Rajesh Kumar v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd.And Others
!"!#!
$!! !!# !
%%%%
& &
#'( #()*+* , -& &
! ./ !
0&& 1 .
.
!
!
$!!" 21 ! !2# . 0& . #. !#
& & !!/ !
3!!#.!2 0&& 1 .
.
!
!
$!!" 21 ! !2# . 0&& . #.
!, 4"2 & ..!#
# 2&
.!#
# 25
!" # $
% which involve similar set of facts and identical common question of law.
2.
To avoid any repetition, the facts are being taken from CWP No. 7112-2022.
&
'" !"" ())* ))+ # , "
% "-"
" + .* ).) /"$)% " "
% "
.0 + ).) & .+ ).) /"$ 1$2
3 "( % "
3 3 4!
.
.* )..+ #"( ( " 3 5 "#
% (
% ' % "( ' , (
"
( (( (( " ( "(
6 % (
' % %,
( ( " " " " #
"(" '
% (" 7" # (% , #
( #(
%(( "" ( " (( 768 (
-"
"" % % " "( % ( "( % " # " (% ( "
"# "(" 9
( "(
" ( ( # % "" :;;
%! 3
#
( # ( " &
% %
( #" "( % "# (#<;= # 4 (/"8>&% "$
!
"#!
$ %& '$( ) %&* * + " * * , *-.+ * -, /01&2+3
) )2 *
* $ *' 4 &1 5 67 '2, . , ) +
4 4 7
+ 7 0 ) ) 7
8 )
4
*-..3 ) , , ,)
)
'$ -*(
9
) 9 , :( %& '$; ) * 4 6 4 *
, )- )
+
),
' ) )
+
4 ) . 4 )+
: 9 ; ) ) $
< %&' *.$ $,
4
=, , + ) 4 )
. <
)+
=> , = ) , ) *-.+ 3 , ) - ) , ) + *-.+ 3 1 ) ) 1 %& * * 5 - )
+
) ) ) 0 ?
)) ) >
+ , ) +?*
4
,
' 7 )
0
)
7 , ' , + @ 'A +*67 '2 $ %
*' ) , ) &1$ *'
%&* * ', ) $ *'+7
0 B 'A +67 '2 ) $ %
*' 5 4 %& %& - ) ,
+,67 %
7'2
' A! + 67 '2 ) $ %
*'
) , )%& '$( ) - ) , +, 67 $
, , ) &1
'A!# +67 '2) 5
(
A! A!# -"
3 , ,:61-') ; , => = *-. 3 !
. -
) A!
)
#! A!
- )A!
A! +,
) 4 )%& '$ ( ' A
,
, ) * * 4 &1
) %& 6-* %&'
0 4
, , , 4 ,
) 4 . 5 @ => , = ) + * -, 3 @ 7
4
)3 ) + , , , 1 ) 8) + , , 3 5
67 %
C= +
, 4 ) 2,* * 67 '2 67%
)" , )
$ *' D@ 4 ) 4 ) 5 67 '2 5 5 )9 ) 67 %
C= *=.+/01&2+$ => ,= ) , 8*9#"=$9< #
2 "
* C $, 2 + 6 + ( 67 '2 : ; $ *' : ;
E * 5 ( "(
+ 7 " ( "#
# #" ( ( $8 ' 3 #( ' " " % !?$0+ 2$).)) #( , " (( ( -" ' % " ,
6 % "
# "
( !" (
"( # " # %,"( #"1 % ((
6 % "
# !" (
@ #( ( 678 -5
.!#
# 2
# D 4 )" F "8 D F "8