$ 8 #& (, '(#$0#( (( ## (( !

  0 +* 

*     !

  

* +* 

* 

*  8    



*!

0 #'"#'

#7 1

*   5   @A*  ,"$0   *=    000 0  

/ 0!

      *

 * 0 *!

 **  

$                0 /

*  *   *   0+*   !

    *    0      *      -  0 - 

* 3 3*  "3       '# (, '(#$ 8 /   1

* 000 4                  

 8/

* 0

= =      1 !

+* 

*     

3 /

*     !

#& (, '(#$0 #'"#'

#7   *0      1

*5    *00 0  * ,"$0  * 000  !

 * /  !

            -        !

>   

& =  =         0          *  



.

    8 

  +* 

*    0    !

     

             1    

*       ,"$      -     1

*     *        

 *!

 *  1

*        

 B   *  *0!

 -  0  * !

  

8 *   0   0  

0 1

*   *    0 B 

*    @A    0    0   8                                  *     *    #7 #( '(#$   3; *                0   0     '& (# '(#&  *   

*2   8 ** 1 

*   '6 (# '('( 80  *  0           1 *     -

#(

    3; *   (7 (% '(#&#( (7 '(#&     0  . *    *   *       / 

! !  #: /   0   *  -      .

*  "<    '' / 0    .     -

 #$ (, '(#$0 :

%(      0* 8    <*0  01  

*        0  000   *  8     *     0  

8    0                  #7 #( '(#$*     *1

*    8            '& (# '(#&  *           

*  2    8   

#$ (6 '(#&#6 (7 '(#&  * *       '6 (# '('(   %('67'#'("

3 8      

##

     *+  

*25   0                    5  =    < B"#0    1 *  

-<  "

" "<     ('

(, '('((% (, '('(  5= *    #:#    C< .

 0    C< .  C< .

'# (, '(#$5 =  *+  =      +  

*25   * E  *#& (, '(#$0 #'"#'

#7   *   1

*5    @A,"$0 *0 '("'7



 *"      5   E 



 E5   !

   40   01

*  E5

      E  

* 1

*,"$  

* 

  E'("'7  *     *1

**              5   E 

#'

1

*   /  !

     0       3C< . '# (, '(#$ 5=  .5 '#?6 3+/     *+  =  *   +  

*25   * 

  *#& (, '(#$ 0 #'"#'

#7  *   1

* 000   5 * ,"$0  '("'7 * 9  0 

 "         

           0 *  0  

 *      5   !

  0 1

*  40   0  *      1

* ,"$       0 '("'7  *   

* 1  

**          

    * 5    

*

   0C< .

 C< .0  1 

*0  @A  

#% 0 * 0 000  

   1 *5=  <  "

" ('

(, '('(    +  =  

* +  =   . 

* *        +  

*5     *   *+  = #& (, '(#$0 #'

(("#'

#7   +  

* 5

0 ,"$ *     +  

*5

9

* " 1

*+  

*5 

 8:",    1

* 00@

0 + 

*!

 0 1  

*  

*         -   !

    8,"$  

'("'7  * 0

8    +  

*5  +  

* 5            *     +  

*  5

 - 0 3 * *9    

1

*  

@3  0/   * 

     *  

#6

   1 *                     



    A 9(% (, '('(5=  

       

 * C< "#"6  0/0/   0    3"<  *    #:#   1

* +  

*5   -  C< .     *  /0 



 * C< .

  *  *  *0    

   1

*       C< .

   C< .

 * 0 '

(( '# (, '(#$ C< . *C< .

0   

 C< .* 0    C< .0 

  

 *  C< .

  1

*+  

*5  

                                                    

*  *F

#7  

*  0  

          

 

  * 

2+  

*!

21* 

* 12!/

*/

*   0 - * ;

43!5 #($(:

(7 '(#,*  

 %(,%'%%'6%6#6',#6$#6&3  

 .

 5 '  0        * E!

 21* 

*   43!E       /

*12!/

*      43!;

0 - *     *  43!5 #($ (:

(7 '(#,0       0 1

*      < 0    *               *           * *0  



 * *

  *      0 *> 0   *F"

"        0 *F  #:##      

#:

  0+  

*5 '(,'

  +  

*5  0     <  00   0          0 %((   **         **          .0* "

" *0        0*+  

*5

      .  *      *F   =08        0=08#:#'

   0  0  *= 08     

 =0 8     .   **  !

   *      !

 *     !

 ** *

 * C< .  0/0/ 



 !

  * C< .C.4  *   0/0/     ** !

 

#,    **    !

 *  @ *5= ;

 0*  *   0 *# #7  -;

 *    * #( A #& (, '(#$0 #'

(("#'

#7   +  

* 5

* 0 #'"

#'

#7#& (, '(#$   + 

*5

 C< .        > > 0     ?           +  

*  5

      ** !

 0 1

*   40

  **     1

*

*     *43!5 #($'(#,   **     1

*     0      #:#   * C< .

             ?          +  

*5

 C< .



     C<  .

    > >     0    

#$   *   +  

* 5

 * 0  

0  8 

*      

     0       **  **   * #& (, '(#$     * 

   **     *      #& (, '(#$    0   **          0  0                            

  + 

*2!/  *   *       40  '(#$  +  

* 5   0   **   + 

*2!/

   **           1

*     +  

*5  1

* 

0       **  0   1

*       -      1

*     -     

8    0   **  8*1

*

#&

         8*0       * ;

  *  * C< .

.  

         

  *,"$0  0     1

* 0   * 0 * 0





* ,"$0   

                83

   0 



    0        **  

 8  5= 0 *  *             0         *      

       0                 

  - *            

-0   !

    01

*    *    3 *           0   

'(   ;

  

80 * *  0   

9   0       0       

    *0    8        0       8    G"

        8    0    *<  5= 0     

    0   0     0 

     0 +  =   *5=  +  

*25 0#'( 4    0    0  7>:>> /         0  0  35 =   *    *  00* * +  

*2 5

0

*  ;

  0    0*     0*0  80     0  @ A     0* 0    E@

A *  *E@

A     E@ A

'# * 0 * * 0 E @A0     * E @ A    

         0 *   E  @

A  0    0 *  E@

A* /  0 *0 *0 H  +",*- "": #,";0$%% 1<-$(%= +"+ - ":-0," *9 + 1;0 !5(1 - (=I 3  +",*- "" @ A

      * *0 *    J0* 0  *F J F     * *0 

  *

*      00         * 8  <  *  0  **

 0 0 0

8

 0         * 0           <   *       

  *    <    0  *     0  *           *

       3 0/   *0  0 < 0     **            E    E        E0    * E     

''

     E      0           0   

3 8,/ " *+-+>+: 3"  3 ;0$%%<15 -?$(= 

   <     /     *0       3 0 *  <   0    0  ** *0           *  0  0*    *   *     3 - 3/" *+: +, +  :

;0$% $1 -<%=

 00/0       0 < * 0        

8

  0 0      0*      0       *



3 0      *     0 *  *       0     *     0   J F     3    3   0;



   0    

 0     

'% 0  0    0   0       0   <     3     0     0       0

     0       0    0      *  * 

          8 

                     /    0<  * 0 0 * 0 * 0       * 8

     *0     /  <  3     

 0  0*  9

                   #,     E      *E     0 E    / 

    8

  *     

*  *  0  *0   3 -**"+9  -, @@  &"+  :  -   &"+"+;0$% 1 -A!<=

 0  0      *  0     0    *     - * 

 0

'6 /  0          F    0;   

3-  :9+9 +@";0$%%?1(-$ = 

 0  <     0    *;

 0        / * *     /  0  <     0 0 <         9     0  0 * @44,-" >+ "

9 "*: -&"+"+;0$%%?1 -?A!=#2:>8 9+:-

 ;0$%%%1!-<<)=&""8 9+"B ">:- ,";0$%%%1!-)()=A

3  0  *        0  * 0 <  

1

*   0 * *     0

            

  !

 8 0 *

   000  *  

   !

 3  < *             *             0 <    * 0  

   

*            

'7        !

"

0 *    /0

-     "

  * 0 *0 1

*        

  1

*  0  0  *  5 0*    0 *    0    *  0 8** 1

* 

 #'("

3  00 <*0    0 

*  0  

                          

!

 3  /* 1   

*                       !

 *    0 <  0      

3 *  0  0 +* 

*!

>0 3    0 *  43! 1 

* *   *  !

 3        

':

0  * /  01 

*            

 *!

  *  8   

  +  

*25 1

* 3      1

* *000    -  *         

5 <           #& (, '(#$ 80 *    5= 0  

0 3 C< .

.   *  J F    0   *    +  

*25

8 >

 >0     0   *  *     *        "<      K- >

 >/    *   *1 

* '("'7  3  0    0*   +  

*25 K 5

', =                  

    *                      #& (, '(#$  8     <   * 5=  *    E  + 

*25 E  *  '("'7  0     0

 -    0  + 

*25     +        +  

*25

   *           !

  0 0 

   

*               8     +  

*25 *  5=  *        -         3      ? *0     0 5= F   *   +  

*25          *           5  =  /

*     

 0   - 1  !

     * *  0 1

* 8

'$  0< 0 0 1

* 3            <     *             !

     /   *0  

*

   

+* 

*  0 +* 

*       *0      +* 

**  1 /

*>       3 

   !

>             * *  1 !



 /

*= =   *        +*

* -+* 

*>  = = K

         *    =   =    !

> +* 

* 30  0   * 0 

- 0

*   !

>     = =    

 !

0 ***         <          1

*  

'& 000  ;

 * 5= = =  *   

*  * 000  

     *1

*   0   0    /   0 !

 0 0   "*                        * *   0 > >  >000>

8                     3 * 8    1

*        *                       -     #"#L=   8  0         *  

 1

*  

      -     8        *0

        *  8           

 *  0         

8  *  +  

* 25   0 *   0   0      0    -  

   

*        

%( +  

*25 0 *  0   1

*0 *     

  - +  

*25     +   * D0      / 1

*    < 

*         -     0    0    3   +  

*25 0 +* 

*      77(

  0 

  +  5  ./  * D          .

   5 '    

    *   

  *      0      0   0     * * 0 .    @M9A  

*    *  +  

*25   /     0 *  /   

9           0     1

*  !

 3    0      *     

+* 

*  0    

%#    <   *+*

*       

* 

5 =   

                        0       8  3

            8 ;

   0 



   * 00       *      *"

  *   0  0   0 



        #'("

3 -

. + /0  *    *0 *     5 0   *  *       

  *



-*  0 *        0

          

        0 *   

     0     *    * 8  0 *          +  

*25 1 

%'

*         

*

   0       8  *       0  *     > " * 0 0    <  0     5= 0<  3  *   0      *     0 93."#&        *   

1

*0     ''

(, '(#$/    0     (7 (& '(#$/   8  0  *0   *   0/  

0    *   *   * 0  43!5 ##$#& (, '(#$               .

   5 '        

  * 0   ' *         

                   3;?.

*  8      *    3;?.

 *   0   0    /0            4                *  

          * 

 *        00      *  

%% 3 0             *0    8 0    0   0          *                           * #&'('( 0- 3/8 9+1

*?



* B 

*? )?5 B 0 )?5